Delivery guy took an hour, and immediately demanded cash tip. I didn't even have time to say hello. It was the most awkward thing ever. Good portions, but my fries were soggy. I asked for ranch and they gave me honey mustard. read more

Ordered a pizza tonight from this business based on our hotels recommendation. Placed the order at 8:10pm and was quoted 45 minutes for delivery. We called multiple times because we were unsure if they would call us upon arrival or if we should wait in the lobby. When we called they said he was on his way, but it took another 30 minutes for the pizza. At 9:50 we received our pizza, cold. Without the ranch we ordered and were charged for. The driver took the ranch off the order, but the girl on the phone... She was rude and unprofessional. She would tell us to hold and scoff for a couple seconds then ask what we needed. It's a Monday night, we understand it's busy, but completely uncalled for. Pizza isn't even that good. read more

To be completely honest, I ordered from them by accident! But it was so good, I ordered from them again. Usually when you order from a pizza joint you get the pizza, I was in the mood for burgers and believe me when I say I was pleasantly surprised. Try the double cheeseburger with bacon! Really good! read more

I thoroughly enjoyed their cheese steak wrap. Loaded with tender steak. The pizza slice I tried was good as well.

1.5 hrs for delivery, probably because I pre-tipped $8 on my card which was a mistake, anyway.... Food tasted like some kind of makeshift pennsyltucky Italian restaurant, very poor by comparison to others in the area but I'm sure it'd taste great if you were into incest in the middle of the country somewhere. Late night spot what can you expect I guess? F me. read more

Quick delivery but very, very mediocre food. I've had pizza from here and it was pretty soggy and thin. I recently decided to give this place another chance and grabbed a buffalo chicken sandwich- big mistake. I just wanted chicken, buffalo sauce and the blue cheese. Somehow wound up with onions, which ruined the entire sandwich. Skip this place, you won't miss anything. read more

If i could give this restaurant a lower rating i would. Ordered online and waited an hour and a half for my order. Called and asked whats going on, they said they didnt have the order in the system. The girl on the phone kept saying they dont have a ticket for it and wouldn't do anything about it other than saying put in another order. Asked to speak to manager she said he wasn't there. Awful customer service. Seemed like she just wanted to get me off the phone. Said she couldnt do anything and that was it. She couldn't even cancel the order. read more

i live in town and was out with my husband for dinner - i used door dash to order kids and babysitter pizza quick and paid ths extra fees to do this quick and efficiently using door dash. delivery guy called saying he couldn't see the house numbers- and i described the house. he said he found it but we never got the food. 2 hours later kids still waiting for dinner. when i called they told me it was my fault. not cool guys read more

After a long day, my husband and I ordered a pizza and garlic knots around 9 pm. Received it 37 minutes later, so delivery time wasn't bad at all. During my call I specified I'd be paying with cash. I also received a call from the person I assume was delivering the food asking if I was paying cash or credit. I confirmed it would be cash. The delivery person arrived and had zero change (I don't think this is his fault). We were paying with a $50 bill for a $25 meal, also figure tip would have been added to that. I called the restaurant to see where the confusion was. They said "the driver just came in" which I'm not entirely sure how that answered my question of I said I was paying in cash, what happened. They said he could leave the food and then come back with change, which seemed a little insane for them to come back some time after 10 pm. I just paid with my card anyway, which was a little frustrating for me since I specified twice I'd be paying with cash. Foodwise: The pizza was good. Garlic knots were ok. read more

This is a great pizzeria! They always deliver on time and the food is high quality! I would highly recommend.

Very friendly staff and great food! Their buffalo pizza is out of this world as well as their buffalo chicken wraps! Also try the grilled chicken mozzarella wrap, you won't regret it and the prices aren't bad either! read more

There is a reason this place has low reviews. I ordered delivery and that was a bright spot for this business, the gentleman was friendly and timely. Now for the poor marks. I ordered a Caesar salad that came with no dressing and dried out chicken. The pizza was ok but tasted bland compared to area standards. The worst was the tasteless alfredo that came. This was a New Year's Day choice because all the other area delivery businesses were closed. Wish I had ordered Chinese read more

The food here is awesome..can't beat 5 mussels. For $4.50...everyone is nice glad I love next door now and it's open til 3am can't go wrong..the pizza is too notch, the chicken sandwich with roasted peppers and fresh miss is BANGIN...PROMISE U..,YOU CANT GO WRONG read more

Pizza came hot and seasoned perfectly. The calzone was great with plenty of dipping sauce.

Hands down the best pizza ever! Great service, friendly staff and fast! I drive all the way from Clifton to grab a pie or sub, they're that good. read more

The pizza was yummy for sure! However the place could use a real good cleaning. The counter area is sloppy and unclean. Staff was nice.

Been going to Lyndhurst Pizza for a long time!!! Definitely the best pizza in town!!!!

Worst customer service ever. We accidentally ordered from this restaurant and when we called to cancel they talked to us like we were stupid and didn't understand English. Idiots. If I can give zero stars I would. Then they threatened to call the police on us and asked if we were housekeeping (probably due to their preconceived notions of us having accents). After the one guy hung up on us and we called back he used the excuse that it wasn't him on the phone and he just started the shift. This type ignorance is unacceptable. read more

Ordered from here at 1:30 am last night. Can't believe the food was so fresh and good when it came at around 2am. We ordered off the Yelp Eat 24 app and were not disappointed. I would recommend the cheesesteak with peppers and onions and also the meatballs. Other places should definitely try and step their games up and stay open later. It was so convenient to order off the app and I was relieved to see that we could still get food at 2am without a problem. Also, it was delicious! read more

Seriously, try this pizza!!! We always ask for it to be extra thin and crispy!!! I am sure the thin and crispy pizza is the best in Lyndhurst. If you doubt it give it a try!!! You won't be disappointed!! read more

We were staying in a local hotel for a softball tournament and the front desk recommended Lyndhurst Pizza. We ordered a large pie with sausage and some fettuccine Alfredo. Yum, yum, and more yum! Everything arrived piping hot and within the time they quoted. I have eaten A LOT of Alfredo sauces in my 47 years, and this is definitely in my top 5. The sausage on the pizza was nice large slices and very tasty. I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Pizza is always cold when they deliver and they are VERY RUDE. I was rushed off of the phone when trying to place my order and then overcharged at delivery. They claimed that they changed their pricing yet i got a new menu from them just days prior. The best part is that they even forgot the pizza at delivery!!! how do you forget to deliver the pizza? They had a special for knots, pizza, and wings so i only received half my order at delivery and then was overcharged by $10 (due to "menu price changes"). This is the 3rd time I have had an issue with them and will NEVER order from them again. Bruno's or Foshini's is more money but well worth it from now on. read more

Best pizza in town and great family owned business. They have a large menu unlike some of the other pizzerias in the area and the portions are nice and big there's always more left for leftovers read more

Worst pizza I have ever had. Never again. Delivery took 80+ minutes and pizza arrived lukewarm.

I ordered a steak pizza, it was out of this world..... So good ...... I usually eat a whole pie but this pie was loaded I could only eat two slices of it and two hours later I ate another slice. The next day I ate two more slices and gave the rest to my neighbor he loved it also.... This was the first time ordering from them it was great.. I am ordering something again tonight I hope it is good as last time....Keep up the good job guys!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Walked in and got a freshly made large pizza within 15 minutes. The cook even asked me how I wanted it specifically. It tastes amazing. He made the Sh*t out of my pizza haha read more

Waited over an hour on a Wednesday night for a plain pizza that was burnt and cold!? Will never order from here again.

Excelent pizza. Very impressed by the flavor and delivery speed. A great surprise, no more dominos.

We ordered pizza from here last night, and even with it being a holiday, we received very friendly customer service, and fast delivery. The food turned out to be delicious too. Will definitely order from here again! read more

They make the best grilled chicken sandwich! Their cheesesteak and pizza are pretty awesome too. Definitely try them all.

I usually only eat here when nothing else is open or available and I regret it each time. Nearly every time I have something delivered from here they get my order wrong. The first time it happened, the delivery guy took it back and brought me another one so it took over 2 hours for me to finally get my food. The 2nd and 3rd times it happened, I called and the woman said she'd give me a pizza on the house the next time I ordered there-- then the next time I ordered there and asked for my pizza on the house they acted like I was making it up and I still had to pay so I stopped going altogether. Then last night came. Last night I ordered a cheese pizza (plain) and when I arrived it had pepperoni on it (I don't eat pork). It was too late to send it back because it arrived after 1 AM and they close at 2 AM. I just don't understand why it's so difficult for these people to simply pay attention to what they're doing and get an order correct. They're not even tough orders... Just a cheese pizza! And if that weren't enough, the pizza arrived cold and hard!! So last night I (again) got a COLD, HARD, WRONG ORDER and paid for it! Maybe they're doing it on purpose, I don't know, but I'm going back to never eating here again. I'd rather not eat than to give my money to this place again. read more

Absolutely dissatisfied with the service tonight, 03-20-17. The driver had to call me to figure out where the delivery was going, which was new to me since we order quite frequently from here. Once he finally got here, he had no square to run a card, and when I tried running the card over the phone I was hung up on twice. Food is cold, parts of the order are missing, and took an hour and a half for a plain pie and 10 wings to be delivered. Never ordering from here again. read more

Not even one star ... disgusting ordered delivery took an hour pizza was so cold the cheese was congealed. When I called the guy on phone didn't let me finish said he'd send another one and hung up on me took over another hour for "warm" pie .. Wings and fries were also not edible fries were microwaved or something and the wings are so oily and stale read more

I believe this is the first time I have reviewed delivered food. At home I would just go get something, but we are not at home. It is late and I am unexpectedly sitting in a hotel room, our flight cancelled after being delayed for 5 hours. I should be writing a review for Jet Blue. But I digress. read more

Checked into my hotel and ordered around 12:30am,...delivered between the projected time grubhub gave. The food was hot, and tasted good unfortunately forgot the dessert! I Made the mistake of not checking the order initially so I didnt realize until 2am..am i really going to call them back out at that time? took away 3 stars because if your going to charge a delivery fee, i cant offer the benefit of the doubt..id expect the order to be on time and correct every time. read more

We ordered a pizza TONIGHT at 9:43 pm and told it would be delivered in 40-45 minutes. It is now 11:35 and still no pizza.. at 10:55 we called - said it was on way would be HERE w/in 15 minutes.. Now, I'm not sure how they do math here, and my college degree is just a degree. But if it is 11:35 and we called at 10:55 - That's more than 15 minutes.. He said the driver got in an accident and it will be here any minute. When i asked why in God's name didn't they call us so we could make other plans (we have 3 children WAITING to eat), he hung up on me.. When I call back - it rings and rings and goes to a mailbox. ."General Mailbox is Full." --- so, does this guy think I'm just going to be ok w/no pizza, no call and not feed our kids? WTH is wrong w/people? read more

Ordered again in the snow last night. Everything was great and on time!! Great pizza love the sauce. Also very good chicken Marsala.looking forwArd too our next pizza night so we can order again. My kids love the pizza read more

Food was never delivered. When I called the restaurant the guy hang up the phone. I called again and again he hang up. He was very rude. I'll never order from there again!! read more

So where do i start..... horrible customer sevice over phone. I called thr place didnt use grubhub. The person who took my order told me 40 min wait. And i order at 824pm I was fine with that. So im waiting at my hotel which is a 10 min drive. I cant pick it up cause have no car to get it.didnt want to wait for uber. Soo anyways... i just order a simple pep/cheese pizza and coke soda 21. Dollars and some change isnt bad. And this was my first meal of the day cause i was flying all day to travel. Soo i was really hungry!! So waiting in the lobby of hotel. I was talkin to front lobby person while i was waiting. And time flew by talkin to the person. And i check time and it was 920pm and still no pizza. The person in the front even asked if i got my food or a call bit noo nothing and finally at 945pm the delivery guy finally shows up. And first thing he say was like... "tip"?? Wtf!! Really!!! And hour past what an employee told me. Nooo!! Tip for you. And he was like"really why not" YOUR LATE DUDE!! I also deliever pizza on my other job." Is what i told him and that "it was not ok."no call or anything. And the pizza was cold sorta a lil warm but mostly cold. I was really not happy with this place at all!! Disappointed!!! read more

Always an extremely quick delivery. Food is always good. Great for late night orders.