Tried the white slice with spinach and garlic knots. Unfortunately, the slice and garlic knots were bland and I would not recommend. Service is good and there is dining space upstairs. They have cannolis which they fill fresh but didn't try this time. read more

Sally Boy's Pizza - White slice and garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

Having once ordered often, I don't know what has happened. The past two times we've ordered from there, the food was inedible. The first was a caesar salad that was half lettuce, half crouton crumbs drowned in italian dressing, not caesar. The second time, I ordered a pizza due to the bad salad experience. It smelled delicious. It was not. Everyone who took a slice, threw their slice out after one bite...five people spit out and threw out their slice; me, work friend, husband, and two teenage sons. read more

Passed by Sally Boy while visiting Jersey on a prior visit and the food on display looked and smelled good. I found myself In Jersey again and decided to order food.....so glad I ordered. After many visits to Jersey and being thoroughly disappointed in my prior pizza purchases, Sally Boy will be my "go to pizza place" moving forward. There are no seats inside but the staff are pleasant and quick to process your order. Delivery is also fast. Finally a crust that isn't thin like the sheets of paper, oily or tasteless like the other pizzas I have tried out here :( Sally boy was fresh, spiced nicely and not greasy. Albeit pricey so dig deep in your wallet but I don't mind paying extra if the food is up to par. read more

See all

Great vodka sauce chicken parm slice. Detroit deep dish meets Sicilian. Perfect balance between sauce, cheese and chicken. I'll be back Jeremy. read more

I might have reviewed this place before and said I wouldn't return, but I did because my friend wanted pizza and they had the only outdoor dining on the sunny side of the street. And once again, was a big disappointment. She ordered "Brick Oven Pizza". She loves Brick oven Pizza, extra char. Server brings out pizza. "Is THIS brick oven pizza?" Nope. Regular Pizza oven pizza. Apparently they only do that on Fridays and Saturdays! Was there ANY indication, whether by written or verbal communication of that fact? Nope. The people there had plenty of of opportunity, the ordering kiosk had the ability to state so, but nah, who the F**k cares? Not the owners, not the managers, not the staff. And to top it off, the pizza was no better than the low end of frozen pizza. Shame, Sally Boys, Shame. read more

The good- easy to order on the kiosk, sausage sandwich roll was fresh and soft, ambiance was ok (typical for Red Bank), drink selection was just okay. The bad - sausages on the sandwich were pretty burnt and dried out. The service was nothing great. Not very friendly. Would I come here again? Probably not as there are other choices in the area. read more

Sally Boy's Pizza - Pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

I liked this place, because of it's authenticity and the homemade, unique offerings. I felt a price of $42, to include two pizza slices, two drinks and a salad - was a bit pricy. Though I enjoyed my slice, the crunchy charred bottom, detracted from the overall flavor of cheese and tomato sauce. A Nice Salad (though fresh) at $13.00, comprised of the salad standards, plus green olives - not worth the hefty price tag. Suggests selling the salad as a smaller portion/price and and adding more sauce to the pie, evening out the taste of char. read more

Sally Boy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

See all

This review is just for the pizzas they put out in their display. My first thought when I looked at their speciality pizzas that they keep out in their display is that they were all way too thick! I tried to find a thinner pizza slice, but there weren't any. I ended up getting the white with spinach, eggplant, and a Sicilian slice. The white pizza slice with spinach tasted all dried out! It tasted like it was sitting there since early in the morning! I obviously didn't care for that one at all. The eggplant pizza was very good! It tasted fresh, and the sauce to that one was very tasty! The Sicilian slice was mediocre. The sauce wasn't as flavorful as the eggplant pizza, and the cheese was all dried out. The pizzas were way too dense to my liking. I'd come back and try ordering a whole pie next time, but I definitely won't be ordering any pizza by the slice here again. read more

Sally Boy's Pizza - Sicilian (just ok), eggplant (very good) and spinach (mediocre) pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

I had a really good experience ordering pizza and pasta late night on a weekend. We were helped by an employee who was very nice and cheery. Food was made quickly and was tasty. I thought the pizza was especially good! read more

If I could, I would give this a 3.5. I really liked the ambiance, the friendly staff, and the price point (a Sicilian pie was about $23, which is on the cheaper side nowadays). The two cons for me, not insignificant, were that the bottom was just too crisp for my liking (understand why they did it -- so that the pizza didn't fall apart when you picked it up -- but I would still take a light crisp/less integrity over super crispy/bordering burnt), and unfortunately, it didn't taste like the slices had any seasoning. I added a ton of oregano and garlic powder to each, which helped, but it would have been better if there was seasoning in the red sauce or in the ricotta of the white slice. Texturally, everything was great. I would give it another try if it was closer, but I wouldn't make a drive (over an hour) for this again. read more

See all

This place is pretty good, I first wrote it a half review cause the price was high but in all fairness the location is prime. This is my favorite pizza in the area. read more

This place is way overpriced, especially the 2 inch thick $8 slices. I prefer thin crust not Sicilian or pan pizza. And the pizza is just not that good. There are too many pizzerias in the area that are much better. read more

Pizza was great, chicken parm hero was solid, Jeremey provided great service. Overall great experience, will be back soon

Pizza was amazing. Highly recommend the vodka grandma slice. Service was quick. The place is brand new so everything was very clean. read more

Sally Boy's Pizza - Plain slice, Vodka Grandma Pie - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

Pros: The staff is friendly, the place is clean Cons: the pizza is terrible, it's very expensive for not great food I've been three times... Once I had reheated slices, the other times I ordered ahead. All of the pizza I had was borderline bad. read more

one of the best if not the best spot in town... Variety and Quality is top notch ... views of downtown Red Bank from their top floor dining room ! read more

Ok is exactly right for this. I was excited to try this place. I came in with my daughter on a Wednesday night. I will say the people there were very friendly. But overall I probably won't return. The price here is really just ridiculous. I got 2 slices and a small bar pie for my daughter, it was over $25. The slices were $8 each...are you kidding? Sure they are thicker crust, kind of like a sicilian pie. But, they were small and definitely not worth that price tag. The little bar pie was good for a 6 year old, that was thin crust. The flavor was ok, I got the buffalo and vodka chicken, they were good. Not $8 each good, half that good. I think the hoagies were $18. While they were nice, there's just no way I'd come back here with the rest of the fam when I could get a full meal for the same price. I wish them the best but I'll skip it. read more

Burnt pizza and it taste like shit. For $43 Hard as a rock. The owners are a real class act too. read more

Sally Boy's Pizza - On $43 for some burnt cardboard - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

Sorry. Wanted to like it. REALLY wanted to like it. Really cool spot visually.. looks nice both inside and outside. BUT. I won't pay $6.00 for a slice for, to put it lightly, mediocre flavorless pizza. I've paid and will pay $6.00 a slice for exceptional pizza. Needless to say that won't be here. read more

Go to after drinks anywhere in Red Bank. Fresh at 10:30 at night crisp delicious don't miss it

Someone mentioned this new pizzeria, so I figured let me give it a try... ehhh, I was expecting really good pizza especially since they mention a "Ferrari oven". Pizza was just okay, kinda bland. But personally this place is way overpriced. I also felt the staff was not so friendly and actually quite rude. The place and atmosphere was nice. Hopefully they can get it together. I don't think I will return when there are plenty of other pizzerias in the area. read more

Sally Boy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

See all

This place blatantly rips off unsuspecting customers by charging an insanely unreasonable charge when using Slice, and I'm sure other third party apps. Slice charges independent pizza shops and other mom and pop businesses a very low fee when compared to competitors BECAUSE they want to see these small shops succeed. Yet, the greedy owner of Sally Boy is exploiting the ethical values that slice was founded on. I won't ever give Sally Boy a penny of my money and I'm contacting Slice to let them know of this "theft." read more

Sally Boy's Pizza - The 1st screenshot shows the prices in a Google search. The 2nd & 3rd show the prices on the Slice app - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

At 8$ a slice, it's a stretch to justify the flavor to price ratio. It was alright but nothing crazy. read more

Sally Boy's Pizza - a car driving down the street - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

Tried the new Sally Boy's! So good. My fiancé and I got the plain pie to see how good their basic pie was. It's great! read more

Sally Boy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

Wood fire pizza: amazing. Slices: amazing, but for entirely different reasons. Garlic knots: addicting. Staff was friendly and helpful. Restaurant itself was clean and well designed. Cannot recommend highly enough. read more

Friday night. It was busy so be patient because it's worth it! I ordered a grandma, a margarita and a 16" neighborhood pie. My wife and daughter loved the margarita while I was a much bigger fan of both the regular pie and the grandma. The garlic knots were incredible. My other daughter got a chicken caprese sandwich and was two thumbs up. Congratulations Sally Boys. read more

Sally Boy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

One of the best pies I have ever had! Service was great! The new restaurant was beautiful! A must try, an added gem to red bank! read more

Sally Boy's Pizza - Pepperoni Pie - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

Trash! Not good at all. Tastes like Sbarro Pizza with a hefty price. The only good thing about this spot is that they stay open late to feed a late night cravings. One and done... never returning. 4 slices $28 read more

I have no idea why I'm seeing any bad reviews. Maybe they're just not ordering the right things. My most recent order chicken Parm hero, chicken vodka Parm wrap, and I'd have to say some of the best chicken tenders with fries that I've had in a long time. You pay for what you get. unfortunately, with the economy right now, prices are pretty high, but Even ordering on Uber eats I'm fine paying the extra money for food. I KNOW will always be good. read more

Decent pizza but $6 for a slice of plain cheese!? fugetabowdit!!! Good luck surviving with that business model. I'll go to Mr slice for 2.99 thankyou very much. read more

Sally boys has proved to be a great addition and staple to red bank. Late night window open for bar crowds and always consistently great food. Support Sally Boys! read more

This place is great! Recently hosted a birthday dinner for my teenage daughter and her friends. Everything was perfect and easy. Jeremy was wonderful to work with from beginning to end. Highly recommend if you're looking for a fun casual place to host a dinner party! read more

this establishment is one of a kind. Not only is the crust thick and sassy, the whole experience is lavish. The vibes, the atmosphere and the cuisine were stellar. And not to mention free garlic nots????? You got to be kidding me!!! From the amazing vibes and music, the hilarious Halloween decor, and one of a kind server, sally boys you made my night. #viptable #ifyky # read more

$8 a slice???? Get the f**k outta here. Take this BS somewhere else. It's evident people don't know good quality food to think in any instance it's okay to pay $8 for 1 slice of mediocrity on cardboard at best. This place will only last because of the walk-through window that'll serve all the drunk college kids come summer. ‍ Staff was friendly enough, but this place is overhyped for nothing. NEXT. read more

Good food. Fast service and reasonable prices. Nice seating area on the second floor

I had the Vodka Grandma pie, the vodka sauce was to die for. The staff is pleasurable and are happy when you come in. Good luck Sally Boy's!

This place is waist of time and money. I did my or by phone before 45 minutes, and went there and i waited for more 20 minutes, and the lady was very unprofessional. I will never go there anymore. Even for free food. read more

The best eggplant parm I have had in ages! My daughter loved the penne vodka and my husband had the chicken parm that just needed some extra sauce. Other then that excellent! read more

I'm a first timer that came into Sally Boy's because my main pizza spot wasn't open yet BUT for all the dopey comments you read about the price being too high, let me inform you that maybe the price for a slice is higher than most, it's a large slice and 1 slice is like a meal. The sauce and cheese are really good. That being stated, it's really flavorful! I had the eggplant slice and I'm very picky about pizza and I definitely plan to return as soon as I have a craving for pizza. Try this place at least once! read more

Good pizza and salad was a huge fan of their sausage and pepper roll.vodka sauce is delicious.