Why we do not come here more often is what we asked ourselves after our experience. Definitely busy at peak hours and it was a moment before someone could take our order. Nevertheless someone took over our table and he was awesome. Wings were good, salad was good. Loaded Fries not that loaded but the Pasta Alfredo was a good sized portion & plenty of sauce. Pizza not so NY style, thicker and breadier than expected. Great selection of beer on draft. Something for everyone and tasted fresh. Lively & loud atmosphere, expected in the packed house with families. read more

See all

Nice pizza spot! I came here twice and the pizza was consistently great! The staff were friendly and the service was good. I found the place to have a pretty relax atmosphere. Overall, this is a great place and I can't wait to come back. read more

See all

Hey Johnnys. Do you know what thin crust is? Cause I ordered in and you sent a regular crust. AGAIN! How can you be so incompetent? read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Grayson, Georgia

We ordered two large pizzas and an order of knots. The pizza cheese literally tastes like vomit. The meat pizza was extremely salty, dangerously salty. The crust was tough and brittle and the sauce is salty as well and devoid of any flavor. Overall it was horrible. I do not have any comments about the service because we placed a to go order, and I didn't see the inside of the location because my son and law picked it up. Overall I spent close to $60 for a chewy abomination called pizza. I believe that the pizza needs more quality cheese, maybe made in house at this price point! The sauce could use basil and garlic and the toppings need less salt. Overall I would prefer little Caesars or frozen pizza to those. read more

Cutest spot during the holiday season! All decorated with lights and festive! Our server was attentive and everything was ordered perfectly! read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Meat Deluxe Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Grayson, Georgia

Went inside to order to go. The employee who took my order was kind enough to call me when it was ready while I waited in my car. The food was ready earlier that expected and hot. The feedback I wanted to give is the packaging and family meal options. The containers were smashed since three meals were stacked on top of eachother. The bread was wrapped in foil and was smooshed when opened. I wish the bread was packed in a box container instead. The takeout bag is also a thin plastic bag. Pasta is heavy and I'd suggest a paper bag. The food tasted good and the portions were also great. I would love to see more family meals as an Orion. Especially if like a meal that comes with pasta instead of individual entrees. We will be back but hoping management makes some improvements on take out containers, bags and meal options. read more

I ordered 2 slices of Johnnys deluxe pizza. it looked like they had taken two cold slices of already cooked cheese pizza and added toppings to them. none of the vegetables were cooked. when I tried to pick up a slice, all the toppings fell off. when the server checked back with me, I told her my issue. she said sorry but no offer to make it right. i said I was ready for my check. I won't be going back! $21 for miscellaneous pizza parts. read more

This a the go to for pizza in the Northeastern Metro Atlanta area. There are a few Johnny's stores in the area, but for some reason, Grayson is the best one. Their service is always on point. The food is delicious and the environment is a nice vibe. Johnny's menu has a full array of pizzeria items and it's hard to choose wrong. The Johnny's in Grayson a must visit. read more

Johnnie's pizza is great. It's New York style with crunchy crust and tasty marinara. They have a patio which is terrific. There is a corn-hole group they plays there and they are amusing to watch. The beer selection is huge. This place is right next to the Grayson park so the kids can play before and after getting pizza. read more

First time being back home from being stationed in Japan with my husband. My sister and I went to Johnny pizza in Grayson. Haven't been there in years and I was craving American pizza. Our server was Alex P. Made the whole time wonderful. Super polite made sure we had everything that we need asked if we needed refills on our drinks and asked about how everything tasted. Always came by with a smile on his face. Alex made my first time being back home a wonderful experience and I'd love to have him again as my server. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Fried Mozzarella Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Grayson, Georgia

See all

Visited Johnny's on Halloween night after my wife had a craving for pizza. We had never been to Johnny's before and wanted to try something new. We placed an order online for pickup. The Parking: Free parking The Service: When I picked up my order, the young lady was friendly. The Atmosphere: It's a pizza bar. Take that for that you want. It's a restaurant, but has a strong feeling of a bar. It's not too loud, so you could definitely have a nice time. The Food: We ordered a medium Meat Deluxe Pizza ($19.79). A medium is 12" and large is 16" ($24.99). The pizza was very good but smaller than expected. We had enough for three slices each. Neither here nor there, the pizza was good. read more

Had bruschetta as an appetizer. I wish the cheese was melted on it but it was good. My wife and I had pizza and Johnny's is consistently good. Extra bake if you like it crispy. The service & atmosphere is nice. Feels very warm and friendly. 5:30 pm on a Wednesday and this place is buzzing. Jimmy Buffet playing on the speakers is always a winner. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - 16" Large Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Grayson, Georgia

I've ordered through your app plenty of times. Twice now I've ordered with delivery through door dash and not received items I've paid for. After calling the store I was told to contact DoorDash for a refund. DoorDash has stated contact you for a refund since the transaction was processed through your store. The driver has not responded either. This process needs to be fixed on your end. I'd like a full refund. read more

Good pizza and great service by an awesome staff. It really doesn't matter if we eat in, take out or have delivered. Johnnys in Grayson always is on point and has been forever. read more

See all

I hadn't visited this Johnny's New York inquiry a while. This time I Took advantage of the online ordering system which told me my order would not be ready for 45 minutes. I should've known that was too much time. By the time I get my pizza home it wasn't even lukewarm. Tip for anyone else ordering this way it would probably be a good idea to arrive 20 minutes before they tell you to. At the very least you may have to wait a few minutes for your order but that's better than a cold pizza. In the future I will just arrive earlier than the time given. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Right: Johnny's Italian Special + Left Specialty: Margherita - Pizza Near Me - Grayson, Georgia

Food is good. Tends to be a little slow for lunch when you sit down - so order ahead. Many beers on tap.

I called to place and order and the I wanted 2 SLICES. the lady said it was an hour wait. WHATTTT! for some slices, and I was ordering ahead and an hour before the order could even be placed. That's so messed up! read more

Our server was Aiden. He was very prompt and great at getting things right. Their cook was superb!

I've been to a few Johnny's but this one was by far the best one I've experienced. The flavor of the food was awesome. Usually you have a kind of generic flavoring to the pizza and wings but these things were seasoned nicely. I had boneless wings cooked with mild sauce and a couple of slices of pepperoni pizza. The atmosphere of the place was very conducive for watching sports or hanging out with the fam. Bill was roughly about $60 for 5 people, so a little more $10 person. For the food, I would honestly declare it was worth it on this visit. We all left full and happy! read more

Place is lively, service friendly but getting your food could be awhile. It's also very loud with the high, open, metal ceiling. Bathrooms need attention. Although "pizza" is in the name of the restaurant, I recommend the calzone. It is very good. Hopefully, we just caught them on a bad day. read more

We use to always go here weekly, then their score dropped it was like they quit caring about quality. Decided tonight since the score went up a little to 92. Our pizza arrived and we found two black hairs baked in two separate slices of pizza. Not like it use to be, our family is done with this Johnnys anyway. The service was great it was not our waiters fault he was nice as could be. They need new management and a certified food safety manager. read more

Best pizza in Grayson!!!!! The staff is friendly, nice atmosphere, easy parking..... I recommend it for families

Terribly disappointed. Ordered through Uber Eats. For $12, the portion size was insulting. Plus the ordering instructions were confusing. It says the entree comes with a salad yet you are given the option of "adding" a salad for the requisite up charge. For a simple garden salad the up charge was $4. Based on the description provided, the entire entree would then have been $16. Again, way over priced. I have not been to this restaurant in about five years although I pass it every single day. Accordingly, I do not know what their menu prices are for in-dining or pick up. But if they are charging $16 for a ridiculously small piece of lasagna, a garden salad and two pieces of garlic bread, I can not understand their appeal. However, if they are doing the despicable practice of charging different prices for delivery, you are doing yourself a disservice. If we order for delivery, we obviously pay the convenience or delivery fee. Then as we should, we will tip the delivery driver. Everything adds up. If you're charging us more for the same item, when it comes time to dine in, I will not consider your establishment because you are over priced. Reviewing your own delivery option through your website insults me even more. Not only does your picture make the lasagna seem twice the size, it comes with a garden salad for no additional cost. Very disappointing. read more

See all

The food and the staff are great but for the 4th or 5th time in a row when ordering, they have left off my caprese salad. They are always very apologetic and quick to give us a credit for next time but at this point it's super inconvenient and annoying that this item keeps getting left. I should probably stop ordering it but it's just so good and I enjoy it. just the staff needs to be more attentive with pick-up and delivery orders to make sure every item is in the order. 5 times is way too many times for this to happen. 2 times really is too many. read more

Johnny's Meat Deluxe We ordered this pizza on a busy Friday night online. After 30minutes of eating it my fiancé felt sick. His stomach began cramping. He ate two pieces. I kept eating my pizza and I ate two. I just thought it was him. 2:00AM, I ran to the bathroom nauseated and with diarrhea. Saturday morning I couldn't eat. Called the reaturant to share what happen and there was no manager working. I left my information. I am still waiting for a call back for our $33.00 meal. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Johnny's Meat Deluxe - Pizza Near Me - Grayson, Georgia

Excellent service, good very hood, best garlic knots in town. Prices see equal to other pizzerias

Had a delivery order. They left out a large salad. We called and were told they would refund it. They didn't called back and the manager would call us back. Two weeks and still waiting. So we are not valued customers. We not go back to this location. read more

Service was amazing and Dayne (The Pizza Chef) was hard at work and made us the BEST pizza we've had in quite some time! Thanks again guys we will definitely be coming back real soon! read more

Tonight I placed a large order for pickup. Person who took my order was friendly and thorough. I arrived 10 minutes early for pickup and my food was not only ready on time, all the special requests I made were handled correctly. Kudos on the attention to detail and the prompt, courteous service! And the food was fantastic! read more

I'm sitting here waiting for a waitress or waiter to come up and at least get my drink order for almost 20 minutes now. Do not go here if you want to get out in a reasonable time. read more

Love the ambience, love the service and LOVE the food. Huge slices packed with flavor. I wish I could eat here every single day. Def order the garlic knots - you won't regret it. read more

Came here to eat tonight. The hostess told us it would be a 30 min wait to eat inside (no one else was waiting) or we could be seated right then if we were okay with sitting outside in 90 degrees weather with our 2 year old... There were 4 unoccupied tables inside. read more

I went to Johnny's Pizza for the first time last week, in Grayson. it was a fun and yummy experience. The staff was very nice. My order was correct and nice and hot. The food was very good. The portion size of the slice of pizza was huge! i recommend if you love great pizza and service! Neeter D. read more

I am proud to announce I've found a spot that comes alarmingly close to the taste of NY style pizza! Ive approved them to use the NY in their name. Lol. My goodness. With so many fakers in the city I was starting to lose hope in finding a taste of the Bronx. They don't get much traffic but the pizza is on point. Very thin crust, sauce from scratch, fresh herbs and cheesy delight! I didn't have anything else but their cheese slices are the bomb! Stop by for an authentic taste of ol New York! read more

See all

Great atmosphere was very friendly people. The bar and patio is my favorite. Outstanding deluxe calzone.

Our service was great & our food was prepared fresh & came out fast. Our pizza was great, beer was cold & our server was very prompt to our needs & made sure we were well taken care of. We will definitely be back! read more

This is the coolest Johnny's I've been to. I haven't seen all of them, only a few, but this is the one most focused on the bar area and the local craft beer lovers. The servers are pleasant and accommodating and the food is consistently good. (I haven't tried the calzone at this location, though - I did not enjoy the calzone at another Johnny's and never made that mistake again.) Today I had a sub - ranch chicken with bacon. This is technically a wrap item, but like I said, they are very accommodating here. It used to be on the subs menu long ago, which is where I first fell in love with it. The fries were good, my bride's chicken parm sub was good, my beer was good... a great way to spend a lunch on a Saturday. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Crafts on drafts! - Pizza Near Me - Grayson, Georgia

See all

Johnnys pizza is our go to pizza place but I have to give them three stars because it's really hit or miss. On a good day the pizza is perfect and really tastes like home! Other times- well the bottom is soggy, you get three pepperonis on a large pizza and maybe a sprinkle of cheese . read more

Placed a delivery order for the first time last evening. Literally the WORST pizza l ever had! Crust raw, anchovies old as my grandparents, and the sauce not fit for my dog. In addition it was really expensive. There are better quality, value-oriented places in the area do yourself a favor don't order from here.. read more

I don't k ow if this is their fault or the delivery apps but I ordered a pizza at 9 and never got it even though the charge went through and I got a confirmation that it was going to be here from 10:16 to 10:31. This didn't add up though because they close at 10. I tried calling but nobody responded. read more