Ziti chicken slice is sooo good. Super friendly staff of young folks who work hard to give you the best. Try the Sicilian pizza too! read more

We just use them to cater for a family reunion of 31 very picky Italian's . Everything was perfect. We had eggplant Parmesan, chicken, piccata, pizzas, and Greek salad. Everything we had was delicious and prepared perfectly and and each tray can easily be 25 people. I would highly recommend this place for a very good pizzas and casual Italian food. Also, the young man who took my order was very precise and then when I picked up, the order was very very helpful and making sure everything was done as requested and help me get it into my car. read more

There is nothing better than New York pizza. I was thrilled to be able to get a slice while on Long Island. La Capricciosa Pizza was a great choice. The pizza came out hot and it was delicious. They had several options to choose from so we all got what we wanted. No complaints from the group. We were all happy. Thank you! read more

See all

Great Pizza ! brick oven style well done was perfect ! Must try. Grabbed some pies after a party hung out in town and ate it at local Jail museum. Grabbed a fresh beer from brewery next door. I would highly recommend will be a must every time we are in town on the NOFO. read more

La Capricciosa Pizza - Kids love the Pizza ! Excellent - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

After several evenings of exotic and sometimes overpriced dinners, we craved a plain cheese pizza on our last night in Greenport and La Capricciosa fit the bill. Ordered a small (14 inch) cheese pizza and a garden salad at the counter, waited about 10 minutes and a pleasant young woman took our food over to our table. Everything was fresh and delicious, especially the homemade tomato vinaigrette that came with the salad. Wonderful neighborhood pizza place that has survived many years for a reason - it's unpretentious, reasonably priced and serves excellent food. read more

La Capricciosa Pizza - Pre-Pizza Salad w/Delish Homemade Vinagrette. Gotta get my veggies :) - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

Tasty pizza always and open late. They do a good job with a solid menu. Please bring back the cannolis.

Never dissapoints. Consistently good pizza, pasta and salads. Friendly staff. Inside/outside seating or take it to go! Enjoy read more

La Capricciosa Pizza - Never disappoints! - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

The service was quick and efficient. They served so much food, we had to take a doggie bag home. The only issue me and my guests had was the didn't have coffee, so we didn't order desert. read more

I had a pleasant experience with a meal served by a patient staff. The pizza was fine but almost too much eat in house

Such a find! We got off the ferry and were looking for a place to get some quick food after 9pm. With the help of Yelp we found this place. Loved it as soon as I walked in. We got a couple of slices and a salad and it was really delicious. Classic NY style pizza and super tasty. The garden salad was bigger than I thought and all the vegetables were really fresh too. Nice tables to sit at inside and out. Can't recommend this place enough. read more

I didn't get a chance to take any pictures because I was corralling a toddler into a booth. The inside had the traditional pizzeria booths. The sicilian pizza was standard. Good and thick. The buffalo slice was exactly how I like it. Not overdone. My daughter enjoyed some pizza and french fries. The price wasn't bad and the inside wasn't too crowded. I would recommend it for a quick bite if you are in the area. If we come back, we would definitely go back. read more

Good friends factoring in on this... This to me is a three star Pizza that a best friend said I better not give three stars to!. One of the few Pizza places in the popular summer tourist town of Greenport, on a side block a bit away from Main St... Of the few, most people generally have a preference. To me the other on Main St., Emilio's is 4 this is 3. However........ A best friend and a few others having Pizza from both keep insisting on La Capricciosa! Try for yourself. Always willing to be fair, I'll go to or pick up from either. So 1 Extra star for friends insisting this is their Go To Pizza. Has plenty of toppings and seems to be a crowd pleasing place. To get the most flavor here, I'll opt for pepperoni, or an everything pie, which are the best of their choices IMO. Wouldn't take a CC once when picking up two pies. So bring paper money. Open during and off season out here, so a bit of an east end hero also. read more

La Capricciosa Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

OMG! Only the best pizza ever not exaggerating. This pizza is crispy crust through the center. That's right no gummy chewy garbage here. And the tomato sauce is ample , you can taste it the flavors of Italy. We bought Mamas pizza and it's located in a quaint little coastal town called Greenport New York. Must try. read more

La Capricciosa Pizza - Mamas Best pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

My Favorite pizza on the North Fork. Consistent & delicious! Delivery is always on time. Thank you! read more

La Capricciosa Pizza - Half Meatlovers, Half Veggie!!! - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

Used to be a fan, but went there last night and let's just say they're not exactly a paragon of safety in the COVID19 era. Walking around either maskless or with masks below their noses, with clientele who do the same. Considering there are other, better and safer options for pizza in town, this kind of shortsightedness is neither good for business nor for the current public health crisis. read more

Great food. Service is okay. You could either eat in or take out. This our main place to order out of

I don't understand the 3.5 stars?!? This place is GREAT! Their pizza is fantastic. Their pasta Alla Vodka is fantastic! Their lasagna is just as good. Their portions are huge. We came here in October and no lines. We sat outside and it was a lovely evening. The staff their were kind and helpful. The person who made our pasta did a wonderful job. Do come here when your in town, you will not regret it! read more

See all

We ordered from La Capriocciosa for delivery on a Saturday evening post-wineries. The food was very delicious, especially the pizza and mozzarella sticks. I recommend the pepperoni and the chicken parm pizzas for sure! There are only 2 reasons for 3 stars instead of 5: first, the french fries ordered did not travel well, but I think that was due to the second reason: our driver was delayed in arriving by almost 45 minutes. We were staying at a VRBO home in Greenport, just 5 minutes from La Capricciosa (I saw it earlier that morning when parking for bagels), so I knew it was very close, and the house was very easy to find with GPS/Google Maps/Waze. So, I was disappointed in the delay and the need to call the restaurant, as well as having to go out and look for my driver up and down the neighborhood. read more

I am a NYC pizza snob, so my expections were "average". I was pleasantly surprised with my slice of chicken parm pizza. It was delcious and filling. I actually liked it better than "my local pizza guy"...and that's saying a lot! read more

I just had a family get together catered by this restaurant and the manager, Elio (I apologize if I spelled his name wrong) and his staff helped us have a perfect day. The delivery man was on time, so friendly and helpful and the food was beyond delicious. This place is amazing and never disappoints! ...More read more

We order from them for delivery all of the time and it's always good. But tonight it was even better then usual! Pizza and wings were delivered so quickly and the pizza tasted like it just came out of the oven. They're the best! read more

Driven out here a few time and had several of their dishes. The calamari is absolutely delicious. The chicken francaise, chicken marsala, spaghetti and meatballs, and mussels have always been fantastic. This is also the only place where I will actually eat their house salad. We haven't tried the pizza yet, but the meals are very very good! read more

Friends and I were hungry looking for a substantial meal 3 men and 2 ladies. Pasta and pizza was high on the list. We ordered a pie and a few dishes of pasta. I was quite pleasantly surprised at how delicious the pizza was since we love pizzas and are quite picky about such things! Absolutely enjoyed the family style pastas, its large servings so go with a group, its more fun to try other items. You definitely should try the following that stood out: Vodka Penne Pasta Pizza - which ever toppings (We had meats and some veggies) Seafood Spaghetti read more

See all

I was in Greenport on business and was hungry. Saw this little place on the way in and decided to stop and eat on the way home. This is a basic, no-frills pizza spot. They have a few tables in the pizza area and a dining room off to the side. It was busy when I arrived and had to wait a couple of minutes. No biggie. What was a biggie was that it was hotter than Hades in the place. I mean, they do have outdoor tables but the door was closed. Really, what would it have taken to prop the sucker open. Anyway, I had a couple of slices. They were ok, nothing to write home about. They had a very thin crust which is not my favorite. Sauce and cheese ratio was quite good. I would probably stop back in next time I'm around, but only if it is about 50 degrees cooler in the place. read more

We popped in for dinner last evening around 8:30PM after traveling from BLock Island on our boat. The food was exquisite. The family style salad was terrific and plentiful. The house dressing was a tomato vinaigrette that was a perfect balance of flavors. The four of us split a Chicken Parmigiana and Eggplant Romano dinners which easily fed us. The food was absolutely out of this world. The sauce was delicious! We would highly recommend this place and come hungry. It is BYOB at this point some bring a nice Chianti and Manga! read more

My husband and I are so in love with this place. Their food is exceptionally delicious the pizza is great but their veal cannanoli is off the chart.... read more

I'm giving this poor excuse for a restaurant 1 star because I can't give it no stars. First, Greenport is a resort area - but I live there. I just bought a house there and am trying out all the local restaurants to see which ones we like best. This one sucks !!! We went on July 5th - so, yes, I know it's busy and expected a bit of a wait - but we only waited a few minutes for a table - However...Once we were seated, that was it. The waitress took our order and we were left sitting. Nothing at all was brought to our table - no beverages, no bread, no salad. Nothing. Meanwhile other people who came in after us were seated and served very quickly. We asked why and were told that it's because they're just getting pizza. That wasn't true because they had other dishes on the table besides pizza. Another table was also served before us and they had main courses. Finally the beverages arrived and out of 5 ordered, only 3 were correct. Then the bread came - and the bread was good. Then 1 of the 2 salads came - but no dressing. We were also 5 people with 4 forks. We had to get up to get what they called dressing- it had tomato in it and was sort of oil-based, but that's about it. The lettuce wasn't good either - like it had been frozen and defrosted. We asked another waitress about the dressing and the other salad (not our waitress who was M.I.A.) and was told to "ask your own waitress". RUDE. We tried to speak to a gentleman, who is supposed to be in charge, but he didn't speak or understand English too well. He sent over a young lady to our table who was supposed to check on our food. It took quite a few minutes for her to return and she said she would bring the other salad while we waited. First, why didn't she just bring the other salad out with her ???? When I asked how long it would take for our food since we were already in the restaurant well over an hour - she refused to directly answer the question. It's being prepared was all she said - I asked again what that meant - how long would it be - and was told it's being prepared and would be a few minutes. She was so arrogant, we asked for the check for the salad and beverages and 2 slices of pizza for 1 person at the table. When we took out money to pay, she threw it at us and told us to get out. There was also another table who had ordered pizza - they also waited a very long time and were not even given plates for the pizza. I can't comment on the food - the portions look big - but after close to 1 1/2 hours didn't get to taste them. We were also told to consider ourselves lucky because people wait 2 hours to eat there - Not this person !!! Please heed my warning - with so many places to eat in Greenport and the surrounding area - run, don't walk - away from this pizzeria. We deserve better for our money than rude waitresses and very poor service. read more

Had a great meal! Large portions. Had the chicken piccatta. Very good. Sister had eggplant parmigano. Very good. Would recommend both dishes. Come hungry. read more

La Capricciosa Pizza - Chicken piccatta. - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

This place is a typically designed pizza joint with a dining room to the side. The dining room was not open at lunch time, so we decided on a pizza, sitting in a booth. Our mutual choice, we were four hungry women, was the eggplant parmigiana pizza. It was wonderful. The crust was very thin as it should be, the tomato sauce was not acidic tasting, the cheese was very fresh and the fresh herbs were not over powering If you want pizza, it doesn't get much better than this place. The decor reminded me of the old Brooklyn pizza place near where I lived. read more

Local residents trying to find the best pizza in town, and so far this is it. They have many options and make everything exactly how we ask (yes we're a little particular). Prices are reasonable, except for when we added a single 20oz soda and it was an additional three dollars... it's not much but doesn't seem reasonable. They have many ready to service options many including protein, the chicken Caesar is my favorite. Can't wait to try more. If you're looking for a quick bite in greenport, stop in and you won't be disappointed. read more

If you're in greenport town and are looking for a quick bite pizza and salad, This place is great!! They offer several different kinds of pizza , a bigger selection than I expected! It's all very fresh and I enjoy their sauce and crunchy crust! read more

Being 100% Italian Its not possible for me to settle for mediocrity, well thankfully there is nothing mediocre about this place!! It is truly the real deal, authentic and delicious Italian food combined with great service and fair prices, this place is great find!! If you are in the area definitely check this place out!! Take it from an Italian who knows. read more

So we drove to Greenport from our home in the pizza capitol of the world, Brooklyn NY, for a little R&R. We were running a late and decided to use Yelp to grab a pizza for the room and do the restaurant crawl the next day. We found La Capricciosa, called their number and placed an order for pickup. Then I plugged La C's street address into Google Navigator and drove into town to pick it up. Google instead directed us to an address on Front Street. No La C there but my girlfriend said she thought she had seen a pizza place a few doors back so she got out of the car while I drove around the block to meet her. Then I got pulled over by the local constabulary. No big deal. Just a headlight out and the cop was pleasant about it. I asked him if there was a pizza joint on that block and he said there was but it sucked and that I should go to La Capricciosa instead, which was on a side street about 500 yards from where Google thought that address was. With that long preamble out of the way, and a recommendation/directions from a uniformed local, on to the food review. We ordered a pie with extra cheese and green pepper. The pizza was surprisingly excellent, and by that I mean we're Brooklyn folk spoiled by the likes of Lucali, Tontonno, Di Fara and Grimaldi's. Sure it was a little oily but it held its own with best non-celebrity pizza in Brooklyn. The crust was perfect and the toppings fresh and generous. I mean, it's pizza. It's dough, sauce and cheese. How can you get it wrong? But most of the world gets it wrong anyway. La Capricciosa gets it. read more

My Husband and I are new to the area and after a long day of cleaning and tooling around the new house, had an urge for italian. We originate from Brooklyn so italian is readily available to us but we are always looking for a good place. I have to say, La Capricciosa was AWESOME. The place serves large portions and starts the meal off with fresh baked bread and a really tasty salad big enough to feed three or four people. We ordered: - baked clams which came in a garlicky lemon sauce, perfect for bread dipping. -Baked Ziti- very fresh -Rigatoni Puttanesca - perfectly al dente, just the right amount of olives and anchovy in a rich tomato sauce. The portions were large and we brought leftovers home. The table next to us had a pizza which looked fabulous. We are going to make this our go to place for italian. I highly recommend. read more

Probably the best pizza game in town. Food is good and prices are fare for basically being on the water. Definitely recommend

As Bad as it is expensive. Crust was tough, slice was dry. Toppings were so-so. Two pies and a limp salad cost $64 plus tip.

We are staying in shelter island but wanted to get some Italian in green port. Asked many people, they suggested this place. Excellent choice! Delicious food!! Hidden gem!! The eggplant parmigiana that I ordered came out hot, crispy and fresh, the salad had a dressing that was sweet and tasty. If you are in town, come here for some great tasting food. read more

So this review is based off of my second time ordering from here because my first time was so unmemorable that my boyfriend didn't even remember we'd ever had pizza from here. One off-season Friday night I was out here in greenport and craving pizza. My go-to spot was closed and there's not many other options. I pull up la capricciosa'a Facebook in search of a menu since I couldn't find one in the house. That's when I stumbled upon a photo of their pizza with garlic knot crust. I immediately knew I NEEDED to try it. Lately I've found myself on a pepperoni kick so we ordered a half pepperoni half buffalo chicken pie with the garlic knot crust. When they told me the price ($28) I was shocked. A garlic knot crust pizza back in the city costs quite a bit more than that and that's for a plain cheese pie with the garlic knot crust. (Please don't read this review and adjust your prices!) They told us it would take a little longer to make, which was fine by us. We were super happy with our order. It was really delicious and the garlic knots were perfect. Would definitely order this pie again but maybe ask for some ranch / marinara on the side. read more

See all

This pizza is pretty garbage but not quite as garbage as the people who work here - who will charge you $29 for a plain pie if you say something about "8 slices" over the phone. Then when you ask about the charge they'll comeback with "you ordered by the slice" - okay, yah got me, I guess. Disappointing. Probably not as disappointing as these d-bags missing their true calling, which would be working the phones at a Spectrum call center, but disappointing nonetheless. Anyway, I hopped back in the car, opened the box, and discovered it was a fresh pie, not a by-the-slice situation at all, and not really a silver lining either. It's airport pizza at best. read more

Food is less than average. Pizza is ok at best. Service is slow and unfriendly. Prices are way too high. Best thing is parking. Unless you desperate, there are much better places in town read more