The wait for our food was a little on the long side even though when we got there it wasn't busy. By the time we got our food, the place was packed. It looked like they had A LOT of to-go pizzas though. The food was worth the wait. Sandwich was good and so was the pizza. Staff was very nice and the atmosphere is fun. We'll be back. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

See all

Good pizza, not much for ambience but the service was good and we had a short wait to get our pizza to go. Carry out is definitely their expertise and they do it well. read more

Love the folks at Johnny's! The pizza is always good and consistent. The environment is cozy and warm.

Very nice service. Pizza is mediocre though and far from New York style with a rather bland pizza sauce. It is nice enough as a family dining spot and it always seems busy, so they seem very popular. If you seek true NY style pizza, then drive further south to Duluth to New York Pizza Company (next to Cava) if you know NY pizza and this style. Johnny's pizza isn't bad, but it is definitely GA and not New York. I find GA pizza to be more crunchy instead of the bendable and thin dough that one seeks with NY pizza. read more

I love Johnny's. They have amazing food at a great price. Everyone makes you feel welcome and is always willing to help.

I was in the mood for pizza and decided to give Johnnys a try this time around. I was able to order online and pickup at the store. Ordering was super easy and they had the pizza ready by the specified time. I ordered the Great white pizza without tomatoes. This location is located right by Aldis and has a spacious parking lot right outside. The pizza was probably one of the best ones I have had, and I liked how the white sauce was not overwhelming. It was also one of the few pizzas I've had that wasn't greasy at all. The chicken and spinach was in ample amounts. I got a large and two slices were very filling. I can't wait to come back and try some other ones! read more

I've been coming to this Johnny's around 5 years now. I think once while I was picking up some pizza to go I first noticed they had a small bar. I then noticed they had real beer. Like effort and thought was put in to what's on tap. Since then I've been coming back at least monthly. The pizza is good. The calzone is TOP NOTCH. I come here for calzone, great service, reasonable prices, and enjoy the fact that the owner takes great care in selecting both local and other SE Brewery beers to serve. This is the kind of place you find Ghost In The Machine (Parish Brewery), or Spacedust IPA. A taste level I'm more accustomed to at a Gastropub then my neighborhood pizza joint. I'm here 1-2 times a month. It's what a neighborhood place should be. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Not going to front. It's a very good Calzone.... - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

See all

Another successful visit. While they were busy when we arrived, not so much when we left. This location does a tremendous amount of take out business. Seemed like they were missing s waitrreess, but she was keeping up. We ordered a house salad, a slice of the meat with added banana peppers, and I had the meatball sandwich with added side of fries. Our food did take a little longer than usual, but they were busy. The food was hot and tasty as usual. read more

See all

The absolute worst service and inconsistency. We continuously get the same waitress a short Hispanic girl who is rude and shouldn't be in the hospitality industry unless she is kept in the back. Our pizza was burnt to a crisp, completely black and we explained this to the waitress and her response was " is all of it burnt "? As if we should expect only part of our pizza should be. She never brought our drink and overcharged us for beers. After asking her again about our blackened pizza she had exact same question a second time -is it all burned. We inquired why she would ask that question and she was unresponsive. Must be how they are trained here. read more

I was in tonight, for some garlic knots and a slice of buffalo pizza. Even on a Saturday night, the food is always hot, fresh, and simply amazing. The service never disappoints, and the place is always clean. The garlic knots were perfectly seasoned and baked to perfection, and the buffalo pizza had just the right amount of spice. I couldn't help but smile as I took another bite, savoring the flavors. This place truly never fails to impress me, and I know that I'll be back again soon for another satisfying meal. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

I've been here many times as I used to live right around the corner. I've done both takeout and dine-in. I LOVE pizza, it's my absolute fave. This location is great! Their pizza is always dead on. Their toppings and ingredients are fresh and tasty. They always cook my pizza perfectly too, which is a huge plus...undercooked pizza is gross. Overall, this location hits the mark on quality, price and service! 5/5 read more

We regularly eat at Johnny''s in Suwanee but tonight (9-8-25) the pizza was subpar!!! The taste of the pizza was off and it wasn't cut throughly all the way!!! Very sloppy and disappointing! read more

Stopped in for some amazing pizza and they didn't disappoint. We were so hungry that I didn't even remember to take pictures lol. The service is always superb. Kate is always such a welcoming hostess. The vibes here are so chill that you could easily lose a few hours here without realizing. If you haven't visited a Johnnys in Ga you are missing out! #ashsaidit read more

food was great, and the small lady (I think her name was kyra) was very nice and attentive. made sure our drinks never ran out

I'm a cross country coach at North Gwinnett Middle School and we ordered our catered, end of season banquet from Johnny's in Suwanee. We had a combination of pastas, pizzas, salads and garlic knots. Everything was delicious! The service was amazing! James helped me put the order together and got it just right for the number of people we needed to serve. They delivered to the school on time, hot and read. They helped us get everything set up quickly. Parents were raving about the food and were especially surprised at how delicious the pastas were, since many of them hadn't had anything but pizza from Johnny's. I'll definitely order from Johnny's again! read more

We picked up a couple of calzones I had the mushroom and pepperoni and my friend had The Italian. Both very good. They have a pretty broad menu and a very good selection of calzones. read more

See all

Three words I would use to describe this place are amazing, professional, quality, delicious, cheesy, yummy, mouth-watering, out-of-this-world, extraordinary, majestical, magical, heartwarming, caring, loving, carbonated, beverages, beer, fresh, homemade, farm-to-table, authentic, clean, quick, nice, tasty, greatest-of-all-time, dedicated, New-York-Style, al-dente, convenient, established, and everything-you've-ever-wanted. If those three words didn't make you hungry I don't know what will. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

I read the reviews and gave it a shot and they delivered a very nice pizza. Everything worked together and satisfied my Italian craving, including the really sweet young lady that took care of us at the counter. I will definitely come back! read more

It's directly behind Aldi so you can't see it from PIB. Parking is available but probably not right near the restaurant due to the Enterprise car rental and other shops in that strip mall. Seat yourself - the dining room is smallish but the have a large enclosed heated patio area that even has TVs. 3 seats at the bar for a quick drink while you wait for your to-go order. Pizza is their main thing but they also have sandwiches and salads. Service was average. Pizza is ok. Better than the Dominos and Papa John's but not much. Toppings are skimpy and double cheese is the same amount as a good pizza has standard. They do have Coke Zero read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Xtra large 3 topping. Closest half has double cheese - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

I have eaten at several Johnny's, but this was my first time eating at this location. By far the worst pizza from any johnny's. I won't be back. read more

Miserable interpretation of a pizza, not to mention the audacity to refer to it as NY style? Cheese was of poor quality, sauce was acidic and crust was overly thick and under cooked. Johnny needs to take up another profession cause this ain't cutting it Do not recommend ! read more

Incredibly good pizza! Haven't had Johnny's in quite a while and we both agreed to start making Johnny's our choice for pizza night.

My "go to" restaurant and I eat there several times a week. Lots of variety in the menu to mix things up each time. Not only is the food great, but everyone working there makes me feel welcome every time. And they treat everyone that way (I'm there often enough to witness it firsthand). If you're old enough to remember the TV show "Cheers", it has that kind of vibe where "everyone knows your name". And Monday Night Bingo is lots of fun as well even though I never win. Hoping they will bring back Trivia Night. Great food. Great service. Great atmosphere. read more

Really great pizza. We use to go to a different location but we found this one. Very nice pizza and the crust was perfect. The ingredients were fresh and lots of them. The app wouldn't work that's the only thing I was disappointed in. But other than that a really great slice of pizza!! read more

Slow service. Won't even acknowledge you while you wait on them to serve you. Done with them. read more

I ordered the spagetti and meatballs. It was absolutely horrible!!!!!! The meatballs taste like, what I would imagine dog food taste like. Never again!!!! I will stick to their pizza only.. yuck!! read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

I noticed it the first time I went to Johnny's. I've only gone one time since, but it's a real big problem I have, and it's still... hanging over my head. The pizza is pretty good, don't get me wrong. But in an area with so many pizza, places with "good" fair, you have to be at least average in every other way. The service was hit and miss. I went one time, and there were three tables with two waitresses and, although my waitress was pleasant, and I can't say how things would have gone in the long term, because I only saw her a couple times. Well, I saw her, but it was standing on the other side of the room, talking with another waitress. The second time I went was during lunch, and my waitress was amazing. Pleasant, accurate, and fast. So, besides the two visits. Here's the problem. Johnny's is one of those places that hangs random stuff from the ceiling. I have no idea why they do it, but it is a constant point of neglect when the time comes to clean. I will bet a slice of pizza, at another place, that they haven't cleaned the dust off of those objects. There's a lot. The door was opening and closing frequently the second time I was there, and all I could do was watch for gunk to come snowing down onto everyone's food. It would have been like watching a car crash. You don't want to see it, but you can't look away. And if it did happen, would you tell the person? If you want Parmesan cheese to be the only white flaky stuff to top your pizza, as I said, there are a lot of other OK places to get pizza in this area. I can't wait to see what canned response I get! read more

We ordered on Doordash and the pizza is my kind of pizza! The boys usually like Pizza Hut, but everyone liked this place. The prices were twice as much, but I might have to splurge every once in a while. The Supreme pizza was good. We also got a Pepperoni and then I ordered half cheese & half olives and bacon, but the whole pizza came with olives and bacon. It's wasn't a huge deal, but maybe I should stick to calling in my order instead of entering online. (But this is the reason why I took off a star.) read more

Johnny's Pizza in Duluth is the best! We won't order anything else at the office - as a matter of fact - I do not have one near my house so I stop by on Friday's to take one home - Do yourself a favor and order the best pizza in the Atlanta area! read more

Hello Jeff Patrick the owner of Johnny's Pizza called me and he replaced it with a new one. I just picked up the pizza at 12-30 PM and it was very good. Jeff & Patrick,thank you for your wonderful customer service. Ann read more

This location has really stepped it up over the last few years. I used to come here and it was so so. I've been here 3 times in the last two weeks. The food is very good, the service has been excellent. They really seem to care in the back line. $4.00 drafts on Thursday is a winner and the music is always good. Both the female and male servers are on point. Glad to see the positive changes at Johnny's... read more

They have very good food there pizza hamburgers, sandwiches sub sandwiches and their services is really good. Excellent lighting plenty of seating. Free parking out in front. read more

Always great pizza! Never disappoints! Guys making pizza do a great job. It's nice to see familiar faces for years. Service is alway great when you dine in. Just good solid pie. read more

The food is great the person answering the phone sucks and the delivery sucked. Other than that I love the pizza

Johnny's is very quick and easy and dependable. The food is great, the staff is awesome!

Really a Bad Pizza I was in Atlanta over the weekend and decided to give Johnny's a try. Many positive reviews so I thought it would be a good pie. It had to be one of the worst I have had in many years. Forget the NY style because it was far from that. It had a very thick crust, unusually thick with some really poor cheese and sauce. This was a real disappointment The doughy mess was way undercooked but there was nothing that could fix this mess. Most of this pie was thrown out. read more

Great staff and service. Best pizza I have found around here since moving here in November. I have a long story, but trust me, I was treated fairly. read more

Johnny's is our go to spot for pizza. We have had most of the selections and are yet to be disappointed. Highly recommend.

Just did take out. Great pizza, clean location. Solid service: When host was on phone, another employee jumped forward to assist us and ring us up. Can't tell you how many other places just let customers stand there while 5 employees watch you. Would return. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Bacon pepper pizza - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

My party of nine came in after we couldn't find any other pizza restaurants open the day after Thanksgiving. Even though it wasn't our first choice, we were glad we ended up here. They were able to accommodate all nine of us with no problem or wait on the heated outside patio. We were comfortable, the server was attentive, the price was reasonable and the food was good. We had pizzas, salads and a baked pasta. They also serve beer and wine. We will definitely be back. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - The heated outdoor patio. - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia