Delish and brings back memories of New York pizza and the Ambience in the pizzeria is like being home read more

Round Pie Pizza - Freehold - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

See all

After visiting the awesome Floor Store, we were looking for a quick bite, and Kevin recommended here. We had slices of supreme, chicken bacon ranch, arugula, and cheesesteak. I love thin crust pizza and Round Pei served really really good thin crust pizza! The place is clean and the service was quick. Too bad we live over an hour away but if you're in the area, you should definitely try it! read more

Round Pie Pizza - Freehold - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

See all

A friend of mine recommended I try this pizza. Had it for the first time tonight. I ordered the classic cheese pie. This pizza is fantastic! It is a thin crust. On the first bite you can taste the sauce which is delicious and a little on the sweet side. The crust is very good as well and the cheese just makes for a trifecta that is really amazing! I called in the order and was told about 15 minutes it would be ready for pick up. I arrived a little early and found they have a screen I over the counter that tells you the status of whether your pizza is done or in the process of being made which i found pretty cool. The staff were very friendly and I waited maybe a few minutes before he handed me my pizza. The pizzeria itself is very clean inside and nicely decorated. There are not many tables but I would have no problem eating in there. You can get pizza by the slice and they have some very good looking salads available from what I saw. This is authentic NY pizza. We have a lot of good pizza in the area and it's hard to be a standout here. Round Pie is definitely a standout and a new favourite for me. read more

Yes I finally found a place to fulfill my pizza craving thank you Jesus. It was so good I ate the whole pie by myself. I'm sorry that it took me so long to try you guys out. Now that I know the background I know why the pizza is so darn good. I am a fellow New Yorker who knows good pizza. I love the whole restaurant with all of the wall displays. I have already been back twice so I will be visiting the brick location soon. read more

The service and the food was really good. The restaurant was clean. Recommend this place.

There's about 3 Round Pie Co's near me but somehow our first time trying it and to our pleasant surprise, all locations have stellar reviews! We opt to come to the Freehold location and it did not disappoint. The staff was so welcoming and patient, which is extremely helpful when dining with a toddler lol. It was much appreciated. We ordered the pizza, an eggplant sandwich and garlic knots. The pizza was obviously the star of the show. We ordered the margarita with hot peppers, which was delicious - cooked perfectly with just the optimal amount of cheese and basil where it's not too skimpy or too overbearing. Looking forward to coming back to try more of their pies! read more

See all

Pizza is always good and was good tonight. Ordered a Chicken Vodka Parm Panini as well. The chicken was dry and there was hardly any Vodka Sauce on it. Very disappointed. read more

I give this place 5 stars If I could give more, I would! Round Pie Pizza Company in Freehold is hands down the best pizza I've ever had. The crust, the sauce, the flavor--everything was perfect. What really blew me away? My son, who always complains when we get pizza, actually loved it. That never happens. This place has officially changed the pizza game for us. Highly recommend! read more

Round Pie Pizza - Freehold - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

The website was very easy to order. The staff at the location was super friendly and nice. The food was ready before the time they told us, it was super quick. The food was amazing. Highly recommend and definitely will be back again! This great place! read more

The Buffalo wings were some of the best buffalo wings I've ever had in my entire life. They were super juicy and super hot and crispy was delicious. Best buffalo wings ever, it literally fell apart when I bit into it that's how juicy and crispy it was, the pizza was delicious and warm, the garlic knots are good aren't full of oil which was great , coming back! read more

See all

Had to try this spot out, got two slices for around $10. Both were pretty good, they were thin and had good flavor. I'd come back for a full pie one day read more

Round Pie Pizza - Freehold - Plain and Buffalo chicken - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

Best pizza We went to our first round pie pizza in Brick NJ we were going regularly. It's nice to know. They have one close to our home here in Farmingdale . It simply delicious comes out nice and hot, but is very thin and the taste delicious like for Pizza's are used to thin crust light tasty marinara sauce, and fresh mozzarella just delicious. Try it you won't get disappointed. read more

On February 9, 2026 I tried Round Pie after hearing about it in the Freehold New Jersey area. I live in a surrounding town and made the trip to their Rt. 9 location. If you like thin crust pizza you'll love Round Pie. Thin crust is one of my favorites and Round Pie was great. Good firm crust, no flop, very tasty flavorful sauce, good cheese. The sauce didn't give me agita 3 to 6 to 9 hours later and it was tasty. The pie was hot out of the oven and cheese was stringy at first but after cooling a bit it firmed up. Had a plain and 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 sausage. The sausage was great the way I like it crumble pieces on the pie, the pepperoni was small thin slices that cupped up. Highly recommend if you like thin crust pizza. The ambience was plan and simple maybe id consider it a little cold looking. read more

Pizza was tasted fresh and crispy with a variety of slice flavors. Spicy pasta rigatoni was deliciously creamy and comes with garlic bread. Would come back for the pasta at the price read more

Round Pie Pizza - Freehold - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

Pizza is so good man. First off I got a white slice and garlic knots (they're huge) Im bout to finish this whole thing and also the staff is kinda nice read more

Round Pie Pizza - Freehold - Pizza is so good man. First off I got a white slice and garlic knots and the garlic knots are huge Im bout to finish this whole thing. - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

Staten Island where you at?! This is a new spot in town and I can understand why it is busy. I have had their pizza in other locations and it is always good. It took a while to get the pizza but they gave my son a free slice while we waited. I went with the Signature pie and the hot honey roni. The hot honey roni isn't as crisp because of the pepperoni but it is still awesome. The signature is delicious and I highly recommed you get it. It had a crispy crust and flavor that sticks up to any nj pie. One of the best pizzeria's in the area in the same category as Federici's and Brooklyn Square. read more

See all

I've been waiting for this place to open for a while. So, when we decided to step out to eat, this was the first place I thought about. The place is small, but comfortable, with one tall table sitting in the back and the rest being regular tables. The walls are made of brown wood panels and are adorned with a large mural and a portrait. We ordered the following: 17" Veggie Supreme pizza, which has tomato sauce, mozzarella, peppers, Kalamata olives, red onions, broccoli and mushrooms. We had this minus the olives. This was pretty good. It's a thin crust pizza and the crust was crispy and we all liked it a lot. Meatball Parmigiana panini- this was delicious as well. Meatballs were nice and soft. Rice balls - this came with 3 in an order and were delicious as well. We saw another table that ordered 2 small pies and said that we should've done that. This way, we could've tried other pizzas on the menu. Next time. Service was quick and friendly. Will definitely return to try other items on the menu! read more

Awesome food, clean, new pizza place. Love the thin crust pizza, fill you up without feeling terrible after. read more

See all

Thin crust, well done, tomato sauce was great! No lack of pepperoni on this amazing hot honey pepperoni pie! This place is going to do great! read more

Round Pie Pizza - Freehold - Finally open! - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

See all

Since their grand opening, I have placed a few orders at Round Pie and for the most part the orders were hot and on the money. Not this time. Today, I ordered a 12" pie with sausage and hot peppers, and utilized a 50% off coupon for this purchase. When I got home, less then 10 mins say, the pie was Luke warm at best and looked extremely anemic. There was a minimal amount of cheese on this pizza, almost like they used 50% less cheese on the pizza to go against my 50% off coupon. This pizza is all bread and sauce... sad Most businesses never realize why they lose customers. It is Really sad that there is such a great inconsistency in their pizza quality . I will think twice before I order again. read more

Round Pie Pizza - Freehold - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

One of the best thin-slice I've had that rival's other pizzerias in the state that get a lot of recognition.

I live 5 minutes away and since they opened I would only buy pizza from there. Krispy and Tommy's traven and all the locals lots me for good. I'm just disappointed bc I wish they had been in my life long ago. lol. read more

Fresh ingredients, pue is always ready. Thin crispy goodness. I Love their tomato sauce.

Delicious date night at home! Food was delivered fresh, hot, & delicious! Dessert was worth it! We finally found a reliable spot that's a taste of home (Brooklyn). eat here- you won't be disappointed!!! read more

Round Pie Pizza - Freehold - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

this place was fabulous! beautiful food, very delicious, best food in freehold, scratch that, new jersey, scratch that the world! read more

Round Pie Pizza - Freehold - Me (person) with my two plates (finished) - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

I had the pesto pizza, and it was a hit. It was a thin pizza, but they used cherry tomatoes instead of tasteless winter tomatoes(KrispyP) and topped it off with thin shavings of Parmigiano cheese--what a nice touch. That was a 5-star pizza. I was surprised there was no chicken franchise on the menu. read more

Ordered signature veggie pizza,it was watery and saggy, doesn't taste that great , there is no wow factor to go back! Not ordering here again! read more

Been there 3 Fridays in a row and heading back tonite to pick up .But there's nothing like having a plain pie right out of the oven . so crispy and the sauce is perfect read more

Delicious, crispy thin crust pie. Comes in personal or family size. But the best part is the customer service. My take out order took a bit longer than expected and the apologies came along with a very nice discount. Any establishment that respects their customers' time is an establishment I will visit again and again read more