My friends and I get takeout from here almost once a week and really enjoy their eclectic selection of unique pizza choices. Although I do not dine in often, the ambience is reminiscence of a typical pizza joint with takeout seating as well as sit down dinner experiences. One of my favorites slices is definitely there buffalo chicken slice, and their garlic knots are the best around here. read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - Grandma slice and Sicilian slice - Pizza Near Me - East Setauket, New York

See all

Good fantastic, staff are droids, no eye contact, no words, just toss the pizza box and tells you the price. Zero customer service

Great pizza, fresh flavors, friendly staff, fast service, worth every visit! again!!!

Oh my gosh have I been missing a good slice of NY pizza. Luigi's is Definitely delivering tasty delicious pizza with great crispy crust. The variety of pizza they had was great. I wanted to try them all but I could not definitely not eat them all. We tried a vodka slice, pepperoni slice, and balsamic with tomato slices. They were all fabulous. Can't wait to go back read more

See all

This is DISGUSTING. I ordered two pizzas and 3 salads. My daughter had 3 friends over for a birthday party. One of the pizzas was a cheese pizza. There was a human hair in it. That is disgusting. I don't know if it was the Uber Eats guy or whatever but i will NEVER be ordering here again. Horrible experience. read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - hair in pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Setauket, New York

It was good, but I don't think the value matches. I ordered a medium chicken bacon ranch pizza and 12 garlic knots. The medium pie was more like a personal pie as it came with 6 small slices...not even regular sized slices. A but it a rip off honestly. The flavor was good in both the pizza and the garlic knots...but I don't think it was worth the almost $40 price tag. I wouldn't order again when I'm back in the area. read more

Good pizza, amazing staff. They took care of myself and my family. Fun people watching spot too since the Stony Brook U kids stop by. If you're looking for a solid pie and great service, come on by! read more

I wish I lived closer to Luigi's, it seems to be a good neighborhood pizzeria. I received a great coupon in the mail so I decided why not, if it's bad it wouldn't be a huge loss. Last time I went to a place for a coupon, it was terrible so I had low expectations. And Luigi's exceeded it. I loved the online platform and the ability to add coupons on there. The pizza was really good. I don't know why some would say it wasn't flavorful, it certainly was. If they keep mailing me these coupons, I'm sure to be a frequent flyer. And they actually used real garlic on the garlic knots. Surprisingly using real garlic is becoming a lost art. read more

Ran in for a quick slice and there was an amazing selection of pies from salads and broccoli and all kinds of meats. We sat in a booth and enjoyed our slices. Staff was friendly and the pizzeria looked clean. Slice was generous but nothing special, there wasn't much flavor; tasteless. read more

See all

Get pizza for take out and have eaten inside as well. Pizza is delicious and Pasta dishes have been delicious as well. Service is quick and efficient and the place is clean ans bright. read more

My new favorite pizza shop. The eggplant and veggie pizza are bleeding-edgily awesome! Everything is so well-balanced! This is the only pizza I think I can eat an entire pie. The gyro pizza looks quite promising too! Next time for sure. read more

See all

Great pizza! Staff is always really nice! One of the better places in the area. Great pizza! Staff is always really nice! One of the better places in the area. read more

Wide variety of specialty slices and rolls. There is something for everyone. I've never been disappointed! Always friendly service. The dining area is large and clean with multiple booths. read more

Order was wrong , went back got it wrong again , large slices were so old you can tell when pizza is old just gross , never was this way gone down hill fast read more

variety of pizza slices. good size. fresh, tasty. service with a smile. quick lunch options

Where do I start with this one? How terrible this place is. Pizza was flat and tasteless. Almost like having an orange pool of greasy cheese on a piece of cardboard. Service was a typical in-N-Out wasn't very friendly. They were overpriced six raviolis and no cheese on top. Always seem to forget part of the order. Please could've been cleaned up a lot more. Defiantly not going back read more

Came here with the family since we were passing through. From the outside, it's underwhelming with an olive green sign. Once entering, I was pleased to be welcomed with a clean and organized dining area and simple decor. The dining area is of a reasonable size. My family and I ordered: - linguini with red clam sauce - penne a la vodka - salad pizza - 2 Sicilian slices - 1 mushroom & sausage slice Not quite sure why there were bad reviews. Though, this was our first time, my family and I had a great experience here. The workers were quick and very accommodating, the pasta was great...the pizza is mediocre, but not at all as bad as some people have mentioned. I hope that people will give this place another shot. I'd love to see this place thrive read more

See all

I did the too good to go deal and it was great! I received 4 big special slices, a bag of garlic knots and a chocolate chip cookie. Such a great deal and it was delicious! We've been going here for years for great pizza! So delicious and huge slices! read more

No question this location has gone through changes over the last 26 years I've been in the area (I remember when we called it Anthony's.). Is it hands-down the best pizza in East Setauket? No, as there are plenty of other solid choices. Do they have their share of bad days? Yes. Yet there's something to be said about going here everyday for six-years straight (No, really, I did.), and never getting tired of their pizza and other fare [including the Freestyle machine]. (Let's not forget: https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=TNvH7amEBrPWFunNl4H5pA&userid=_XDqHYiMCJaeOYIfpk4H6Q ) Though I'm no longer a VERY frequent flier, Luigi's is still a solid, go-to for me whenever I am in the area (Make sure to get a slice with sauteed onions.). Their staff were top-notch then, and seems to continue that trend now, at least based on the limited times I've been back since. More importantly, they do address their shortcomings, like when to get rid of bad staff (See: https://www.yelp.com/biz/marios-pizzeria-commack-commack?hrid=083gY6O8DUkc4VsAbvtS7Q ). read more

Order penne with Alfredo sauce. When I had the free time to eat it I had to heat it up and found no alfredo sauce which is not an issue as I have a jar here, but had to drain over 40ml of oil from the penne. I could have gotten a better meal from Domino's Pizza than what I got from Luigi's. This will be my last time as the meal was so oil-saturated that I had to throw it away. read more

I ordered 6 cheese slices. One minute later i realized they charged me more than the price for a pie and asked if they could just make me a pie. Their answer was no. These guys are crooks. Zero stars if that was an option. read more

COVID era: They take orders on their website with curbside pickup. Got myself a delicious chicken Parmesan hero. Great experience! read more

See all

Luigi's is our go to spot for an after school slice with the kids. Their favorite is the macaroni and cheese slice. I really enjoy sitting there and eating a slice compared to take out. I feel the slices are much larger and cooked better. Some of my go to slices are the plain, BBQ chicken, chicken bacon ranch, and Caesar salad slice. The new empanadas were tasty especially the spinach and artichoke. read more

See all

Pizza is slightly better then dominos. Stopped here quick to grab a quick lunch before heading home. Place does look nice and pizza looks good but the taste....mehhh at best. Crust and dough had 0 flavor. Sauce tasted jared. I cant remember the last time i didnt finish a slice of pizza. The tomato and mozz slice i got was slightly better but not much. Service was decent and place was clean. Id recommend looking for another spot in town. read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - Dinning area - Pizza Near Me - East Setauket, New York

See all

Stopped in today. On Long Island so I wanted to get pizza again,while I was still here. Walked In around 2p.m. and was greeted by a friendly counter person, so that was good. Got a couple of slices and a coke for about 10 bucks, not bad for the island. Slices were hot but the crust was too thick. You pick it up and fold it, and there was no droop. Sauce was not too flavorful and no oil from the cheese. Tried to jazz it up but no red pepper or garlic powder on the counter. Decent pizza for upstate New York or South Carolina but not good for Long Island.I kicked myself for not going to pizza carnival. read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - Ehh, crust too thick and sauce was not too flavorful - Pizza Near Me - East Setauket, New York

The service was not the best. Shrimp parm was great. Bolognese was okay.... It's not the real way it's made but not horrible. The bread was never given until we asked . More than anything else the service was bad. read more

Delicious and generous portions too! Staff always friendly and you get your food quickly too.

I found the slice I had too cheesy, too soft and too large. The slice lacked texture. I really didn't even have to chew. I think the pie was underdone and over-cheesed. The whole slice melted on to the paper plate. read more

Very good no surprises - my friend brought 4 different hero's for us to try very good I came back the following day and ordered three pies read more

Love this place, great food and friendly staff. Go about once a week it seems. Their pizza and special slices are delicious. I love the Boone slices and the chicken bacon ranch slice. Family loves the pasta as well. Great garlic knots. read more

Found a good pizza place that delivers. I was pleased with fast delivery and the pizza was hot and fresh. Their sauce is on the sweeter side. I also tried the white pizza which had nice garlic flavor. I recommend a plain cheese pie as well as a white pie. Or half and half. I will definitely order from them again read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - East Setauket, New York

Fantastic food and customer service! The staff is amazing! Highly recommend for picking up slices!

This is our go to pizza place for the kids. They like it here but its not my wifes favorite place. We'll buy the kids their pizza here on a Friday night before going out to the movies. Its not a bad pizza, my wife & I like the pizza around the corner from our house. Sorri Luigi! read more

The pizza looks a lot better than it tastes and is definitely not worth the price. Pepperoni slices are $4.50 each, which is outrageous in my opinion. I would not recommend this pizzeria. read more

If I could give this place 0 stars I would. Horrible customer service! Manager is so rude! I've been ordering from here for years and we just recently ordered 2 pies. They made the grandma pie half the size it used to be and when I called to complain the manager said oh I'll come swap the pies and bring u a new one. So what are they planning on doing with the one I'm giving them back? That's a little alarming considering COVID. We're u going to resell the slices? And on top of that he's telling me they ran out of the bigger one. No that's straight up BS, we all know you stretch the dough and make it the size you want don't try and play me for an idiot. What they should have done was apologize and send me a new pizza on the house. That's what customer service is. The customer is ALWAYS right. Never eating here again. read more

Eh. I decided to order a hero for lunch since it was mad prom season and couldn't break from the work counter. Meatball hero was very disappointing in looks. Taste was eh. The bread was not toasted making the hero soggy from internal contents. To top it all off the cheese was no fully melted. You can still see the shredded cheese clumped together in a poor attempt in reheating the food. There was no peeling of the cheese off the wrapper or stretchy goodness from hero to mouth. Just "WTH is this this"? - "this" not a typo but an anagram. read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - Poor excuse of a meatball hero - Pizza Near Me - East Setauket, New York

Decent pizza, avoid going after 6pm - that's when they stop making individual slices. Their remaining slices gets ultra cold and not really edible. Otherwise a very comfy interior and wooden seating. Good place to bring your family. Now that Mario's pizza(not far away)is in limbo status, many come here instead. Check out Luigi's menu - they have a varied menu including a buffet. Haven't tried it yet before. I just order individual slices. Try their buffalo chicken, and eggplant. read more

See all

Tasteless regular pizza. No flavor at all. Looks normal but the sauce is tasteless. I am trying it for the first time. I won't be coming back. And $10.91 for two slices and a soda at 2 in the afternoon. Way too much. read more

Ask for large pie very very very small no taste Long wait never go back ripe off very on organized place

I have never really liked Luigis and have found the crust like cardboard but I thought I would give it a shot as the other pizzeria was closed down. I ordered a Margherita Pizza which is my favorite and to me what I like best are the small bits of fresh mozzarella and sauce with basil. However, what I got from them was not that at all. It was awful. covered in the thick yellowy cheese and covered all over in fresh tomatoes and no sauce and dried basil not the fresh I am accustomed to. What a waste of money. It cost extra and no one wanted to eat it. I called to tell them and the young girl was apologetic and offered to let me speak a manager. I said ok and waited and waited and waited...and gave up. Never again. I don't care if this is their version, it is not what you would expect so that is misleading read more