[[HIGHLIGHT]]On a warm summer day, Lugia's hits the spot![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We ordered a "small" which was huge Pineapple soft serve with chocolate sprinkles in a waffle cone and a special black raspberry chocolate taco with peanuts and fudge! Our total was $19 and worth every penny. Quick service and the frozen treats were delicious! read more

See all

Best ice cream around, So many flavors to choose from. Service is fast. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Plenty of outdoor seating and a text too in case it rains.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

I have heard a lot about this place so recently me,my wife and 2 sons went to check it out and [[HIGHLIGHT]]Once I got there oh boy it was packed[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]],my wife had a scoop of ice cream cake and double chocolate also my oldest son had the same as well and as for me I had a banana split,it was really good plus the staff were really friendly and helpful absolutely amazing,I will definitely be returning soon Thanks for everything!! read more

Just a warning that the sizes are larger than you think! I ordered a small and ended with more ice cream than I could eat. The soft serve was great, didn't melt immediately either. There's so many flavors and hard ice cream too and great prices read more

Lugia's Ice Cream - Blackberry swirl - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Spencerport, New York

Awesome ice cream and very friendly workers. They were also great in handling the huge lines with ease.

Cheap for the amount they give! Very nice staff who let us sample flavors. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Very family friendly and tons of seating[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

The best spot for ice cream on a steamy evening. The lines may look long, but they go fast. So many flavors to choose from! read more

See all

I have become a regular during the warm months for a number of years, and it never disappoints with the different combinations of flavors I have tried. Some flavors are discontinued, and new ones emerge. Post-pandemic some of the offerings are no longer around, and they closed the covered seating area at the back of the store. Plenty is space in the open areas under the trees. read more

See all

Decent ice cream. I came here on Sunday around 6:30pm. It was very busy and long lines of customers. It took awhile for my turn to order. I got kiddie side which is 2 big scoops of 2 flavors: strawberry cheesecake and black raspberry. The staff somehow skipped my order and prepared the next custom ice cream instead. Once they realized it, they got my ice cream, but it took some decent time waiting. They had good size of parking lot and plenty seats in the back for customers. Ice cream was good, but can be creamier. They took cash only. read more

See all

Many options to choose from when ordering ice cream. The staff are amazing. Today was a little slow because there was some training occurring. No issues waiting because they truly were amazing and not many in line. It is a cash only business so three orders a flurry, a baby ice cream and a baby soft serve vegan was 16.80 for those three things. I get it's inflation but if we had a few more people with us or bigger sides the cost is more than a quick cash purchase. They might want to start considering credit card for in person transactions. It was good, but for the price it won't be a frequent visit. read more

Lugia's Ice Cream - Play dough ice cream. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Spencerport, New York

Huge portions of ice cream! The line is long, but worth the short wait. Staff works hard to keep the line moving quickly. We really enjoyed the Cookie Monster and blueberry cheesecake. The blue food dye is usually overpowering in Cookie Monster ice cream, but this one was perfect with generous portions of Oreo and cookie dough. Only negative would be there are no prices listed and it is cash only. Come prepared. Also recommend bringing your own lawn chairs if you want to enjoy your treat outside, there are not a lot of places to sit. read more

Lugia's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Spencerport, New York

Ice cream cake was really good. Staff was super helpful. Overall good experience. Pricing is fair. read more

First twist of the season. Lots of flavors and toppings to choose from. Service was fast read more

Lugia's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Spencerport, New York

See all

So many people told me I had to check this place out for their massive ice cream cones. I stopped by and was surprised at how busy it was ( told the lines can be crazy long, but it moves fast) Large selection of different hard ice cream flavors. A few types of custard and sherbets. It's all about the size here, I knew enough to go small.,, I went with a baby size chocolate ice cream and I'm not ashamed! Lol I love ice cream but some of those sizes are just way to much! The ice cream was good but not fantastic. The location is not great for me, so I won't make a special trip for this. Limited seating, lots of bugs... I prefer an abbots ice cream. read more

Lugia's is a staple in Spencerport. The lines are long, but it does not take that long to get through them. Ice cream sizes are crazy so beware! We got the smallest size the mini, which was still a little pricy, but we could barely finish it because it was a lot of ice cream. I had the vanilla/raspberry custard twist and was very happy with my choice! It was delicious. They only take cash, so please come prepared. Also, there isn't a ton of seating, so when you come on a busy weekend, there may not be anywhere to sit but the grass or your car. read more

See all

Lugia's is a place that consistently wows everyone we bring here. At times, the lines can be daunting and customers often don't move out of the way enough for the staff to hand you your food. That said, if you deal with that, you're treated to the best ice cream in the area. Wonderful flavor combinations with so much to choose from that making a decision is downright difficult (but fun). My only gripe that prevents me from going with five stars is the cash only bit. It's 2024 and people don't always carry cash or not enough sometimes. Yes, there is an ATM but that's a pain and there is a fee higher than a credit card fee -- mostly it's inconvenient and I don't know how much to withdraw so I have to take out too much. If they are interested in speed, only allow contactless payments. Aside of mobile payments on iPhone and Android, most physical cards come with that built in now. If it's about the credit card fees, charge the customer and let them make that decision. Lots of businesses do. If I can pay festival vendors out of the back of their van or under a tent with contactless or card, surely I should be able to at a very busy brick and mortar establishment with lots of staff. read more

See all

Haven't been to this place since I was a kid. They have so many different flavors, it's crazy. I like that they allow you to sample flavors. I ended up getting the campfire s'mores. It was good. The flavor tasted like a s'more. It has pieces of chocolate and marshmallows swirls. I would of liked graham cracker pieces in it. That would of been 5 stars. Overall it's a great place to get ice cream and the cost is low considering the amount of ice cream they pile on your cone. read more

Lugia's Ice Cream - Campfire S'mores ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Spencerport, New York

I'm still confused why this ice cream place is so popular when you have other options in the area. Yes their portions are ginormous but their prices aren't exactly cheap. Their small which is like half a gallon of ice cream is about five dollars... But you could also go up the road and buy a gallon for 5 dollars (many of the ice cream choices are Perry's) They sell a variety of brands, largely Perry's but also Hershey's, Guilford's and Turkey hill. So they do have probably the biggest selection of flavors when compared to other places. Buuuuuuuut, they limit you to only two flavors despite how big of a size you order. This may be negotiable, I didn't try but it was stated on their sign. The location is just placed amongst roads, no cute walk way or seating area to enjoy. Its quite large and gives of the feel that your just chilling in a large parking lot. You can tell it's popular though, there are several windows to take orders and they all usually have lines. I would much rather go up the road to Byrne Dairy. Their large soft serve is under three dollars, it's creamy and delicious and can't be bought in the store. read more

See all

I am almost 49 years old grew up in Brockport have passed this place over 1000 times in my lifetime and never once tried it. Today was the first time I decided to try it. The girl on the other side of the counter was rude and walked away. I couldn't even place an order so I have no idea what their ice cream is or how good it is. I just know that their service sucks and I will never come back. read more

Lugia's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Spencerport, New York

Yummy. Delicious. Scrumptious. These are the words that would best describe how my ice cream tasted after trying this place for the first time. My cousins raved about this place ever since I arrived in town and made sure that I was not going to go home without trying it out. There was several lines of people waiting to be serviced. However, my cousin did say that the lines tend to be much longer regularly. I cannot begin to tell you the amount of flavors that Lugia's offers but it has tons of flavors of soft and hard serve ice cream. I decided to opt for the vegan cookies n' cream and it was really good. They have lactose free options for those who cannot drink milk with lactose like me. They have various serving size options to choose from to satisfy any appetite. Cone or cup, it's all up to the customer. There is outdoor seating for customers to sit down and enjoy their ice cream while savoring the moment. read more

See all

Worst Italian Ice I've ever had. $10 for a large when I've never paid more than $4 before. I had mango and my brother had blue raspberry/ cherry. The flavors were extremely watered down, sour and flavorless. I won't be returning. read more

100% would recommend! I got a junior sundae and it had three scoops and three additional toppings. I had the fireball ice cream as one of my scoops and it was so so so good. read more

Ice cream is amazing, they have huge sizes for the money, and [[HIGHLIGHT]]the overall atmosphere is amazing with tables around the back, and an amazing flag area for you to sit and eat your desert.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

This ice cream place is located at the intersection of two main streets and has fantastic parking to accommodate will surely be a very large crowd Our group was something around 15 people which was a small group within the hundreds that were there that evening The size of the portions as well as the quality of the ice cream is what makes this place a legend in this area and everyone I talk to seem to know exactly this ice cream shop and warned me of the large portions It really makes no sense until you see exactly how large the portions are so be prepared And yes I ordered the one scoop! read more

See all

Cash only!! Super generous portions which makes the price worth it. I got the "baby" size which was still very large and thankfully it came with a drip try or else my hands would've been covered in melted ice cream. I got campfire s'mores which was very good- a sort of graham cracker flavor with marshmallow fluff and chocolate chunks. read more

Lugia's Ice Cream - Campfire s'mores baby size - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Spencerport, New York

This is my favorite ice cream place in Rochester! They have a stupid amount of flavors and toppings to choose from. The line is always long, but it moves quick since there are so many lanes. It's cash only, but they also have an ATM inside. There are some tables in the back but not many, and parking can get a little crowded, but its' worth it. It's not in the most ideal place ever, but it's not so far out that you can't get to it easily. Definitely a Rochester staple. read more

Lugia's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Spencerport, New York

We truly enjoyed this ice cream shop! The ice cream was delicious and the serving size was huge! The only thing I didn't like is they only take cash. However, there was an atm inside. read more

This was the first ice cream place I went to in the area when we first moved here (7 months ago) and have gone back quite a few times! Always satisfied and never turned off by the long lines. The serving sizes are crazy - I'm sure you've seen the pictures already! It gets super busy in the summer, but they have plenty of outside space and seating for customers. My pups love coming here too! read more

Lugia's Ice Cream - Yep, still a kiddie size - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Spencerport, New York

See all

I have been coming to LuGia's for over 15 years now! This Ice Cream place used to be the best spot for the best Ice cream. However it seems that in the last couple of years it has gone down hill from what it used to be. The best thing about LuGia's and what they are known for are their portions. Starting with Baby going up to Large it's a lot of ice cream! For example a Kiddie is two huge scoops of ice cream if not more. This used to be great, getting a good portion of ice cream for your money. However now the prices have gone up and the scale is just skewed so now a baby (one scoop) at LuGia's is the same price if not more than a small (one scoop) at any other ice cream place. The quality of the ice cream has also gone down. The past 2 times I have been there I have had chips of ice in the ice cream and others complained their ice cream tasting frost bite. The only things that have remained the same are that there is always a line and they still have a huge nice picnic area in the back to enjoy your ice cream and converse with other families. I would say go for the experience but not for the quality anymore :/ CASH ONLY NO RESTROOMS - PORTER POTTY ONLY read more

Wow...great ice cream. Portions are big, and lots of flavors to chose from. Banana Splits are amazing!!! read more

Lugia's Ice Cream - Small Banana Split...yes there is a larger one than this. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Spencerport, New York

Does anyone not like Lugia's? No. There are a bunch of standard and specialty flavors. And the scoops are huge. The down side is that the flavors have weird names with no description and that they only take cash. read more

Came over after dinner with friends around 8:30 pm on a warm summer weekday night: the (big) parking lot was almost full. The lines were so long that I could not read the items on their menu other than the categories in yellow when we just joined the queue. The time we spent waiting in line was necessary because there are just too many flavors to choose from and some might confuse you, like Queen of Hearts, or Gone Fishing. They have sizes from baby (1 scoop), kiddie (2), small to large, and I was shocked seeing people holding a small. Bless their metabolism and/or guts. I tried the Gone Fishing, which is like a cookie dough with chocolate bits, and settled on baby size Kahlua Almond Amaretto in a plain cone. The almond flavor was straightforward in the taste and scent. Kahlua, on the other hand, was not discernible. I tried one of the vegan ice cream (lemon strawberry??) from my friend's cone and the texture is similar to a chilled well-blended thickened smoothie. Anyway, it was an experience worth having, and the location is just right off 490. Price wise, mine came out $3.50, similar to other ice cream shops in town. Don't forget to bring cash though. You can sit by the tables on the lawn as long as you are not bugged by bugs. read more

HANDS DOWN - A ROCHESTER WARM WEATHER STAPLE ! I love ice cream - but as someone who has celiac and cannot have dairy - going "out" for ice cream is quite difficult and often leaves me left out watching everyone else enjoy, while I have no options. LUGIA HAS MULTIPLE VEGAN OPTIONS THAT ARE ALSO GLUTEN FREE - I had the pleasure of speaking with one of the owner's GIA on the phone and she was AMAZING - she spent at least 10 minutes on the phone with me - detailing all the vegan options, and then all the vegan options that were ALSO GF as well - she even told me I could do a custom cake order - of GF DF if I gave notice :) It's rare to find an ice cream place that caters to allergies, and even MORE rare to find one that has SO many options - I always feel safe and secure when I order here - they follow an allergy protocol - change gloves, and even will scoop with new scoopers or a bin if I ask BUT I usually get the pineapple swirl so no scooping necessary! Prices are reasonable and the portions are HUGE - a must try! read more

Lugia's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Spencerport, New York

LuGia's was a summertime staple while I was in school and I went back last night for the first time in years. I really like all the updates they've done, the interior is nice and bright and modernized. They've always had a huge selection of hard ice cream from Perry's, plus soft serve custard, sundaes, shakes, and more. This time I tried to Deep Sea Treasure (caramel ice cream with caramel swirl and salted caramel candies) and it was perfection. Anyone who's been here knows about the sizes, but if you've never been here, be aware that a small is a large in most other places. The scoops are enormous! I usually get a baby (two scoops) and it's more than enough. read more

Lugia's Ice Cream - Still busy at 8 PM in September! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Spencerport, New York

See all

Huge selection of flavors. Be prepared to wait in line as it is a popular place, but worth the wait. Staff works as quickly and efficiently as possible. read more

Like Dr. Evil, I took Luge lessons as a child, and that makes me uniquely qualified to say LuGia's is one of the best-tasting custards you'll ever put in your mouth. Even better than your best-tasting ex boyfriend's custard. It's the kind of custard anyone would swallow, even if you're not into boys at all. Then again I'm not into boys, but I love swallowing custard. Go figure. What to get: Vanilla Custard. What else: I like cats. Also: It's not really open til 10.30 every night. Only on weekends. Other nights it's 9.30pm close. If it were full of people who mis-hear rumours like Chinese Whispers, then it'd be LooseEars. They say Loose Lips Sink Ships, so what do Loose Ears do? They cause people to end up in Police Custardy. Rochester is blessed with some fantastic custard spots (far better than its rival Buffalo-716 area), with the best national Custard chain (Rita's) in Henrietta, and the best local chain of custard shops (Abbott's) in the whole world. 585 is so freaking awesome for custard, even more than a bunch of Frat Boys at a ranch with neon red lights in the Nevada Desert. And LuGia's is right up there with the best of them, making some of the thickest, most luscious Vanilla Custard you're ever likely to gulp down, girls. And boys. If all the people using the restroom were applauding loudly, then it'd be LooCheers. But it's not. I mean, depending on what's happening in the loo, but it's usually not. I stopped here one night as the final port of call on my second 585 food tour of summer 2015. I was already stuffed full of every kind of custard you can imagine (minds out of the gutter) and yet LuGia's made a real impression. It's the pride of Spencerport. Unlike male custard, it's not salty at all. It's creamy, sweet and delicious. If it were full of people exposing themselves for attention (like I often do), it'd be LookHere's. I was shocked by how busy it was. I had to park all the way in the back on the grass, as most people did. There were hundreds of people here, including lots of hot girls, boys dressed for the Prom (and ready to make their own custard), plus old people, and crazy maniacal tattooed muscle guys that were looking for a fight. How Spencerport of them. I even saw a girl wearing a Neymar shirt, which pleases me. When white suburban America can name Neymar more easily than naming who the Bills selected in the draft, my mission here is complete. If it were full of underdressed hotties, it'd be HooChias. Oh wait, it is. The girl at LuGia's told me to skip the Lemon Ice and get the custard. She was a teenager, so I took her advice. I'd never say no to a teenage girl, ever. Oh wait, that came out wrong. That's what he said. After he made some custard. OK this is getting weird. Then again when do my reviews not. If you come here with your friend and make them buy you custard, then it's MooChias. And it'll only set you back $3 for a large baby size. So come to Rochester, try Abbott's, try Rita's, and make sure you try LuGia's too. Three of the best custards you'll ever swallow. Don't get it all over your face, as napkins cost money, and you wouldn't want all of that money shot. Shot, as in wasted. And of course if it were called LaBia's then it would be perfectly named considering you come here to open your lips wide and get filled with custard. read more

See all

This place has tons of flavors and gives big portions. Service is quick but often has a line due to the popularity of the place in the summer. read more

HUGE sizes, wide variety of hard flavors, quite a few soft serve flavors, and crazy insanely cheap prices for the size... can't go wrong coming here but also be prepared for chaos in the parking lot and a line at the windows. PS: they only accept cash! read more

Lugia's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Spencerport, New York

I have been wanting to try out LuGia's ever since my husband mentioned them, like 3 years ago when we first met. (We lived on the East side for years and then moved to NC... But finally, FINALLY I got to go today because we are up visiting family!) I came around 2pm. There was not much of a line because I have heard that it gets crazy busy here at night. Sometimes even wrapping around the building. Despite being a short line, there was still a bit of a wait. No big deal because I wasn't in any hurry. I went with the Peanut Butter S'Mores (my sister-in-law's highly recommended suggestion) and it was AMAZING! I got the "kiddie"-size and it was huge! I actually got a stomach ache from eating too much. Next time I will get the "baby"-size. I liked the little cone holder which will catch drips so your hands don't get all sticky. There are just sooooooo many flavors to choose from. Hard to decide which to try. If you get a kiddie or bigger you can try 2 flavors. Baby-size is one scoop and thus, only one flavor. Cost-wise, the kiddie was $3.75. Not too bad. (But then you think about how you could go to Wegman's a buy a container of Perry's ice cream for about the same cost as 2 scoops....) Like other Yelpers said, the parking is pretty limited. They do have a small area to enjoy your treat. Will definitely be back this week before heading home to NC. read more

Lugia's Ice Cream - Starting melting before I could take a pic. Kiddie-sized Peanut Butter S'More's. DELISH! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Spencerport, New York

When it comes to sweets, I don't leave a crumb behind or a clean spoon. I couldn't do that at LuGia's because their servings are enormous! Their sizes are double what you ask for. As painful as it was, I had to toss half of it out because I was stuffed. My eyes almost popped out of my head when I saw two girls walking away with a leaning tower of ice cream piled on an apparently sturdy, made-for-LuGia's ice cream cone. There seems to be a loyal crowd regardless of the day and weather. The clouds were threatening, but we waited until it was our turn at the window. It gave me some time to check out their wall of flavors while we waited. I ordered the Caribbean coconut which was soft vanilla ice cream with coconut shavings. The coconut added the right amount of sweetness without overkill. The bf ordered coconut almond fudge with chocolate sprinkles. It was hard coconut ice cream with lots of chunks of fudge. It was too sweet for me and I didn't catch any almond flavor or nuts in the few bites that I tasted. Overall, a 4.5 out of 5! The only improvement I would like to see is a description of the flavors. I think it would help shorten the wait time so that the indecisive (ahem) already know what to order without asking for descriptions at the window. Also, a few more benches would be nice around the fish fountain. I'm looking forward to going back for more flavors. Next time, baby cone please! Ice cream this good cannot be wasted! read more

Lugia's Ice Cream - Caribbean coconut and coconut almond fudge with chocolate sprinkles. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Spencerport, New York