(calling 9 days ahead) Dined here 2/17. We could only get in at 5 PM. First seating. Popular!
I soaked in lots of details. First, Designers Guild wallpaper on the accent wall. Loved it. The touches of white in the paper definitely brightened up the space. The book matched marble wall---worth the investment. The bench seating along the wall that so many restaurants indulge in typically bothers me. What's the big deal? Well, I don't want your husband's ass in my face when you go in and out of your seat. Nor do I want your wife's cleavage in my face. With that said, this McGuire guy actually spaced the tables with enough distance that butt sniffing was not a problem. Thank you Matt. Acoustics...thanks again matt for not overbooking your very popular eatery. We were a party of four near the window, and I didn't need to raise my voice once to be heard. The restaurant was full. The greeter/mgr? was a nice looking guy who had a great vibe. Whoops, I can't forget to mention I loved the flatware and the serving pieces. The spoons handled more than a tablespoon worth of food. Thumbs up!!
Food---
We ordered castlevetrano olives (just a favorite of mine), raviolo special (tasty, but I'm a little skittish when it comes to raw egg yolk floating onto my plate, but I walked through my fear and enjoyed it), and the polenta (WOW, I loved it, Mushrooms done to perfection). I regret not ordering the gnocco and the cauli fritto. Next time! I might become a regular.
Entrees: Two of us had the pork chop which was OUTSTANDING, great flavor. I'd highly recommend it if you like roasted peppers, not too spicy on my heat scale. Husband had the grilled strip steak, OUTSTANDING, and my friend had the trout special. She raved about the trout, my bite was slightly fishy which is so odd for trout, I'm going to reserve judgement. It's unfair to judge on one small taste. Presentation beautiful on all dishes.
Bar---- I loved the cocktail menu, prices weren't crazy. Thanks again to management for that. No one had wine, but the list looked well researched.
SERVICE----here's where the fifth star became 'a shooting star' and disappeared into the galaxy. Ok so we weren't rushing to order when we first arrived. We probably spent 30 minutes at our table talking and enjoying our cocktails. The server, big guy, beard, w tatts and some darn cool ink started off well welcoming us. He probably realized we weren't hurrying through our meal, and left us alone. I'm cool with that too. He took the next table's order before ours, TOTALLY appropriate. He spoke so loudly that I couldn't help but be distracted by his conversation. I caught him saying that he use to be a server at Niche. At first I thought to myself, oh Gerard's servers were always top notch. How nice. He recommended several dishes to them, as he should.
So, I refocused on our table, and a few minutes later he took our order. Our starters came, a LONG time later. (My friend's husband was very hungry for traveling, but we were all relaxed and enjoying Louie). Again I hear server announce specials to the table next to us on the opposite side and I hear NICHe mentioned AGAIN. OK dude, this is not Niche. Niche is in restaurant heaven. Worry about serving and establishing Louie as a place where service excels. *insert long wait for food between starter---over 25 minutes* Food was delivered by a lovely girl. Waiter checked back after I had just taken my first bite. He did not check back after that, and I did want another drink. He did find his way back to ask if we wanted dessert but nothing was mentioned. Maybe "we have a great XXX tonight for dessert"...we may have been interested in splitting one. I don't know, maybe the patrons mentioned that they recognized the server, I probably should not judge. He just seemed like he was bellowing Niche's name. The patrons are right there, no need to shout, right? I predict Louie will be around a long time. It feels like that great neighborhood spot that everyone wants in their zip code.
We were there a bit over 2.5 hours and we were seated the moment we walked in. Yeah, kitchen had to have been slow, and my food wasn't exactly HOT when my plate was delivered. Maybe coordinating the delivery of fish, pork, and steak was tricky. It WAS Oh-so-good though.
I DO RECOMMEND eating here.
WE LOVED THE FOOD.
Glad to have Mr McGuire back doing what he clearly excels in. I've missed King Louie's and that wonderful patio.
PLEASE get lunch going soon if you read yelp reviews :)
Bummed I didn't peek at the restrooms. read more