Lyndsay was great to work with! She made our cake for our gender reveal and it was everything we asked for but even better than I imagined! I was shocked with the quality of the cake. Even the color for the gender was vibrant and I loved that she colored the actual cake and didn't just use colored icing on the inside. It made for great photos!! She was great to communicate with during the process, gave clear instructions once we picked it up and it all turned out great! I will update the review with photos once we reveal to our families but I just couldn't wait to give her a review! read more

My husband ordered my 40th birthday cake from Lyndsay and it was both beautiful and delicious! She was really easy to work with and the cake turned out even better than I imagined! I highly recommend her for your next special occasion :) read more

See all

Lyndsay is a true cake artist! I sent her a photo of a LEGO-themed cake I wanted to emulate for my son's 5th birthday, and she somehow managed to surpass the original. The decoration was actually more perfect for a 5-year-old than my example photo! Not only was the cake gorgeous, but it was also absolutely delicious. Lyndsay was a dream to work with--I loved that we could communicate via text, and she was always incredibly responsive. I've already passed her info along to a couple of moms from the party who loved the look and the taste. I would recommend her in a heartbeat. Thank you, Lyndsay! read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Cupcakes Near Me

Lyndsay was the best! Not only is she a master at her craft, but also super professional, organized and responsible. It's amazing how she works alone and is able to crank out so many beautiful cakes :D She follows local health regulations/ restrictions and has a special studio kitchen for her business. My 13-yr. old niece wanted a black "fancy" cake and Lyndsay delivered! :D She is quick to reply via txt and gives you feedback based upon your request. Her cake was delicious and it made such a lasting impression upon my niece. Thank you Lyndsay for making her feel so special and "fancy!" read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Birthday Cake - Cupcakes Near Me

We put in a last minute request for a 2 layer wedding cake and Lyndsay absolutely crushed it!! Not only does this cake look amazing, the cake looks like everything we asked for and every single one of our guest loved the taste and look! Lyndsay also responds very quickly whenever we contacted her via call and text. We definitely will be coming back to her for our cake needs for other special occasions! Thank you Lyndsay! read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Cupcakes Near Me

I would highly recommend choosing Lyndsay's Cakery! We provided her inspiration for 2 specialty birthday cakes & she executed them beautifully! Not only were her cakes decorated incredibly, they tasted delicious. We chose a marble chocolate/ vanilla for the Monster cake & confetti for the Mini mouse cake. I also noticed that she was timely with coordinating with the timeframe to order & picking up at car side, as she wanted to be sure that the cake was safely inside the car for a safe arrival. read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Mini mouse with confetti cake & buttercream icing - Cupcakes Near Me

See all

Had a 10/10 experience from start to finish. The cake was exactly what I had envisioned. As an out of town customer who was hosting special event I was nervous about things coming together; they were able to deliver directly to the location of a surprise birthday dinner I was hosting. When I say obsessed, the cake was so instagramable. On top of all of that Lyndsay was exceedingly kind and pleasant to deal with as well as efficient. Lastly, the cake was super moist and the strawberry whipped buttercream was the perfect texture. Cannot wait to use them again for the next time I'm here. read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Cupcakes Near Me

Amazing! Ordered my mom's 50th birthday cake from Lyndsay and was sooo happy! Communication was easy and fast and the cake looked beautiful and tasted even better. Totally recommend! read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Birthday cake! - Cupcakes Near Me

This place is awesome! Lyndsay makes the entire experience so easy and personalized. Having to order a cake in a different city than from where I live isn't always the best option but I loved working with Lyndsay. She reassured me in every way possible she would meet my expectations. The cake was going to be for my daughter's proposal party. That's also another plus, is my daughter is LGBTQ and Lyndsay was not judge-mental. She created a beautiful cake and it was exactly what we had discussed when I placed the order. And she also delivered it to me not once but twice because I had accidentally given her the wrong address! She was so kind! The cake was delicious! It was a huge part of the party turning out successfully and I really appreciate her service. I highly recommend her for your party or wedding cake! She is fabulous! read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Seeing the cake! - Cupcakes Near Me

See all

Stunning cake for a gender reveal! Super accommodating with quick responses. She was able to bake a delicious and gorgeously decorated cake within a week from first request! Very gracious to accommodate us on short notice. Pick up was fast and easy in University Heights. Remember to bring a cooler or freezer bag! We loved it! Thanks Lyndsay! read more

Such a perfect cake, and a good price!! I reached out to Lindsay via Instagram, sent her a few photos for inspiration, it was ready a few days later. Payment and pickup were a breeze! The cake was beautiful and delicious. Could not have asked for more. My new go-to cake maker. We'll see you again soon. Many thanks!! read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Birthday cake - Cupcakes Near Me

See all

Our gender reveal cake far exceeded our expectations! Lyndsay is responsive and professional, and so talented. Everyone at the party said how delicious it was and the entire cake was eaten! Most bakeries weren't open for pick up on Sundays, and Lyndsay was so accommodating. She has my business, and family's too, forever! read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Cupcakes Near Me

See all

Our custom cake was PERFECT! Birthday girl loved it, it tasted AMAZING! Lyndsay was so responsive and helpful and nice through the whole ordering process. Pricing was very fair & she delivered! Thank you, Lyndsay, for the amazing cake. We look forward to using you for desserts in the future and recommending you to friends and family, as well! read more

See all

I ordered a custom cake for my 21st birthday and it was amazing! Lyndsay was so easy to communicate with, and she was excited to bring my dream cake to life. In addition to the cake being absolutely beautiful, it was delicious too. I highly recommend Lyndsay's Cakery and can't wait to order again for my next event! read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Cupcakes Near Me

See all

Lyndsay made my daughter a beautiful and delicious birthday cake for her 13th birthday. My daughter wanted a vintage style cake with a Halloween theme. Not many bakeries know how to make a vintage cake, but Lyndsay pulled it off. Everyone at the party commented on how delicious the frosting was. Definitely coming back for future cakes! read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Cupcakes Near Me

See all

Lyndsay did an amazing job on my daughters bt21 cupcakes. It was a last minute order and she was great to communicate with. They were yummy as well. Thank you Lyndsay! read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Bt21 - Cupcakes Near Me

See all

This cake was simply amazing. Not only did the cake look great, but the flavor was top notch. The Ravenclaw cake was a cookies and cream chocolate cake, buttercream frosting with fondant accents - seriously packed with delicious flavor. Lyndsay was very communicative, and very easy to work with, making this cake ordering process very enjoyable. The price was very reasonable, and I'll definitely be a repeat customer. read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Ravenclaw cake - Cupcakes Near Me

Lyndsay is a gem of a human being. I contacted her less than a week before I inquired about a cake, even though her website states 1-2 weeks in advance. She was super nice about it and helped me out a lot. I've ordered a specialty cake before, but for this one, I didn't have much guidance or direction with it. She came up with these brilliant details after I just said my friend likes sprinkles and donuts. I was blown away by the creativity and beautiful cake. Seriously. My friends were even more impressed and excited, not just for the gender reveal, but also because they ridiculously love cake. They were so so so in love with the cake and thoroughly enjoyed it. They're still working on eating it each day and continue to tell me how good the cake tastes. Lyndsay is so brilliant, kind, and talented. I told her the day I picked up the cake that I'm going to keep going to her for cakes, even before I tried the cake, and I know I'm going to keep my word on that. read more

See all

I booked with Lyndsay on Instagram but had to cancel due to an emergency. She was kind enough to give me a refund as most business these days are very stringy about that so thanks again Lyndsay! Hope we can work together in the future. read more

This cake was simply sublime. The cake was beautifully decorated and the delicate attention to detail from Lindsay, the owner of this little gem of a bakery, will have me ordering cakes for all my special occasions. The taste of the cake surpassed my expectations and it equally matched the beautiful presentation of the cake. I received layers of rich and moist chocolate cake, with a raspberry cream filling, chocolate ganache, and the most delectable and perfectly sweet frosting I've ever had. Lindsay was a delight to work with and her cake is absolutely memorable. read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Impeccable and simplistic attention to detail. - Cupcakes Near Me

I reached out to Lyndsay via email to see if she would be able to make some cupcakes for a gender reveal and she got back to me so quickly. Not only was she able to make them she had a quick turn around time and was patient with us since we needed to drop off the envelope with information inside. I gave her a few ideas I liked and told her to have fun with them, I'm so glad I did! The cupcakes she came up with were absolutely perfect and she even brought them out in a Disney mask to go with our theme :-). The attention to detail and taste of the cupcakes are far superior to anything I've seen or tasted before. I'll definitely recommend her cupcakes to everyone! Thanks again Lyndsay. read more

See all

Omg this was the best cake ever! We were over the moon happy and excited for our gender reveal cake! It was absolutely delicious and such a sweet treat! We loved the decoration and how Lyndsay incorporated the little munchkin sign into our cake (we were keeping with a Dunkin donut theme). Seeing her work online, we knew it would be beautiful but it far exceeded our expectations and I highly recommend Lyndsay for any of your events! read more

See all

Lyndsay is incredibly talented! Our cake was absolutely perfect and exactly what we were looking for. It was also delicious. Her communication and planning was also impeccable. We can't wait for another excuse to work with Lyndsay again. read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - It's a boy! And it was so fun cutting into this cake. - Cupcakes Near Me

See all

Best chocolate cake ever. It was a piece of art. I can't wait for the next birthday.

Lyndsay was great. Requested a gluten free version of a cake she had previously done and she killed it. Constant communication to make sure everything was just right. Couldn't be happier. Get your cake from Lyndsay. read more

Thank you so much Lyndsay! The cake was perfect. From the decor to the theme to the taste. It was for my sons 3rd birthday and he truly was so pleased. My entire family said it was the tastiest and prettiest cake that they've seen. I've attached pics so you can see truly how awesome it was. She will be our go to cake lady from now on. P.s presentation and boxing was perfect! read more

See all

Cake was good for what I got BUT it looked nothing like what I ordered and certainly not worth the price. . That was disappointing. Roses and sprigs not edible. When you removed them not much else on the cake. Asked for not so sweet buttercream and she added chocolate on outside like a crumb coat. I don't like chocolate thus the reason I didn't ask for it but the party goers were ok with it. Wanted a fruity filling and had minimal strawberry slices Couldn't get fruit in every slice. read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Cake for baby shower - Cupcakes Near Me

SO HAPPY I went with Lyndsay's Cakery for my daughters birthday. From the moment we first connected everything was smooth and easy. We had a farm theme birthday part and as you can see by the pictures she nailed it! The cake was everything I envisioned and more! My daughter is obsessed with the color blue and she even above and beyond to add cute little blue bows to the cow and pig! TOO CUTE!! Aside from the cake being the cutest thing ever -- the taste was UNREAL! Everyone loved it! Can't thank you enough for making her day extra special. Would highly recommend! read more

See all

Words cannot describe how amazing my experience with Lyndsay was. The communication was thorough and concise. I needed a special cake and she was the one and only person who could bring it to life. I am a perfectionist and very picky and Lyndsay delivered exactly what i wanted. I couldn't be happier, the price is reasonable. Thank you so very much for making a birthday extra special this cake was not only beautiful it was delicious. This will not be my last time doing business with her again. read more

See all

I have left several voicemails and emails with no response. I wanted to special order a cake that you have to order weeks ahead, but no response whatsoever from the owner Lyndsay. I really admire her cakes and wanted to give her some business but I guess she doesn't need it or doesn't need new clients. I feel frustrated that I got no response at all. Now I only have a couple weeks left to find someone else that will return my calls and emails. I'm taking my business elsewhere. Not very professional considering the times we live in. read more

Lyndsay Bakery is amazing. Lyndsay is very nice and will definitely work with to help you get the cake you want. My mom's birthday cake came out very beautiful, the only thing I would say that was disappointing was the cake was dry, wasn't moist at all. The icing and decor was nice just cake it self wasn't. But overall I'm happy with everything. Thank you Lyndsay. read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Cupcakes Near Me

See all

I ordered a smash cake only a few days before for my son's 1st birthday portraits (Should have ordered it 2 weeks before - Thanks god, Lyndsay accepted the order) Cake was delivered on time (few minutes early) and Lyndsay was super nice and kind. Cake was far better than I expected!! Even the photographer asked me where I got this cake from. So glad my son's birthday portrait came out nicely with the cake!! Thank you so much Lyndsay! I will order again!! read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Cupcakes Near Me

See all

Lyndsay was so awesome not only did she do a fantastic job on our gender reveal cake, but she did so in a timely manner upon short notice. I highly recommend Lyndsay for any and all of you cake needs she will not disappoint and its so worth it !!!!! read more

I am so happy we found Lyndsay for my son's first birthday. She really exceeded our expectations. Not only was the cake absolutely adorable, but it was also delicious! The cake was a hit with everyone and I couldn't have been happier. I will 100% use Lyndsay again for any special occasions in the future. read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Zoo themed 1st birthday cake. - Cupcakes Near Me

I ordered a cake for my daughter to celebrate her 21st birthday. Lyndsay was wonderful. She helped me decide the cake flavor and decoration (chocolate & peanut butter). I was coming in from out of town and it was ready on time and absolutely beautiful. Our entire dinner party was very impressed. Thank you very much Lyndsay. You are truly gifted. read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Chocolate and peanut butter decorated in my daughter's favorite color. - Cupcakes Near Me

Lyndsay replied to my inquiry quickly and designed the cutest cake! Pick up was easy and the cake and boxed up perfectly so I didn't have to worry about transporting it. Would definitely recommend and will probably be ordering another cake from her sometime in the future! read more

Everything about this business is simply wonderful. I contacted Lyndsay less than a week out from my wife's 40th birthday, and not only was she was able to take the order and offer delivery, she was super flexible when I needed to change the delivery date/time. Now let's talk about this cake--it was simply stunning, and I kind of figured that because it looked so good it probably wouldn't taste very good--can't have both, right? I couldn't have been more wrong! It was hands-down the most delicious and decadent cake I've ever tasted. Because it's April 2020 and we couldn't have a celebration (and there was no way the two of us could've eaten the entire thing), we delivered slices to some close friends (at a safe distance) and every single one of them said the same thing. Can't wait to order another! Lyndsay will be getting all of our (and our friends') cake orders in the future! read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - 40th birthday cake on fire! - Cupcakes Near Me

Amazing cake mines was a sort of different unique request wasnt sure if it could be done but she killed it everyone loved it and the inside DID NOT dissapoint thank you! read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - Cake - Cupcakes Near Me

Beyond thrilled to have stumbled upon Lyndsay's Cakery! Lindsay is soooo sweet--a true pleasure to work with! Very responsive, CREATIVE AND TALENTED!! She definitely helped make my birthday extra SWEET with my dream designed 30th b'day cake and super cute and extra delicious gym cupcakes... everything was a hit!!! Thanks so so so much again! Recommend 1000% and spread the word to the numerous people who asked about your beautiful and tasty creations at the party! Great price, delivery, and came through for me in a time crunch! BEYOND grateful! Keep following your passion--you truly are a baking artist! Xoxoxo read more

Lyndsay’s Cakery - My beautiful 30th birthday cake!!! - Cupcakes Near Me

See all

Lyndsay is amazing. She is easy to work with and quick with her correspondences, which takes a lot away from the stress of planning an event. Her cake is beautiful and delicious! All my guests loved the flavor and design. I would definitely be ordering from her again for future parties. read more