My husband and the kids love the pizza from Kate&Al's. It is kind of like a deep dish pizza, I've tried it as well and it's pretty good. It is tasty, crunchy but soft, it is really good. They are really busy, every time we call we get a weird time to pick up, we are not from the area so usually we would call 1-2 hours before the time we would pick up but they would have 4-5 hours from the time we called. So we decided to call right when they open and put in our order for the afternoon. They do not accept credit cards, so if you are in the Columbus/Bordertown area and want to eat some good pizza stop by Kate & Al's and make sure you bring cash with you. Also, they are located in the flea market area. read more

pizza was great..I was constipated for 7 weeks before eating a slice of this stuff.i was pooping in less that a minute..thank you al and kate.. id send a bowel movement picture but i cant figure it out read more

Yes, yes and yes! Delicious and perfect for as long as I can remember. One of best tomato pies I've had.

Kate & Al's Pizza is a must when you visit Columbus Market! The family that runs this pizzeria has been here for years, providing awesome customer service and the flavor has never changed! You will not regret your visit, the pizza is one of a kind and amazing. Save yourself the trouble of standing in line again for more- don't order less than a half a pie. If you go during the weekend expect a wait and long lines, but they always do their best to get slices out fast. Slices are served Sicilian style and on mini cake plates and pies are boxed. $2.25/slice (from what I remember) There is free parking at the market. read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

If you are at the Columbus flea market you must stop in and get the best pizza from the friendly, courteous, hilarious, world-famous pizza makers. You'll feel like you're with family. You just don't get this anywhere anymore. Great pizza, great people, great fun, Papa Kate & Al. It is worth the drive and if you have to wait, it's worth the wait. I recommend that you call ahead and show up when your Pizza Time is ready. They are famous in NJ for the delicious pizza and quick-witted staff (the staff is a lot more fun than meeting those people named Bruce Springsteen or Jon Bon Jovi). I reckon one visit here and you'll be back weekly - they are only open Thursday through Sunday. It is the best pizza, and I really can't say enough great stuff about the people who work there. Ask for a signature on your box because you'll eat the whole pie and frame the box. read more

See all

One of the best pizza places in NJ. Good Sicilian slice...mostly it's the good sauce; not a lot of cheese, so if cheese is your thing than this may not be your spot. read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - Plain slice - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

Really nice tomato sauce and mild cheese but not a big fan of the focaccia-like thick crust. Overall a tasty pie but not for me.

I am from New Jersey. I lived in Florida and Myrtle Beach for 7 years Was so happy to come back and get pizza at Kate and Al's I believe it the best pizza ... ever ... bar none ! read more

We've been waiting for years to get to New Jersey and taste this pie! With our family's help, we were able to finally get our hands on this pizza and truly it's the stuff that dreams are made of. Perfect, saucy, light on the cheese, thick crunchy crust almost like pastry. Holy tomato pie! I need to go back and get more. read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

The Pizza here is amazing. Enough sauce and cheese. The sauce has great flavor Some pizza places just use unseasoned tomato product out of a can and call that pizza sauce, not Kate & Al's Hands down . Worth the hour drive. read more

I've probably had over 500 different kinds of pizza from hundreds of pizza places over the year and this is by far the best. The sauce is the greatest. I wish the bottled that up and sold it. People will complain about the wait times for the pizza but that just goes to show you, a lot of people want it and if something is in high demand you are going to have to wait. Or get there early. It's places that don't have a line that you should avoid and Kate & Al's always has a line and for good reason. read more

Never disappointed. Worth the wait. Or order ahead online. Consistently good Classic Pizza

I never understood the hype of these pizzas but, to me, it's like eating a thicker slice of Elllio's.

This is typical South Jersey pizza. What's does that mean? In a nutshell, way too much sauce in the sauce to cheese ratio. This is a big problem I've seen with any place east of the Delaware and under 195. Kate & Al's does not escape this fate. My boyfriend, a Jersey bred person who resides in Columbus, told me that the big pizza place everyone went to is this place, so I was really excited to try them. While the pizza is good, it's underwhelming. The best part is the crust, which is thick and fluffy, but they lose me because of the amount of sauce dribbled on the pie. Plus the sauce isn't that good, it's too sweet without enough salt from the cheese to balance it. Oh well, I guess this is the best for the part of Jersey it's in. It's not bad, just not something I really care for. read more

Best slices. Hot hot all the time and fresh. Ladies serving never see them sweat.. service is fair and they keep you in line of order receipt read more

Not real pizza. Not good. Average for being in a marketplace. Convenient. Go up the road for true Italian pizza.

The only negative I can say about this pizza is that it's hard not to eat so much you burst. I usually love the corners of a Sicilian but somehow the centers are the most amazing slice of these. read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - Regular with pep - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

Unexpected deliciousness. Living in NYC, I'm snobby about my pizza. This isn't NY pizza. It's different. It's more like the mouth watering room temperature pizza they serve in Trattorias in Italy (but this pizza is hot). I would have taken a picture but I ate it too fast. Ambiance is not what this place is about so don't expect it. It's all about the ZA! Many folks were ordering entire pies to go (can you even call it a pie when it's rectangular?) read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

I am officially taking back my positive review. The pizza is not worth putting up with the rudeness and ignorance of the employees. If you want pizza at Columbus Market, walk down to the other end of the building and get it from Pete's. The pizza is just as good and the people are nice. read more

Definitely one of the top pizzas I've ever had definitely should try a slice while waiting for a pie because when you get a slice out of the oven it's real crispy on the bottom A lot of times when you bring the pizza home it gets soft on the bottom so I would recommend to throw a slice on the grill or heat it up in a frying pan to get that crispiness on the bottom sauce is great cheese is excellent definitely would recommend for everyone to try read more

This is literally the best pizza I have ever had. Located inside Columbus Flea Market, which is fairly run down, but that's part of the charm. Call ahead to order because they get super busy. This is mainly a take out place since the only available tables are in the walkway of the market. If you are in the area GO HERE. read more

This is the worst customer service ever. We waited 2 hours for pizza and when we came up they said someone stole our order... then made us wait AGAIN. The young cashier in the front DID NOT check for the ticket which caused the mistake and they tried to avoid telling the manager and fixing it themselves. You can guarantee I will be spreading the word about how you cant guarentee your order even after 3 hour of waiting. Way to go guys. read more

Kate & Al's is a little "hole in the wall" place reserved mostly for Columbus locals. From the outside, it doesn't look like anything special. But, don't let the plain-Jane atmosphere fool you. The pizza is incredible! Just the right amount of crispy, super fresh dough, chunky tomato, jussst enough cheese....You'll think you're eating a slice straight from New York! read more

I've been going to this take out classic pizza place for a super long time, never disappointed! People are great, pizza's even better!! It's not quite Sicilian, not as thick! The red pie's aren't loaded with cheese like regular pizza joints, it's just right! Enjoy read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - Broccoli cheese and garlic! As you see it's delicious! Definitely try it! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

Kate & Al's Pizza - mmmm, the very thought of it can make my mouth water. It's difficult to describe - kind of tomato pie, but not exactly...but you can always count on it being delicious. The crust is thick, then they add a layer of cheese, and on top is the most amazing sauce. Let me tell you, I got a big chuckle after reading another Yelper say this was "canned" sauce. Honey, if you can get that taste in a can ANYWHERE just point me in the direction on where to purchase cause I'm in for a few cases of it. Seriously. Bring your cash cause they don't accept credit cards. read more

Yum! I'm so happy they are still open through the pandemic! Order ahead this place gets BUSY!

I love this place. Cash only though. But omg, I could eat an entire pie myself. The sauce is sweet and the crust is perfect. Yum yum yum.

Probably the best pizza I've ever eaten. Now, I know pizza comes in all shapes and sizes. Believe me, I pretty much appreciate them all, but there was just something simple, yet pleasing about this pizza. Perhaps it was due to the fact that it just came out of the oven? I have no clue, but it was SO good. If I had to compare, I'd say it's closest to a Sicilian slice. Sauce is pretty bare bones, didn't really see any spices, but it was sweet! Cheese wasn't salty at all and melted to perfection. Each bite was as glorious as the next. The place itself is no frills, even serve you the pizza on happy birthday plates In no way does any of that effect the execution! Don't go in with any expectations and I'm sure you'll love it. read more

There's nothing really wrong with this pizza but I just don't care for it. It's nice and crispy, good flavor but I'm just not a fan. I wouldn't go out of my way for this pizza. I prefer a round pie with more cheese. Definitely give this place a try, if you haven't before, and decide for yourself. They can be super busy. I would recommend always calling ahead or ordering and then walking around the flea market. The service can be a bit on the rude side. Also, they only accept cash. read more

One of the BEST pizzas in the ENTIRE state of NJ. Great crust, and a very unique sauce that will make you a big fan, too! :-) read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - 'the legendary' Kate and Al's Pizza Pies :-) - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

Best pizza in NJ! Yes, there is usually a long wait and it is expensive, but it is totally worth it! I grew up eating this pizza every Sunday while the family walked around Columbus and still to this day it's my favorite pizza, ever! read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

Tradition every Sunday, I order via phone as soon as we arrive at Columbus, and once we are done walking around it's time to pick it up. It's cash only and a large pie is $18, so we always save a $20. Wait time is as long as an hour on football Sunday's. Order early and this is true even if you are there at 10am. It's actually worse earlier in the day. They open at 8am. Enjoy! read more

This is the best pizza in NJ by far. I've been coming here ever since I can remember and I am always greeted by warm smiles and great service. If you are ever in the Columbus area or even just in Burlington County, you have to come here read more

LOVE THE TOMATO PIE!!!!!!! My absolute favorite pizza place to eat at while in the east coast!

Gree up eating from Kat and Als. Best pizza around. Always love the girls working there. I travel over an hour sometimes to get it. Giants Mike they call me. read more

We've getting a large pie (take out) every Friday night for years. Many locals do. I see reviews complaining about time & service. The wait is because they are always busy with orders. (That should say enough right there) The service? Once again, they're busy. If you want a pizza in 10 minutes, go to a place with less business. ( FYI, 20 minutes to cook a pizza ) K & A make a great pizza. read more

Really fresh pizza and the sauce is always good. Best pizza in the area! The price is reasonable and the ladies making the pies are really sweet. read more

pizza is all hype I've had pizza all around the country I've had pizza in italy I've made my own and when I was told this place is the best I figured I'd try it. First pizza isn't pizza without basil it's why it was made the color of basil, mozz, and red sauce make up the color of the Italian flag it's why the food was invented so for you to serve a pizza without any hint of basil even in the sauce is an insult to the Italian culture. Second the sauce was raw and over done This pizza tastes like chuckle cheese pizza at best I think this place is only popular out of hype alone and the fact that nobody wants to admit they waited an hour and a half for a pie that Tastes like shit. For a place with four ovens to only put one pie at a time in each is honestly the first clue this place has no idea how to run a pizza place. Raw sauce No seasoning Undercooked crust Long line Let down read more

Went to pick up a pizza for take out because I ACCIDENTALLY called them instead of Pete's pizza. Well, they are by far the most disgusting group of women I have ever laid eyes on!!! No teeth, rude & dirty!!! Needless to say I told them I no longer wanted the pizza...went & waited 20 minutes for Pete's..if you're going to be gross in appearance at least be nice..Yuck. read more

Wow overpriced and I'm sitting with a hungry special needs kid who wants a slice of pepperoni pizza. They won't sell a slice with it on, even offered a couple bucks for him to give it to him. They could buy a whole bag of it for a couple bucks, so what is the issue. Hope owner reads this because his place sucks read more