Review's were right on!!! This place was not disappointing!!! If you're a steak & mushroom person, the Kansas City Steak Pizza is for you!!! Loaded!! Cheese Pizza spot on!!! Loaded!!! Have to chew it!!! Crust on both pizzas, very good!!! Onion Rings & Breaded Mushrooms, very tasty!!! From ordering to delivery,service was SPECTACULAR!!! THANK YOU for a GREAT EXPERIENCE in Buffalo!!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! Hope to visit & come back here again!!! Forgot to mention that they even brought paper plates & napkins!!! Much Appreciated!!!! read more

See all

Ordered a personal-sized onion crust with mushrooms & jalapeños. It was awesome! Light, airy, perfectly flavored crust with a little crisp on the bottom, perfect amount of cheese, lightly sweet sauce, and generous toppings...so good! & the guy who took our order was very welcoming & cool! Great casual, unassuming spot for badass Buffalo-style pizza read more

Lovejoy Pizza - Onion crust, mushroom/jalapeño - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Dude. Everything was awesome. We were visiting Buffalo for a few days after a stay in Niagara Falls Canada. I was checking on Yelp for local pizza places, and discovered that Buffalo seems to have a style of pizza all its own. So I had to try it (of course). Lovejoy did not disappoint! The pizza was flavorful and yummy. (For those curious, Buffalo style has a thicker crust than NY style. Not as thick as Sicilian or Detroit, but definitely thicker than NY. And although it's not woodfired, it has a little more char than a NY style pie.) I LOVED the pizza, and Big Daddy enjoyed it too (and he doesn't normally like pizza). I am not a huge fan of wings, but these were delicious! Crispy and juicy... really good. If we had wings like this where I'm from, I'd eat them more often. The meatball sub was fire, too. Very flavorful with massive, tender meatballs. Overall, this place was lit. For sure we'll eat here again if we ever return to Buffalo. read more

See all

Lovejoy Pizza never disappoints it's so good. Anthony is a gem of a human and makes you feel like you have been friends for years! Keep supporting Lovejoy!! read more

Lovejoy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I called and asked them for a bundle deal with a white pizza in 20 wings. They told me one price. When I got there it was $7.50 more Then the originally told me. Then the wings that they made me were overly cooked were the wings were not even edible. It was like chewing through dry dehydrated meat The texture was. I paid $60 total. You would think that the food would be decent I'm very disappointed. The pizza wasn't bad. The wings were super horrible. I can't believe They would even serve that to me. read more

Tried two hot subs this time and they were both terrific. Steak sub and a Yum Yum sub baked to perfection and delicious. Delivery was speedy and Anthony was very friendly and accommodating. I have always loved their pizza and now can add subs to my favorites. read more

Wow! Ordered "The Ultimate Veggie Pizza" and it was one of the best I have ever had. This is Buffalo Style which is not NY, Chicago, Detroit.... It's Buffalo! The proportion of the ingredients was a masterpiece. The garlic, spinach, broccoli and mushrooms we all well balanced. That crust was light, and just the right thickness, crispy but melt in your mouth. Damn! My wife has 10pc wings medium sauce. First thing she said is "that is the way wings are supposed to be done!". Crispy, saucy and the heat was just right. I couldn't resist and dipped my crust in the sauce. I wanted a cup for dipping! The blue cheese stood up! Anthony, the owner and his crew definitely know how to deliver! Listening to Anthony greet every customer and knew everyone that came through his doors. You don't find that anymore. What service, someone that cares about your experience and wants you to enjoy his pies as much as he does. Don't expect a fancy sit down, but prepare for great food. You will not be disappointed. read more

Lovejoy Pizza - Lovejoy Main St location. - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

WOW -- hands down one of the best delivery experiences I've had! The estimated delivery time was an hour, and the driver(the same guy that took my order and maybe even made my pie one of the hardest workers in Buffalo the 1 and ONLY ANTHONY) showed up in just 30 minutes. Super impressed! The wings were MASSIVE, incredibly juicy, and packed with flavor. Every bite was delicious. The pizza was excellent too. Fast, hot, and absolutely worth it. This place just earned a repeat customer -- highly recommend! read more

Great quality for a low price, very friendly service, and always ready on time or at least close to it. One of my favorite pizza places in Buffalo read more

Visiting the area and was looking for a place with buffalo style pizza. If you're looking for something similar, this is your place. Get the charbbq wings too. Nice people, great food!! read more

Visiting from New Haven county, CT, so I'm biased: Pizza and wings were good. Delivery was timely.

Lovejoy with the clutch delivery tonight! In town for a few days, wanted a BUF style pepperoni pie while slugging down a few nice beers at Other Half downtown. Easy ordering over the phone, asked for a few plates, napkins and some crushed red. Everything came as promised; on time and still crazy hot! Will order again. Guy who delivered the order was a cool guy, said he was the owner, forgot his name (beers). Will support anytime in town. read more

See all

This is it! Peak Buffalo! We got pizza and wings delivered and Anthony the owner delivered to our Air BnB. Everything was perfect. We're with family from New Zealand who wanted the Buffalo experience, and they sure got it. Skip the chains and get your Buffalo eats from Lovejoy! You can't beat this! read more

Shawn's Pizza Reviews REVIEW # 26 LOVEJOY PIZZA E. LOVEJOY ST. BUFFALO, NY SCORE 6.9 One of two locations, the other being downtown. This one is located in Lovejoy near Buffalo's east side. Pretty cool spot with a friendly staff who were enjoying a Yankees game when I went in to pickup the pie. Not a huge fan of the pizza though. The sauce was pretty good, although they did use a bit too much. The cheese didn't taste all that great and the crust was hard as a rock. Check it out if you're ever in the area! read more

Lovejoy Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Was passing by Buffalo, NY to check out Niagara Falls and of course you gotta have Buffalo wings in Buffalo. Used the Yelp app to see who was the "cock-in-the-henhouse" around the area and Lovejoy Pizza looked promising. Walked in and almost instantly the owner had a conversation with my girlfriend and I and made us feel at home. Since we made the drive up from San Antonio, Texas, he let us try some complimentary wings which were amazing! The employees were real humble and showed a lot of respect. Now to the food: the pizza was ON POINT! The cheese and dough were FOR REAL. But the actual takeaway were the wings... nice and crispy without being stingy with the sauce. So glad I'm able to say I had Lovejoy Pizza. You guys rock! read more

See all

When I'm in Buffalo I make it my goal to try a new pizza and wing place that I've never been to before. Lovejoy kept popping up as places that not many people know, but always ranked high on pizza list I have seen. Plus just the people talking about it finally made me go try it. It's good. It's all good. Classic pizza and wings buffalo style. Here's what's different from this place from every other, cheese. I can honestly say this was the cheesiest pizza I have ever had. Not sure if it was just this pizza or if it's always like that. Also, the pizza heated up the next day was excellent. Good wings as well. Lightly sauced. Crispy. Big. read more

Lovejoy Pizza - Sheet pizza. Two slices already taken. Look at that cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Pretty good pizza joint in Buffalo. Nothing fancy but if you want wings and pizza this is a good option for travelers who are interested in local food at a decent price. read more

Things I learned today: Lovejoy Pizza is amazing and you must order your pizza well-done next time you get some. Our office gave us some lunch money and we decided to get Lovejoy because who doesn't love pizza? We ordered a sheet pizza, half cheese, half pepperoni. The distinction that made all the difference was ordering the pizza well done. Let me tell you this, my life has been changed for the better. The pizza was so delicious. The crust was extra crispy, the cheese had just enough burnt goodness, and the sauce was incredible. Not too sweet and distributed perfectly. Lovejoy is a real contender for some of the best pizza in Buffalo, in my opinion. I will most definitely be ordering from here in the future and telling everyone I know to start ordering their pizza well done. read more

Pizza and wings were both fantastic--Anthony is the man! If you're downtown or within striking distance, you have to try this place.

A staple on Main Street for many years, Lovejoy Pizza always delivers a fresh slice and a nice cold drink. I go by when I'm in the area. It hits the spot. read more

I was in a bit of turmoil when I heard it was national pizza day. Immediately I knew I wanted to participate, but which local do I patronize. I haven't had pizza from my favorite joint in a while but sadly they were out of a few key ingredients and their covid hours were not convenient. What to do, what to do?! I scoured the Inter webs, wracked my brain, consulted YELP...aha! Lovejoy pizza - with the works! It's national pizza day so I figured I better get my order in early. That was a wise thing to do because the wait time turned out to be 45 minutes. Well, I arrive to pick up my pizza and tell the counterman...the works hold the anchovies...so he asks me why don't I like anchovies? It's not me, I say, it's other people sharing the pizza. I got good anchovies he says, I'll put them on the side for you. Wonderful, I say. And the Lovejoy Pizza with the works was definitely epic. Everything was spot on...from the fresh mushrooms to the crunchy, chewy crust. Just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Thank you, Lovejoy Pizza on Main St. for making national pizza day. read more

Lovejoy Pizza - Large pizza with the works - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

We tried Lovejoy for the first time as a treat for the Bills game. We LOVED the pizza (traditional cheese and pep with sesame crust)! Their pizza has tasty crust, cup/char pepperoni, and loads of cheese that is slightly crisp on top and melty underneath. A true 'Buffalo Style' pizza. The 'char-b-q' chicken fingers were good, but not the best I've had. The chicken was a bit tough and the sauce wasn't great. We will definitely be getting the pizza again, and I'm curious to try their specialty pizzas. read more

Lovejoy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

We went out looking for the authentic Buffalo Pizza we've been hearing about. Reviews on this place looked good so we gave it a shot. Definitely not disappointed. Anthony and his sons gave us the experience we'd hoped for. Super friendly, got my family the "Cheez 'n Pep" (hear that in your most authentic New York accent, at least to these Southern ears) and took care of my dietary needs with a white pie. Also got to try the BBQ wings and OMG, slap yo Mama good. Could not recommend this place more. Lovejoy's on Main should be on everyone's bucket list. read more

Lovejoy Pizza - Lovejoy's Buffalo Pie - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Good pizza, good wings, good service, this guy gets it Favorite place in the area when I'm feeling some za, 10/10 would recommend to a friend. read more

Anthony the owner was awesome to deal with! Friendly , had a staff worker walk the food out with me to my car. If you want to talk about Hospitality with equal go here! You won't be disappointed and the food was delicious! Can't wait to order again! read more

quin·tes·sen·tial: Adjective That's the best way I can describe Lovejoy Pizza. It's the most Buffalo pizza out there. Medium Crust, sauce - not on the sweet side, and perfect amounts of cheese. Their wings come out crispy, and are huge. It's also refreshing to see places hand cut carrots and include them with the celery (too Boujie? whatever) I've been there twice now, and the service could NOT have been better. read more

This is my go-to spot for pizza, I order here at least 2-3 times a month I think... Most of the time we get pizza, curly fries w/gravy, garlic bread w/cheese and I often add a taco... Consistency is the key word here b/c having ordered for over 11 years now, I've had one bad pie and it was the delivery driver's fault b/c the cheese slid to the side---but when i called to just let them know; they insisted on bringing me a new one at no charge. Whenever the one manager, Frank is there--I just know everything is gonna be on point. I've never had the downtown location's food but I imagine it's awesome too! Also they are very generous with quantity for their salads and the stuffed peppers & stuffed pepper pizza is probably the closest to my cousin's OG recipe (Billy Ogden's, IYKYK!). I think the reason they are always so busy and consistent is that they hire great employees---everyone is always nice and I've worked in restaurants a long time before i got old, and I can tell they all know what they are doing! read more

You know what kind of pizza I love? The kind that's greasy, cheesy, and delicious (I realize I just described Pizza in general). Lovejoy Pizza is a speedy little pizza place that offers all types of pizza, wings, and whatever else you want from a place like this nice and fast. I ended up stopping here during the week while in search of a new place to get lunch from. I came in around 12:30PM and was sold right way when I saw the pizza slices and wings in the little display case. I decided to get 2 slices of cheese pizza and some of the CharBBQ wings on the side (It's the last week of the year, don't judge me). The pizza was way better then I was expecting and was kind of a mixture of Italian/Greek style pizza. It was on the thinner side but the sauce and cheese reminded me of the thicker greek slices, either way they were fantastic. The CharBBQ wings were also pretty darn tasty. They offer a unique flavour while still being pretty big. Lovejoy Pizza won me over this week and I look forward to coming back for more. I highly recommend checking this place out if you are in the area! read more

Lovejoy Pizza - Kinda hot right? - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

The pizza was absolutely perfect! Perfect Char on the top and crust and the sauce was not overbearing. Wings were excellent and crispy. Not too wet and mushy. Will definitely order again the next time I'm in Buffalo! read more

The best and nicest man works there. The pizza and wings are soooooo good. Everything about this place is stellar.

Always the best pizza and subs. pizza is consistently great. Specialty subs are to die for. Turkey Club is outstanding too.

We had heard about Lovejoy recently and decided to visit. THIS IS THE PLACE, FOLKS. It's so good. Lots of cheese on the slices and the staff is super friendly. Whenever we get the opportunity we will surely visit again! read more

Lovejoy Pizza - 2 slices of cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Best pizza around and the char b-q wings are bussin. Everyone is very friendly; service here is top notch.

I work on the BNMC and this place is my lunch go to. It's fast, cheap and good. I've been here countless times and my go to order is the Turkey Sub combo. I order my sandwich to go light on the mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion and no oil. The sandwich is made with good quality turkey and provolone and is prepared on a toasted roll. The combo sandwich is huge, honestly could be enough for two people, comes with a bag of lays chips, and a bottled drink for $7.56, including the tax. The employees are fantastic and always fun to chat with. The owner is also extremely friendly! I've tried their wings a few times and they are also really good! They have a nice flavor to them and the perfect amount of crispness to them. They will continue to be my go to lunch place. read more

Lovejoy Pizza - Turkey sub - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Not only was the pizza amazing, Anthony and his employees were such a pleasure to speak to. Great pizza and great people!!

I ordered their pizza and wing combo today and chose to have it delivered. 20 wings and a large pizza for $28 including tax. I asked for the pizza to be half mushroom and half peppers. Yum, the anticipation of a sweet mushroom peppery-pizza. They didn't have any red peppers, so I went with green peppers. Meh, but okay. Let me first say their pizza was excellent. Great quality cheese, ingredients and great quality dough that is savory to eat. Cooked to absolute perfection. If you're looking for a delicious pizza, this is the place to go. So why the three stars? They messed up my order a bit. The half pepper and half mushroom pizza turned out to be half cheese, with the other half being a mix of mushroom and green peppers. I thought I communicated what I wanted fairly clearly, so I'm not sure where the mistake came from. I was disappointed with the miscommunication, because come on who wants a pizza that is half cheese and the other half with two toppings that don't go together that well? My other concern were that the wings, while decent and crispy how were not spicy at all. I ordered 10 bbq (which were delicious and perfectly sauced), and 10 hot which may as well have been called "slightly mild," because my mouth had absolutely no burn after eating them. Not sure where their definition of hot comes from, but it definitely doesn't jive with me. I'll give this place another shot sometime and maybe I'll have a better experience if I come in to pick up the goods, but this delivery experience did not cut it for me (although the delivery guy was very nice!). read more

Lovejoy Pizza - 10 hot wings and 10 bbq - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

OK, I read the reviews of this pizza and came as a result, so Yelp gets the "Shout-out" there. But, to be honest, I was skeptical the reviews could be that accurate, after all, Buffalo is not known for terrific pizza (notwithstanding the flights full of Bocce and Molson/Labatts for Bills/Jets games), and the various "Bob and John's" fanatics out there. I love pizza. I have had alot of pizza in my life, and always try pizza wherever I find myself in the world, as a result, I have had things I'm not really sure are pizza, but they were good. But its been years since I have had pizza in Buffalo. I have a vague memory of having "Just Pizza" (Hertel / Delaware location) once some 5 years ago, and it was indeed, ok. But just OK. In NY my favorite pizza is actually the "hole in the wall" type, found outside of Port Authority, on the seedy side, for a buck a slice. I know. I can hear the groans. Made by immigrants from Delhi no less. But terrific pizza, even though you have to stand there eating it (no inside at all), and there are at times homeless people wandering around. But for a buck you can buy them a slice too (which I often do). In DC I loved a place that made "artisinal pizza", so those pizzas with salad on them or various other healthy type things, thin crust, lots of seasoning etc. Also really really good. In Chicago I went for the deep dish, but have to say it was a little much for me, so while I liked it, not my favorite. There are so many different versions of pizza around the world that its hard to define it anymore. But, I still think dough, tomato and cheese are a good place to start. But I digress. I LOVED my cheese and pepperoni piece here today. LOVED it. Could not believe I was having this in Buffalo. At $2.75 a slice this is not cheap pizza, in fact, one might say its overpriced. But it was tasty. After the first, I went back to the counter for a repeat, and saw they had a "white" by the slice on offer now. So I had that, white pizza with onions, garlic and something else. Also very good. But have to say the basic cheese and pepperoni did the trick for me (and I have not had pepperoni in ages). From here I went to Hyatts, basically next door, and mentioned to the staff there they should try this if they have not yet, and they all said "we are regulars". So word is out. There are a few places to sit inside, but its counter, not super comfortable, so be prepared to use this as a pick up or delivery place. While I did not try anything else, there were people lining up for other offerings they have, wings and more. I'll be back, and I think you should be too, if you have a love of good basic old fashioned pizza. read more

Lovejoy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Pizza was awesome. Wings were very good. I will definitely order again and explore their menu!

Read the great reviews here, and decided to give this place a shot. Spent $50 on a Saturday night for all this and all I received was inedible burnt pizza. Had to go spend more money someplace else to feed my family. And on top of it all they are closed Sunday and Monday, so it's not like I could have called someone to make them aware. Will most definitely not EVER be coming back here. I'd rather go down the street to Allentown Pizza read more

Lovejoy Pizza - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

They delivered Fast (within about 20 min) and it was so good we couldn't wait to take the photo before eating. Delicious!!! read more

Lovejoy Pizza - Pepperoni large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York