Some of the best ice cream I have ever had and the best we had in Key West. Highly recommended!

The boyfriend and I wandered into Kilwins as we were making our trek down Duval Street. I was in the mood for something sweet and this place just looked right. I tried a sample of one of their salted caramel fudge, and it was divine. I really wanted a pound of it but I knew I would consume it too quickly (I have self-restraint issues) and most likely die, but that was probably the best fudge I ever tasted. I wandered over to the ice cream and discovered that they had salted caramel ice cream. Oh yes please, a few scoops in a waffle cone, that was heaven on earth. I'm a big fan of salted caramel and Kilwins did it perfectly. And the waffle cone was still warm and so fresh. It's a good thing I don't live on Key West, or I'd be 400 pounds. The boyfriend got chocolate fudge ice cream in a cup (so unoriginal :P) and really enjoyed his. If you like sugar and joy and happiness, go get something at Kilwins. read more

Great milkshakes and amazing chocolates. My girlfriend used the phase "super freaking awesome" to describe the place. Great find in KW read more

Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge - Front window - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Service was awesome and all that,, but ehat really crazy was the fudge.. I bought the toasted coconut and original turtle fudge. Sugary heaven on tongue. Coming back for more if we do visit kw again read more

Best Ice cream in Key West!! We walked in here on whim while looking for late night ice cream. I had the raspberry ice cream with sprinkles and my fiance had milk chocolate chip. I also got 4 chocolate covered strawberries (I'd pass on those the strawberries were too mushy) and a box of chocolates with caramel in the middle with a sprinkle of sea salt. I am hooked!! We went back the next night before we left the island to get another box of chocolates (don't judge me) and I wish we got more. I actually tried the sea salt ice cream the next night and it was so good! Right now, I am craving those chocolates. I have bought 2 different brand here in Mass, and they are not even close! read more

They have wonderful homemade sweets here. The sights and smells of them making the goodies make it just about impossible not to try something. The ice cream is very good also. read more

They have the best chocolate and ice-cream ever. The staff are extremely nice. Loved it!

This place was actually making fresh fudge when we showed up. We did the 2 for 1 special on the fudge and got the key lime, cookies and cream, and toasted coconut and it was all very good--kinda expensive but u get what u pay for. We also got a waffle cone with ice cream and it was very good. I would definitely return and or recommend to others. read more

Great store! Amazing ice cream and the chocolates and fudge are awesome. Staff and owners are friendly and very helpful. A "must" stop anytime we're in Key West. read more

Whatever you do, do not going to Kilwins if you've smoked pot. You will leave significantly poorer. Ok, seriously, Kilwins is awesome. Their candy apples take me back to my childhood (well... the good parts) and their ice cream is the best in all of Key West. The staff is friendly, the pace is spotlessly clean and I love them. read more

It was worth the 20 min walk from our hotel. It's just like any other Kilwins I've been to. We got ice cream and some mixed chocolate loved it was right in the center of all the busy things going on. Easy to find. read more

Customer service was excellent! We sampled a few diff fudges and ice creams. We decided to take caramel pecan covered pretzel back to the hotel for snacking. What a disappointment! The pretzels was NOT sweet. As a whole and with all the toppings, one would assume it would be super sweet. NOT! We have come to the conclusion that the pretzel had been sitting there for quite some time b/c the inside was almost like an old shortbread cookie w/out the crunch. What a disappointment. We were planning to return for the ice cream, but will pass and go to a different place. Two stars are for the sampled fudge. read more

The smell of this place will draw you in. So intoxicating. Super creamy and rich ice cream! So many flavors! Perfect for a hot day. A wide variety of goodies like chocolate covered Oreos, taffy, FUDGEEEEE, and many other chocolate assortments that you can buy by the pound. read more

Missed having one near me. So, being in Key west, had to have it. Their toasted coconut ice cream is everything(haven't seen this flavor anywhere else). But in addition to great ice cream in great flavor, their waffle cones are incredible. read more

Stopped in three days ago for a chocolate shake....not bad, but at $9.95 expensive even by Key West standards....Matthesons' is just as good and cheaper and a locally owned place.... read more

Should you really have to wait ten minutes to get helped with only two other customers in the store? No, didn't think so. I'll admit I didn't get any fudge, and it did look yummy. I opted for a two-scoop waffle cone of NOLA pralines and salted caramel. OK but not spectacular. As we were walking up Duval toward home, a lady with a cone full of custard from that other frozen treat spot declared, "Mine's better than yours." I couldn't argue. read more

Toasted coconut with caramel sauce is UNREAL. If you like coconut, dooooo it! The s'more flavor was my second choice, also delish!

Followup to Matt M of Kilwins Key West. My husband and I were there about 5pm on 18 Apr making a sizable purchase. We always get a military discount and when asked your manager that day was very rude. She said this time I'll give the discount but not next time. The original clerk that waited on us was excellent and very nice. read more

The people who worked there were really kind. The ice cream was great but the wait was long because beside that the people were nice the kept ignoring that we were there and let people cut us. read more

Best ice cream in Key West. Sample the unique flavors. Smell the waffle cones and fudge as you you walk thru the door. Excellent service!!

We walked in because of the delicious smell that was wafting out of the store and into the street. When we walked in they had tons of selection to choose from. The place is extremely clean and all the items are highlighted in clear glass displays. While I was there employee were making different candies and treats, so everything is very fresh. On one of the employees recommendation I got a apple pie carmel apple. The green apple is dipped in a homemade carmel and then redipped in while chocolate and then rolled in cinnamon and sugar. I had the apple cut into slice to enjoy when I got home. Later that night I bought it out and the apple was still super crisp and the carmel was amazing. I also got a white chocolate dipped pretzel which was pretty standard. The best thing I had was a carmel dipped pretzel rod. The carmel is the best I have ever had. It almost melts in in mouth and doesn't stick in your teeth like most carmel. I cant wait to sneak back in here and try something else! read more

Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge - Yum apple pie caramel apple - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Delicious ice cream and fudge. Have been trying to convince my family to allow me to return for more! A little expensive, but terrific staff and service. read more

Great ice cream. Would give it five stars but it is so pricey!

I am sad to write a bad review since they were so pleasant. My fiance and I tried 4 different flavors. I couldn't eat either of mine, I ended up throwing them both away after walking around for awhile and feeling bad. My fiance ate his but was not happy. We went to Flamingo Crossing afterwards to make up for it. read more

If Kilwin's was the last thing I ever ate, I would die happy. I'm a caramel corn junkie, and this place can't be beat. Chocolate covered graham crackers! Chocolate covered nutter butters! Chocolate covered Oreos! Oh man, the caramel apples!!! There is just too much to rave about. read more

Toasted coconut ice cream. Freakin delish. My husband had the caramel and he loved it. Smells amazing and the staff does not hesitate to give tasting samples! read more

Mediocre chocolates would probably only warrant a three star review, the fact that they charged me the wrong price, really frustrated me.

Great ice cream and chocolates! Ate more than my fair share during our trip to Key West.

Tried some fudge and a couple of ice cream flavors. Definitely very good though maybe not the best I've ever had. The prices were high for what it seemed like we got. But overall would recommend it. read more

The chocolate malt shakes are beyond amazing and the turtle marshmallows are my new ultimate favorite treat!!

Great ice cream and other goodies. This is our fav place every time we visit Key West. Everything is excellent. Yummy.

Ice cream and fudge are good but Iced Mocha is nasty. It tastes like a diluted hot chocolate. Tasted nothing like mocha.

The service here was great. The owner & staff encouraged me to try several flavors & looked into their ingredient list to find out which flavors were eggless - most were! Their nutcracker sweet is also nice. A good place for ice cream & sweets in the main tourist area of Key West. read more

Unfortunately, Matt, that was our first time in Key West, and our commute from Indiana doesn't allow regular visits. So sad! I can guarantee we'll come see you again if we ever make it back to Key West! read more

Great stop for ice cream and a sample of their delicious fudge. Staff are very nice and accommodating!

We love Kilwins in general, but the woman who was working there the night we went in must have been having a bad day and was clearly not happy to have customers. And it wasn't even late when we went in, but the ice cream was good though! read more

Saved us from the heat the AC is amazing and we got some refreshing treats. With the humidity in key west it's like swimming in a pool. Definitely a good stop when exploring around. read more

Kilwins is one of the best place, other than Better than Sex, to have desert. Must try the Milk Chocolate Cashew Bear Claw.

Good, high-grade chocolate. We tried to stop by the day before, but there were two cruise ships in, so the store was too busy. The day we went (on a Monday, no ships), was very enjoyable. We got to talk with the owner for a bit, enjoyed samples, and purchased a fair amount. read more

$5.50 per scoop of ice cream and $8 for a small milkshake...was so so so disappointed with this place. The ice cream was good but not for the price. You are paying for the location (on Duval street), not even a place to sit and eat your ice cream. I got a scoop of cookies and cream and a scoop of apple pie ice cream in a dish. My husband got the coconut milkshake. Has a lot of different flavors and you can taste them before you buy which is nice but still... was NOT worth $19. read more