THIS PLACE IS SO GOOD! The inside is so cute, the staff are very friendly as well. The pizza was so good and affordable. I also picked up a cookie from the front counter, from a local bakery which was great! I will be back soon. read more

Lupo Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Fair Haven, New Jersey

The food was amazing and the service top nonch. If you see Jeff working you know the pizza will be amazing.

Pretty much your typical glorified pizza joint. You could pretty much copy and paste the menu from hundreds of similar restaurants in NJ. A shade beyond meh. read more

I love this pizzeria! Top quality food and everything always seems super fresh. Great pizzas, pastas & salads. Based on some other reviews and their photos, I think people are mistaking this with another restaurant with the same name and leaving inaccurate reviews! read more

Lupo Pizzeria - Outside of restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Fair Haven, New Jersey

See all

Detroit pizza and chicken vodka wrap are my go-to! Also the amount of options they have for slices is always different . Great spot for a quick bite or great dinner . read more

$15 + tax + tip = $20 for 3 slices of pizza. are you kidding me??? no thanks. i'll buy myself an amy's pie and make it at home.

$18 chicken parm. 4 chicken fingers with Mariana. Awful. Awful. Awful. Life long resident. This place is a disgrace.

Ordered a large pie with half sausage and half plain to go. The ingredients tasted fresh, but the flavors weren't over the top. There was a little too much dough that took away from the flavor of the sausage and sauce. Overall the pie was pretty standard, decent flavor and not too much grease, could be a decent takeout option. read more

Lupo Pizzeria - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Fair Haven, New Jersey

I've been getting pizza from Lupo since it opened. They have been on a downward spiral for the last 6 months. Covid is over and can't use that excuse anymore. The last two times have been borderline inedible. Margerita is a plain pie with a little bit of basil sprinkled on. I'm looking for a new pizza place if anyone has any recommendations. read more

We just moved to the area from California and tried this pizzeria with my son. The pizza was amazing, service was good, and they have cute outdoor seating. But for me, as a vegetarian which comes with it's challenges in this area for quick not overly priced go-to healthy meals, Lupo serves a delicious beans & escarole with tons of garlic! The dish is not expensive and they give a big portion. I hope they never raise the price or take this out of the menu. read more

I paid $7! $7.00!! For 2 plain slices of dry chewy pizza that looked like it was 2 days old!! To make it worse the girls behind the counter had no personality. Not inviting at all. Didn't say thank you, or your welcome. This was the second time I went there I thought maybe I should give it a second chance. Never again. ‍ read more

We are fed up with this place! Overpriced, below average quality, portion sizes are a joke. I ordered chicken fingers and fries, we got three tiny nuggets and 9 French fries. Seriously 9 small soggy fries. I actually counted them. We are absolutely done with this place. read more

Their delivery person parked in our driveway with lights on our house. When I went out to see who it was, there was no one in car. Went back in house to consider calling police. Then went back outside. Driver came back. Asked him why he was in my driveway. Told me to "shut the F..." up. Not so nice member of our community. Won't be doing business with Lupo. read more

The fig and prosciutto pizza...maybe if u leave off the fig jam would be ok..but u only taste sweet..no balance. The beet salad...if its gonna be a beet forward salad...don't use canned beets! Overall not real excited read more

Amazing pizza. Love the thin crust and beautiful, delicious burrata fig salad. Will be back! read more

Lupo Pizzeria - Burrata Fig Salad - Pizza Near Me - Fair Haven, New Jersey

Love their Detroit style pizza, the crust is amazing! I could eat all crust and be perfectly happy. We like their pepperoni and have enjoyed other toppings along with their wings, salads and broccoli. Their regular pizza is pretty good but is definitely overshadowed by the Detroit-style. read more

The food is good although they skimp on the sauce and charge extra for an adequate amount. The sub comes with barely enough sauce to cover the chicken on the sub and doesn't even come close to covering the sub. The edges have no sauce or chicken. Just biting into naked bread on both sides. Its very frustrating because I already pay 13 dollars for a sub, which I expect to come with an adequate amount of sauce. I have brought this up while ordering and was told thats how they operate and they can provide extra sauce for a charge. They charge nearly twice the price of a sub from red bank, with nearly half the ingredients. Beyond frustrating. Lupo you will lose a regular customer if it continues. If the problem is fixed, I will adjust my review. This has happened multiple times. read more

Ordered a large pie (Half Plain / Half Mushroom). Size: It was literally barely larger than a personal bar pie. Taste: A bit bland and forgettable.... read more

local. I'm one and done. Not a fan. ordered the large pie, square, with pepperoni and hot peppers, chilies, pick up, skimpy on the everything and I'm not a fan of fluff crust. Def premade. Sadly i've already seen this place too many times. I won't be back. read more

Will not order again. Ridiculously under cooked pizza, completely doughy. Garlic knots are a joke...there's no garlic, oil or anything...It's just a bunch of bread rolls! Bunch of kids behind the counter bickering.... No customer service or appreciation. Zero stars...save your money and go elsewhere read more

Hit or miss. I would say the safest thing to get is margherita with sausage. The crust is consistently bready and bland. I tried to branch out & try other things from them a few times & it was very disappointing. Burrata and fig pie was a round, tasteless cracker-like crust with a smear of jam and a tiny ball of cheese in the center, sprinkled in arugula leaves. Grandma pie had a fluffy, oddly dry tasteless crust with rubbery cheese on it that all the grease leaked out of. It had an aftertaste like the dough had been sitting in a smelly plastic bin for awhile. The salads are good, though and generously sized. read more

Just meh... so hit or miss. Some days you order a pie and its good. Other times it's awful. Our last order was a cold burnt pie and overcooked mushy pasta. It was inedible and I had to scramble to feed my kids dinner. I should have known when I placed the order and they said it would be ready in 10 mins. read more

I have ordered from Lupo's several times! They are accurate with their times for delivery and the food is amazing! The Brussel sprouts, Detroit pizza, BBQ wings, and Nutella Calzone are amazing. read more

rating not based on quality of food -- the pizza is best in the area. HOWEVER - they accidentally gave my order to a different customer... it's okay, it happens! What I found so irritating was that the person who was responsible for the mix-up took no responsibility, offered no compensation and I had to wait for a new pizza. To make it worse, when the customer with my order returned, they hand him his correct order without realizing they were giving that customer a free pizza, while I waited for an order I already paid for. I couldn't help but mention something, and to rectify the situation the cashier had the returning customer pay for the accidental, additional pizza. They completely took advantage of the situation and exercised no customer service. read more

Sorry! After several visits, all I can say is consistently bad. It is a shame, as the staff is really friendly, and they seem to use really fresh ingredients. The food is way over priced (I don't care if it is Fair Haven), and takes entirely too long. And, it just is not that good - mediocre pizza at best, and the lamest cheese steak I have ever had. Try elsewhere! read more

I consider myself a connoisseur of Chicken Parmesan and Lupo has one of the best in the area! I also love their arugula salad and pasta fagioli. I pretty much love it all! read more

The plain pizza and the grandma pizza were both very good, as was the salad selection! The garlic knots were very nice too, and they tasted very fresh. A nice place to sit down and eat in the summer, or even for takeout. Staff is friendly too! (: read more

Sorry, Lupo, been waiting forever for you guys to open in west long branch. Really wanted to welcome you to the community. Ordered last night. Not so good. Pizza came with cheese stuck to the top of the pizza box. Arugula salad was ok, but the artichokes were a little off. I will say the pepperoni and the crust was good. Will try again. read more

We are very picky about our pizza and we were so pleasantly surprised. The pizza is amazing and the crust delicious. We got a regular pizza and a Margherita pizza. The sauce was great. We are new to the area and kept driving back to our old pizzeria. Well we are eating local from now on! Highly recommend read more

Terribly inconsistent. Sometimes thick crust sometimes thin. 100% of our delivery dining sucked ass. Pizza where we asked for no garlic comes ladened with garlic. How can you take this approach with pizza? read more

Everytime I go there they never use the spatula to pick up the pizza they use their hands. to put the food in the oven. I don't know about you but I do have a problem with somebody touching money touching their bodies touching everything and then touching my food. I feel like this is a health hazard and you're opening yourself up for any kind of disease that could happen to be on their hands. If they're doing this with Pizza. God only knows what's going on in that kitchen behind closed doors. read more

This is definitely my favorite pizza place. The food is great, the drink selection is great and the service is excellent. I would recommend Lupo Pizzeria to anyone in the area who was looking for pizza. The buffalo chicken pizza is incredible alone either the salad pizza. The dessert selection is excellent too! The pizzeria offers Nutella pizza that is incredible served with fruits. read more

I come here every weekend with my friends and it'll always be my go to place for as long as it's here. It's super close to my house so delivery doesn't take long. The staff is incredibly friendly. And the pizza is delicious. Would definitely recommend read more