Been coming here for a long time and realized no review from me yet. Great Sicilian - Italian local restaurant. Always a great meal and the service is very good. I always love the Branzino. The Antipasto Siciliano is always a favorite along with the Frittura Di Pesce. Always love it here . The place does get loud but that's always a great sign. It's also BYOB and there is street and lot parking. I recommend getting a reservation as well. read more

See all

So the 'Let's try something new' is becoming a 'go to'. The BYOB Italian restaurant is small, loud, and always crowded - channel not only the food from Italy. Started with the meat balls - the sauce is unreal. Calamari is still too salty for me but fresh and tasty. I had the carbonara this time and commented if the chef could add a little extra guanciale - he did not disappoint! We also had the pork chop with potatoes and peppers - very moist. Call early for a reservation. read more

See all

We came for a family holiday dinner where I found the food to be quite good but the service was mixed. We were promptly seated and the server brought out some great, homemade, warm bread. One of the better house-made breads I've had. We started off with a few appetizers, the seafood frito misto, the Sicilian mixed appetizer and a pear salad. All were quite good with the Antipasto Siciliano being everyone's favorite. I had a specially made pizza for dinner, which was not on the menu and found that to also be very tasty. The crust had a nice sourdough component and the pizza was not overly loaded with toppings. The main reason I did not give four stars was the staff was constantly clearing plates while other people at the table were still eating. It gave the entire meal a rushed experience. read more

5 stars across the board! BYOB Service was excellent. Our waitress was informative and gave great suggestions. The portion sizes of the appetizers and meals were huge! I asked for gluten free pasta after not seeing any on the menu and was told they had penne and it could be topped with any sauce they had. It was delicious too! I had grilled salmon as my meal and it came with salad and potatoes on the side. Everyone enjoyed their food. My friend raved about her pear salad. Only complaint at the table is that 'some' of the mussels were a bit cold. For the price we paid, we were 100% satisfied with our meals! read more

Made In Italy - Grilled salmon - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Totowa, New Jersey

See all

Food and service is great at this restaurant. One of my favorite restaurants in NJ. Byob. If you do not mind picking thru some bones, I highly recommend the whole branzino fish. read more

This place is definitely a must try. The food is authentic Italian. The staff is very attentive. You must make a reservation or you will not get in on a Saturday Dinner read more

See all

Excellent. Went there last night. Everything tasted great! Pasta was deliciouszHighly recommend.

The food was very good. Everything was fresh and delicious. The bread was so good. Baked perfectly! The service was wonderful. Our server thoroughly explained the many specials and details of the dishes perfectly. The inside was very cute. It was clean and vibrant. The decor was simple and well thought out. I loved the screen with different regions of Italy playing on it. read more

See all

Owner turned us away- party of two. The restaurant appeared to be empty but stated he was fully booked. He straight said go to another place. read more

Was delicious had pizza delicious crust! We had 2 different pasta dishes both great & cappuccino one of the best I ever had!! But service was by far excellent Marco the waiter so nice & his assistant Estaban was also great! Can't wait to go back for the delicious food & to see these young men again!! Thank you so much!!!!! This review was still in phone from a few years ago I'm not too good with any electronics. I went today and was Even Better service and Food!!! read more

Appetizers were phenomenal - we had stuffed artichokes, mussels, and pear salad - all unbelievably delicious, Main course of beef short ribs ragu, baccalaureate and onions, crab with pasta and shrimp, swordfish, pasta carbonara - everything excellent. Dessert - yummy Bomba, Nutella cream puff, lemon cello pudding, cannoli - yummy! A bit disappointed in crème brûlée with fruit. Service was impeccable read more

Wow! Such an amazing meal. I put together a surprise sprinkle for my cousin and from the reservation process to the end of the meal, everything was great. The staff and owners are extremely friendly and went above and beyond to learn all of our names and use our names when serving us. We chose to do one of their set menus and it was crazy how much came with that. It was family style for apps and first course and then a choice from 2 entrees and it also soft drinks and coffee. They let us bring decorations and a cake and put us in our own area of the restaurant. We will definitely be back, the food was incredible, most is made from scratch from their chef who is from Italy!!! read more

See all

Loved this new find! Food was great, staff pleasant and professional and the ambiance was just right! I recommend trying it!

OUTSTANDING is the word I would use! Perfection from start to finish ! We took my mom here for her birthday. I work down the street and heard amazing things which were all true! Service was amazing the waiter was friendly and really knew the menu and specials. He also set it up To sing my mom a happy birthday song. Five of us went and we ALL were pleased! So many great choices and amazing desserts. It is also a byob. I would suggest going early as it does get loud read more

Made In Italy - Salmon - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Totowa, New Jersey

See all

Food and service excellent!!! We were able to patio seating on a beautiful Father's Day with no reservations. We had pear salads out of this world and my husband said his eggplant was the best. Entrees were great!! We'll definitely be back in a hear beat!!! read more

Food is great but menu never changes. Also very noisy inside. The mussels and whole branzino are delicious

3 months ago, I went on my second trip to Italy and discovered the deliciousness that is guanciale (aka pork cheek)! I couldn't believe my tastebuds. In my book, it was better tasting than pancetta and rivaled bacon! Alas, not as common to find here in the U.S. Fast forward to today, I was feeling nostalgic and craving it badly. I was searching for a local and authentic Italian restaurant, and found this gem of a place less than 10 minutes away. Once I saw the menu, I immediately knew what I wanted, which was the carbonara! I felt like I was back in Rome They were generous with their portions of guanciale, which I enjoyed with every bite. It was truly satisfying! What made it a better experience was my waiter, who was kind, friendly, attentive, and made me feel so welcome. Which helped me get through a negative restaurant experience that I had just the day before. Seriously- fast and top-notch service done right! Thank you so much for healing my heart and brightening up my day read more

Made In Italy - Carbonara topped with guanciale - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Totowa, New Jersey

From picking our own seats, to friendly knowledgeable service to the fact that it's bring your own... And the food...tasty, fresh & delicious which is the icing on the cake. I had the rigatoni special with meat sauce and mushrooms. It was in a light cream sauce, nothing short of tasty and worth every penny. The fresh, soft bread that comes out first is also delicious & complementary. We were celebrating my girlfriend's birthday, so we both enjoyed cappuccinos, served hot and strong, just the way I like it. The cream puffs, you get a choice of pistachio, Nutella, or another one. Absolutely delicious and fresh. If it's a special occasion, they turn off all the lights and singing happy birthday, which is so sweet and thoughtful. I highly recommend! read more

Made In Italy - Menu - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Totowa, New Jersey

See all

I've been coming here for years and it is absolutely excellent. The food, the ambience and the service, I highly recommend anyone that wants authentic Italian food to come here. read more

Excellent restaurant and Food. BUT DO NOT COME!!!!! There is little parking and may have ti park on the street. Municipal parking signs are inadequate, sparse, and it is easy to park in a no parking area. I parked where there were 3 other cars parked and I never relized there was no parking on the side I parked. The sign was 200 yards away. The restaurant had no warning to this dilemma, which they should. Do not Come and have your wonderful food and evening ruined by a parking ticket. read more

Our lunch was delicious!I look forward to dining there again. I highly recommend the food.

The food was exceptional!! I had the best spaghetti carbonara ever. The pear salad was excellent. Service was warm and efficient. Definitely will go back many more times. read more

First: I am a fussy, never "5" star review sort. But, I had to! We worked with Frank to host a repast for our mom. We do not live in the area, so we did not know. But, we do know that NJ can have great Italian food-- you just have to know where. This place is so definitely it. The food, staff and service all get rave reviews. We had close to 60 people, with an unbelievably delicious 3 course meal. Staff is easy going, but on top of things. I grew up in NJ, and know that NJ can have great Italian. This place is definitely it. Frank was phenomenal and easy to work with. After a long morning, we couldn't have asked for a better place to be. And, my mom was 100% Italian heritage. I have to believe she was vicariously enjoying everything through us. Thanks to the staff. This review is the least I could do to convey my thanks and appreciation. read more

Great food great service like being at home for a homemade Italian meal. Traditional Italian. ​

Yummy, We loved the Grilled Octopus. It Is FIRE. If you have ever eaten fried squid or grilled squid, than you know what I am talking about. We had a party of 4 and they greeted and sat us down. Aww, the Octopus was delicious. Tender, juicy and not chewy or dried out. Our first time here. Love the vibe, and the service here by the wonderful folks that work here. As typical Italian style, food portions were huge. Nothing really overpriced. We were happy campers. Next time I come here, I want to try other foods I observed on their menu. read more

Thought the food was good. But I wasn't overly impressed. The service was great. I felt it was authentic Italian. But I wasn't completely blown away by it. The grilled octopus was good but not tender. Maybe a little overcooked. We also had a pasta dish with eggplant (not pictured) thought that was maybe the best thing we had. The desserts are store bought. Not homemade. The restaurant is small but it's cute. I liked the decor. I would maybe go back. Also it's a BYOB. read more

See all

Wonderful staff, great food! As usual, they never disappoint! Can't wait to come back for their music night on Monday! The sword fish was delicious! read more

Made In Italy - Sword Fish with fennel, tomatoes and potato salad. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Totowa, New Jersey

I don't have enough good things to say- first being that I love that they're open on Mondays because so many other good restaurants in Totowa aren't. Second, the food was authentic, flavorful, and well portioned. The service was great& love that it's a BYO. We will definitely be back sooner rather than later! read more

See all

Wowza this was a surprisingly fantastic meal. Really enjoyed the food and service was excellent. The only reason it didn't get another check, was intolerable noise which made it almost impossible to hear anyone at the table. However, an alternative would be to sit outside... Started with bruschetta which was fantastic and mussels, which were unbelievable I even asked for more bread, which I usually don't do and I almost could've picked up the whole bowl and drank the broth. Tons of garlic too, so beware werewolves. Magnificent... really good. Service was absolutely on point. Silverware replaced, plates replaced, attentive service. I really liked my Bolognese. Swordfish was an incredible plate and delicious. Everyone gave a high mark except for the high-level noise, but will definitely be back hopefully soon. read more

Made In Italy - Bolognese - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Totowa, New Jersey

See all

This Italian restaurant stands out as an authentic culinary experience, ranking among the finest establishments in the area if not the pinnacle of its kind. As an Italian, I was particularly impressed by the authenticity of its cuisine. I will definitely go back. It puts others so called Italian restaurant in the vicinity to shame. read more

Was my first time eating here for dinner with family after a flight. And got to say the food and dessert were amazing! The place was pretty quick to get a table just keep in mind because we had to wait they take a break around 4:00-5:00 PM so you will need to wait before getting a table. But overall I would recommend coming here for dinner with family or friends! read more

Now I know why my mother has been here three times! Service was great food was great! They had so many specials it's hard to choose! I went with the stuffed calamari and the pasta with a salmon and shrimp white sauce. Wife had the eggplant appetizer special along with one of the pasta specials with red pesto. The bread for the table is fresh! As in they pop a small loaf into the oven and in 15 min you've got a loaf fresh from the oven! The chef/grandmother came around to see how everyone was enjoying their food. It's all the little things that make a difference. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

Totowa's best kept secret! I've had this little bistro caffe on the radar for a few weeks. Came here for lunch today and I was not disappointed at all. The bread is made in house. Super soft and airy. I ordered their special of day and my sister ordered their Tano Panini. Their food is beyond fresh and extremely tasty. Best panini I've ever tasted! The bacon is not regular bacon. It's more like thin cut pancetta. Also, the grilled chicken is super tender and sliced thinly. Not chunky or dry at all. The pulpo was perfectly cooked, crispy and tender all at once. I am so excited to come back for dinner and become a regular. I have fallen in love. Their outdoor dining is definitely an added benefit too. read more

See all

Wow...Wow...Wow!! Made in Italy located in Totowa, NJ is just Amazing!! We had a surprise party for my Mom and Son who just absolutely loves this venue, the food and the entire staff who goes out of there way to make you feel like your in Italy with there hospitality is just incredible. If you've never been there please do so, the food and service is exceptional. FYI...it's a BYOB!! Thank you so much Maggie, Alessandro, Frank, and Joe. Gracie...Giuseppe and the one and only Mama for the amazing food they cooked. read more

See all

It was my first time trying to order food from Made In Italy and after putting my pick up order in they charged my card and within minutes I received a call saying my order was cancelled from Made In Italy. I called the restaurant and they would not take my order.....so I guess my first experience is my last experience there....stay away, the gentleman was also rude about it when I called read more

Everything was excellent. First time there but will be back. Small and cute byob Make reservations because it is a small place

What can I say but excellent food! It does not get any better as it was a tough decision between their fresh pasta or a panini but since I was there for lunch with my niece decided to go with the lighter fair. Incredibly delicious Tano panini and my niece enjoyed her gnocchi. She finished her entire plate and I am bringing half my Panini home with me it must have been the french fries which were over the top tasty that filled me up. Sadly I did not take a picture of their amazing desserts but I did bring one home with me for after dinner tonight. read more

Made In Italy - Tano panini (chicken) w fries, I took half of it home with me! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Totowa, New Jersey

sat outside and was immediately greeted with excellent service. fresh bread came straight out of the oven on to our table. Server recognized that we do not eat pork due to religious reasons and pointed out which dishes we should steer clear of. Their attitude and demeanor was beyond friendly. I had the Gnocchi, and my mother had the Ravioli. Both dishes were beyond my expectations. You can quite literally taste the freshness and flavor of the ingredients in each bite. This Bistro is truly a hidden gem and i will be visiting again! read more

The food here truly gave us the experience of Italy. From the bread - light and crusty - to the marinara sauce - seasoned perfectly - it made us want more. The service was impeccable - an entree that wasn't quite what we expected - we were assured it was no trouble to order something else - which was delicious. Maria was professional and so personable: easy to talk to and friendly Definitely would recommend this charming restaurant with its attentive staff! read more

Our first time at Made in Italy but it won't be our last. Everything was delicious and portions were amazing. Our waitress was terrific and had great suggestions when we couldn't decide. All around definitely a 10! read more