Great pizza, fantastic calzone, relaxed environment & our service top notch. We liked it so much, we came twice in our week in HHI!

Really good pizza! Fresh ingredients cooked in a wood fired oven. Service was friendly and quick. Pretty good beer and drink selections, too. read more

The pizza was okay. A little undercooked. The service was sub-par. We were only checked on once during appetizers- and it was happy hour so we were hoping to order a couple more drinks! Not sure I would be back. read more

We stopped by on the way into Hilton Head. I tried to order online but it looked like the site they use charges extra than the prices on the posted menu, so we called our order in and picked it up. We got large Sup Pizza and a large cheese pizza. We were driving into town from Bluffton and it was ready as soon as we got there so our timing was good. My husband loved his Sup/Supreme pizza and said there was a lot of flavor. I thought the cheese was ok. It wasn't anything to write home about. I would give it a 3, he would give his pizza a 5; so I gave them our average - 4. It may depend on what you order. If I came back I would probably try the margarita pizza since I like tomatoes, mozzarella and basil. I forgot to take pictures before we started eating so just focus on the uneaten pieces! :) read more

Local Pie - 16" Suped Up Pie - Pizza Near Me - Hilton Head Island, South Carolina

See all

The family was craving pizza so we tried Local Pie. It was actually really tasty. We ordered the garlic knots and spinach artichoke dip for starters. The red sauce was delicious with the garlic dipping knots, the six were gone in a minute. The spinach dip was very thick dip with a tremendous amount of cheese. It was served with house made chips the were delicious. If you're not a cheese fan the spinach artichoke will definitely disappoint. But, we are cheese fans. We ordered two 16" pies, the little bear and the souped up. They fed six people with left overs for lunch on thanksgiving day. The souped up had a great combination of Greek olives, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions and pepperoni. It was a pleasing blend the Greek olives added a taste punch that black olive lack. Well worth the extra effort by local pie. The second pie the little bear, had pepperoni, Italian sausage and sliced local meatballs, with mozzarella as the main cheese. The three meats combined to make a complex savory blend to the tongue. It also kept my glucose in a stable state after having a couple of slices. The meal was a nice treat for the thanksgiving week stay. read more

Local Pie - The suped up pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hilton Head Island, South Carolina

See all

Stopped in while on vacation for a pizza fix. Orders two pies and they were both super tasty with fresh ingredients. The Cesar salad was also very fresh with awesome homemade croutons. A def winner on HHI! read more

Local Pie - The Duh - 16" Pie - Pizza Near Me - Hilton Head Island, South Carolina

See all

Food was good but service was horrible! Would not return due to the service. Came as a group of 6 and food was served in three batches. No refills or service at all read more

Nice facility, new and spacious. We are looking at it as a pizza place. Of the three pizza joints we tried on HHI, this is our favorite. Wood fired, thin crust, lots of topping. Service was quick and friendly, but I was a little turned off seeing one of the pizza makers eating a slice of pizza where he makes ours, what a perk of the job! My husband wished there was shrimp topping, and more varied toppings. I was surprised by calamata olives on the veggie pizza. We would go back for sure. read more

Such good pizza, knots, wings and atmosphere and service. If you're looking for good pizza in Hilton Head this is your go to spot!

Pizza tasted like frozen. Server forgot our order so waited over an hour for two slices. Enough said.

SO good! We recently moved to HHI and have been looking for our go-to pizza place and we've found it in Local Pie! Picked it up to go but a great atmosphere that made us want to dine in next time. Pizza was outstanding. We will be back! read more

Went with a party of 6 and they could only make the order for five. They literally forgot one person then I had to find a server to get my food. Nobody checked to see if the food or anything was satisfactory. There are so many very good restaurants on Hilton Head. No need to waste your time here. read more

Local Pie had just finished their Happy Hour when we arrived for dinner so we were lucky to get a table promptly. Be mindful that it does get busy during that time so you may have to wait for a table. There are TVs situated throughout the restaurant playing interesting content like funny animal videos and a surfing competition - it kept my family entertained along with the restaurant's playlist of pop-punk hits. Both of my daughters ordered a kids cheese pizza. My husband and I got one of tbt signature pizzas, the Baller. Pies come medium or large. We enjoyed ours but the edges of one of our daughter's pies was burnt- that's the risk you take when going to a wood fired pizza joint. Our waitress was good and anticipated when we needed refills or extra napkins. read more

Went for happy hour. Good values on the menu and one of the better beer menus on the island.

Pizza and wings after church. Food was excellent. Server was friendly and attentive. Comfy cool vibe. Will b back.

Such a delish pizza spot on HHI! We had the Little Bear Pizza & the Local Ball 13 appetizer. Tasty flavor! My only complaint is the pizza was a tad too soggy to hold and eat. read more

Biggest rip off on HHI. Ordered a pie with onion and green pepper for $3 each. The toppings were a joke. Maybe 2 tablespoons of chopped pepper. A few slices of onion. Never going back read more

We had the wedge salad which was really good. My husband got the LaLa pizza which needed a little more sauce and I got the Veggie Pie which was delicious! The wood fired crust was great. The service was quick. Actually, too quick. We had just gotten our salad starter and our pizzas came out right behind it. The server was sweet & apologetic, but the exact thing happened to the table next to us. So, if you want your salad or appetizer truly ahead of your meal so you can enjoy it without letting your pizza get cold, hold off on ordering your pizza until your starter arrives. I'm not sure what it was, but both my husband's and my water had a really bad taste. Last helpful tip: be sure to ask if there are any specials for the night if your server doesn't tell you when they first come to your table. I heard a different server telling her tables after we had ordered and had I known I would have ordered differently. (I didn't hear our server tell any of her tables about them) We will definitely go back. read more

Local Pie - 10" Veggie Pie - Pizza Near Me - Hilton Head Island, South Carolina

Great food. Okay service overall - but our server was off. The specials were great. Overall an above average experience. Worth a try if you are looking for solid pizza. ** didn't appreciate the non explained credit card fees. read more

See all

Extremely Disappointing Experience From the moment we arrived, this visit was frustrating. There was no host at the entrance, and we waited several minutes before a bartender had to step away from behind the bar to acknowledge us and seat us--something that should have been handled promptly upon our arrival. While I appreciated the bartender's professionalism and the kind acknowledgment of my military service, the rest of our experience fell far below any reasonable expectation of quality service. After being seated, we watched multiple parties--including two couples, a family of five, and another party of two--get seated after us and yet receive their food, drinks, and even checks before we were even able to place our order. There was a noticeable lack of attentiveness to our table. We were not checked on regularly, and it felt as if our presence was overlooked. For a dining experience with my family, this was extremely disappointing and frustrating. Service is just as important as the food, and unfortunately, both were undermined by the unacceptable wait and poor customer care. I cannot in good faith recommend this restaurant based on our experience. read more

Wood fired pizza gets me juicy so maybe my expectations were too high. This might be someone's favorite pizza but it's mids for me. Overall the crust was a bit too thick maybe overworked very dense and chewy. Wood fired puts me in mind light airy bubbly crust, this definitely wasn't that. We got a couple zas the specialty mushroom pizza had barely cooked mushrooms and onions for toppings. I like raw onions but nearly raw mushrooms not so much. Overall not for me, might be your new favorite though, possibly worth a try. read more

Local Pie - Meh - Pizza Near Me - Hilton Head Island, South Carolina

See all

21 year old-drunk college student-me would've LOVED this place. Any other self-respecting adult version of myself is embarrassed that I actually spent money here. Poorly constructed. Rough is over worked and chewy. 16" is just the 12" stretched thinner (with an added charge for ....? Who knows ). Whatever the wait time is, add 40 minutes. No seasonings used - literally not even a flake of oregano to be found in this place. Very bland. They do have By The Slice but it looks like the ninja turtles made it in the sewer. read more

Their wood fired pizza is the best on HHI, and the beer selection is always pushing the limits on quality brew-creations. If pizza isn't your thing, the Father Sarducci is one of their money subs. It come on a fresh baked sub roll that's crispy on the outside, soft on the inside with a delicious herb-fetta dressing. Pro Tips: Get the dressing on the side for dipping. Its a popular place for Happy Hour, so get there early. read more

See all

This place is a sleeper Great pizza! Once you order it .due to the heat of the ovens it comes out quickly Pizza is five stars. This is some of the best pizza I have ever had. Margherita pizza is simple and delicious! The appetizer we had was okay Fried green tomato and mozzarella...it was good but something neas missing or off... maybe cheese was too cold , or tomatoes slightly too firm. The whining kids next to us.....ugh.... Next time we will eat the bar or outside Great place for takeout and a lesser expensive meal out in HHI.. WE will definitely go back read more

Local Pie - Fried green tomato and mozzarella appetizer Not bad, not great - Pizza Near Me - Hilton Head Island, South Carolina

The food at this pizza place was amazing, and the service was great as well! My families server was super kind. The place was a tiny bit crowded, but the overall atmosphere was good. If you are hungry, you could easily eat a whole 10 inch pizza. Overall, it is an amazing pizza place! read more

Best pizza on the island! We always get takeout here when we visit HHI! Our favorite for Pizza. Everything on the menu is so good.

We created a pizza with sausage, pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, and fresh spinach and shredded mozzarella cheese. The pizza had great color, and a soft, chewy crust with crunch. The charasmatic hostess/server was attentive and fun. The dining room was clean, and spacious. read more

What a wonderful time I had there today watching a football game. Food was great. Drinks were ice cold. Pizza was perfectly cooked ( not burnt ). Brittney took great care of us ! 5 stars read more

Local Pie is my go to pizza place on Hilton Head. It rocks from top to bottom. Jimmy and Christine and everyone who works there brings a great vibe to the place that just makes it fun to be there. Food is great too. Paul read more

Local Pie - Pizza Near Me - Hilton Head Island, South Carolina

We sat outside on the deck for supper, which is fun! Good meal. Good beers! Service was okay, one of our meals came out a bit later but we survived. read more

Excellent spot to grab a pizza! Stopped in for carry out, had a glass of vino, and then grabbed pizza and wings to go. Pizza had a good crust and the toppings for the pizza were on a thin dough. Wings we got were bbq and were tasty. For those who noted the crust was burnt in previous reviews, this is true, it is wood fired pizza and it is tasty! The bar had 23 beers on tap and had a neat design of half the bar inside and half the bar outside. read more

See all

Loved this place. Friendly staff. Great service!! Unique nicely decorated interior We didn't eat but the pizza looked awesome. Give it a try read more

Best pizza on the island coming from a New Yorker!!! Delicious pie with fun options for everyone. Been coming here for years and it never disappoints. Nice casual vibe and great waitstaff. A must visit for pizza! read more

I had heard good things about this place, and who doesn't love pizza? Plus they have wood fired pizza to get that nicely-flavored crust. Count me in! The wood fired oven enables a quick cook time, so it was a very short wait from when I ordered to when I picked up. I got the Parma princess pizza. It was really good, although I wish there would've been a little more consistency from bite to bite. The bites that were good really, really hit. The prosciutto with the cheese and the olive oil drizzle at the end--chef's kiss. I'm not sure if they're open for dine-in, but the inside didn't look like it. There's an outside patio that I almost just sat at and ate my pizza there because it smelled so good. Overall great experience friendly employees, I would recommend! read more

Local Pie - Inside pickup area - Pizza Near Me - Hilton Head Island, South Carolina

See all

SO good. We were tired of eating seafood on our trip and wanted some pizza and this was honestly the best meal of the week. We got the garlic knots (best garlic knots I've ever had!), the Little Bear and Buffalo pizzas, and then cannolis for dessert. Everything was so good! Server was so sweet as well. read more

Got some pizza and garlic knots for takeout dinner! Came quickly, the sweetest man delivered it, and such great food! Definitely recommend if you're looking for some delicious and local takeout pizza!! read more

Food is pretty good, but the water just leaves a taste that ruins everything. Really need to fix it.

So glad we stopped here. Pizza was delicious. Happy hour specials are awesome. Our server was great. Wish we would've stopped on our first day of vacation, probably would have come back several times. read more

Local Pie - 10 in build your own Pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Hilton Head Island, South Carolina

4/1/24 I wanted to love this place as it was a second return. The dough / crust was so salty it was almost uneditable. Even my 14 y.o. Son who eats everything said on his own how salty it was. Very disappointing. read more

Super slow service. Waited for 20 minutes just for 3 items. It tasted good tho but it's not worth it.