Service was good, and the breakfast sandwich was well made. My only issue was that I specifically asked for provolone cheese because I do not like yellow cheese, especially American cheese, but they still did not add the cheese I requested. I also placed an advance order for a dozen bagels and cream cheese, which turned out great. The pickup time was before 7 a.m., and it worked out perfectly since the lines don't start forming until later. The place was quiet, and there were plenty of tables available. One thing I really enjoyed was that they offered an extra 6 bagels with the purchase of each dozen, which was a nice bonus. I've been here many times, and I definitely recommend their breakfast sandwiches and wide variety of bagels. Just make sure to double-check your order before leaving. read more

Lenny's Bagels - Create Your Own Egg Sandwich: bacon, egg and cheese pumpernickel bagel - Bagels Near Me - Rye Brook, New York

I went in while the door was propped wide open and no sign stating hours anywhere. The woman behind the counter saw me standing and waiting to order for 5 minutes before she tells me they're closed. I wish I could've at least tried their food. read more

Quick and friendly service! Fresh food. Love the freshly baked goodie options. I had the Bacon, Egg, Cheese and Hash Brown on a Plain Bagel and it was delightful, warm and the crisp of the hash brown was a perfect touch. read more

See all

12-28-25 Needed a few bagels for a quick breakfast thing after picking up at CVS. Waited on the very long slow line, looking at the food and wishing it didn't gross me out so much. Behind the counter, just sitting out unattended, the entire time I waited which was over 20 minutes, was a full side of smoked salmon. Waiting to be sliced. I'm sure it had been there a while before I walked in and even more sure it sat there long after I left. Thing is, that salmon needs to be kept cold to avoid getting anyone sick. It just sat there getting warm. How the health department hasn't closed this place down I have no idea. I reasoned with myself that there was nothing to get me sick in a bagel and took them to go. But really.. where's the owner watching out for us? No one cares. Stay away. read more

Lenny's Bagels - Bagels or bread alphabet? - Bagels Near Me - Rye Brook, New York

The bagel itself was very delicious. I ordered a plain bagel toasted with butter. The muffin selection ran out of what I wanted to order. There was a decent drink selection from coffee, energy drinks, soda products. The line was out the door and it took almost an hour from start to finish. It was very crowded. There was indoor seating, but I personally wouldn't want to eat inside with how packed it was. I do not recall seeing a restroom available for customers. read more

See all

This was the worst catering experience I've ever had. I arrived to pick up an order for 50 people, only to be told there was no record of it. Trying to resolve the issue afterward was just as frustrating--there was no accountability from management, and it took multiple calls just to reach someone. I would strongly recommend taking your business elsewhere. read more

Honesty is always the best policy. I ordered a Turkey sandwich on a plain bagel and it is posted on their sandwich sign at $9.99. When I paid for it the cost was $11.99. The cashier said that is the register price, and when I pressed further she asked the manager over. He said the sign has old prices and threw up his hands with a smile. Really!? Take down the old sign! read more

Got a everything bagel with bacon egg and cheese all fresh and tasted good when in area will stop in again.

Great bagels and a great selection of cream cheese. Classic bagel place! Very solid cup of coffee. Service is super quick and never once has messed up my order. read more

Lenny's Bagels - everything bagel with sun-dried tomato cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Rye Brook, New York

I've been going to Lenny's since the early 90's. Bagels are always fresh and among the best you can get in Westchester. They're BIG with a nice crust on the outside and chewy on the inside. They serve up all the fan favorite flavors and a couple of their own inventions. My fave is the BAD BOY E'rythang. I like mine with butter . They have so much good looking stuff here that I want to try, but I can't past them bagels cause they're really ON POINT. This morning I ordered a dozen for an event and they delivered them to my door on time and OH SO FRESH, the aroma was wafting from the bag. It's great to have something so reliably delicious for so long right here. Inside there's long lines on the weekend. That can be a fun social event if it's your vibe. Seat yourself after getting your order. Coffee is okay which is why I prefer to bring them home. Lenny is there often, and we all should visit him. This is a the only show for bagels in Po Cho'. read more

Pulled 3 hairs out of my sandwich. Called the restaurant, and there was no apology. Person I talked to on the phone just shrugged it off and said "yeah, but the hairs were just on one sandwich right?" Was told to take a picture and bring it back in lol...After I had just spent $36 at the business. Horrible service. read more

Lenny's Bagels - a turkey sandwich with lettuce - Bagels Near Me - Rye Brook, New York

This place is terrible. The bagels are stale. The coffee is the worst I've ever had at any professional establishment - it is flavorless and tastes like drinking a cup of warm brown water. And on top of this the staff is rude. read more

Terrible service, rude, over priced and the bagels suck. There is always a wait time with no line management , no communication. Food ordered online is never right and the wait times are just as bad as going in person to order. The choices in this town are limited but if you like quality this is not the place. read more

Don't buy bagels from here, I bought 4 blueberry ones and they were all hard and moldy!!! I also have had their yardbird meal and it's good but there is basically no seasoning on it so it's pretty bland. At least it wasn't moldy. Their hash browns are good though! read more

Great fresh bagels and spreads! The ex is my favorite. They also have gluten free bagels and low carb which are great! They have great spreads with such interesting flavors like garlic and herb and fig! The service is great and they were busy but pretty quick despite being a bit crowded! Definitely recommend! read more

Lenny's Bagels - Part of the deli bar. The pasta salad was superb - Bagels Near Me - Rye Brook, New York

See all

If poor/rude/disorganized service, stale bagels, and an appalling lack of cleanliness are your thing, this place would be right up your alley. If not, avoid this place like the plague. read more

I tried to come here one day while staying in the area, to find that they weren't open because of a random power outage, and they had no idea when they would be able to open. Next day, I thought give it another go, glad I came back by here. I wanted to take bagels to my customer and had stopped at a Dunkin Donuts previously. I can't even describe how much of a difference it makes coming to a place that is specifically a bagel store. Much larger selection. Considerably fresher. Also, even more surprisingly, about half the price. I didn't try any of the warm options, but if you want a bagel sandwich they can hook you up with that as well. Coffee and drinks (juices and sodas) they have everything you need to get going in the morning. If I'm in the area again I will totally be coming back here again. Also, intend on trying one of the bagel sandwiches next time. Great location and glad I came back! read more

Lenny's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Rye Brook, New York

Stale and not good bagels... would not recommend ordering bagels from here. Also found a piece of salmon bone in my lox spread...

Excellent bagel deli, food, and service is grate, I always like Lenny's bagel for breakfast or lunch, a great environment there.

Recently decided to order off of DoorDash for Sunday breakfast. Since it was online I cant attest to the atmosphere inside, just my experience with ordering. I liked the menu items and found them to be interesting. I created two egg sandwiches, which had a lot of choices but got pricey. I ended up paying $9 a piece for a simple sandwich (bacon, egg, cheese, hash brown, and sausage, egg, cheese, has brown), which I was definitely turned off by. After ordering through doordash the store was very delayed in confirming my order. The delivery driver arrived to the store ~15 mins after I submitted the order and after him being there was told they hadn't even started making my order yet and it would be another 10 mins or so. It took almost an hour since ordering to actually receive my food, and this was due to the stores delay in starting my order. The estimated time was 30 mins so this was disappointing to me. Once the food arrived the sandwiches were very good. Loved the bagel that my sausage egg and cheese was on and found it to be hearty. Still likely not worth $9 though. I had also ordered an iced coffee that came with no ice, which was odd. While I did like the meal I had, the delay and price kind of turn me away from ordering again. I would give it another chance and go into the store itself next time and see if that yields better results. read more

As mentioned in prior reviews staff is incredibly rude. The inside is remarkably dirty with trash and crumbs on the floor. It's impossible for the workers to get your order correct. They have no idea what's on the menu. If you order a side of lox ask for Nova; if you want nova spread ask for lox spread. It's like herding cats. Drive the extra mile to have a better bagel experience. read more

This is a picture of the gobbler wrap I ordered for lunch today. Can someone please explaim to me how I am supposed to eat this? I literally watched her attempt to wrap it up and fail miserably, yet they still gave it to me. For a $14.00 sandwich, I'm at beyond disappointed. I would have been better off getting all the ingredients myself and making three or four wraps. Now yes, abundance of food but literally it is Impossible to hold because it falls apart immediately. read more

Lenny's Bagels - a burrito wrapped in aluminum foil - Bagels Near Me - Rye Brook, New York

Great bagel sandwiches. Extremely loud music. I may be going deaf but read other reviews, I'm not that crazy. When will Shop owners understand that the experience is part of the purchase. Blowing your ears off is not the way FrankG read more

Excellent but be sure to check your bag before you leave- they are very busy and may forget to include all items. Otherwise terrific

Overpriced, overrated and understaffed. Staff grumpy and unhurried tho not shy about pushing the screen asking for a tip. I asked for my bagel toasted - it wasn't . I just wish we had more choices because Lenny's stopped being great a long time ago read more

I was hesitant to write a review for a small business because I felt bad but everyone else said the same thing so I don't! The food is ok however the service is horrific. They move at a glacial pace and are so rude. I almost took a picture today as they had a line and the 4 counter people are just standing talking not doing anything. I am pretty unsure how this place is still in business. If you have 45 minutes to wait for a ok bagel and extremely rude service this place is for you read more

My favorite bagel place! Been coming here for years, I think they're the best bagels around. There can be a long line but I find it's worth the wait. You may be able to avoid the line by going first thing in the morning (around 6 or 7am) or after the lunch rush (so 1-2pm). They close at 3. read more

I love Lenny's! I have been going since I was a little girl (now I am 22) and it's always been amazing. I found out over the summer that I had Celiac Disease, and Lenny's has GF bagels that are delicious! The service is quick and everyone is very friendly. The line can get pretty long sometimes but it moves fast and it's worth it! read more

So it's finally time to seek out a new place for bagels! The tables were dirty and sticky (not to mention completely beat up and should be tossed to the curb), thank goodness I took the top off my coffee to stir the sugar because the Half and Half had curdled, and the deciding factor is what they are charging for jelly with a cream cheese bagel! I asked for the jelly on the side and they put it in the smallest container (4 oz.). Now please note the weight and how much they charged! Not even three ounces and $2.32!! We used to get those little individual jelly that were maybe a tablespoon, some restaurants even have them on each table! Another thing to note is the sticker says "cream cheese", so is jelly the same price as cream cheese? Are they charging for a higher priced item? I could've bought an 18 oz. jar of jelly for that price! Needless to say, I'll be LEAVING LENNY'S! read more

See all

Owners sons a cry baby. Customer service is at all time lows here. When they get busy these kids really shit the bed. But with the options so slim in the area... ill be back. Hard to lose when you're the only game in town. But common. Smile be calm, be cool, you're serving bagels. read more

They are rude and I guess they have enough customers they can afford to do that. I called because I could not order a flat with scallion and tomato online so when I called to order they guy said order on line and hung up. So we went in to order and the guy who took the order did not understand anything I said and had the nerve to get annoyed with me. I live in the area and after countless negative encounters I AM DONE. I will never go back. read more

Mediocre bagels and worse service. Place is dirty. Rarely a smile or thank you from the owner. Better alternative is rye hand rolled bagels near post office. More expensive but well worth it. I have no connection to them. read more

I stopped going to Lenny's a while back and thought I'd give them another try. The bagels in my opinion are undercooked and "doughy". Probably worse than I remember. Taste is the main thing , but the dozen I bought today were all miss shaped and just look real sloppy. read more

Placed order online. Two egg sandwiches and coffee. The website said 45 min to pick up. Once in-store staff was rude and unattentive. Waited another 10 minutes when finally got sandwiches from the very disinterested staff sandwiches were luke warm and coffee cold. I cannot understand how the corporate culture of rudeness is tolerated in this shop. Will never return. Too many good spots in the area! read more

Horrible customer service, called in to see what I could order then I was hung up on 3 times. RUDE rather go to bagel emporium any day. Horrible customer service, what do you expect from A place in rye brook read more

This place is normally hit or miss. Went here for the second time in two weeks and had issues both times. The first time a friend got food poisoning, and the next her chicken was undercooked. Luckily they were nice enough to give her a new sandwich free of charge. I got the Downtown sandwich. It was a tad bit dry (no mayo on this one). Next time I will ask for that. read more

This used to be an ok place for bagels but not anymore. The quality and value has gone WAY DOWN and it is the same owner! We moved away but were in the area so picked up a dozen to bring home. They were pathetic. No better than grocery store bagels. It seriously seems like Lenny is trying to pinch pennies by making the bagels smaller, not cooking them enough, and skimping on the seeds. I really couldn't believe it when I got them home had to take a picture. They're barely bigger than an english muffin and so soft and undercooked that the bagels at the bottom of the bag were crushed! Shame on Lenny for milking this location and the cheapness or laziness that is making his bagels suck! read more

Lenny's Bagels - These were rolls with holes - no bigger and less cooked than an untoasted english muffin! Lame. - Bagels Near Me - Rye Brook, New York

Ive had quite a few breakfast sandwiches but this was my first time at Lenny's and it was delicious. I went in at around 10am with my girlfriend and the place had a short line. The woman behind the counter took our order which I wish she wrote down because I thought she might forget something but in the end she got it right. Coffee was good, pictures of sandwiches are attached. Nothing really to complain about here, the food and bagels are great and the service is decently friendly. read more

Lenny's Bagels - Egg bagel, egg, avocado, American cheese and peppers and onions - Bagels Near Me - Rye Brook, New York

See all

Let me say first that I do love this place! They make the best low carb bagels! I ordered 3 bagels and cream cheese.. I know they are busy on Saturday morning that is why I ordered for pick up.. went at the time they said it would be ready. It wasn't so I waited.. after a 10 min wait I had to ask for my food. I am not complaining about the wait time it happens. My issue is while waiting for my order I saw that they were filling all the large orders first and neglecting the small ones.. there was I and another person waiting for our small orders. It was apparent that they did not take the orders in order of request .. very disappointing! read more

This has to be one of the best bagels Westchester by far! I have no idea why it gets only 3 stars. The cashier was really nice to me and repeated my order to make sure I got everything. I got the cheese bacon and egg bagel and it was warm and divine! Well done and I will be coming back for more! read more