An update: There are…read moresome really excellent coffee shops on Long Island, but there is no shop like this one. Not even close. The coffee is that good. It's one of the few places in the world that the line of customers transcends all boundaries. Billionaires, builders, artists and house painters all in the same line getting their favorite coffee from one of the nicest guys you could ever know. Coffee so good, you won't see the name on the door of a nondescript commercial building in a gravel lot by the train station. I don't get here every day like I used to, so I grab a couple pounds to keep the house stocked. This place is like a favorite shirt for my soul.

A double espresso was very smooth and delicious. The coffee shop itself is very no frills and…read morethere's some left to be desired regarding the friendliness of the person behind the counter on this particular day. But, they do roast their own beans which you can tell in the product. So as a coffee lover, for that I would return!

A true borderline review where a half star could possibly be tacked on to those three, though it's…read moretough to tell as my recent trip out east with my wife to Bonfire was definitely middling. Now we don't venture all the way to Amagansett often, but we like to head out to Montauk once a year, and social media presented a cute coffee shop to stop at on the way, Bonfire. Cute could definitely be the word, especially the exterior of the place with some shaded seats on their deck and the small grassy courtyard that encompassed them and the neighboring storefronts. The vibes worked, though many other factors were more iffy. I'll try to focus on the other good options in that the menu of Bonfire is intriguing from their coffee and food options as well as gelato. I'll also say the staff, despite a small snafu (more on that in a sec), were able to take orders and keep things going. I'll even say that on first sip of my coffee I was wowed, but that's just what you see on the surface level. Underneath those positives was a pricier coffee spot with my wife's blueberry whip latte coming in at $11. Between that, a chocolate croissant, and my own latte we spent $27 which is a little much for what we got. Yes, eastern Long Island can be pricy, but dang. As for my aforementioned coffee, I got the Bonfire Latte which combined vanilla, hazelnut, and cardamom flavors to create what started as a truly delicious taste, but after a few sips once the flavor punch wore off, I would've at least expected a coffee kick in there. Honestly, there wasn't much. The real sign this was true was my wife who prefers a little more sweetness than coffee taste in her drinks saying that she couldn't taste any coffee in hers either. Oh and that croissant while soft and flaky, definitely felt like the chocolate could've been a little more melted in to it as I pulled out a whole piece when trying to tear it for my wife. One last item about the croissant was the fact that we ordered it and no one gave it to us. Our coffees came out relatively quickly despite the place being somewhat busy, but we stood and watched a few people who ordered after us get their stuff before I had to ask about the croissant which seemed to have been forgotten about. Oy. Overall, Bonfire Coffeehouse presents itself as a lovely eastern location to get some morning brews and then some, but perhaps it's not as fantastic as the facade it showcases. I'd like to try them one more time in the future, but that'll be a long time off (probably not til next summer) and that's if I feel like it's worth the price and I'm willing to believe the lack of coffee flavor was a fluke. Head out on the south fork and you be the judge.

Went there for breakfast with sister, got 1 bacon/egg & cheese we split, 2 iced mocha drinks and 1…read morecrossant. Total= 43.00 ! They charged me 1.25 xtra for the milk and 50 cents for the ice! Not to mention the sign said $8 for the drink when in fact they charge $9.75 because of the xtra charges, why not just say it's $9.75? And the sandwich could have been better, it used to be. I don't think I'll be back there any time soon, I'm not a wealthy person on Vay-cay who can spend like that, it was shocking! I'm sorry but the prices are getting sinful around here and it's sad because I love to eat out and have done so often but lately, not so much. :-(

Cute coffee shop in East Hampton. Unfortunately, when I came their espresso machine was not…read moreworking. I had a cold brew and we got a bunch of donuts that all looked delicious. I did not have any due to my food allergies. Everyone who did have a donut though in my family liked it. The cold brew is self serve from a tap near the counter. You pour your own milk. Pretty pricey coffee shop but not surprised as it's in the hamptons.The workers here were nice and working hard. Though, the people infront of us were having like a full blown convo with one of the baristas they must have been friends/locals. It was a tad annoying but oh well.

Delicious iced coffee, but the donut fell flat. You can tell from the picture that the icing was…read morepretty dried out on top. The donut itself didn't taste too fresh so that was a bummer, but it was still a nice treat (and the perfect topper to my iced coffee!). Very friendly and hardworking staff are running this place, and there was a small selection of things to look at before ordering. Super cute spot!

Friendly, fabulous! Excellent atmosphere and selection,…read morealways have tasty treats and lots of eye candy on the walls and shelves.

My girlfriend and I have been to this coffee shop a good handful of times since they opened. The 2…read morestars are for the food/bev. There's no denying they make great coffee and pastries. The lack of the other 3 stars is for the service. The first few times we came in, we were barely greeted with a "hello" let alone a "good morning!" Usually, it's a flat "hi what can I get you." You are the first person someone encounters in the morning. Is a warm welcome and some sort of report that difficult? Our last 2 experiences were actually good, and I think our server's name was Kate maybe? I guess we accidentally tried to come in slightly early this morning. When we opened the unlocked door, we were greeted with "give us a minute." If this was my business, I would have said "hey guys good morning! Still finishing setting up, but feel free to come in out of the cold and look around!" That was the last straw for us, so we left. In reading previous reviews, this seems to be a reoccurring theme here and a shared sentiment. I've lived here my entire 31 years of life, and I don't like this cold city vibe they harbor in Springs. Kristi and Jenny at the Springs General Store would never act like this

Best smoothie in montauk. It's a must stop and love all their healthy options. I go for their milk…read morebanana shake.

We were really excited to try this place, but unfortunately it was a disappointing experience. The…read moresmoothie tasted like overripe, almost rotten bananas. The bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich was severely undercooked, which made it inedible. The coffee also wasn't good, especially since it appeared to be freshly brewed from a canister, so I was surprised by the taste. The one bright spot was the chocolate donut as it was delicious and easily the best thing we ordered. We spent around $60 for just these four items, so we left feeling pretty disappointed. I hope this was just an off day because there's definitely room for improvement. Employees were very sweet and nice.

Came here for the first time this afternoon and immediately felt the buzz as soon as I walked in. I…read morewas in dire need of some caffeine and their americano coffee was perfect. On the way out, I noticed they have tons of different drip coffee roasts options, including cool flavors like cocoa coffee. The place was packed and cleary for good reason... so I've definitely got to come back here for breakfast one day.

Rude staff and terrible coffee. No matter how many TikTok's you see skip this one. We saw a TikTok…read morevideo saying this was a good coffee should have seen yelp.

This bakery is such a gem. Everything looked fresh and beautifully displayed, and it was honestly…read morehard to choose because it all looked so good. The pastries were light, flavorful, and not overly sweet you can really taste the quality of the ingredients. The atmosphere felt warm and inviting, perfect for grabbing a coffee and treating yourself. The staff was friendly and patient while I decided (which took a while because I wanted everything). Overall, a lovely experience from start to finish. I'll definitely be back to try more.

Really good coffee and relaxing vibe. The employees were kind and efficient. I'm glad Southampton…read morehas this establishment

Very nice staff and a great location. It's pretty much what you would expect from a place like…read morethis. It has a nice, positive vibe, which makes it a pleasant place to stop by. My wrap was good, although it was a little dry. I just wish they had more seating, especially since it can get pretty busy at times. Overall, it's a good place to grab something to eat, have a drink, or get a quick snack.

Perfect brunch spot - delicious smoothies and food. However this review is for the "I Love Chicken"…read morewrap - holy cow, the BEST wrap I've ever had. Chicken was tender and seasoned, the wrap itself was warm, perfect mix of beans, rice, avocado.... I thought about that wrap for the next 2-3 hours.