Our new local go-to place for Italian food. The quality is consistent and excellent. They have a…read moreyoung but well-trained staff. You need to get there early to avoid a long wait, but that is indicative of the good food and service. One issue though. The bread that they serve is absolutely terrible. I mean REALLY TERRIBLE. But, I have to think that they'll get this minor issue fixed before too long,

Base my reviews off what you pay:…read more *Place was packed. Went here at 8:00PM on a Friday, was able to get a table with no reservation. Place was clear by time we left. Price - $110 (2 appetizers, pizza, 2 drinks, tip) Food - 2/5 - tasted premade. Service - 3/5 - fine and on par. Ambiance - 4/5 - decent vibe inside. Overall - 3/5 - ok spot that doesn't have the best food in town. Did have high expectations going in here but food was a let down. Pizza was ok but appetizers tasted old and potentially premade (i.e. not made fresh). Drinks were fine. Service was good but waitress was noticeably put off when we didn't order entrees. Inside was actually really nice. Open kitchen design and renovated nicely. Pizza oven is on display too. Cool place but not worth a stop. Best Dish - Carmine Pizza Would Return - Not Likely

the best chicken pizza i have ever had…read more fattuscos is so good, honestly my favorite pizza. the only reason i gave 4 stars instead of 5 is because their pricing is higher than other pizzerias in the area

Try the vodka garlic roll with chicken cutlet and mozzarella $15. A little disappointing I was…read moregiven a small one & the roll was bigger than cutlet. Definitely gets a 5 for taste!

I've been eating at Gino's for over 12 years plus and always have fantastic food there along with…read morethe service and Alex and the rest of the staff. I made the mistake one day going to Piezanos and I had a hair in my food and I went back the next day cause I ate late and little Joey the manager was very rude not professional and definitely does not know the hospitality business so stay away from there & he wouldn't even give me my money back and I brought the food back so don't go there... Gino's is the place to go & the Commack location.

I picked up a mushroom pie tonight. I added pepperoni to 2 slices along with the mushroom. Eating…read morethe 1st slice with pepperoni, the overwhelming taste of salt was pervasive and off-putting. Next slice I grabbed a slice with just mushrooms. I realized that this pizza was unbelievably salty and had no other flavor to balance it out. It was essentially a salt lick and nothing else. It blew out my pallet in the first bites. It became inedible. We threw out more than half the pie. Every pizza place has their balance you either love or can pass on. This one was full stop just pretty much inedible. I can't see ever going back here

I saw a lot of good reviews from locals so we tried it out passing thru. Inside is simple pizza…read moreplace. It was very warm inside almost to the point of eating was uncomfortable. I'm not sure why the air conditioning was off. The guy behind the counter was friendly. He was the best part, pizza seemed a bit old. Very minimal drink selection from the self serve refrigerator.

Timothy's pizza is great! We have been ordering from them almost every day when we need lunch for…read morethe contractors doing work on our house and they deliver the food on time while prepared and Michael's also so great on the phone. The pizza taste delicious or hot sandwich is also taste delicious we appreciate them so much!

Excellent NY style pizza, crispy/chewy ratio the best I've had in LI, maybe even better than…read moreL'industrie in BK. Their dough is now my go to for my at home backyard high heat Gozney pizza oven. A nice high hydration you won't get from most pizza restaurants or worse a grocery store.

Really good pizza not flimsy.? Chicken Caesar wrap was good but a bit disappointing. Too much…read morelettuce and a very hard wrap. Chicken was good though.

10-9-25. Stopped in for lunch because I had an errand to run…read morein the area. Very satisfying specialty slices. Tried a chicken bruschetta slice, a sweet chili chicken slice, a sausage and pepper with onions slice and a chicken parm roll. All were very good. Staff was very friendly and accommodating. Good amount of seating in a nice, casual setting. Huge selection of pizzas and other items to choose from. I would definitely return when in the area.

Mushy shrimp scampi don't waste your time or money so bad horrible terrible and awfulread more

Slices and the full pies are just a little better here than other nearby pizza places…read more The crunch on the crust is top notch. Sauce is way above average. Just a very very solid pie. Day to day Staff, management, ownership are always welcoming!

Simple, welcoming ambiance. No nonsense food. Great, crisp pizza and quick, efficient service. I…read morelove this place. I am from Orange County, CA and visit the used bookshop across the street, owned by an old friend and her husband. I always stop at Amore's for a couple slices before a long drive. Thanks, Amore! I will be back.

The prices on the menu are laughable. I get that most of Northport is expensive, but if you're…read moregoing to charge $15 for a meatball parm hero, maybe remember to fill the entire sandwich and put more than a dripping of sauce on. 95% of the time, a meatball parm is 2 meals for me, and I was able to eat this in one sitting because it was mainly just bread and what seemed like a half portion of meatballs. I noticed right away when I picked it up that it felt oddly light in my hand. You can't overcharge AND have small portions. The going rate on LI for a meatball parm is 10-12$. $12 for 6 wings? $9 for TOMATO SOUP!?? C'mon...

Came in tonight for a little nightcap with my friend before heading home from dinner. We've been…read moretrying to get here for dinner but decided on just a drink tonight. Terry took wonderful care of us at the bar. I had an espresso martini and my friend had a glass of wine. My martini was made perfectly and we really enjoyed our visit. I can't wait to come back to try their food! Everything about this place was so inviting!