I'm surprised by the bad reviews. They have, by far, the best sicilan in the area. You need to ask…read morefor it well done because they don't bake it enough otherwise. I dined-in once. The service was good and the pizza was good. Not NY or NJ but good for the area.

Up front, all my reviews are based on my expectation going in. That is; the best 5-star sushi I…read moreever got from a truck stop would fail if I were at Nobu. That said, Palermo's is a Pizza+ place strategically located outside a managed (vacation) community. From the top, the parking lot is a danger to get in and out as well as just navigating the trucks parked in front in unmarked spaces better suited for compact cars. You walk in the front door, facing the restrooms with dining room to the right and the bar / dining room to the left. We were not so much greeted as stared-at, like we were supposed to tell them what to do. We witnessed the same lack of kind control at the entrance by 3 other employees, as there seemed to be no one in particular who was meant to control front of house. We were early for dinner on a week day, about 4:30 pm, so the place was empty but for 3 men at the bar and a pait on the patio. Still it took a while to get menus. Then longer to get drinks. We just wanted to get a fresh pizza, which should have been a slam-dunk for a business that thrives on delivery into a gated community. We ordered the 'granma pizza' and an order of calamai. Again, it took 20 minutes to get the calamari, which was dreid out, possible from a heat lamp. The batter was light and crispy, but they had no flavor at all. Just a little salt/pepper would have given it flavor. We had asked for extra sause with them, that was forgotten. The 'granma pizza' which is simply square flat crust with sause and cheese took another 20 minutes. Maybe they got stuck peeling the plastic wraps off the cheese-like slices? At least that's what it looked like. The service was barely a notch above 'get it yourself!'. Which made the final cut such an insult. I've seen plenty of places list suggested tip calculations on the bottom of the check. Usually it's just a note in fine print showing you the math for 15, 18 & 20% - and hoping you add one of those or more, which since COVID, we always do. This roadside nightmare had the stones to print 4 check-boxes for you to choose - 20, 22, 25 and 30% !!! I did tip over 20% because we do, but that will be the last. I stopped short of a 1-star review, because, although Palermo's was a complete disappointment, that's all it was; disappointing on every level.

I always try my best to support local businesses, which is why I was really hoping to love this…read moreplace. The staff was friendly but unfortunately the pizza just wasn't for us. The cheese had an unusual taste, and something about the pies seemed off. The slices were also falling apart and really weren't edible.

Saw the menu in a local shop, nice cover and food descriptions looked good. I thought it was…read moredine-in and went to try for lunch when I had errands up that way. Location is in the middle of rural farm country. Looks like pulling into someone's private home. Tiny shop with only 3 outside tables. Woman at counter was very nice, but sorry, plain pizza ($3.50 per slice) was awful. Barely warm, greasy, thick, poor quality cheese and flavorless sauce. Crust kinda over baked but ok taste. Just a very strange experience.

The pizza was excellent!! It was fast, hot and so tasty! We moved to SC from NJ 27 years ago and…read morewe just cannot get pizza like this! The crust was amazing, the sauce, cheese and pepperoni was so good!! And the service was excellent, too! Next time we visit our dad, we'll be back!

Gone so far downhill it's almost unbelievable. Pretty much…read moreburnt. Ordered a plain cheese and a pepperoni. Both burnt. NOT GOOD

Great service. We do take out... small area for dining. Cuban sandwiches are the best!!read more

For a small deli shop in Hamlin Pennsylvania they know how to treat customers with dignity. From…read morecold to hot subs, panini or salads they can make just about anything you might desire. Personally I prefer the hot subs especially chicken with bacon and sautéed mushrooms, peppers, and onions. Normally not something you see on the menu and yet they excepted the challenge and successfully executed. Very small inside space so definitely take your order to go if you're going with a group. Parking is limited as well. Hope someday they can expand to a larger atmosphere until that time they still have my business always.

Love the food . The wing pizza is so delicious. It's Kay's hot wing sauce. Every thing I ever…read moreordered has been delicious.

All I can say is OMG the boneless wings in garlic honey sauce were AMAZING! My entire family loved…read morewhat they ordered!! The bartender was very friendly which made the experience great! We will be back to visit from NJ

Great food with large servings. Service is top notch too. This is a casual restaurant that won't…read morebreak the bank.

Met up with some people here as this is one of their favorites. It's just your regular joints to…read moreeat. But their Asian wings were actually amazing good. The rest is just eh' food in stomach n go home.

Just had their Penne Alla Vodka, Pizza and wings and I'm telling you right now... hands down the…read morebest I've had. The pizza was unreal flavorful, cooked perfect. The wings? Crispy, sauced right, and done exactly how they should be. On top of that, the order was done FAST and the employees were absolutely dynamite. Friendly, on point, and hustling. If you haven't tried that Penne Alla Vodka pizza yet, you're missing out.

Service was terrible. We waited at the register for 10 min while the staff behind the counter…read moreawkwardly avoided greeting us and not a single staffer even looked at us. We finally get the food and go home--salads are missing from our order. We decide to let it slide, but then we start eating. You would think that the LEAST they could do was make their food taste good, but no, absolute garbage. The penne vodka tasted like they used a dirty pan to cook it. I've never given a yelp review and this experience pushed me to make an account just so I can warn others. Please for the love of god start a different business outside the food industry. I would rate it a zero if that was an option.

We got there just past 12!. 9of the 10 tables were filled. Server was sweet and service was spot…read moreon. The bf ordered a cheese steak which was good but different than he was expecting. More like chop meat than minute steak. Still tasty. I ordered the loaded GIANT baked potato. Pulled pork w/bbq sauce smoked cheddar, sour cream, topped with an amazing amount of crispy fried onions.

The best best best gluten free pizza ever!!!! Friendly staff.... Love how they joke around with…read moreyou... every thing we tried was amazing... nothing bad to say.