Cook and cashier both greeted me upon arriving. Very friendly and fast. I ordered the haddock dinner with double fries. It was very good. read more

Kithnos Seafood Market - Haddock w/ double fries pic1 - Seafood Markets Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Excellent services and the food was amazing. Fish fry, chicken tenders was amazing. They also have fresh seafood, snacks and sodas. read more

Came here on recommendation from a driver. Pleasantly surprised! Very good seafood combo and haddock platters with onion rings. Batter was light and the haddock and seafood fresh. Service was good humored and professional. Highly recommend! read more

Kithnos Seafood Market - Seafood combo platter with onion rings. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Long time customers here. The fish fry is amazing as well as the fried clams and shrimp. Nothing fancy, but that's not what I care about in a takeout place. Consistency and quality. read more

Been going there for years. Always good food and the staff r very pleasant.Always go back.

Great option for BROILED fish take out. The store is in a strip mall and there is a large open area where you can place orders on the right as you walk in. If you call ahead, you can go to the left where the register is, give your name, and wait there for your order. The fish fry is a huge serving and includes cole slaw and fries. The broiled option comes with cole slaw and baked potato. Definitely call ahead to order since they have a huge take out demand on Fridays. The fried haddock comes with about 3 pieces of fish. The batter is tasty. The coleslaw is generously portioned and delicious. Would definitely order from here again. read more

See all

This place is a great option if you're looking for some yummy fish! I can definitely get busy depending on the time of the year so I do suggest ordering an ahead of time but if you're not familiar with the menu then by all means planned a little extra time and go and wait in line so you can review the menu. The fish is crisp the french fries are crisp I'm not a big fan of the Mac salad or the coleslaw but that doesn't mean you won't be! Staff are super friendly and pretty much everything we've gotten here has been enjoyable. read more

A very disappointing meal. Heavy, oily and a very greasy mess that ended up soggy and not at all appealing to eat. Huge portions but I would rather have less food for better quality. Two employees were yelling back and forth with each other the whole time a large group of us were waiting in line. Wouldn't recommend Kithnos for any type of seafood meal. Expired canned goods on shelves for sale as well (Sardines that expired months ago). Isn't that against some type of food sale code? Two stars for plenty of parking and the two nice check-out employees. read more

Kithnos Seafood Market - 1/2 of a Combo Platter ($16 including tax) - Seafood Markets Near Me - Rochester, New York

Excellent food and service. Portions are great big ones! I'll be back with friends. The guys are friendly and humble. read more

This is not a review. This is an update on the erroneous hours listed here. Kithnos is closed Mondays and Tuesdays. I didn't know how else to post a correction. If anyone reading this does, please make the fix and I will remove this post. Thanks. read more

We've been trying different fish fry to make shelter in place more fun. I'd never been to Kithnos before. But it's my new favorite. Very reasonable prices. Great service. And yum! We loved the ample portions of the fish fry. Perfectly done. Flaky and lush. Not at all greasy. Sweet potato fries were a treat. Light and perfectly cooked. My son enjoyed the onion rings. Despite wishing they were a tad crispier he deemed the best he's had. The hush puppies were the icing on the cake. A treat. Flavorful and firm. Clams were so good that my kids ate them. The scallops were moist and full of flavor. I'm sad that I've lived in Rochester for so long and just found this place. And we called at dinner time on a Friday night and didn't have much of a wait. Run don't walk to Kithnos when you get a yen for seafood! read more

1st time but definitely not my last time. It was a long drive but thankfully, it was worth it. The baked haddock was FRESH, cooked perfectly and delicious. The coleslaw was also very good...not too sweet or too much mayonnaise. Nate was friendly, kind and welcoming along with his wife. My family and I will be driving back for more in the future. read more

Wonderful place. Great Seafood, always fresh. Best Fish fry in town. Coleslaw is always perfect. Best service. Who ever is answering phones or service is always very kind. My Go-To place for Fish when on this side of town. read more

I've been many times to Kithnos seafood market for fish fry's. The serving portion is definitely generous. One fish fry could feed two people easily.they typically make the battered fish fry but you can special request a breaded fish as well. read more

This is the spot for a good fish fry. I've been coming here for years and it's never disappointed. The batter is light and fish is flaky and never fishy taste. Recently I've tried their fish sandwich and oh man it's humongous. It's a fried fish with tarter sauce and cheese it's a must try. read more

Kithnos Seafood Market - Fish sandwich is so good!! - Seafood Markets Near Me - Rochester, New York

This is easily the best fish fry I have ever had. You only get one tiny container of tartar sauce, but that's OK, because it really doesn't *need* tartar sauce. Crispy batter, flakey tender fish... Try it with Cajun fries on the side, and some homemade cole slaw. read more

Kithnos Seafood Market - Fish fry with cajun fries and cole slaw - Seafood Markets Near Me - Rochester, New York

There are no frills here and you shouldn't expect there to be. The food is amazingly fresh, fast, and you get more than a normal person should eat at one sitting. My favorite is the fish fry, but the scallops were numerous big and amazing. They. Even retained that sort of slight sweetness that comes with scallops crabs and lobster. They also serve delicious hush puppies which I haven't seen too much of North of the Mason Dixon line. The owners and workers are blue collar heroes so don't expect a faux smile and over enthusiastic fake courtesy. They are genuine and friendly and they make amazing food for very cheap. I can't believe I've been missing out on this food for years, but better late than never. read more

So, we had to go to Rochester yesterday for a Dr appointment, so we decided to stop at Kithnos for some fish. This is our second visit here and we were not disappointed! First of all they were cognizant of the social distancing regulation and had the proper spacing set up. I placed our usual order, a Seafood Platter for me, and an order of Scallops, Clams and onion Rings for my wife. I also decided to try their FRESH Cod, since we had fresh Cod this past summer in Cape Cod and became instant fans of this amazing fish! Well as I hoped the food was simply amazing! Everything was hot, crispy and DELICIOUS! Since our visit to Kithnos is a 90 minute drive, we found a secluded spot in their parking lot and enjoyed our food while it was hot and fresh. Now about that piece of Cod... it was absolutely amazing! It way just as good as the Cod we had while visiting Cape Cod! Everything we had was just delicious, including the Coleslaw. I highly recommend Kithnos for any fish or seafood you may desire. It's worth the 90 minute ride for us, so if you are in the Rochester area, check it out!!! read more

Fresh, hot fish and great batter! Coleslaw and mac salad were great too! I know it sounds petty, but the tartar sauce is tiny and blah. I'll be back soon though. read more

Great food. Good service. Always going back. Batter is light and crispy and the serving is huge.

Used to be so good. It's hit or miss. The last few times I went there it was not good & they got my order totally fucked up. They threw me my change & food as if I was less than nothing. Never again. I never felt so low before in my life. Black people please stay out of there read more

Amazing fish fry. Just a great value . fast service friendly staff. The best fish fry I've eaten in many years . everything was crazy good I also ordered the scallops and WoW they were wonderful. Cooked perfect and fresh tasting. Better than most Fish n Chip shops in the UK. Next time I'll get the broiled fish platter. The fish is so fresh it makes you want to try everything . They set the standard . You can't please everyone but its hard to believe that you could get a bad meal here. Its a little hard to find but its worth the search. Go for it ,you shouldn't be disappointed. read more

Just ate there yesterday. The food was delicious, service was great and price very affordable. I highly recommend broiled scallops and broiled haddock. The seasoning was amazing. read more

I've heard from several folks that this place has the best fish fry in the city and holy smokes they weren't kidding! This is a no frills take out kind of place, I don't even remember seeing seating. Not only can you get take out but you can also order your pick of fresh raw seafood to take home and make yourself. I got an order of the fish fry with Cajun fries and the Mac salad for my husband and another order of the broiled scallops with a baked potato and Greek salad for me. The portion sizes are huge! The fish fry batter was buttery and crispy and delicious. The Cajun fries had a bit of a kick to them, they were awesome. They only give you one little package of tartar sauce so if you want more, you can get 3 packets for a dollar. My scallops were spiced with Greek spices and they literally melted in my mouth, that's the way scallops should be. My baked potato was just that, a baked potato wrapped in foil. No fixings, not even sliced. No big deal though, I just cut it up myself and salted and buttered it. Greek salad tasted fresh and wasn't overdressed and soggy. Overall great seafood for a great price, can't wait to try the other entrees. read more

We had dinner from Kithnos last evening and it was OUTSTANDING! The coconut shrimp was the best I have ever had and the fish fry is so big you can bearly finish it! The prices are fair and resonable which is important in todays economy. The salads, sides dishes etc. are excellant as well. I don't know how I could have missed it all these yrs......but now that I have found Kithnos....I will definately be a repeat customer! Keep up the good work. read more

Love going here during Lent (and a few other random times as well). Their fish fry is HUGE and so delicious! I also like that I can get mac salad instead of cole slaw on the side. My only complaint (which isn't even a solid complaint because it IS a seafood market) is that every time my fiancee gets home from picking our fish fries up, he smells like a big fish himself! But its worth it to me! So good! read more

This was my favorite place for fish fries for decades. No more. I was ignored by the lady that's there now and the male cashier. I placed takeout, I walked towards the counter she saw me and started to walk away and stood to the side . When she walk back over she stood there and ignored me and took other customers. I literally stood there 3-5 minutes the male cashier saw me and ignored me as well. Just an FYI - Customer Service is the lifeblood of your business. If she doesn't like or want to come in contact with "certain types" of people she shouldn't be up there. read more

Used to love this place, but last month I thought the stench would kill me. We were guaranteed the fish was fresh - needless to say the sea perch was NOT fresh. Never again. read more

If it was possible I would give Kithnos a negative rating. Before I purchased the combo plate, I inquired about the number of scallops included in the combo plate. I was told eight. I received FIVE! There was more breading on the scallops than the actual scallop. The scallops were chewy, grey, and flavorless. Instead of battered fish, I requested breaded fish. The breading was so thick part of it was uncooked and the other part was chewy. The fish was so thin, it was difficult to find it in the breading. The french fries were limp and soggy with grease. The onion rings were all breading, the onion was so thin, I could not find the onion ring, and they too tasted greasy. The breaded shrimp was flavorless, and chewy. When I received the order, it looked as though there was a huge portion of food. However, in actuality it was all breading and grease. After eating the food, it was too late to call and voice my displeasure. I have had similar combo plates to go at other places, and this was the worst by far! To end on a positive note, although it was very busy, the employees were pleasant. read more

yes, I'm a fan. Been there several times now. The cooked fish is very good and the people are easy and friendly. Haven't found anyone better in Rochester. read more

This place is the best seafood market ever! The owner and the staff are wonderful and kind. I came in on a Friday night at 7:45pm, just 15 minutes before they close and they treated me like gold! I couldn't make up my mind and they were so patient while I pick what I wanted, and then they cooked it for me. It was after 8pm by the time my food was ready and they were just great about it. They really know how to treat their customers! Love them! And I love the seafood and how well they cook it! Great place! read more

Good old fashioned fish fry. If your looking for authentic fresh fish fry, get there early on Friday nights! It's worth the wait. I had baked salmon, delish. Friendly atmosphere. Great fish market. read more

My first time at Kithnos Seafood Market and I was not disappointed! They really do have the best fish fry in Rochester. The new owners were very nice and you can tell that they genuinely care about the business and their customers. This may have been my first time here but it definitely won't be my last! read more

Giving this place one star is being generous. A co worker recommended going here for some great fish. Like some of the older reviews written in 2014, a friend and I ordered several fish dinners from this place. I was kind of leery after walking through the door, because the smell of this place had me immediately thinking that the seafood is stale. The two men behind the counter were NOT the friendliest. Taking our orders home and out of the bags, we noticed the fish had an odor to it that was not a "normal" fresh fish smell. I didn't eat mine and gave my dog a small piece, which he threw back up. My friend's husband got an upset stomach. We called Kithnos to tell them about our experience, and all they offered was to cook us more fish. No thanks! Haven't been back since. read more

I had the best haddock at this restaurant I would highly recommend anything on their menu. The service is fabulous. A diamond in the rough! Take out and enjoy! read more

I went today 3/14/12 at 3 pm to eat a fish fry and some soup. He advertise that he makes the soups fresh everyday and when i ordered the soups, he takes them out of the freezer and heats them up. Then he gets the fish with his hand without wearing gloves!!! I asked him if he makes the soups everyday, just like his ad says and he tells me "dont think like puertoricans". Staying calm bite my tongue and proceed to tell him that i dont want the soup or the fish any more and to give me my money back very nicely. He gives me the money and yells at me me to leave this country and go back to Puerto Rico very loud in front of the other costumers read more

I was looking for a place to buy sashimi grade fish. I looked up a few in town and drove around hoping for the best. I finally made it to kithnos seafood market and found what I was looking for. The man working greeted me and was quick to offer help. The price was extremely reasonable and much less expensive than wegmans. I'm looking forward to going back to try their fish fry. read more

I came there today 12-29-2014.,.and the owner was rude., I ask for scallops and he ask "how much" I said I didn't know" what can you whip up for me " I noticed he had cleaned up 2hrs. before closing ., and it looked as if he was tired. Just like me., I own a business too., working monday to fri 6:30-6:30. And I don't treat my customer., they way he treated me., So me being me I didn't want him to dirty up the place., just to cook food for me., so i'm looking at his menu to say can you just wrap me up a pound of scallops. And as I turned to look at him to speak., I thought he turned to hackles and jackals., and said" are you going to order the scallops".!!!!!!!!! I said "excuse me"in shock., and said no thank you., and I walked out., to hear him making signs. I got in my car and said" this happens to me here every year at this fish market., with the owner., shape up guy., it's us that's paying your bills. I hope your reading this., remember me. I know you are because I read my reviews about my business. : read more