Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Lost Pizza

    4.2 (52 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Order Lost Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Lost Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    LOST PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Trendy
    Dogs allowed
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Lost Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Meatball marina with potato salad 07-28-2025
    Bonnie B.

    This was the first time visiting Lost Pizza's Barrancas Ave location. Overall, it was equally as pleasant as the Nine Mile location. In comparison, it was more upbeat and loud. It was also a lot busier, as anticipated, and took much longer to be served food than at the Nine Mile location. The quality an taste of the food proved to be consistent between each location. 07-28-2025

    Happy Hippie (LARGE)
    Janice S.

    We just moved to the Pensacola area and found lost pizza on yelp. Excellent phone service when we called in our order. We asked for thin crust extra crispy and that's exactly what we got perfect. We got the happy hippie and we had them add roasted garlic, and it was simply wonderful Looking forward to trying some of their other pizzas. We will be a return customer.

    Menu
    Scott B.

    The food was great! The people in my party shared a large salad, garlic sticks, and a large Lucille pizza. The large pizza is big enough to share with 4/5 people. The large salad was big enough for three people to share. The service was great and the waitresses behind the counter were very helpful while we were ordering. The place is laid back and good for groups. There even sounded like there was a small group party happening on the back patio. Will return!

    Otis (LARGE)
    A D.

    Really great takeaway pizza in Pensacola! We tried the Beekeeper with thick crust and hot honey. It's seriously one of the best flavor combos we've tried. The crust is actually super thick, so beware if that's not your thing. The Otis was pretty much a meat lovers pizza, but we could've done without the chicken on it. The quality wasn't the best chicken I've had on a pizza, but it wasn't terrible. Picking up the pizza was super efficient and they got it out right when they say they would. Would love to come back and dine in sometime!

    Custom ordered with fresh Jalapeños.
    R Scott R.

    I really enjoy the thin crust pizza here. The staff and cooks are very accommodating. Atmosphere is kid friendly and very relaxed.

    Pepperoni Pizza

    Was told this was one of the better pizza joints around this area..Maybe this was a one-off, but seemed pretty mediocre (see pics)

    Thin crust pizza
    Cathy J.

    Great thin crust pizza, sauce was great. Good atmosphere. Great place to go for lunch or dinner. Good service, self serve non alcoholic beverages. Tea was good. Overall great place for pizza!

    Pizza sizes
    Robert D.

    Chain restaurant so it's standardized but it's not. Each pizzeria is decorated differently - eclectically. It is clean and neat. Defining the service is difficult. You order at the counter and get your own drink. They bring the pizza to your table. No one really checks on you or the taste of the pizza. That's why I only gave them 4 stars. We ordered the large Otis with a thin crust. Definitely a pizza to try. Lots of fresh toppings. The sauce tasted fresh. I've never had chicken with Italian sausage but it works. There were no vegetables on this pizza but lots of meat. There are plenty of other choices on the menu that I need to try.

    Two personal size thick crust.
    Alex M.

    Great pizza and good selection of draft beers. A great spot to hang out with multiple areas including a back patio. This is definitely a favorite spot of ours. The staff is always really friendly and it's just a casual comfortable place to be. I prefer their thin crust pizza, but give the thick crust a try if that's your thing. They also started serving frozen drinks that are really good!

    Hot Chick (LARGE)
    Chloe K.

    Best pizza in Pensacola hands down!! We have been searching for a pizza that is consistently delicious and fresh, and this is it. It is a very chill and inviting atmosphere. We got wings, the fried ravioli, 2 pizzas and a pina colada. All were 10/10!! The hot chick pizza is the best pizza my family and I have ever had (and we have eaten pizza everywhere). Everyone couldn't get over how good it was. Definitely recommend!! They do uber eats if you want to order it from the comfort of your couch:).

    Half-eaten Meatball Sub
    Jeff L.

    Great pizza with counter-service and lots of seating. We went with a LARGE group on a Friday night - didn't have trouble getting tables, and the restaurant was otherwise busy. Both inside and outside tables and they had a sign up indicating the outside was dog-friendly. Also got a meatball sub - it was better than the pizza. Just on the outskirts of downtown - so you can actually find parking!

    Jalapeños and spinach
    April Y.

    Pizza was amazing. Ranch is delicious! The Hefe I had was soooo good! Service was bomb! Atmosphere is fun. Seriously best pizza I've had in a long time!

    Small BYO Pizza (SMALL)

    See all

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    We ordered the pit boss pizza and cheese sticks for carry out--both were amazing!! Oh my word. Will absolutely be coming back!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of L B.
    0
    21
    16

    2 years ago

    Pizza was great and Jacob's customer service was outstanding! Will be going back for sure!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jay S.
    1
    28
    0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Sm J.
    0
    39
    0

    2 years ago

    Really good place to stop if dining with kids. Great pizza and fun atmosphere. Would definitely recommend.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Food was amazing! Daughter loved the chicken Alfredo and my son loved the spaghetti and meatballs. Pizza was great! Service was good.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Good pizza. Not the best. However the Mississippi Delta Hot tamales are excellent. Just twice the price I pay for them in the Delta

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Pizza is good. Menu is extensive so you have a variety. Staff if friendly and helpful. Large area and nice atmosphere.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    So good! Olive bread is amazing. Always timely, Only wish they had olive bread on doordash menu

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    One of the best pizzas I have ever had in my 70 years! Great service adds to the experience.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Lost Pizza

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Sandwiches 409 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Lucy's In The Square - Piggy Picnic Mac N Cheese!

    Lucy's In The Square

    4.2(153 reviews)
    1.2 mi
    $$

    This is my second visit almost a year since we first came to Pensacola for my husband's job. We…read moreshould probably be back more often now that he's on a project here, so I will be eating at Lucy's more often. My first lunch stop was back to Lucy's, and I couldn't help ordering the same lunch as last year. Pick-two: I again enjoyed the delicious, thick tomato red pepper soup with a crisp, melty grilled cheese and a coke zero. They have a great bar but I was driving a rental. staff is lovely and I saw that the server I had last time was still working there, which makes happy to see staff that seem to love their jobs. Don't forget to dunk your sandwich in the soup!

    My wife and my first visit for the snowbird season! We chose to sit outside as it was a absolutely…read moregorgeous day in Pensacola! As it was taco Tuesday, we started with their queso and chips! I ordered one of their special margaritas and my wife, a glass of the house cab. Our queso dish came out fairly quickly with our drinks. The queso was delicious! We ordered a side of salsa to go with it. Was surprised that the salsa side was $6. Being taco Tuesday, her tacos were just under Half Off for a bargain of $3each! My wife ordered their steak and blue taco and the California chicken taco. I ordered their pulled pork and shrimp taco. The tacos were absolutely delicious! Must say our margaritas were delicious as well!

    Photos
    Lucy's In The Square - Inside

    Inside

    Lucy's In The Square - Spread

    Spread

    Lucy's In The Square - Sangria popsicle floating in champagne

    See all

    Sangria popsicle floating in champagne

    End of the Line Cafe - Mediterranean Wrap & Sriracha Mac & Cheese

    End of the Line Cafe

    4.5(424 reviews)
    1.4 mi
    $$

    Amazing Vegan Restaurant! I've been here several times and…read moretried a bunch of different items, everything I've had so far has been fantastic (with a couple personal notes). * Hummus & Pita Plate - 10/10 Best hummus ever! The veggies are super fresh, and the warm pita is my favorite menu item. * Bacon Avocado Club - 10/10 Hearty, flavorful, and seriously satisfying. * Lion's Mane Chimichurri Sandwich - 5/10 Flavor was great, but the mushroom texture was too chewy for me. * Sriracha Mac & Cheese - 10/10 Absolutely addicting. * Knuckle Sandwich - 8/10 Tasty, but not as filling as the club sandwich. Even my non-vegan friends love this place! Delicious food, good vibes, and a super friendly staff. Definitely recommend checking it out!

    This is one of those restaurants that makes you feel REALLY good about eating there. Everything -…read moreand I mean EVERYTHING - is vegan. Our waitress was a lovely woman and was very helpful and informative. My friend has a nut allergy, and our waitress was very cautious and informed us of EVERYTHING that had nuts in it that the table ordered just in case she wanted to try someone else's dish. And they make their cashew cheese in-house???? AMAZING! The food was delicious, the atmosphere was rustic and original, yet had a light, airy feel with all of the vining plants hanging around the room. A lovely little lunch spot. We will be back!!

    Photos
    End of the Line Cafe - Seating area

    Seating area

    End of the Line Cafe - Oyster Mushroom Gyro and Red Bean Stew

    Oyster Mushroom Gyro and Red Bean Stew

    End of the Line Cafe - Coffee bar

    See all

    Coffee bar

    Cafe Single Fin - Vegan Blackberry Cheese Cake!

    Cafe Single Fin

    4.5(198 reviews)
    1.6 mi
    $$

    Had lunch here and tried a few menu items. I liked the smoothies, avocado toast and tofu scramble,…read morethe açaí bowl was ok but the açaí itself didn't have much flavor. The everything cookie and matcha cheesecake were really good. All the staff were super nice and accommodating, and I enjoyed the live music on Sunday. Will be back!

    Cafe Single Fin: Great Concept, Average Plate…read more Cafe Single Fin is one of those places where the experience starts before you even find the restaurant. I drove around the block several times looking for it. Turns out, the restaurant is tucked inside a surf and skateboard shop. Once I finally figured that out, I walked in and immediately knew this wasn't going to be your average Pensacola lunch. The cafe is basically the centerpiece of the shop, surrounded by some seriously interesting vibes. I was greeted by scream-o music, which eventually segued into coffeehouse music and then some lighter indie stuff. Quite the musical journey. I half expected the playlist to ask me to pick a lane. What drew me in was the menu. Clean, interesting and exactly the kind of thing that makes you think, OK, these people might be onto something. I went with the blackened mahi tacos with rice and beans. And this is where things got a little less interesting. The food was fresh. The presentation was nice. Unfortunately, the flavor never really showed up for work. The mahi was supposed to be blackened, but I'm not convinced the blackening seasoning actually made it from the kitchen to the plate. The beans were also undercooked and under-seasoned. Nothing was bad, exactly. It just lacked the punch that the menu had promised. And that's the frustrating part. There is clearly a cool concept here, and the menu has enough personality to make you expect something memorable. The plate just didn't deliver the same energy as the room. Maybe I'm simply outside the target demographic. There seemed to be a pretty strong twenty-something surf/skate crowd, and perhaps I'm just not fluent in the culinary dialect of that demographic yet. Interesting place. Interesting concept. Interesting vibes. Friendly/helpful staff. Pretty average food.

    Photos
    Cafe Single Fin - BLT.  It's delicious!

    BLT. It's delicious!

    Cafe Single Fin - Pastry display

    Pastry display

    Cafe Single Fin - Avocado Toast!  Also delicious.

    See all

    Avocado Toast! Also delicious.

    Pearl & Horn - Fried Red Snapper Collar & Chef George Martini

    Pearl & Horn

    4.7(496 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    $$$
    Locally owned & operated
    Fine dining

    My boyfriend and I make it a tradition to stop here every year when we're in town for the Blue…read moreAngels, and it has easily become one of our favorite spots! We look forward to coming back every year, and it never disappoints. Aaron was our server a few weeks ago and was absolutely fantastic. He took the time to explain all of the specials thoroughly, gave us some great recommendations, and was incredibly attentive throughout our entire meal. You can tell he genuinely knows the menu and wants his guests to have a great experience. As for the food, the miso scallops are an absolute must and, hands down, my favorite thing on the menu! My boyfriend always gets a steak, and they are consistently cooked to perfection. Definitely make sure to try the salmon crudo and oysters as well- they're both delicious. And whatever you do, save room for a dessert cocktail! The limoncello carajillo is absolutely delicious and the perfect way to end the meal. This is one of those places we come back to year after year, and it's always a highlight of our trip. Great food, great service, and such a memorable experience every time! Side note- please keep the Dolce Vita martini on the menu forever!

    Service is the star! We walked in Saturday night, no reservations and they found us a spot at the…read moreraw bar - and that felt like a VIP experience. Dirty martini was excellent, Kumamoto oysters and all accompaniment's were delicious. Where they fell short...we ordered salmon crudo at the same time that we ordered oysters and there was a very long delay between the two, our waitress even came over twice to reassure us that the crudo was coming. But...our entrees were brought out before the crudo. kind of defeats the purpose of a cold crudo when you're eating it with your hot entree :-( We were comped a dessert, which we would have ordered anyway...to add insult to injury, my snapper was overcooked and dry! DH said his scallops were delicious, but lacked the promised orange flavor. Funny/not funny, eating the crudo left me disappointed and wishing for a better experience. I actually continued to think about it when I got home, it bothered me that much. Not sure what the restaurant could have done differently...as they say, timing is everything! $216 + tip = $258.19 for dinner for 2...I should not leave disappointed.

    Photos
    Pearl & Horn - The Pearl | Signature Cocktail

    The Pearl | Signature Cocktail

    Pearl & Horn - Oyster Bar | Pearl & Horn | Pensacola FL

    Oyster Bar | Pearl & Horn | Pensacola FL

    Pearl & Horn - Pearl & Horn

    See all

    Pearl & Horn

    The Burrow - Cesar wrap. Great waffle fries!

    The Burrow

    3.9(92 reviews)
    2.0 mi

    Great food. Fun place to visit with friends and enjoy cocktails and appetizers. Loved the…read moreatmosphere and quaint surroundings.

    Fantastic cocktail bar, biergarten, and lounge restaurant as part of the historic Sacred Heart…read moreHospital building. With somewhat dim lighting and a speakeasy's ambiance, The Burrow offers a great spot for just a drink or a full meal. For starters, check out their cocktail menu. Sure, they can make you your favorite drink, like a Manhattan or a basic Cosmo, but their featured drinks are outstanding. The Giving Tree is a smashing blend of pear & vodka, with a mint garnish, and it is seriously drinkable. The Burrow even offers CBD-infused cocktails for those that really want to take the edge off. The fare is beyond the standard bar & grille, though they do serve a fantastic burger. For appetizers, the Raclette Fries are a must-try with rich flavors that could captivate any palate, and bigger appetites can tackle the Pork Shank, served bone-in and topped with cabbage for that authentic German approach. If you want something lighter, then the Little Wedges (the only time I actually enjoy iceberg lettuce) could be a meal to many, topped with the usual bleu cheese & bacon crumbles - so good! Pricing is right on par with the value and the drinks themselves are simply outstanding. The bartender even made a previous 'seasonal' offering for my father-in-law, so you know the service is top-shelf. The space inside isn't huge, but the decor and layout is pretty well optimized. Great spot for any season, and with the biergarten space, you have plenty of options.

    Photos
    The Burrow - Interior

    Interior

    The Burrow - Smoked muscles, artichoke dip and strawberry fields forever cocktail

    Smoked muscles, artichoke dip and strawberry fields forever cocktail

    The Burrow - Lavender lemonade

    See all

    Lavender lemonade

    Lost Pizza - sandwiches - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...