Delicious and super cute!! First time ever ordering from Renos. I called to see if maybe They would make me a Heart shaped pizza to be extra corny on Valentine's Day and they came through. The pizza was delicious and fresh like a NY pizza. My hubby and kids were impressed with the heart lol yess I was so happy. I expected to pay more since I was such a pain in the a.. about this heart shaped pizza but nope the price was great read more

Reno's Pizza - Heart shaped pizza for Valentine's Day - Pizza Near Me - Hawley, Pennsylvania

when you can catch them open, the food is ok. closed the oddest times. pizza place in a summer resort area where you can't get pizza at 7pm on a Saturday in any summer month blows my mind. no idea how they're still in business. theyre "open" but don't answer phones and lights are off. read more

Delicious pizza! We're so glad we stopped here on our weekend away, and we'll come back if we're ever in the area again. read more

Reno's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hawley, Pennsylvania

Pizza and wings were good , crispiness in all the right places . Service was very fast , super chill spot.

Every visit from pizza to sandwiches and meals is filled with Excellent food. The Service is quick and customer service is excellent

Great pizza, the food and service was incredible in this small town. Would highly recommend making the stop if you're in the area.

Thanks to our neighbor in the cabin next to us he let us know on New Years places in the are get slammed and if you get through on the phones you better order 90 minutes early. With this tip was able pick up my food 90 minutes after ordering when they were closing up. Kudos for a good pie. Appearantly they are known for their Stromboli which was tasty sausage, peppers, onions with sauce on the side. Buffalo wings were solid and garlic knots were great as well. read more

See all

Cool place. I was mostly excited to see gluten free pizza AND Vegan cheese on their menu! Rare find for sure. It is hard to find a restaurant that offers vegan cheese, kudos to you! I never expected to find that offering in the mountains! Better yet, they use Violife Dairy Free cheese...this is the best vegan cheese! Thank you for being helpful and awesome! Vegan gf pizza was delicious! read more

Absolutely astonishing! Best garlic knots I've ever had and I'm from New York. Chicken Parmesan hero? TOP NOTCH! The hero was to die for. Packed thoroughly with crispy, perfect chicken and the sauce..amazing! The hero was loaded with mozzarella which led it to have an amazing cheese pull. The bread was crispy on the outside, soft and warm in the inside. I consider this a perfect semolina. I got some wings just to try, and it blew my out of my seat on the ground and knocked my socks off in awe of how tasty, crispy, delicious, and flavorful it was. Not to mention the prices? Best prices around! I'll consider it a bang for your buck. Highly recommend, 10/10! read more

Since they opened they hitthe floor running! After living in the Poconos for 30 years this NYC born gal finally found pizza she could eat! The best I have had in literally decades! Receptive staff! read more

I drive almost an hour and pass many other pizza shops to get to Renos . It's always worth it, always perfect . Staff is polite and fun no matter how busy they are . read more

By far the best pizza I've ever had, and I'm a fussy Italian cook!! Excellent service and the owner is a sweetheart of a guy. Love this place! read more

The pizza was just OK! The picture looks better then it actually is. Considering where we are, it's probably the best you can get in the area. read more

Excellent pizza sauce!!! Best pizza around! We do takeout so I really can't rate the faculty or service.

Hands down best pizza in the area! Pizza is always consitant, sandwiches and wings are terrific, and they deliver!

Love the food, wish dining area inside was open. Damm Covid. Love the food. Great staff. read more

I do not recommend. Far cry from " NYC" pizza. Ordered large meat lovers. Where was the meat? We didn't get any! Sauce is virtually sugary. I couldn't eat it. Pleasant staff, but wish the would mention when you order by phone cash only. read more

Excellent ordered twice and was pleasantly pleased each time. Finally New York style pizza restaurant in the Lake Region . read more

Reno's Pizza - Excellent pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hawley, Pennsylvania

Seriously tasty pizza! Has the perfect combo of crust, sauce, and cheese in flavors and quantity. Highly recommend!

Love, love, love Reno's pizza and chicken cutlet parmigiana! Great staff and delivery personnel, a personal go-to favorite.

It didn't take long for this perfect, Margarita/Pepperoni pizza to disappear. It's a very good one. New York thin with just a few drops of oil. Foldable, good NY pizza. read more

Reno's Pizza - It didn't take long for this perfect, Margarita/Pepperoni pizza to disappear. - Pizza Near Me - Hawley, Pennsylvania

Probably the best pizza in Pike/Wayne County. These guys must be from New York. Also hands down best calzones.

Piping hot NY-style pizza made fresh to order. Ridiculously delicious garlic knots . Great food and affordable family specials. Our 10 person family ate for under 100 bucks with two pizzas wings, garlic knots, mozzarella sticks and two liter bottles of soda. Nearly perfect meal (mozzarella breading needs a wee bit of seasoning ). Great service. read more

The best place for pizza in Poconos. My family loves their reign supreme pie, it's just the best.

Love, love, love Reno's! The foood, the people, the environment overalll pure perrrfection! The quality of food BEYOND PERFECT, I usually get the same thing and for me the consistency of my lil meal is exact, maybe some days a lil extra goood! The prices are another big factor for me as welll, especially living in a "tourist" town, the prices always change once the summer comes rolling along and I am happpy they don't up their prices like a lot of the places in my area, even through todays economy with literally prices rising left and right, I am happpy they don't kill us people! I work right down the streeet and I always recommend Reno's to my customers! read more

Best pizza spot you will find on the lake. Dined in the other night there and had the meat lover pizza it was excellent. Staff is courteous and attentive will definitely be back to try some of the other menu items aswell. read more

Reno's Pizza - Meat lover pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hawley, Pennsylvania

Never open. We tried to order a bunch of times but it was not open even on the weekend.

Order frequently from Reno's, amazing pasta, pizza & wings every time. Hours can be inconsistent & confusing, social media pages are not always updated for unexpected closures or business hours. read more

We ordered Reno's while on vacation in the area, it came highly recommended by our family. We ordered cheese pizza, cheesesteak, knots and antipasto salad. All of it was really good. I do wish the cheese and meats in the salad were sliced already, thankfully we were somewhere we could slice them ourselves. That's really the only thing I would've changed. This place is CASH ONLY, they do have an ATM on site, but keep that in mind. Overall I would recommend this place for some tasty pizza! read more

Reno's is a great place for pizza and Italian food. It's really close to the lake so that is great.

Our opinion; don't even think twice about buying their pizza . As an example, for the two of us, we recently ordered a small 8" pie. The standard pie was only cheese and sauce. We added on mushrooms and sausage. The basic price was $8.95 and the total was $14.00 + tax. It appears the cost of the add- ons were at least $2.00 each. Now comes the rip-off! The mushrooms and the sausage would not fit in two tablespoons. The basic pizza had VERY LITTLE SAUCE and CHEESE. And we live in the area! Will never return for any reason. read more

Highly Recommend!!! No other pizza parlors makes better than Reno's. Everything made with perfection. Thank you Reno's!!

We have never had a bad meal or experience here. We've seen many businesses go in/out of this location but this one is definitely the best. Great menu, friendly staff and they have gf and vegan options. Their pizza is delicious and they always satisfy. read more

Culinary pizza chefs are incredibly talented. The most amazing food and it's a carry out only for the most part. It's very busy for a reason great staff and food in a dive atmosphere. Cash only. read more

Apparently 15 minutes is too far for a delivery driver to make the trip worth while. Never calling again even if I can pick it up myself.

Excellent wings at a reasonable price. Pizza very good but unfortunately about 20% smaller than other Pizzerias in the area but still a good value at about $12. Long waits on Friday and Saturday should tell you that they are doing something right. read more

Only had twice, first time it was amazing but today i ordered a mushroom pizza and wings. They said it'd be an hour wait, which is fine, after waiting an hour and a half the wings still aren't done. After 15 more minutes the wings come out. The pizza was cold with hardly any mushrooms. Very upset today :( read more

Very interesting experience. Glad they offered gluten free options, and the woman on the phone was incredibly kind and friendly. Don't add any protein to a family sized salad if you don't plan on spending $40 for it. Family sized salad was $15.95 (menu online was a different price) and adding shrimp was apparently an additional $24?! The owner said adding the $6 shrimp to a salad was multiplied by 4 when added to a family sized salad, though the menu never stated it, and they didn't mention it when ordering over the phone. I would never spend $39.95 for a salad. Absolutely ridiculous, and the owner wasn't understanding or accommodating at all, even after an hour and 50 minute wait! (There was also a fly in the salad, which we sadly noticed after calling to complain.) read more

Good pizza and awesome sandwiches, I like the Philly cheese steak. We eat there often. Location is close by too.

A pizza small joint with young friendly staff, clean open kitchen in what it looks like a fresh renovated space. Those guys know how to do a great thin crust pizza : Dough is hand-stretched in front of you, all ingredients are fresh and tasty. The veggie pizza is really good, and the reno supreme will suit the meat lovers. Definitely a 5 star pizza joint, great value for money read more