Left hand coffee was the most highly ranked coffee shop in Montauk so I wanted to give it a try. I came on a rainy day and was pleasant to find a small shared parking lot. The entrance is also shared - you have to enter the building before going through their actual doors. Upon walking in, I see that seating is very limited about 4-5 already all occupied. Another thing that caught me by surprise is how much other products they sell on the shelf and in the fridge. Once I walked passed those, I saw their actual products - coffee bags and pastries behind the glass. The employees did not greet me or give any recommendations. There were several of them behind the counter just standing in place. I took a minute to read the menu behind the cash register. It wasn't too big but had options. I ordered a vanilla latté. It was strong and good, not sweet at all. Definitely a good coffee shop, would come back to try other drinks and baked goods. As for the aura, the place is a bit dim and was crowded with products on shelves on one side and people sitting on the few chairs available on the other side. Wished it was a bit more welcoming! read more

See all

Wanted to like this place - we're not too hard to please. But our coffee was super bitter/acidic. We couldn't drink it. Service and ambiance were pleasant, but that's not enough if the core product is wack. read more

I was excited to try this place, since I was in town for a couple of days and had heard it was good. I came with my friend to check it out and it was quite crowded. The line moved quickly, but I felt very rushed when I got to ordering. The ambiance of the space is very nice with some places to sit and cute (but overpriced) merchandise. It's very instagrammable. I deducted some stars because the matcha latte was just not good. It tasted mostly like milk and hardly had any matcha flavor coming through. I might try something else if I come again. read more

See all

Double espressos were delicious and smooth. Clean cafe and friendly service. An interesting menu. They have their act together for sure. read more

Left Hand Coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

I ordered a Vanilla latte with pistachio milk from here while visiting. It was the perfect ratio of sweetness for me, not too sweet and creamy with the pistachio milk. They had some delish looking pastries including a couple of gluten free ones but I had just had lunch. They also have matchas and other coffee drinks that looked good. My coffee came out pretty quick less than 5 minutes so I appreciate that. I would definitely come back when in Montauk. read more

Left Hand Coffee - Vanilla latte with pistachio milk - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

Owner replied and asked how can a latte taste sour? You're a coffee shop - don't you know coffee can taste sour if it's under extracted? Coffee is acidic.... Anyways, I was trying to give an honest review. No need to be defensive and as a business owner, I hope that you take a customer's criticism and work on improving your business. read more

Left Hand Coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

As a matcha enthusiast who has enjoyed lattes both in NYC and Japan, I was excited to try the matcha latte here. Unfortunately, it turned out to be quite disappointing and might be the worst I've ever had. The flavor was off, it didn't taste like matcha and had a strange fishy taste that I had never encountered in a matcha before. Despite trying to salvage it with a ton of honey and simple syrup the drink just ended up overwhelmingly sweet, to the point where I couldn't finish it. My friend also ordered an iced latte, which sadly fell short as well - it was very watered down and lacked the aromatic richness I expect from a good coffee. The staff were friendly which I appreciated. However, given the quality of the drinks, I'm disappointed and don't see myself returning. read more

Left Hand Coffee - matcha - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

Pretty solid coffee beans and milk options, and cute vibes/interior. Located right by the beach which is nice. Got the macadamia milk flat white which was delicious, and the macadamia milk dirty chai, which was OK. Chai tasted a bit sweet/artificial, so I would just stick with the basics. read more

See all

No notes! Delicious coffee and contemplated buying the beans. Cool merch inside as well. read more

Left Hand Coffee - ICED Hazelnut latte with oat milk - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

We got some iced coffee and a muffin. Everything was yummy. very cute and cozy spot to get really good coffee. read more

Left Hand Coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

Service was nice but place was clearly unmanaged and very overstaffed. There were three girls up front who were all so friendly and helpful. After that it was all downhill Went twice and each time the espresso tasted completely different but equally as terrible. Second time around I watched multiple people that ordered after me get their drinks first. Watched a female employee snap at two different employees and it ended up holding up my drink even longer. Absolute disaster in there and the ambiance is entirely performative. Would do anything but recommend this place read more

Went for coffee and got a few donuts. Without exaggerating it was the best chocolate donut I have ever had. Seriously if you don't do anything else why you're in town go get the donuts. If you see the long line don't worry the staff handles it seamlessly. read more

My boyfriend & I went, I got an iced matcha latte with almond milk & he got a black cold brew. The matcha is really good, I added a bit of honey but regretted it after because it was perfect the way it was! He loves the cold brew. No complaints here, would deff come again :) read more

I thought the coffee was pretty good - we got a Vietnamese coffee. It was sweet, creamy and tasty. The vibes inside were rustic and chill. They should add more indoor seating but it doesn't really matter because the beach is so close by. Additionally, It was overpriced for two shots of espresso ($7.60 for a small). read more

too expensive and ice latte tasted like milk. I don't recommend for the price. But it was nice inside and the service was good, not worth it tho. read more

I got the Nutella latte after a 4 1/2 hour drive to Montauk and it was definitely worth the stop! The coffee is delicious,the guy was nice and the place inside was open and nice. read more

Left Hand Coffee - Small Nutella latte. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

Nothing above average. Just a coffee shop. I definitely wouldn't run back but if i was in a pinch I wouldn't mind. Thought I would add a photo for giggles. I didn't even think to add about the service because everyone's experience is different. But the customer service definitely goes with the owner's attitude. I have no desires to go back now. Customer service is key! read more

Left Hand Coffee - Owner being rude! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

Excellent - dare I say, "Best" - coffee in Montauk. They have a fantastic selection of coffees and everything is rich and full of flavor. I was particularly excited to see an espresso freddo on the menu (a rarity outside of Europe). read more

Amazing coffee! Great service. A little pricey but worth it. They do not any a seating area.

My friends and I came here to grab coffee before taking a walk on the beach on a chilly November Sunday morning. They had lots of different options to choose from. I got a latte with oat milk and it was very well made. Given the delicious coffee as well as this shop's close proximity to the beach, I'd say this the place to go for coffee when out in Montauk. read more

Went to a local diner and had a regular coffee, which was disgusting on first sip so I threw it out and walked over to this cute little cafe. Amazing looking donuts BTW but skipped it to not put myself into a sugar coma. Might be tempted to share one of those though... enough chit chat... Ordered an almond milk flat white and it was done well. Nice and balanced, smooth and creamy. The almond milk didn't have sugar which I appreciate and gave the drink more of that strong coffee taste. Only two small kits. Temperature of the flat white was fine but prefer it a bit hotter. Also flat white was served with no lid which is how you do it but I think you probably then need to embark in some attempt of latte art for presentment. Overall the best espresso/ coffee I have had to date in Montauk and would go back. Also might get a donut! read more

Left Hand Coffee - Almond milk cortado - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

I ordered two triple iced oat lattes and a growler of cold brew -- my order totaled almost $50. As I was paying, no lie, the following occurred. The barista turned to me from the espresso machine with a face full of chagrin. Her: We can only do double pulls on the espresso, so I can't do a triple. Me: You _can't_ do a triple? Pleasant worker who was ringing me up: Well, she ordered two, so you can do three pulls and you'll have two triples. Her: But..... IT'S COMPLICATED. Young lady, divorce is complicated. Fighting global temperature rise is complicated. Working within the national media landscape is complicated. You know what's sure as s--t NOT complicated? Making a $10 triple iced latte in 2023. The coffee was good. I'll never go back. read more

My wife loves matcha so we went searching for some when we were in montauk. This place has that hipster surfer vibe which is typical for Montauk. I mean one customer in there was barefoot. I couldn't believe it. I will say the matcha was very good so they passed that test. In typical montauk fashion it was overpriced. They had a type of flavored water in there for $12 a bottle. I almost fell over when my wife bought it. As for the service it wasn't the most pleasant either. $20 for a matcha and bottled water... crazy... but that's the going rate in this overpriced coffee/tea culture especially in Montauk. read more

See all

I got the Iced Dirty Chai and some Compartes chocolates Caramel Crunch and Chocolate Chip Cookies. So good!! Staff was friendly! read more

Left Hand Coffee - Iced Dirty Chai Latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Nice coffee shop with many choices. People in line had mixed mask behaviors. People just cover your mouth and nose, please. We took our order of six to go. My iced mocha was dessert to start my day. I typically am a plain Jane coffee with milk girl, so it was fun to be decadent. They also enjoyed their cold brew. Next time I will try Vietnamese. No wonder the line is long here! read more

This coffee shop was the high point of our trip to Montauk! The service was very good, one of the staff members gave us a free taste of their cold brew - it was outrageous, so good! We had the regular coffee and the iced Vietnamese coffee, both were delicious.They have all types of milk and sweetener. The lines can get long but they move very quickly. read more

See all

This is the best coffee shop on the east end. There's a reason the line is out the door every summer. High quality coffee, huge assortment of gourmet snacks & pastries and not to mention, Nutella lattes...need I say more? read more

Left Hand Coffee - Iced Americano, iced matcha - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

I fully admit my coffee snobbery, and I was happy with Left Hand. Yeah it's expensive, if that's your gripe, there's a Dunkin for you somewhere nearby. Seriously though, there's that place over by the traffic circle, it's slightly cheaper, and the coffee is slightly less good. You get what you pay for? Anyway, a bunch of the negative reviews talk about the matcha. I don't do matcha, so I can't comment on it. We had no issues with the service, or with our drinks. What sticks out most for me from Left Hand was their orange marmalade (?) croissant, that thing was extra delish, I still remember it like, a year out. read more

Left Hand Coffee - driftwood Kyoto cold-brew slow-drip situation - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

Super cute coffee spot. I am not a coffee drinker but my friend is. She LOVED her coffee, said it was the best she had in Montauk. My matcha tea was delicious. There is very little seating (probably due to COVID) but the beach is a 2 minute walk away. The shop follows COVID guidelines so masks are a must. I have to say that this place is a must when in Montauk. read more

See all

Nice ambiance. Great iced latte* and open off-season. And you can pay via Apple Pay if you dont have your wallet. After getting my coffee, my son and I attempted window shopping in the area, but the rain annoyed us so we went back, grabbed two more iced lattes and went "home" to our hotel. *Coffee is smooth and refined with a touch of nuttiness. Fantastic flavor. Clean - clean machines. Definitely recommended. read more

See all

Our friends know I need a constant stream of coffee every few hours. They took me to 7 Eleven when I first checked into the hotel (They were driving) Once I had the lay of the land, I found in my travels Left Hand Coffee. Forget Starbuck$$, this is a "Coffee House". Look at the picture I posted, I'm going to educate you why Starbucks is the fast food equivalent to coffee. Yes, both places have fancy Espresso machines. That's not the issue. What $tarbuxs does is what I call a "Dump & Pour". They'll heat up the milk fast and dump it all in a cup. Here ya go! No no no! First, my server was the sweetest gal. She could see I was excited about the store. I asked for a "Flat White". Yeah, try getting that in stupid Starbucks. They always make a latte. What was crafted was a perfect Flat White. No dump. The milk was gently heated and poured into my cup. They created a palm tree design! I also noticed a few organic items, I bought a few bars to bring to work. I had one today for breakfast, yummy! They sell many different roasted beans, I saw a pound of $70 Jamaican beans? Yeah.. pass. There are other beans that are more reasonably priced. People are talking about a Nutella latte. I was happy getting a properly poured cup of coffee. Right Hand, meet the left hand. Its brewing some outrageous Left Hand Coffee. read more

Left Hand Coffee - This place is cute as heck (no cursing in a cutie looking establishment) - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Service may be hit or miss but I was there 2 days in a row and the employees were really nice. I got a macadamia milk iced latte 2x and I dream about it. It's soooo good. I even asked for a small in large cup w/ extra ice and they did it for me. It is very pricey. And non-dairy milk costs more but take your pick. Soy, oat, almond, macadamia...So it's good for people w/ dietary stuff. Paper straws - good for ocean - not so great if you don't drink your iced drinks quickly. So consider bringing your own reusable straw or drinking w/o a lid. read more

Left Hand Coffee - Macadamia milk iced latte. Large. Soooo delicious but almost $8 - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Really cute small coffee cafe! For the three days I was in MTK, this was my go to spot to pick up iced espresso with half n half before I head out to John's Pancake House for breakfast. Eco-green friendly - first time using paper straw and I'm not a fan. lol read more

The first time I had Left Hand coffee was actually about a year ago. I was very impressed then and am happy to say that a year later, same location, Left Hand continues to produce delicious coffee. Each time I've always gotten a simple drip coffee. I don't remember the name the first time I ordered here, but this time I ordered Camp Hero. It was a delicious dark blend. I personally love dark roasts so this really hit the spot. For a 16 oz you're looking at $3 which I think was reasonable for this delicious cup of coffee. I highly recommend stopping at this establishment before heading to the beach or walking around town. I love Montauk! read more

Left Hand Coffee - Camp Hero :) - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

Cute little coffee shop. The Nutella latte they offer was interesting because they infuse the Nutella, instead of just layering it on like syrup. Expect Hampton type prices. A good amount of inside seating. Definitely that 'hip/trendy' coffee shop vibe. If I ever end up in the area again, I'd go back! read more

Gem!! A pure gem!!! Heaven on earth!! Best coffee I have had since I was in Jamaica If you are used to diner coffee crap or Dunkin crap then you might think it's too strong If you like Starbucks it's as strong but not bitter Had a red eye and it was perfect Vietnamese was so good too The location is so cute too read more

Left Hand Coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Best coffee in the Hamptons! We come here every time we go to Montauk. They have matcha, cold brew, all types of milks, etc. they also have really cute merchandise! Highly recommend. read more

Left Hand Coffee - Hoodie! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

We visited Left Hand Coffee for our morning brew and pastries. The cold brew was solid (if not particularly unique), and the pastries were decent as well. The shop is cutely decorated, and has a couple of seats if you're looking to enjoy your drinks in house. Overall, a solid coffee option, and possibly the best we tried in the area. read more

Left Hand Coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Montauk, New York

Strawberry matcha was out of this world! Bit pricey, but worth it. Will absolutely be back soon. They also have a variety of non dairy milks which I very much appreciated! read more

Coffee was great. Pastries including croissants were just ok. Service was good but with varying demeanors ranging from pleasant to detached hipster to hungover. read more