Tried for the first time and the turkey, roast beef and Swiss sub looked great but had one major issue - end pieces of the roast beef were not discarded and was tough and chewy. I ended up removing most/all the roast beef to salvage the sub. The remaining turkey and Swiss sub was pretty good. With so many good choices in northern nj. This was my first/ last visit, unfortunately. read more

Lenny & Johns Subs - Turkey, roast beef and Swiss - Sandwiches Near Me - Kenilworth, New Jersey

Super clean and fresh subs! Came here for lunch and I was craving a turkey and cheese sandwich. So happy I came to the right place. The bread was super soft the amount of cheese, turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, oil and vinegar was just right! I liked how the bread was super fresh. I feel that makes the whole sandwich when your bread is nothing but softness! The pricing was decent $6-7$ for a half. I would def come back and would highly recommend this place! read more

Delicious and worth the price and the hype. Tried the tuna because I was told it was the best in NJ. I've had better. So I went with a different sandwich and wasn't disappointed read more

Recommendations: Turkey, Ham & Swiss Sub Tuna Salad Sub (With hot peppers) Food: The deli meat is fresh and they give you a lot of it! Topped with lettuce, tomato, and your choice of spices and dressings results in a full-flavored meal. In addition, their tuna is highly recommended as its flavor is just right: not too fishy, not too sweet, not too much mayo. Staff: Very friendly staff will take the time to make recommendations if you ask. Though, seems they say everything on the menu is a good choice. Ambiance: The store is clean and simply constructed. The menu is clear and special options are posted on the dividing glass. Value: For $6, you can fill yourself up with a decently sized half sub. Split a whole with a friend for more savings. Of note, hot and sweet peppers cost extra, but they're a good value for an extra 50 cents. read more

Lenny & Johns Subs - Jumbo Sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Kenilworth, New Jersey

I'm in love with this little place. We've ordered a bunch of times already and everything is delicious. I'm a big fan of the tuna sub in a tub with hot peppers. Aside from the food, the people there are really nice. The phone orders are friendly with 100% accuracy. Delivery is prompt and nicely packaged. Best of luck to this new local business. read more

Read the reviews of the tuna sub and had to give it a try. Everyone was right--the tuna sub is perfection. Enormous sized long roll, no skimping on the tuna, the right amount of tomato, onions, oil and vinegar. Service is always pleasant. Worth the slightly out of the way drive to the new location inside Mike's Place (especially since they were open even earlier than the hours stated on yelp.) read more

Got 3ft subs and salads for my husband's 60th birthday and I can't tell you how great everything was! Great little place and everyone loved the food and the prices are very reasonable! read more

I had the Turkey, Ham and Swiss and it was awesome!!! Definitely coming back to try the others!!! Btw very good customer service and very clean sub shop!!! read more

Lenny & Johns Subs - Turkey, Ham and Swiss!! - Sandwiches Near Me - Kenilworth, New Jersey

I absolutely love coming here to eat. The Tuna is so delicious . I don't know how they make it but it is so good and fresh. The service is always friendly and helpful. We also got the hot roast beef which was also very tasty. We called ahead and the order was ready to go. We love coming here to get our food! The garlic pickles is also a must!!!! read more

the meat was good but the bread that was used was very plain and hard. It would've been a good sandwich but the bread made it displeasing read more

Lenny & Johns Subs - Turkey ham and Swiss sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Kenilworth, New Jersey

Soft bread with fresh sliced meats. Veg was all fresh, and perfect amount of oil and vin. I also liked that they had kettle chips. I tried their own branded root beer and liked it. Good option for a quick bite- I'd go here over subway or jimmy johns any day. read more

3 stars for the product. Subs are good quality and the bread is on point. Shop is tighty, well lit, and clean. Prices are fair. Old lady behind the counter is consistently miserable, rude, and spewing with bad energy. Time to retire granny. read more

My absolute favorite sandwich shop ever! I use to be a super picky eater would never even dare put onion or tomato on a sandwich until I came here. Everything is so fresh and everyone is so friendly. Their tuna is to die for! Highly recommend read more

PLEASANTLY surprised with how good L&J's sub was earlier today. Came by for a quick sub for lunch, not knowing what to expect. L&J's delivered -- HUGE sub for even the half version; supple, white bread, shredded lettuce, and really thick turkey and cheese. Oil and vinegar tastes great as well... You really can't go wrong with this spot. It's a classic sub taste (big, plush, a lot of meat) with a sopping side of your dressing. Delicious. read more

Everything is great! Tuna is the best I've ever had. Our "go to" place for 3 and 6 foot subs.

By far best Tuna sub I ever had! I go and get the tuna sub at least once a month and it's always been nothing short of stellar. I am very picky about where I get tuna from and prior to here I only got it from Dara's in Elizabeth. The tuna is piled on with the works and provolone cheese. If you're hungry this is the place to go because the half of tuna sub is stacked! Also, the bread is really good. It almost has a sweetness to it and is very airy and light but in a good way. Usually I like the harder Italian sub rolls but there bread adds to the overall flavor and texture. I never had anything else but my mother-in-law loves their Italian sub. If you're in the mood for Tuna give it a shot! read more

This is by far my favorite sub shop in the area. The bread is amazing and they do not skimp on the meat. I always get a half roast beef and turkey and I can only eat half of it because there is so much meat! I am also really picky with toppings but they make the sibs absolutely perfect. The place is so clean and everyone is super nice. Definitely try it out! I also heard the tuna sandwich is banging! read more

AMAZING sandwiches!!!!!! I only got a half of sandwich and could barely eat the whole thing they give you so much meat and cheese it's delicious!!!! def 5 stars!!! read more

great guy! great service! best subs ever!! i agree with everyone's reviews... hands down awesome place. read more

Horrible service and unfriendly staff! My daughter will only eat a ham sandwich with pickles on it. The grumpy old lady says "we don't have pickles" even though it's on the counter. So basically she didn't want to slice pickles to put on my child's sandwich. Unreal. Don't go here the food isn't worth the aggravation. It's not even that good. read more

Had the jumbo half and a chicken half. Both were very good. The hot peppers and the other toppings were perfect. We will be back.

I decided on this place over the other sub shops nearby and I'm glad I did. Delicious subs, quality/fresh ingredients, and good customer service! This place is must-try. I look forward to my next visit! read more

Lenny & Johns Subs - #9 Salami & Cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Kenilworth, New Jersey

The best of the best. I don't know what the secret is because they have Board Head products along with 70% of other sub places in NJ but the overall taste is superior. I stop in when I'm in the area and the staff is always accommodating. Fair prices and they don't skimp out on the meat. The bread is also a winner for a great sub and it's just right here. read more

Great little sub shoppe. You get a good portion of meat on your sub. You must try the tuna fish. They have salads or a pickle to compliment your sub. read more

Picked up 2 subs in the morning and there was a older woman there that had made them, we put them in the fridge to eat later on that day and when we opened them they were made completely wrong and not the great subs we got from there in the past. I called and they were just closing and I was told to call the owner on Monday. I did call and he asked what he could do to fix it and I said make the 2 sandwiches that we ordered and that's all we ever wanted. He made the 2 sandwiches and we picked them up, and for make up subs they were extremely skimpy. We thought we finally had a great sub shop. Haven't been back since. There is one girl that works there that always makes a great sub but we would have check to see if she was there and would make the subs and that's a little nuts. read more

I was there once. I placed an order for 5 people each ordering different sandwiches. Everything Turned out wonderful. My only wish on a cold winter day was that they sold some soup, but otherwise it was great. Would absolutely return for more yummy sandwiches. read more

This is my favorite sub spot in the area. The bread is always fresh and the meat and toppings are always delicious. The prices are fair and the service is usually great. Taking off one star because I just recently went and the older lady forgot to ring up our chips that were sitting on the counter and because we didn't have any cash and it would've been too much of a hassle (on her end) to run the credit card for a $1 bag of chips she had me put them back. She's rude and doesn't really seem to grasp the customer service side of things. Any other employee would've either told us to take them and pay next time or run the credit card again. I would avoid if she's working. Otherwise, absolutely great! read more

I've eaten here before-the younger woman is fine! Today I went in there and the older woman made my tuna WITHOUT GLOVES - so Disgusting - with her long black nails and prob smoke filled fingers and NO I did NOT see her wash her hands! Yuck I will not return! read more

This place is great. I've been here three times and each time the subs are fantastic. The subs are enormous. The cold cuts were delicious. The bread is fresh. The guy who made the subs each time (John?) is friendly and pleasant to talk to. There is a little table by the window but I took my sub back to work each time. The prices are reasonable and parking is super convenient on the street. I'm looking forward to my next visit! read more

They make the best subs in town!! Big, full & delicious!! The service is fast & friendly & very clean!! It's a great new addition to our center of town in Kenilworth!!! read more

If you are looking for an out of this world sub, then this is the place to go. Everything is fresh and well prepared to the way you want it to be. The sandwiches and subs you need two hands to handle, there is so much on them. The people waiting on you are the friendliest and best. Everything you get from here is just out of this world yummy. So give them a try you won't be disappointed. read more

I don't know what how they do it but Lenny & John's makes the most incredible sandwiches. Their tuna is a "must have" for me. Both Kenilworth and Bloomfield locations are equally good. I understand they're a fixture in Bloomfield. The Kenilworth store is new. Growing up in Cranford, I was always in search of the perfect sub. Definitely found it!!!! Owner is a nice guy too. Good stories. read more

Great subs, nice and big still. Everything is fresh and tasty.

nice people but here is my order: spiced, (not spicy) ham, you know the old fashioned kind tomatoes a little onions mayo on a half sub roll here is what i got: capicola, lettuce, tomato, a little onion and NO mayo the girl asked me if i wanted oil and vinegar, i said no and i was THE ONLY CUSTOMER IN THE PLACE so it wasnt like she could be confused. i also had a deli pickle which was good but overwrapped..just needed a ziplock bag and i got a half pound of potato salad which had a very weird tanginess that was very off putting i wont go back, how can you screw up such a simple order? maybe they should try opening a flower shop read more

Lenny and Johns Subs is the best sandwich and deli shop on the blvd. Clean and friendly service. The food is always fresh and the bread is great. Big thick subs. You get alot for your money at this sub shop. Tuna is excellent. I would highly recommend this sub shop to everyone. read more

Have tried several sub shops in Union/Kenilworth area. This place is really good. Clean, friendly service and nice variety of subs. Aside from liking their subs in general there are 2 things that standout by comparison: 1. Their shredded lettuce is crisp! It seems that they don't shred it a day in advance LOL. 2. When you ask them to go light on the oil and vinegar, they actually do! No soggy vinegar-soaked bread here. read more

Best place in the area for subs and sandwiches. Each one specifically prepared as you want it. Delicious rice pudding, take 2!!.

They have a small staff, great service but the best is that the subs are great. Quality food, all fresh, I usually get a Turkey & Cheese and it is loaded...I like a generous sub! This is the best in the area. My go to sub place! read more

Great tuna sandwich, worth the ride for that sandwich, just like the Bloomfield Ave store where I originally had a tuna sub in Bloomfield years ago read more