THIS LOCATION IS OPEN. This is in Naples at the RADIO RD LOCATION. Dined here yesterday, April 2, 2026. It's absolutely DELICIOUS! Already planned to return next week for lunch. One diner mentioned this is counter service only. . That's an old review. This place has been remodeled, and they do NOW HAVE FULL TABLE SERVICE. . Our server was wonderful. Very warm and welcoming. The menu is short. But the food is outstanding. You won't be disappointed. They serve lobster rolls warm or cold, your choice. Comes with a side of shoestring fries. The rolls are the freshest I've ever had. Incredible flavor. They also offer a wine selection. The service was fantastic and the seating is quite comfortable- inside. They do also offer al fresco dining. Located on the corner of the shopping plaza near Publix. read more

This is a very casual fast food style restaurant. Usually, I'm not a fan of ordering at a counter and then waiting for the food kind of a place.... however, the lobster roll here was very good and plentiful. I mean, this sandwich had lots of lobster meat, and it wasn't drenched in butter. The lobster bisque was also good... creamy but not excessively, so I guess you can say that it was not light but not heavy either. It is an okay place just to come get your lobster fix. read more

Lobster Rolls No 1 - a man and a woman standing at a counter - Seafood Near Me - Naples, Florida

an absolutely delicious meal that started with the best lobster bisque I've ever tasted. followed by a hot lobster roll. bun was filled with lobster. very tasty. we were five at the table and were not rushed. wine selection was excellent. service was perfect great warm atmosphere. prices very reasonable highly recommend it. serves a great turkey lasagna and beef bolognese great eveniing read more

Another hidden gem from Naples that was AMAZING. Lobster Rolls are a favorite dish of mine, and I knew I had to find some on my Naples visit. I saw this place being recommended to me, and we decided to drop by. Service was super quick and the first bite was everything I dreamed of. The lobster was juicy and chilled, and fit perfectly against the warm buttered rolls. There is plentiful lobster meat within the rolls and every bite was delicious. I loved how close it was to where we were staying, and I definitely will have to come back and grab a bite! read more

Lobster Rolls No 1 - Classic Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - Naples, Florida

Drove quite a ways to try this place out tonight, only to find it shuttered and closed at 6:30 PM...no sign on the door with an explanation, but the hours on the door say 11;30 - 8:30 every day. I would not attempt to try this place without calling them first. Never again for us. You only get to do that to me once. read more

Great service, the food was so good. We teied the classic lobster roll, lobster bisque. They also have a kids menu read more

See all

The service was quick and friendly. We brought our own adult beverages from Publix next door. The lobster rolls are really good (both Maine and Connecticut) and loaded with lobster meat. There's a crockpot of butter on the counter that's used to warm the lobster for the Connecticut roll - I think this added a lot more flavor vs the cold Maine lobster roll. The salad is okay as there's very little greens but plenty of lobster on top. The fries and tater tots were a bit soggy since the oil it was fried it probably wasn't hot enough - will probably order this extra crispy next time, or mention we don't mind the wait for the oil to heat up. Lobster bisque was wonderful and topped with plenty of lobster meat. Will probably return for just a Connecticut lobster roll and the bisque next time. read more

See all

Amazing lobster roll. Got them for the first time when they had the $15 rolls. Service is great. Hoping to go again when they have specials.

Best lobster roll I've had outside of New England, and I've had a lot of lobster rolls! The bun was light and made specifically for lobster rolls (not a hotdog bun). The lobster was plentiful and tasted so fresh, like it had just been caught. I asked for "not too much butter" and it was the perfect amount. The price was very reasonable for the quality and quantity. We also ordered French fries which didn't come out until after we had finished our rolls. They were undercooked so they made a new batch which were also undercooked. They said they were having a problem with their air fryer. I was impressed that they used an air fryer rather than a regular fryer and am assuming this is a temporary blip. There is some indoor seating on picnic benches and backless wooden stools. There are also tables outside. Overall it's a super casual vibe. We will definitely be back even thought it's quite a drive. We used to go to Doug's Seafood for lobster rolls but these are superior in terms of both quality and price. read more

See all

Had to come to Florida to get the best Maine lobster roll... 3.5oz of lobster on a perfectly toasted bun. Robyn's personal touch made the experience even better. read more

Lobster Rolls No 1 - The Connecticut lobster roll! - Seafood Near Me - Naples, Florida

What a fantastic visit to Lobster Roll #1 I googled lobster rolls and this restaurant came up....I decided to give it a try and am I glad I did!!! Probably THE BEST LOBSTER ROLL I'VE HAD SINCE LEAVING BOSTON!!! I was politely greeted by NICOLE she was so sweet. She informed me it was her first day. She was fantastic and will be a great addition to this great restaurant. The Maine-iac Owner (Yahve) was also so polite and accommodating. My lobster roll had the perfect amount of FRESH LOBSTER MEAT with a light lemon mayo. Mmmm the fries perfectly fried golden brown.... If your looking for the best Lobster Roll in Naples it's a Home Run!!! read more

Lobster Rolls No 1 - The Lobster Salad Roll - Seafood Near Me - Naples, Florida

Nice dinner, surprisingly good. The Connecticut lobster roll was fabulous, good portion of buttery warm lobster claw and meat, roll was perfectly browned, moist and full of flavor, really well done roll and at a good price. They also have a German menu, we had the goulash and spaetzle, very authentic, nice spices and gravy with the meat. read more

Lobster Rolls No 1 - Goulash and spaetzle - Seafood Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

The connecticut lobster roll was recommended to me by a retail salesperson in Tin city. I mist say it was delicious and I think it had to do with the breading. The lobster tasted good, but the "roll" was different than most places. The clam chowder was decent too (not the best, but a pretty good fix). They're fairly new to the plaza, but service is good. read more

See all

Hit the spot, nothing special about presentation but good product. Tasty and hands down the top of list in area.

Drool worthy Lobster Rolls! Quick and efficient service. We were in around 3:30, so there was no line. Clean and cute decor. Wish prices were a bit lower for the amount of food we got but it was fantastic! read more

Lobster Rolls No 1 - Tater Tots - Seafood Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

First time trying this place and it was super good! Simple menu so it's not hard to make a good decision. Ordered two lobster rolls, one classic and one Connecticut and a lobster bisque soup. Everything was amazing and it had a great amount of lobster on the rolls. I'd deff come back here when I'm in the area. read more

I made a visit while I was in town with my wife, as I've been hearing about the popularity of this restaurant. This location looks to still be changing over from a former business as there was no sign on the building, but there was on the door to locate the business. We ordered the Connecticut lobster roll, classic lobster roll, lobster grilled cheese, and lobster Mac and cheese. Both rolls were delicious in their own way! My wife preferred the classic as she prefers her rolls with chilled. We both enjoyed the Mac and cheese, as it was very cheesy and had some salt and pepper added to it. The grilled cheese was ok, I hoped the cheese on the sandwich would be melted more. On this day, the store was short staffed, so we waited a very long time for our food, it came out similarly to Waffle House, as we got each order as it was ready. Not knocking the lone individual that was working as she did her best to serve another table of 6 then us. But I hope more peo6are hired to help the food come out faster. read more

We went for the first time yesterday. From the rave reviews posted by fellow New Englanders I was expecting something as good as Kennebunkport or any place in Maine. While the classic lobster rolls we had were good, they were not the best we've had in Naples. The rolls were a tad undersized and my wife's roll had an excess of claw cartilage. They were also not as flavorful as we had expected. We found the lobster rolls served at Hogfish Harry's to be better, tastier and bigger. The $21.00 classic roll here came with no sides. The $2.00 sides we had of potato salad and cole slaw were good, but small servings. The $22.00 roll at Hogfish Harry's came with a side of one's choice. The organic sodas from Maine available here are delicious, especially the Blueberry soda. The interior of the restaurant is small, seating maybe 25 patrons at best. There is outdoor seating and plenty of parking. The restaurant seemed understaffed, a common issue here in Naples. Most of the available seats had trays of dirty plates, etc. as some discourteous people did not bus their own tables as expected. The staff of 2 there yesterday were too busy handling the food prep. so we bussed other peoples' mess so we could eat in the a/c interior. For a $60.00 tab plus tip for two, customers should not be expected to do this. For us, it would not be worth it to make a return trip anytime soon. read more

Second time here for their Lobster Rolls and again very delicious! This time I had their Lobster Bisque and it was delicious. Their lobster portions are generous. Great staff as well! We will be back! read more

Lobster Rolls No 1 - Lobster bisque - Seafood Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

This is The Connecticut Lobster Roll, it's amazing! I loved the lemon to go with it. The chips were munchies to eat on while going back home. I also enjoyed the Lobster Bisque to go with it. It was definitely creamy and the lobster roll was such a good hit to dip it into. The total was 34.13 with tax. I would definitely go again. It is a little pricey but if you were to take yourself on a nice day, I would suggest coming here! Yahve served me, he was very nice and polite. You could tell he made it with love! The wait wasn't bad at all, I understand because I believe he was the only one working. But it is totally fine with me. read more

Lobster Rolls No 1 - This is The Connecticut Lobster Roll, it's amazing! I also bought the Lobster Bisque to go with it! 10/10! - Seafood Near Me - Naples, Florida

Worked nearby and I wanted a quick in and out lunch. The lobster roll was plentiful but the calm chowder had more potato than clam. read more

See all

Delicious lobster dishes. Loved the lemony dressing on the salad - got three meals out of it. The staff was friendly and helpful read more

I went here to eat and had a Connecticut lobster roll and a lobster bisque soup.. the sandwich was a great amount of lobster and the bisque was creamy, buttery tasting and had a lot of lobster on top! Wow!! My friend had the sliders .. I liked everything so much that I a.pplied for a job and work here now. read more

Received the wrong sandwich and no fries. There was only one person behind the counter, and while I applaud him for trying, he clearly does not understand English well enough to be taking orders from customers. Someone should have been there to help him. read more

Pretty sad amount of lobster for $17. Was told at 6:15 we could only order to go when they close at 7:00. Took over 20 minutes for 1 lobster roll and cup of soup. read more

Good food but a little too expensive. Service is great, it was fairly slow when I went there, but has a good vibe.

Top dollar for watery lobster roll. Will not return nor recommend. Another "one and done" for me.

Pretty standard for a lobster roll nothing special, recently they changed the prices which reflect 4-5 star restaurants. when this placed first opened a few not too long ago, its been months i believe the prices were reasonable $16.99 a roll $5 for a cup of soup. Went in today for one roll and two cups of soup and spent $45, definitely not worth the price. read more

We were in Naples this week and I had been researching Naples' best lobstah rolls. We tried Maine Shack at Celebration Park in early spring. They were quite tasty, yet a bit pricey at $29. Meanwhile, on a Naples FB group, this place was touted over and over. Four of us stopped by today for lunch. Three of us ordered the Connecticut roll and one ordered the Lobster sliders. Wow! Our CT roll was huge, a big, buttery, hot toasted brioche roll filled generously with warm buttery meat and a wedge of lemon for seasoning. We were in heaven. Our Lobster slider person enjoyed three mini rolls generously filled with CT, classic and lobster salad style meats. She commented that she probably had more meat than we did for a very affordable $15.95 price while ours were still reasonably priced at $21.95. Each came with a bag of Cape Cod chips. We concluded that this is now our go to place for the best Lobstah Rolls in Naples. Check them out! read more

Lobster Rolls No 1 - Connecticut Lobstah on a big, buttery, hot brioche roll - Seafood Near Me - Naples, Florida

Really awesome restaurant. It was nice and clean and the food was delicious. We got the Connecticut lobster roll and the Lobster bisque. It was an abundance of lobster. But, what made the experience wonderful and over the top was our server Ingrid. I can go on and on about her. She is the bright light in the establishment. She was extremely friendly, helpful, and pleasant to talk to. The food was great but the service was outstanding read more

Lobster Rolls No 1 - Lobster bisque and lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Naples, Florida

Great food, decent price, good vibe, great service. Worth a stop in. Very quick as well

We are from New England and were seeking the perfect lobster roll. Unfortunately, we were disappointed in the quality of " lobster salad roll" which was grainy in consistency and didn't have any seasoning. The " Connecticut Roll" tasted like a fresh lobster roll and was a good value. The server was knowledgeable attentive. We will be continuing our search for the perfect Lobster Roll in Naples! read more

Outstanding Lobster roll and Lobster Bisque. I got the Connecticut Lobster roll was very tasty and had big pieces of lobster. The only thing holding back 5 stars is it is understaffed. there was no line, although 3 others waiting on food, and it took a long time to get my order . I cant imagine the wait if there had been a line, but to their defense, it was very good and fresh. read more

Excellent!!! Great Lobster Roll. Very tasty. Wife made me go back next night. Met owner, extremely personable. read more

Definitely a 5 star review. We are from Cape Cod and really miss a good lobster roll. We were planning a visit to Ft Lauderdale to see friends also from New England and I decided to bring lobster rolls from Lobster Rolls #1. I picked up unconstructed lobster rolls the night before as we need to leave before they opened at 11. I bought 5 Lobster rolls for the 4 of us as I figured I would need to add extra lobster to each roll when I prepared them. The rolls were very fresh and the lobster very plentiful. We actually had the left over lobster the next day. Just the right amount of mayo. The woman that took my order was extremely friendly and accommodating. Can't wait to go back for more. Highly recommend this place to any New Englander looking for a taste of home read more

Lobster was fresh but the roll was underdressed. The lobster Mac and cheese was the smallest portion I have ever seen and was not fresh at all. read more

This place started out being very fair with the amount of lobster but that changed. I went today after not going for a few months. It all depends upon who prepares your lobster roll and it is not consistent. The guy who did it today just did not fill it as they have in the past. I like that they do no drench the lobster in mayo for the lobster salad but that is all I like and may have to find a new resource. disappointed as I used to go there weekly. read more

Took a chance, no one recommended this place and I was intrigued and delighted that the food was excellent! I hope more people frequent this place - it would be very sad if it wasn't still here when I come back! Connecticut Roll was delish- THANK YOU!!! read more

I had their special 3 sliders for $9.99. Each one had a different flavor. Each one was loaded with chunks of lobster. Will definitely go back again. You pay at a window and wait for them to call your number. Unfortunately there is no ambiance. read more

Gave this place a try for take out. WOW ! Lobster rolls were fantastic, looked like a whole lobster worth of meat on each roll. The bisque is amazing and has some serious chunks ( not just bits ) of lobster. We were really happy with our meal and will definitely be back. They do need a bigger sign though ! I drove by twice looking for it. If you love lobster, you will love this place ! read more