My friends and I love Moonlight Creamery. My favorite flavor is the A Piece of Cake. It is absolutely delicious. The workers are always friendly when I come in too. The shop itself is moderate sized with some seating inside. Its location is great to walk around with your ice cream though. read more

Moonlight Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairport, New York

Who doesn't love homemade ice cream, on a warm night with a view? The flavors jump from breakfast, to traditional to even dinner. Blueberry Pancake? Chocolate with SPICY? Strawberry cheesecake?! Who knew?! I love coming here. The flavor combos are so fun. The staff is fun and nice. The small is enough for many with one heaping spoonful, but definitely my favorite thing I saw was a FLIGHT of ice cream. Four sample size ice cream picks of your choosing! Yes please! Not to mention they have various rice crispy treats, cookies and pie/cakes with different flavors! read more

See all

Excellent flavor variety. I ordered the cannoli flavor which didn't really taste like cannolis but was still delicious. There's plenty of seating inside and it's right by the canal so you could stroll while enjoying your ice cream. Definitely a go to spot if you're in Fairport read more

Moonlight Creamery - Cannoli kiddie size in a Waffle Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairport, New York

The service there is always so friendly. We had a great visit today with exceptional service. And they seriously have the best oatmeal ice cream! read more

I can't stop coming back here for the chocolate ice cream. It's so delicious. Got to speak with the owner Mike on this most recent visit. He is incredibly kind and passionate about the shop. Really enjoyed talking with him and hearing him take pride in his shop. Easily becoming my new favorite ice cream spot in the area. read more

See all

I was excited to come in for some ice cream with family after seeing this shop for a while on Yelp and Facebook, but was very underwhelmed. I noticed that some of the ice cream seemed like it had been in the tubs for a while and not very fresh. I picked the one that looked the best which was the black cherry. I really enjoyed my ice cream's flavor, but it had little ice chips in it which I did not enjoy and could not tell from its appearance. I also found that all of the tables inside were sticky, which I thought was not great considering we were only one of two families in the store.We also were there pretty early in the afternoon, so it made me wonder if they had not been cleaned from the night before? We did clean off a table and sit to enjoy our ice cream though. I also found it weird how the prices for their chocolates were not displayed anywhere in the store. We had to flag down the one poor worker who was in the back to ask about chocolate prices. Overall, not the best experience and probably will not come back anytime in the future. read more

See all

Our go to ice cream place in Fairport. Homemade unique flavors & your standard go to's also. Staff is so welcoming & remembers us when we go in. Flavors made in house are clearly marked. They also have chocolates, drinks, shakes, & many other treats we have yet to try. Would love to see free samples of flavors before getting a whole dish or cone of it. Sizes & prices are reasonable in today's economy. read more

Moonlight Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairport, New York

***4.5 Stars*** Nice ice cream spot in the heart of Fairport. At least 20 flavors to choose from. They also have other treats like chocolates, rice crispy treats and other sweets. My daughter loved the strawberry sorbet and blueberry ice cream. It's nice that they have non-dairy options. It's located right alongside the Fairport Canal with plenty of seating inside and also outside by the water. It's a good atmosphere to watch the boats on a warm sunny day. Lots of parking in an adjacent covered parking garage (Fairport library). read more

Moonlight Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairport, New York

See all

Moonlight creamery = best ice cream? I think I may have found my new favorite ice cream flavor: Moonlight Creamery's butterbeer. I'm not the biggest Harry Potter fan, but I love butterscotch, and the flavor was soooo good. They have a wide selection of unique flavors, as well chocolates! They all sound so good, and I'm excited to try more in the future. However, even though I rate the ice cream so highly, I was so disappointed by the waffle cone that I'm knocking a star off. I love waffle cones, and a good waffle cone can really elevate an ice cream place. This waffle cone was very underwhelming and I actually avoided eating most of the cone. I will definitely be back to try their chocolates, more ice cream, and their drinking chocolates! LOVE their ice cream, but I'll opt for a dish rather than a cone. read more

See all

Great service and always helpful. The flavors here are amazing. I love the birthday cake, moose tracks and butterbeer flavors. So delicious

Fantastic shop! I stopped in for a cone and then took a walk along the canal and it was the perfect choice. The staff was friendly and the ice cream delicious. I got the Girl Scout Mint flavor! Amazing. read more

Moonlight Creamery - Girl Scout Mint Cookies, walking the canal and eating ice cream. A delightful evening. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairport, New York

Busy night but plenty of staff to move the line along quickly for service. Taste was yummy and shop is very cute and very popular. I'd go back again this summer! read more

The ice cream is delicious and mostly homemade. We got the "itty bitty" size and it was definitely bigger than expected..not kiddy size. It was $5 for this smallest size, but since the ice cream is homemade, I think it's worth it. The server was very friendly and pleasant despite there being a long line. Inside is your typical ice cream shop, just a tad more upscale. They also serve different caffeinated drinks and wine! We will definitely be visiting again! The read more

Moonlight Creamery - Itty bitty size - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairport, New York

Underwhelming. They don't let you sample...which I understand when you're busy but we were the only ones in there! Ice cream tubs look a little tired... the chair I sat in was broken. Disappointing. read more

Love their ice cream! Walking in when running on the weekend, stop and get your scoop of ice cream! Try cherry blossom, wicked chocolate or coffee ice cream. read more

The place is beautiful. It feels warm and cozy and very inviting --- a place where you want to settle in for a while with a book or a friend. The coffee is very good. The ice cream is very good. The chocolates are beyond superb. There is also, for some reason, a vast selection of Rice Krispie treats. But none of that matters after you've spilled coffee all over your shirt because the lids don't fit properly on the cups. Worse yet, they **look** like they fit properly even though they don't, which fools you every time. I will admit I had to spill coffee on myself three times here before I learned my lesson. Once you're covered in hot wet coffee, it really doesn't matter that the place is beautiful and the food is good. Your cozy relaxed evening has just been spoiled. You can save yourself only by a) remembering what the problem is and b) immediately removing your coffee lid and discarding it so you don't get fooled. But of course then having a completely uncovered cup of hot coffee on your table invites an even bigger disaster. If they would spring for good coffee lids --- or even just barely decent coffee lids --- I'd write a five-star review. read more

This little shop was so cute! The ice cream was absolutely phenomenal and the staff was really nice. The prices were fair, there were a lot of options & the place was clean! read more

Have been twice nice and it's a fun and funky 90s cafe vibe. Super fun and different flavors, absolutely delicious and it's hard to choose! Both times I've been there's only one person working, so it's a little slow but so worth it! read more

See all

It was 25 degrees the day we went and I felt it was balmy enough to enjoy some ice cream. First of all, hard to beat this location, even with the bridge closed right now. Stunning view of the canal, gorgeous grassy area with plenty of space to enjoy your treat day or night. Very magical and transportative, even on a 25 degree evening. They have a lot of flavors and cute novelties in the case, which are super tempting. I went with cookie dough ice cream (my go to!) in a dish. My date went with espresso (or coffee maybe?) with waffle cone bits and chocolate sprinks. Mine was absolutely fab. I loved the creaminess, ratio of dough to ice cream to chips, and the fact that they use CHIPS instead of CHUNKS. Big distinction. His ice cream was just not great? I know that's not super helpful. It just tasted a bit bitter and lacked the warmth you sometimes get in a coffee ice cream. To me, neither held a candle to some of the other homemade ice cream spots in town. I'll be back for the pretty scenery and anytime I am looking for a good dessert option in Fairport! read more

See all

The service was great. The ice cream was expensive, and it was nothing special. The ice cream was about the same as store bought. The waffle cone tastes like cardboard. I would not go back read more

I love the variety of different of ice creams. So many to choose from, plus many toppings to choose from.

Homemade ice cream and so many unique flavors. We got the batteroo (peanut butter and brownie pieces with cake batter ice cream) and the to sow my wild oats (brown sugar ice cream with oats). They both were good but I wouldn't get the oats again-- they were a weird texture for me but will be going back to try different flavors! Atmosphere is great as well... right on the canal. read more

Moonlight Creamery - Batteroo and To Sow My Wild Oats - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairport, New York

I was there with my kids on a rainy Saturday at 11:15am, and the store was supposed to be open at 11:00am. The guy who works there didn't allow us to go in, he just opened the door and said the store is not open yet. Unfortunately, he opened the door at 11:30am. It was rude to ignore opening hours, make us wait in the rain, and say we are open now instead of apologizing. read more

Elevated ice cream (I can't believe I just used that phrase, but I do believe it fits). Wide array of flavors, ranging from classic (cookie dough) to novel (overnight oats, which does in fact taste like very brown-sugary and creamy oatmeal). They pay attention to sustainability; spoons are recycled material, bowls are compostable paper-based material, and they do not offer samples. At first I was put off by this last gambit, but it makes sense: When every person in line samples multiple flavors, that leads to a ton of single-use plastic spoons thrown in the garbage. Kudos to them for taking a stand on the matter. For all this elevatedness, you pay higher prices than other places ($5 for a kiddie, $6 for a regular, $7 for a large). I wouldn't go here every time we have a sweet craving, but once in a while it's a nice treat. read more

Who does not want ice cream on a hot summer day? Or for breakfast in February? This place caters to all. They are indeed on the pricier end for ice cream for the amount you get, but it's specialty flavors and some that you do not get else where. You could say artisan if you like. I fell in love with their orange cardamom. It's a creamsicle lovers dream. The pistachio is so flavorful and delightful filled with crushed pistachios. I feel like they use real ingredients to make/mix into the ice cream. You do not exactly get this at your run of the mill ice cream shop that sells Perry's or eddys for a dollar cheaper than buying the quart at Wegmans. They also make their waffle cones right there with a press or waffle iron? My husband and I always get the itty bitty and it's plenty for us. You can choose two flavors in the itty bitty 1 scoop of each. Give it a try! You get to try more than one flavor to try when there are so many good choices to choose from. If you are looking for large amounts of ice cream for cheap, this is not your place. What you will get is flavorful ice cream, with real ingredients, real flavors. Sometimes unique flavors. It's definitely worth a try. read more

Moonlight Creamery - Itty bitty Pistachio and maple walnut in a waffle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairport, New York

Excellent ice cream! Im an ice cream snob and this place is high quality. Creamy and flavorful. Got the butter pecan and peanut butter-fantastic read more

No lines filled with impatient kids here... At least not when I've visited. Moonlight has a more boutique like feel with glass cases containing delightful chocolates and ice cream flavors that you don't see just everywhere. Coupled with an off-main street, parkside location, delightful service and a sitting area hinting of an old soda shoppe, this this a great little place to stop for desert after a nice dinner or while exploring Fairport and the Erie Canal trail. read more

Milkshakes were delicious, would totally recommend the birthday cake!! I have to complain about the pricing though, since the pricing was EXTREMELY over-the-top, but the quality was worth it. read more

Most unique and delicious flavors. I am always impressed by a new and delicious flavor every time I visit. Best ice cream in Rochester. Don't miss out! read more

Def had a lot of good flavors. You can not taste test any here. The location is nice too. A little pricey.

Cute little corner spot at the end of a dead end. Staff was super friendly and upbeat. The chocolate peanut butter was amazingly delicious! I'm thankful for a spouse willing to share his choice. The blueberry pancake was heavy on the maple syrup, but it was the last few scrapes from the container (hence it was topped off with the Parisian breakfast). Both were more sweet than flavorful. read more

Moonlight Creamery - Regular sized Peanut Butter Fudge-tactic and 2/3 Sunday morning blueberry pancakes, 1/3 Parisian Breakfast - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairport, New York

Best ice cream in Fairport. It's right next to a small park with a nice outside sitting area overlooking the Erie Canal.

The location is nice but you can't sample the flavors before you buy the ice cream even if your are a young child . As a grandparent, I feel at the very least children should be able to sample two flavors before selecting their ice cream. read more

To expensive. They overpriced it's 7-10$ for a small. Hard to find. No parking. Rude staff

Amazing selection of store made ice cream and sorbets. Great coffee and sweet treats available. The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is fun. It's great having a business open late in Fairport especially when so many other places close early read more

There's plenty seats outside. I got the bourbon sour cherry and wild oats. The oats taste like overnight oatmeal, with real oats. The bourbon sour cherry is bourbon-y. It's a bit far from where I live but I hope to try more flavors in the future :) Also while the price looks higher than other establishments, you get SO MUCH though. I got regular and one scoop feels like a double. They really try filling up your cup haha. read more

Moonlight Creamery - bourbon with sour cherries & wild oats - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairport, New York

We have been coming here since they opened years ago. Best ice cream in Fairport. Imagine my surprise when I was told I couldn't enter without a mask. The place was empty. I had little ones with me who can't see over a counter. We got 4 small cones at a price of 25.00!! Then I was asked if I would leave a tip. That's ballsy. No other store requires masks and they had more customers. Lickety splits and Abbott's will get our business. read more

Cute shop all around and nice location in the village by the canal. As for their home made ice cream, it just doesn't do it for me. It often has that refrigerator/stale taste to me. Their ice cream is pretty popular though, idk whats up with my taste buds vs others but I don't like their ice cream. It's expensive and it just doesn't have good flavor in my opinion. read more

I haven't been here in a couple of years. Yelp insists that i post something despite "dismissing" it repeatedly. Somewhere along the line it registered a one star from me which was from Yelp insinuating it on my list repeatedly. They had decadent ice cream when I was last there but it was not recently. read more

Great Ice cream and creative flavors. They make their own waffle cones fresh onsite daily. Be patient since they have so many choices and typically only two counter staff. read more