I went with a friend to check out Kilcoyne's Friday night fish fry. They offer an all-you-can-eat cod dinner for $17.75 or lake perch for $27. So ... cod it was! The cod was tasty and came with mixed veggies, coleslaw and a choice of fries, tater tots or red potatoes. I chose the potatoes and really enjoyed them. We arrived at 4:30 and snagged the last table in the very small dining area. The bar was pretty full, too. As we ate, a line began to form at the door for people waiting for tables. We probably would have stayed longer and eaten a little more fish if not for the number of people standing basically right behind us waiting to eat. All-you-can-eat is a great offer, but with only a handful of tables inside, it's probably not the best business strategy. And honestly, the plate had a good amount of food on it, so we didn't *need* more anyway. Kilcoyne's is tiny and has a better menu than I'd expect for what seems like a dive bar. I'd try the fish fry again, or maybe something else from the menu. However, I would not be willing to stand in the crowded doorway waiting for a table. read more

Kilcoyne Redwood Inn - Fish fry! - American Near Me - Wheeling, Illinois

Yum perch fuss fry, the batter is sublime comes out piping hot. Red skin potatoes crispy on one side with a bit of garlic accompanied by steamed broccoli and cauliflower . Served with a sweet bun whipped butter and a tart coleslaw. The batter is wonderful, better than tempura . I asked the bartender perch or cod, hands down he ordered perch. It's wonderful. I can't get enough of that batter. That's all you can eat. I just ordered one platter and my boyfriend who hardly eats kept eating off my plate, but they're still plenty for two people with only one portion. I have to come back when I'm off on Fridays. It's really good neighborhood local bar if you like fried perch come here on Friday. read more

See all

Stopped by for a couple hours as my son had an event nearby. This place is amazing! The food is solid and all from scratch. I had the Saturday night special - fried chicken. Half a bird and 2 sides for less than $14. Seemed like everyone there was a local. And they were all exceptionally friendly. I made instant friends will all the old timers. I will definitely be back to this classic bar. read more

A place where everyone knows everyone... and everyone is friendly! Sat at the bar to watch a Cubs game... there were groups of friends having a beer, couples having dinner, and a very attentive staff (shout out to Jenna and Julie!). A BIG step up from the Old Munich Tavern in terms of food and atmosphere... will go again! read more

Kilcoyne Redwood Inn - American Near Me - Wheeling, Illinois

See all

The Friday fish fry was amazing; delicious and the service was fantastic! I love the "Cheers" vibe this place e has going on. The whole experience was great. I can't wait to come back! read more

See all

The ambience and food is mediocre. I would not recommend this restaurant for St. Patrick's Day or any other time.

Watered down drinks and 27.95 for perch. More than a restaurant Perch was ok. But not frozen vegetables.

I know I wrote a one or two star review for this place a year or so ago due to a snotty crabby bar tender/server. Even though I like the food here I said I was going to give this place a rest due to that. Hey YELP where is that review? Anyway I did go back recently with my wife and brother who was in town and wanted a fish fry and did not want to travel. Since Kilcoyne's is under 10 minutes from our home we decided to come back here and I'm pleased to say the crabby smart aleck tender/server was not there, so thankful. We got a table in the much brighter remolded dining room and was warmly greeted by the server who promptly took our bar order and asked if we were here for the fish fry which we told her we were. Even though the server was working the room of around ten tables by herself she was very nice and efficient. Our beers were always replaced and when we needed more fish it was brought out promptly. It was a very pleasant dinner and it was also very good. The coleslaw is killer and so is the fried perch. I think cod is offered as well but we all had the perch. I like the choice of fries, red potatoes and/or a veggie medley. The reason for four stars over five was the bill was screwed up. The bartender fixed it but it took a couple times. I'll probably come back again for the fish fry and the all you can eat corned beef on St Patty's week. Cheers! read more

Kilcoyne Redwood Inn - Perch fish fry, all you can eat! Larger fillets these days - American Near Me - Wheeling, Illinois

A friend of mine wanted to try Kilcoyne Redwood Inn, as he had driven by many times and had not been inside. Kilcoyne Redwood Inn is the very definition of a neighborhood bar. After I walked through cigarette smoke to get into the establishment, the first person to greet me was a regular. I felt very uncomfortable walking into a poorly lit tavern with that type of greeting. During my time there there were patrons at the bar yelling at each other, which just added to my unease. I asked the sever to sit in the back, away from the bar. The menu is very small. The kitchen was in the middle and visible. The good news was that the kitchen looked clean. I had the Bacon, Bacon, Bacon L & T Sandwich (our famous bacon sandwich stuffed with crisp lettuce, fresh tomatoes, creamy mayo and an insane amount of delicious bacon). While the sandwich did contain an insane amount of bacon and a generous amount of mayo, the bread was brunt and was very dry and stiff. There was an upcharge to French fries. The French fries were unseasoned and I had to add salt (something I haven't done in a long time). Our server was the only one serving in the entire restaurant, so the service was slow. I will not go back to Kilcoyne Redwood Inn and cannot recommend this bar and restaurant. read more

See all

This is one of the most chill neighborhood bars I've found on the North Shore, and the food is also good. I've been there several times, after a friend who goes there regularly recommended it. The first time we went was on a busy weekend night. We were seated at the only table available, which was fine, and were also told we could sit at the bar. We had sandwiches -- I had a patty melt and my husband had a burger. Both were quite good. Then we moved into the bar to have drinks, and that's where we really got a taste of the vibe here. The bartenders are friendly, as are the other regular patrons. I've had some great chats here with people who just happened to sit down next to us. My Manhattans are always prepared perfectly (thanks, Julie!), and my husband usually likes one of the beers they have on tap. We haven't been to their Friday fish fry yet (we've heard the lines are crazy long waiting, which isn't our thing) but we hear that's fantastic. Maybe one of these Fridays we'll get our courage up to either go really early, or go and wait. (One more note, after reading some of the negative reviews from those who've panned the place because they wouldn't let you take your fish fry leftovers with you, that's pretty standard for all-you-can-eat meals. You should only order as much as you can eat there, otherwise they'd go broke if they let people order an all-you-can-eat-here-and-at-home-later portion Please don't ruin it for the rest of us. The employee has probably had to regularly rip containers out of rude peoples' hands, so I can't fault her on this one. Maybe they could add an "only order what you can eat here -- fish fry leftovers can not be taken home" disclaimer or similar on the menu.) read more

Kilcoyne Redwood Inn - My Manhattans are always made perfectly, and are reasonably priced. - American Near Me - Wheeling, Illinois

Well run local spot that reminds me of the north woods. Not really a supper club, but feels Wisconsiny. Enjoyed the Friday fish fry, we were lucky to get the last available table, and the last parking spot. Ate and drank well here, clean and homey. It seems like there are a lot of regulars, but they were all happily minding their own collective businesses. Biz-nigh? It seemed like our server was either the manager or owner because he clearly cared about our well being. Thanks Kilcoyne! read more

Absolutely love this place. Best fish fry on Friday nights. Anywhere in the northwest suburbs. We brought our sister in law from Mercer,Wisconsin and she absolutely loved the perch! She said it was better than any fish she has had in Mercer. Could not believe the size of the portions and also that it was all you can eat. She is looking forward to returning in the Spring to come back to Kilcoyne's!!!!! Yay!!! read more

Phenomenal food! I travel with work almost every week and this was the best meal I've had in a while. I got the mozzarella sticks as an app and they were perfectly cooked. I was deciding between the ribs and fish and the waitress - who was excellent - recommended the ribs. She was right. They were truly fall off the rib but had thick, tender and moist amounts of meat on the bones. I got the onion rings as the side and they were great as well. I highly recommend the food and atmosphere here. The environment is friendly and accepting which is really nice to experience nowadays. read more

Saturday dinners always the best. Friendly staff plus great regulars and newbies always welcome read more

See all

Had such a fun time! Great service and environment! Oh and the food! The Prime Rib is fabulous!

Oh WOW! I tried the BBQ ribs for the first time. The best I've ever had. Tender and full of meat. I forgot to take a picture because I was so overwhelmed with the beautiful ribs I dove right in and thoroughly enjoyed. I'll get a picture to post next time. read more

Kilcoyne Redwood Inn - Absolutely the best BBQ bacon Swiss cheeseburger! - American Near Me - Wheeling, Illinois

Went there on a Friday night, arrived at 5:30pm didn't get seated for over an hour. The owner does not believe in first come first serve. He writes you name on a little pad and takes as needed. If a table for four opens up, that's who he seats. A party of 3/4/5. So if you are a 2, your wait will be, well you get the idea. The kitchen is very small and open to see everything. The Friday fish fry was very good and plentiful. Your choice of Cod or Lake Perch (all you can eat. Get there early read more

Kilcoyne Redwood Inn - a sign for fire island - American Near Me - Wheeling, Illinois

The food is fantastic. It is a neighborhood bar that reminds of my father's tavern on the west side of Chicago when I was growing up. The customers and owners are always nice. I tried the steak last night and it was excellent. Great place to watch Bears games. They have a Friday Fish Fry is excellent. Get there early. Prices are in line. read more

Ordered the ribeye steak dinner tonight and it did not disappoint! Perfectly cooked and delicious. So big I took half of it home. Next time my husband and I will split the dinner. If you haven't tried Kilcoynes yet, you are really missing out!! Juicy burgers, Friday fish fry, ribeye on Thursday. Something yummy every day of the week!! read more

My first time eating in at Kilcoyne's pub. Really enjoyed an incredible Irish brisket dinner for St Patrick's Day. A delicious and healthy portion. One of the best Irish Brisket dinners I have had in years. The service was fast and friendly. The atmosphere was great fun, really festive, lots of St Patrick's Day revelry. Enjoyed the Irish music selection all night. Will go back again soon. read more

I wasn't expecting this place to be a "bar" in the front and a little cramped in the back but they make it work. We went for the fish fry Friday. It is a great deal - unlimited fried fish - cod and perch, and a side. The cod was my favorite, so so good! The fries, tater tots and onion rings were great! There was a steak special - $30 for 24 oz ribeye. I ordered it and it was cooked perfectly - medium rare. It was delicious. Our waitress was also very good. She was attentive and very friendly! I know we will be back!! read more

Omg the food is horrific!! Also, they use an incredibly cheap cut of corned beef so tough (like rubber) for SPD and the worst sickly sweet junk desserts, probably from dollar store. Stay away... read more

Food is real good bar food, hamburgers, fish fry, Ruben but no salads. Bar reminds me of Cheers everyone friendly and locals.

The people here are really nice. But there burgers Are amazing the best burgers I every had. They Have a bunch of tv's. Is probably the best bar/restaurant I've ever been in. I definitely recommend this place. read more

Literally the best grilled cheese and bacon I have ever eaten. Sandwiches come with fries, chili is yummy and server is super attentive. For a hole in the wall the women's bathrooms are clean. read more

Wings and tots were great. Beer was ice cold. Prices very reasonable. Very clean and bright. Good place to watch a game.

Great appetizers, burgers and Sammie's. The grilled cheese with 3 cheeses, bacon and tomatoes is worth a try. The service is great too!

The loaded grilled cheese is to die for. Great ambiance and service. Server was a just delightful!

Food was awful. Kitchen was out of everything at 7:00 pm. Ordered soup it was salty and watery. Service was good. Wont go back

Always go for the corn beef and cabbage on St.Patricks Day. Just as good as ever. For a divey bar it is clean and the food is good year round. read more

Fish fry on Fridays is the best. Great pour in the cocktails as well. Old school ambiance

Horrible... we asked for a box and the waitress said "sorry we don't give boxes out becuase your supposed to finish your food" and we got up and grabbed a box and the waitress took it out of my boyfriends hands and elbowed him in the rib while grabbing it. Very disrespectful. Oh and, while we were waiting for a table we were standing up waiting for 45 min and then we finally decided and said ok we will just sit at the bar. Ridiculous. read more

Great neighborhood spot. They have a small dining area. Tables are really crammed into a tiny area. It's an effort getting in and out of your chair. The bar is packed. That being said, fish fry is delicious! The cod is hot, crispy, and delicious. It's served with red skin potatoes, vegetables, cole slaw, and a dinner roll. The cost is very reasonable. This reminds me of Cheers where everyone knows your name. If they could fix the crammed dining room, I'd give this place 5 stars. But for now, 2 stars for atmosphere, and 5 for food. read more

We went for the St. Patrick's Day special which did nothing for me. I must say the Bailey's Irish Cheesecake was off the charts great. Go out of your way for that if you are in Chicagoland. read more

Had such a nice time here for their Friday night fish fry. The place is small but they know how to handle a crowd without making anyone feel rushed. The bar was nice and cozy with perfect drinks! The fish is so fresh and delicious too. I can't wait to come back and try other dishes too read more

Some of the best food I've had and great staff. Definitely recommended this place to anyone who's visiting town or looking for a new place to relax and eat read more

Great atmosphere and killer burgers .I drive from the city just to get a burger sometimes. We love Joey and his wonderful place. Don't miss out. read more

Friday night fishfry was awesome had the per h side scallops and veggies. Can't say enough about how good it was. Got bad taste only when tall man bartender short changed me on 2 16oz beers. Went from 3.50 to 6.25 in minutes. Keep your eyes peeled.. read more

Food, service and ambiance is just like a hometown Wisconsin bar with great people. Just a FYI: You save gas money not having to go to Wisconsin read more

Service was TERRIBLE!!! We waited 45+ minutes for a table and never got one we ended up sitting at the bar in their uncomfortable bar stools. We then had to wait another 20 minutes just to get our order taken!! The best part was when we where leaving the waitress said we can't take any food home in a box and we thought she was sarcastic because every other restaurant allows you too, so I grabbed a box which they conveniently left out right in the front. After we paid and were waiting for our card I put the food into the box and the waitress comes over and began to reach around me ELBOWING ME in the process!!! She then attempted to grab the box and rip it out of my hands yelling at me saying that I'm disrespectful and my people ( I am African American man/Black man ) aren't welcome here!!! Absolutely the most cruel and unusual treatment I have ever had from a restaurant in my life and I will never come back to this wretched place and honestly this has scarred my experience with people who resemble her. Please save yourself the heart ache and physical abuse and racism that this place dishes out. NEVER COME HERE!!!! read more