Ambiance: (5/5) Great seating (booth, table, and bar). I loved the branding on some of the tables. Price: (4/5) Prices seem average for the area. Food: (4/5) I liked the garlic bread but I was expecting more garlic. I liked the buffalo tenders. I was glad they were soggy with the sauce. The pepperoni pizza was great (a bit on the oily side). I loved that it was super thin crust. Service: (5/5) Great service! read more

See all

Ordered thin crust pizza. Was great but should have specified to have it well done. Service was great. Old time look. Would definitely return. read more

Love the place the atmosphere and food! The only reason I don't give it 5 stars is because even when you have a reservation there still a long wait, place is small but it would be nice to accommodate who has a reservation faster. Really good pizza it's a must try for sure. read more

This iconic restaurant has been inRamsey New Jersey, just over the New York border for many many years It hasn't changed inside at all for years basically. Went there last night. Have been there before of course. Wanted to wait out the rain after going to the movies in Suffern, New York Lafayette Theatre to see Godfather II Even Tho it was very crowded . I only had to wait about 10 minutes for a table . I Ordered medium pizza with mushrooms and sausage. Came out in about 12 minutes beautiful fresh nice sized mushrooms fresh indeed . it's always bad when a restaurant serves canned mushrooms because they make the pizza wet. Not here sausage also very good. The sauce is flavorful A little sweet good balance with the sauce I like that very very thin crust, crunchy. Suggestion You should let the pizza cool down a bit before you eat it because the toppings can slide off when it's too hot. The only criticism there was not enough cheese on the pizza even though it looks like it was . This doesn't happen when you get a cheese pizza but when you have a few toppings, the cheese is a little bit light, However this IS delicious fresh pizza great atmosphere. They have a pretty extensive menu but I've only tried pizza and once I had a meatball Parmesan hero, which was very good I would say probably stick to pizza and hot heroes like sausage Parmesan meatball Parmesan BIG thumbs up to this place, I go here often after I see a movie at the Lafayette Theatre in Suffern celebrating ITS hundredth anniversary this year. So make sure to come to this iconic "joint you won't regret it. read more

Kinchley's Tavern - Big crowd - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

See all

I have been going here since i was a kid, and at 4 yrs old, and 25 yrs old, the quality of the pizza has stayed loyal to the recipeand delicious! They still have all the train-cars around the building (great for a game of ISpy if you have kids), and the checkered tables bring me back. The service is great, still is a great family owned bar style pizza place. I recommend the egg cream (chocolate is best!) i still like to venture out with a new appetizer once in a while, but 10/10 pizza, 10/10 ambiance! read more

Kinchley's Tavern - Eggplant Rollatini - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

See all

Where to start.... my husband raved about this place, said it was the best pizza ever! PROS: 1. Small and Homey 2. Waitresses were very nice CONS: 1. Staff person who sat us, seemed like he didn't want to be bothered, and put 4 grown adults in a small booth and let me tell ya, the Booths were VERY SMALL we are not fat people. 2. Pizza was too thin, tasted like cardboard, not flavorful like pizza should be, couldn't taste garlic, basil, no spices. 3. Couldn't get a drink refill to washdown the cardboard pizza - thankfully I had water in my car. I'm not really ever gonna go back. read more

This is a fantastic place. It's so homey, like stepping back in time. Start with the homemade meatballs and then order everything else. It's all good - you won't be disappointed. read more

Had always herd good things about this place. I wasn't disappointed. Service was great. Staff was friendly and helpful. Pizza was good as well. O did takeout. Next time I will try dining in. read more

Rare 5 Star Review What a wonderful place! This place has every box checked. Old school business that been around for over a half century. Beers served in small old fashion glasses, drinks served the same. Old school bar on one side and a sit down spot on the other so you do have to be near kids if you don't want to. Cool witty clientele who are friendly and funny. Now for the best part, delicious bar style thin thin pizza. Cooked perfectly served on old pizza pans and paper plates. A real old fashioned pizza pub serving delicious food at extremely reasonable prices. Drinks can get pricey. You just don't see places like this anymore. Tip: You can't miss the horse on the front of the building. Love Kinchley's!!! Thanks read more

See all

After hearing for years that Kinchley's Tavern serves the best thin-crust pizza in Bergen County -- maybe even in NJ and NY -- I finally made it in. It absolutely lived up to the hype. The thin crust is exactly what you want: crispy, light, and perfectly balanced so every bite has that ideal crunch without feeling heavy. The sauce has great flavor and the cheese-to-sauce ratio is spot on. We also ordered the fried ravioli and mussels, and both were excellent. The ravioli were crisp and flavorful, and the mussels were fresh and well-seasoned. You can tell this place has been doing what it does for a long time -- it's consistent and done right. Casual, no-frills atmosphere, great food, and definitely worth the trip. Already looking forward to coming back. read more

Great service and food!!! They know how to make a well done pie! Huge list of appetizers, do yourself a favor and make a reservation. It will save a few minutes waiting. read more

This restaurant honestly has the best pizza I've ever had. It is thin which allows me to have more than just one slice and the pie that I have can actually taste good . But a pizza place is nothing without a good atmosphere but Kinchley's has that right too! It is the perfect lighting, the perfect retro vibe, and beautiful decorations. The workers are also so kind between the short wait and the good recommendations. Over this is the best pizza place ever. read more

The place has the decor of a standard pizzeria which is totally fine. The service was fast but honestly not very hospitable. I felt very rushed inside the restaurant and was asked if I was done while I was literally eating additionally was not asked if I wanted dessert or anything they just slapped the check on the table and walked away. The place is also cash only so keep that in mind. The food was mixed. I ordered the stuffed mushrooms as an appetizer and the meatball parm sandwich for the entree. Stuffed Mushroom ($10) - would honestly not recommend this. The mushrooms were extremely soggy and the stuffing basically fell out of them as soon as you touched them. The stuffing itself was a soggy mix of bread and sausage which was the texture of unappetizing goop. Meatball Sandwich (17$) - this is the entire reason to go. The meatballs are homemade and are extremely good. The bread is crisp and as a whole the sandwich is really delicious. Would 100% order this again and recommend. Though honestly based on my experience sitting down I would probably recommend to just order the sandwich for pickup and bring it home. read more

if you're not getting the pizza what are you doing?? Family spot, feels like home. Go here read more

Kinchley's Tavern - Fra Diavolo & Regular - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

The pizza is really good, so it's not the food that's the problem. It's just not at all the right atmosphere for an autistic person. Both times I've been here I've ended up very stressed out from how crowded, noisy, and packed in everything is. Not to mention the constant voice on the loudspeaker. The place is a nightmare for the ever increasing autistic population. Not their fault, I just can't go back or will door dash only if I'm in the area, lol. read more

I finally made it to this comfy ambiance - cash only - pizza was on point and the service was very comforting. Definitely go and try and even take out! Don't miss out on this little place either dine in or out read more

Kinchley's Tavern - Breaded Chicken Cultet pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

See all

Being from Chicago, I'll say the pizza was good. A very light sauce. I'd do that again. But the French onion... SPOT ON! I mean on the money. I travel plenty for business and if French onion is on the menu I gotta do it. This one does not disappoint. read more

Kinchley's Tavern - French Onion Soup Au Gratin - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

I know they've been around FOREVER but no reason to slack. Ordered medium pizza. OK fine, its thin pizza BUT see through for $11.50. Chicken parm with salad instead of pasta. Iceberg lettuce in a small bowl with not so much as even a tomato. And clean the floors under the tables so customers dont have to have food stuck to their shoes when they leave. Second and last time!!! read more

This place has been around for nearly 100yrs for a reason. They make great pizza as well as food. My go to pizzas are the fra diablo w bacon and the mushroom, onion, sausage ( I add garlic). Service here is always courteous and prompt, at least it has been for me. The ambiance well it's no frill but has such charm to it that it's exactly how you would want a place like this to look like. Make sure to leave room for dessert if they have the Kentucky derby pie. Oh almost forgot, make sure to get the meatball app (so damn tender and flavor pack read more

Kinchley's Tavern - Mushroom , Onion And Sausage Pizza (garlic too) - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

See all

Service not with a smile. Have been coming to Kinchleys with my family since the early 1990s. Walked in today and the first words out of the hostess's mouth were " did you make a reservation?" No we did not. As I looked around there were 7 tables occupied out of about 20 (yes I counted). We then asked if we could sit in a large booth. Hostess retort was "well how many of you?" To which we replied 4 adults 2 kids. Hostess replied with "well how long are you going to be?" To which we replied not long. And we weren't. We were in and out in 50 minutes. Anyway, finally sat down but the whole encounter left us feeling a bit off. Our waiter however was wonderful and efficient. Drinks and food delivered quickly and the bill was only $47 before tip. I drove almost 30 minutes to eat at Kinchleys. Next time I decide to do so I'll make a point of calling for a reservation. read more

Kinchley's Tavern - Bacon pizza - super thin - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

See all

This was honestly one of the best pizzas I've ever eating and I'm not even exaggerating when I say this. The crust was super thin and they loaded up the toppings on this pizza. It was so delicious. The toppings were also really high quality and tasted wonderful. So happy I decided to stop in and try them. Worth the drive to get there :) read more

See all

Great food and service. Been this way since opening. Much thanks for your dedication to providing an enjoyable place to dine.

Billing itself as 'Lively, checker-tableclothed tavern & pizzeria doling out ultra-thin-crust pies in unassuming digs' Kinchley's did not disappoint. A Jersey pizza joint with excellent waitstaff, solid beer and cocktail list and very tasty thin crust pies. There was a bit of a wait but it was worth it. Felt a little like stepping back in time in the best of ways. read more

See all

Best around!! I drive some distance just to get food from here. The pizza and all the food is absolutely Delicious!!! Been a customer for many many years. I recommend this resturant to anyone that loves Italian food and thin crust pizza. read more

My time at Kinchley's Tavern is one of my favorite pizza experiences. When I entered, the place was busy with activity. The seating area was packed with families enjoying Sunday Pizza. I managed to get some seating at the bar. The classic, wooden bartop is a staple in all good taverns. The bartender and staff were very friendly. They recognized and conversed with regulars and were very attentive. I started with a glass of Kinchley's Red Checkered Ale while I enjoyed the wall decorations. These consisted of street signs, famous sports stars, photos, model trains, historic photos, and excellent quotes like, "the truth comes out when the spirits go in." The pizza came out super fast! Now that's good service. The Original featured a cracker-thin crust, the epitome of a classic bar-style pizza. The sauce and cheese were fresh and delicious. The Vodka pizza had some of the best vodka sauce I've ever experienced. Both pies featured plenty of cheese that melts over the the side of the crust and chars in the oven. Each pie had a perfectly toasted base and crust with good structure. I had a truly enjoyable time eating pizza at Kinchley's Tavern. I highly recommend everyone give this place a try - just don't forget to bring cash! read more

Kinchley's Tavern - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

Great friendly Italian restaurant. Warm inviting place. Enjoyed our Italian dishes of eggplant, raviolis and thin crust pizza. Plenty of parking. read more

See all

Upset I don't live closer. I had a pizza with ricotta and breaded eggplant about 3 months ago. Every day since, I have thought about it. I ordered a creamsicle float and they brought it to me in a 40oz Oktoberfest glass. It was so comically big that people were coming over to the table to look at it and ask me what in the world I ordered. I felt important. French onion soup was good. Salads were good. The cannoli raviolis were TERRIBLE!! They obviously get a pass but these shouldn't be sold so bad!! Another cool thing is you can choose Original or Fra Diavolo sauce when ordering your pizza. Love the food love the atmosphere. Can't wait to go back. read more

See all

this spot is very packed and a big hit with families too. there is a bar area with bar seating, but not many. i grabbed the dessert ravioli which are a must get. theres only 4 in the order, but they hit the spot and are unique. the vodka pie was my fave, but beware, its super salty. 2 slices max for me. get a beer in hand to chug it down. we got the garbage pie and i didnt get meat on my side. i didnt love this. to be honest the veggies were over powering and messy. the regular pie wasnt bad, but again, a bit salty and sweet with the sauce. id come back and try more of their unique sauces. ps their house beer is good. read more

Best thin crust pizza , service is very good there is a bar with drafts. We had a great experience and will be back again

We have been frequenting KINCHLEY'S since the late 60's....have moved several times, traveled extensively and tried pizza and Italian food at dozens of similar restaurants - including those fawned over by critics et al........for us KINCHLEY'S is still the undefeated champ - particularly THE pizza. Staff is great, prices reasonable and food is great. There are a couple of copycat pizza retaurants locally but thrvOG is by far the best. read more

Wonderful experience with old world charm and delicious food. The ambiance is casual with white and red tables and lots of wood, and the service comes quickly when you enter and are seated. Tables fill up quickly so get there early or be prepare to wait (I was there for lunch in this case). 2 pizzas plus an appetizer delivered the perfect amount of food for three of us. Can't wait to go back. Note - it's cash only so be prepared! read more

I read all about the hype. Pizza was good nothing like nyc but good but the service was awful. Our waiter had an attitude from the beginning!! read more

We live down south... We were visiting and we tried Kinchley's, the pizza was amazing... My husband. Wanted to eat there every night... I would highly would recommend! read more

If I could rate the vibe, decor, service separately, this place is a 5. Once you introduce the pizza, it gets brought down to a respectable 4. You have to respect this place. It's one of a kind, been around forever, and is a fun, family friendly place with a bar in the back, and the same wood paneling since forever. You should try it at least once, and I could easily see myself coming here if I lived closer. We got the buffalo wings (different, not in a bad way), and a plain pie half pepperoni. They have some really fun options too, which might be worth trying in the future, but when I go to place for the first time I always have to try the plain. The sauce to cheese ratio is pretty good, the crust is thin and crispy. There was ALMOST too much oregano, but that is a personal choice. If you like a sweet oregano-ish sauce, you will not be disappointed. read more

See all

Service fast fast .. pizza was good.. We asked for a refill of soda and the waitress says "no we don't do refills" to which we said ok! ( we weren't asking a free refill) Then she seeing my small bottle of WATER! And says " we don't allow drinks brought in" I told her it was just water, she says it doesn't matter we have a bar here so no drinks can be brought in!! Just was a rude experience! read more

Still amazing pies and friendly folks here. Bummed our last pick up order had a topping missing from one of our pies. We should have checked our order before we left, but by the time we got home, it wasn't worth the drive back. Still support this business 100%! Mistakes happen -- minor blip, but hope it was a one off. Pizzas are excellent regardless! read more

See all

Just ate there, or at least tried to but left hungry. The zucchini sticks and the ranch dressing were absolutely delicious but my Moscow Mule tasted funny. I did not know that they add mint to it, which distracted me from the flavor and was not appreciated. Calamari was overcooked and chewy. I ordered a small white pie, but the ricotta was mixed with SO much pepper that it was inedible to me. Even my boyfriend that loves pepper said it was way too overwhelming. Ricotta doesn't need anything, it's delicious as is!Unfortunately, they did not have any plain ricotta so I had to get my money back, which they stiffed us on the refund by $6. Not going back. read more

See all

Went here recently with friends. Service was great. Waitress was friendly and helped us choose what to order. Her recommendations were great. Pizza was delicious. Love a good thin crust pizza. Desserts were good too! We liked everything and had no complaints. read more

See all

We were going to the Ren Faire in Tuxedo and spent the night and came across this restaurant for a family dinner . It was exceptional . It's not fancy , and it gets crowded so make a reservation . The menu is extensive and there is something for everyone . Cold beer on tap , generous drinks as well. We had zucchini sticks ...best ever !!!Not soggy but flavorful with a nice crunch . A root beer float came in a huge mug and was a meal by itself . My girl had a burger that was terrific . Pizza is cracker crust NJ style . It's awesome , but perhaps not as filling as you might expect . A medium pie can easily be eaten by one person . I wish I remembered the name if our server , but he was polite , attentive , and a really nice guy to boot . Next time we are there we. will surely be back , wish it was closer . read more

I heard good things about this place but to be honest I was pretty disappointed unfortunately. I could barely eat the crust since it just would break apart. I usually really enjoy all styles of pizza including thin/Chicago style but I'd this was just ok for me personally. Oh also it is cash only... I would definitely recommend all the other pizza places in the area. I won't say the pizza is bad per se but underwhelming from my personal experience. I will say though the service was really good. The server was nice and attentive. read more

Kinchley's Tavern - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey