This sub shop was a random find while driving east on I-80 through Pennsylvania. It was dinner…read moretime and we were getting hungry. I suggested looking up sandwich shops and of the list of places, Newberry Sub Shop, was the random pick. Located in a picturesque area of Williamsport, PA, and a decent trek off from I-80, Newberry is a local, mom & pop type shop that is popular among the locals. Their menu offers a nice variety of sub sandwiches which is what we were interested in. The shop is a counter-service type establishment. Menu is on the wall and also on paper near the ordering counter. There's a small dining area inside the shop and also, an outdoor seating area. We were taking our food to go. We ordered 1) cold Salami Sub and 1) Mushrooms and Bell Peppers Cheesesteak with cherry (hot) peppers. We also grabbed a local brand of spicy jalapeno flavored potato chips. We received good, friendly service. The staff was helpful to us in deciding what we wanted to order. The menu items were reasonably priced and you got good bang for your buck. The sandwiches were huge and loaded. Both the sandwiches were good. I got the cheesesteak and it hit the spot. The meat was well-cooked and flavorful, and the veggies and the cheese added a delicious taste. My only gripe about the cheesesteak was that the bread was very soft where the sandwich fell apart due to how hot (temp.) the cheesesteak was, thus making for a sloppy eating experience. But that's why you have utensils like fork. The Salami sandwich was also delicious. The chips were okay. They were a bit salty for my liking and not quite spicy. Overall, this was like a hidden gem of a find for us (since we were visitors passing by and not locals). I would like to have more of their other offerings. I am not sure when I'll be back in that area but suffice to say that I will be going back to Newberry when I return to this part of Pennsylvania in the future. Check out Newberry. Definitely recommended.

Small clean unassuming shop with great AC in the summer time plus nice round picnic tables with…read moregood umbrellas, and gorgeous flowers all around the exterior. The food!! We've been getting cheese steaks from here for years, though this is my first visit. Overflowing with yummy cheese steak, with fresh toppings to order on perfectly soft roll. We haven't tried anything else but surely it's aa good! They have a Pepsi fountain, both Utz AND Middleswarth chips! And a cooler of even more beverage choices. Plus well labeled recycling for the eco nerds like me. TIP: good food takes time. And they could run out. You can call ahead or we even used the website and it worked great! One very clean bathroom

Food is fresh and delicious with generous portions. The mocktails are hands down the best I've had…read morethus far. Service is friendly and attentive. The atmosphere is quaint small town coziness.

The exterior is old school Main Street character and I ended up driving right past it. I'll blame…read moremy GPS. Most of the parking seems to be metered with an actual quarter. Each coin giving one hour means 50 cents should be plenty. Passing by the outside seating made me wish I wasn't dining alone. I was seated promptly and narrowed my choices down to three sandwiches. The parmesan bruschetta Panini, the Milltown Panther, or the Marilyn Monroe. I ended up ordering the former and kept the original side of chips. If I was super hungry I would have ordered Mac & cheese for a side. The panini was super crunchy and toasted to perfection. The chicken was sliced appropriately sized and cooked well. The toppings were justice but not to the point it would ruin the crispy bread. I would visit again and get the one of the same three items I narrowed it down to this first time.

I eat there often. They serve breakfast all day long. I am a vegetarian. I am tempted by several…read moreoptions, but always end up picking my favorite which is a Sarah Scromlet. Sometimes my husband and I will also share an order of sour dough pancakes. They are the best. They are only offered for part of the year. I read the other reviews. Yes, sometimes it takes a while for the food to come. However, they have a small kitchen and staff, so sometimes there may be a wait, but it is worth it. The staff is friendly. Ever since Traci, the daughter took over, I find it extremely consistent and well run. I usually get a piece to take home. All the pies are made from scratch. The pie options change often due availability. So if you have a favorite one in mind, call ahead and ask to have it saved. Since they are owned and operated by a small family, I would suggest checking there hours of operation if you have never been there before. They also post often on Facebook if you want to see more.

Stopped here after three days backpacking the Loyalsock Trail. I had been dreaming of a plate of…read morepancakes...my dreams came true! The pancakes were huge, the bacon fresh and crisp, and the eggs scrambled perfectly. The coffee was delicious as well. Marking this place down for future post-hike meals.

I was at Knoebels and knew I wasn't going to feel like cooking when I got home, so my son and I…read moredecided to grab takeout. The staff was incredibly friendly. They had run out of one of the meats we ordered, but they more than made up for it by giving us extra of another meat they had available. The food was phenomenal! We chose the BBQ beans and mac and cheese for our sides, and both were absolutely delicious. My only small complaint is that the portions were a bit on the smaller side. That said, it definitely won't keep us from coming back. We'll absolutely be eating here again!

Ribs were great. Brisket was good. Sweet corn (on special) was phenomenal. Mac and cheese was…read moredecent. Great homemade bbq sauces to choose from. Service was great and super friendly. Nice tables to sit at. Cute little country store with handmade items and food connected.

It might not look like much but it's a great, quiet little place just outside Lewisburg on the…read moreriver. Plenty of parking , friendly service, good size portions. I had the brisket and pork. They shred their meats so don't get upset if your brisket isn't sliced. It can with the choice of two sides. I had a large mashed potatoes and asparagus. Selection of canned beer. They have an awesome dog. My only negative is that they are cash only.

I wanted to like the food but the meat didn't seem smoked or grilled. It was wet and shredded…read more The staff was nice. No card. But only the mashed potatos were really good.

They have great food and great service overall. I would totally recommend this place to anyone to…read moredine in and eat! Yummy

Dinner tonight was very good and we highly recommend it…read more Like previous reviews, we thought the salad was super simple and the baked potato was just average, but those are very minor concerns in our opinion. We had the stuffed pork chop with ham and bacon which came with a sweet and very tasty bbq sauce and some melted cheese. We also had a seafood dish that was stuffed haddock, shrimp and scallops. The stuffing we believe was crab and it was amazing. They ask you to make reservations but we walked in without on a Saturday around 6 and there was no problem being seated quickly. All the staff we interacted with were very nice and paid the right amount of attention to us. Prices were very reasonable and what was expected. They do pass on credit card fees to the diner if you choose to pay with plastic, but that feels like it is becoming more common so it was not a surprise. We will definitely return and anticipate another wonderful meal!!

Just tried this, wanted a hoagie on a long drive home, holy woah it was fantastic. My husband got…read morethe sausage, I got an Italian with all the stuff, loved how the Italian was a little tiny bit spicy, the sausage and peppers hoagie was also amazing from the bite I took from his. Definitely going to be a stop when we make this drive, we're both REALLY excited to try the meatball parm next time. Quiet little spot, great prices, I only wish it was closer to home so I could get it more often.

I got me a cheeseburger sub and it was quite scrumptious if I do say so myself. The chocolate milk…read morewas fire too.

Stopped by this little gem while traveling and was blown away with the amazing subs we had…read more Definitely going to make this a regular while passing through!

We've been coming here, at lease, once a week for close to 30 years so we know the taste well…read more Something's been changed since the new owner's have taken over. We not exactly sure what, but they don't taste the same. The mayo is watery and the onions or oil seems different. I think we may be looking for a new sub shop.