Their frozen Greek yogurt was a standout (5/5), with the perfect balance of creaminess and tang. We topped it with peanut butter (3/5) and raspberry compote (5/5). The compote was excellent--bright, flavorful, and reportedly homemade, which definitely shows. The peanut butter, while a great idea, could use some refinement. It was a bit too thin and slid right off the yogurt; a thicker consistency would make a big difference. A crunchy option would be even better. Pistachio butter also feels like a missed opportunity on the menu. That said, the fro-yo itself was exceptional--smooth, tart, and absolutely superior to most. The vibes could use some oomph but helps not having to wait in a line to get your fix. read more

To be honest I don't really like frozen yogurt and since I just got the tart yogurt it was just ok. But, I liked how they had unique toppings (like biscoff knafeh and turkish delights) and the yogurt was more like a vessel for my toppings. I would suggest that they get wider cups though because even with how carefully placed the toppings were, I saw a lot of people's toppings fall out just due to gravity. Another thing I kinda didn't like was how the size changes depending on how many toppings you want instead of how much froyo you want. It was kind of strange to me because I was forced to get a medium just cuz I wanted an extra topping but I didn't even want that much yogurt. I would come back though so that I could try their other yogurt flavors; they were out of their special flavors by the time I went in unfortunately. read more

Madison Fare - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great frozen yogurt! Unfortunately the day before they had closed due to the machine breaking down but then they said it would reopen 30 min later and after 45 min they ended up not reopening which was a bummer. But over all after finally trying it, it's worth the hype! read more

Madison Fare - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Went on a Saturday morning and there was a long line, but it moved pretty quickly. One thing to know before you get to the counter is that you need to have your full order figured out ahead of time. I originally wanted to try the Pistachio Royal, but they were out of some of the ingredients. So instead, I went with a medium with cookie butter and Turkish delight, which was good. You could tell the yogurt was high quality, although the price felt a bit steep for the portion size. Pretty disappointed that they were out of ingredients for one of their signature items. Considering how popular it is, I was surprised they didn't have everything on hand. Even so, what I ended up getting was delicious, and I'd still be interested in coming back to try the Pistachio Royal. read more

Madison Fare - Turkish delight and cookie butter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Waited 30 minutes on a Saturday night and were told they only had one flavor available. Nonetheless, we got the original with chocolate peanut sauce and pistachio kadaif. There is a cute basket of candies in the front which was sweet to enjoy as well. Yogurt itself was delicious and fresh! One of my favorites I've had in the city by far read more

See all

I have been trying to hit up all the new froyo spots in NYC and stopped by Madison Fare shortly after opening on a Tuesday. They were running late and opened around 12:15 but it was fun being the first customer. I got a medium since I wanted 2 toppings but found out the pistachio knafe is an extra $3. I was able to get 2 additional toppings since I got a medium size but I should have just gotten a small if I knew it would be extra anyway. For my additional toppings I got crushed pistachio and the raspberry jam. I enjoyed this combo with the tart yogurt. The yogurt is not too sweet which is my preference and pretty thick. Definitely thicker and richer than traditional soft serve yogurt spots and it rivals my favorite froyo in NYC. They add the pistachio knafe on the bottom of the cup which was nice for balance. I do like that there is plenty of knafe and the pistachio flavor is pretty strong. In total it came out to be $15 which to me is pretty steep for froyo even though it was large enough to share between 2 people for sure. I don't think I would necessarily choose Madison Fare over my fav Myka but it was definitely worth trying. read more

See all

I've made my fro-yo rounds this Spring before the summer influx. I've been to Mimi's & Gyro Project this is third in triad. Very cute shop with friendly counter person. There's three flavors here and an excellent topping variety. Ate: small apricot passion fruit with dark chocolate peanut topping. $8.66 The fro to was fruity though not as creamy as I prefer. The chocolate topper was a superstar and best I've tasted though I am a chocolate fanatic. Flavors change and that topping rocks! read more

See all

This is the second location of this frozen yogurt/froyo place, with the original one, of course, being on Madison near the Guggenheim. Speaking of location, this was the old tiny location of La Panineria, an excellent panini place which is now up the block. While they lack as many flavors as some other places, they have some fun toppings. I ordered the "Kid Size" as this is the solo one for $7.95 plus tax, which comes with one included topping. In terms of froyo flavor and texture, it was definitely thicker than the popular Mimi's and more tart, which I prefer. My topping was the matcha crumble, which was very tasty with a mild bitterness from the matcha, a bit of sweetness, and a light crunch. My only complaint is that maybe I wish the cup was a bit larger, as some of it fell out, but they gave plenty of said topping. I slightly prefer Culture down the block as it's a bit more sour and a bit more worth it, but I would go back and try their Pistachio Kadayif specialty topping next time I am in the area or something else. read more

Madison Fare - Kid size with matcha crumble. Very tasty topping. Froyo was thick and pretty sour - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

This place is a little pricy, but you can immediately tell that their frozen yogurt is top-notch. The friendly man at the counter told us that he made the yogurt this morning, and the toppings were so indulgent and delicious. The place was also very clean and pretty. I got the raspberry flavor with the dark chocolate brownie topping, which tasted just like brownie batter with bits of crunch. I hadn't had anything like it before! My friend got the vanilla flavor with berry compote, which also had a vanilla and cinnamon taste. So, so good! read more

Madison Fare - Raspberry with dark chocolate brownie topping and vanilla with berry compote - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Prices are a bit steep, but the yogurt is soooo good! Refreshingly bright and tart, with a really interesting assortment of toppings! Whether you're in the mood for something fruity, chocolate-y, nutty, caramelly, or anything else, they'll probably have something that'll satisfy you. A kids' size with one topping will run you about $8. Staff are really friendly and they have rotating specials as well as rotating flavored froyo -- they had mango and banana "sorbets" when I went this weekend. No real indoor seating besides a single bench inside, so be ready to be stand outside to enjoy, it's not really a sit-and-linger situation. read more

Madison Fare - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

This is the best original froyo I've had. It was super creamy and smooth, and we topped ours with chocolate and pistachios. The only downsides are the potential wait and how small the portions are, but in terms of quality, this is very good! read more

Madison Fare - Original - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

This popular froyo spot in the UES has finally opened its West Village location and I'm so glad I got to try it! It's a fairly small shop inside, with grab-and-go style desserts, and service was good. I got their classic froyo with pistachio kanafeh (extra $2.50), strawberries, and honey. Although it was good, I wish it was a bit more tart and did think that it was expensive for what it was (~$14 with taxes). read more

Madison Fare - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

The yogurt is pretty good - just a tad bit more tart than I would've preferred, but still good. I would have liked more fresh toppings like fruits and berries. read more

Madison Fare - Original with pistachios and yogurt chips - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Wanted to try the Dubai chocolate yogurt today but they don't have pistachio knafeh today so I tried the Dark Chocolate Cream with Peanuts & Pistachios ... tasted pretty good .. will come back again try the Dubai chocolate yogurt read more

See all

definitely a 5-star spot for me. The yogurt was creamy, refreshing, and not overly sweet, exactly how Greek frozen yogurt should be. The employee working was so kind and helpful, which made the experience even better. I highly recommend getting the knafeh topping! it adds the perfect texture and flavor. I'll definitely be going back! read more

See all

Delicious ! Love this place , so much creamier and better more interesting toppings than Culture down the block which is over hyped in my opinion. Forget about that place , come here instead. Much better . read more

Delicious. love the dubai topping but they could definitely be less stingy with the toppings, especially the premium ones that float $2 more. $13 for froyo is crazy but it is super yummy read more

Madison Fare - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped by Madison Fare late at night -- some toppings were gone, but the fro-yo was great. The warm chocolate drizzle was delicious, hardening into a perfect crunchy shell. Will come back again to try other toppings! read more

See all

So delish and has gluten free toppings. The original is kinda of classic sour yogurt taste but with the toppings it was great. The fruit syrups are super fresh so def recommend trying those. They're pretty stacked up too. No hollow center. read more

Madison Fare - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

I absolutely love love love this spot. Out of all the froyo spots i've gone to this one has the best toppings hand down. The portion size is also great, I always get one to share and the prices are reasonable. Pistachio and Biscoff Kanafeh are definitely their best toppings. Everytime I visit it's always Illyana working, nice blonde lady, she's the best!! Service is always top tier and she's the sweetest. Not only does their froyo and quality toppings keep me going but how friendly their staff is, especially illyana. Never bad service. read more

Good ice cream terrible service. Amin was so rude, yelled at us and told us we needed to know what we order or dont come up. Berated the guy in front of us and told us not to be like him. Plus added a rule where you cannot add toppings to small ice cream. Its such a shame I loved this place but I can't go back to somewhere I am scared to order at. read more

Madison Fare - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

If I could leave zero stars I would, and I never leave bad reviews. The worker Amin was very rude to me and my cousins. He was irritated right from the start and shouted at the entire place "if you don't know what you want by the time you get up here I am not serving you". He kept telling us he didn't know how to add extra toppings. I feel awful for the poor girl he was training. He was yelling at her in front of everyone. Horrible experience it honestly makes me never want to come back here. Sad because my cousins have had good experiences here previously with different workers. Then we were sitting outside eating our yogurt and he started yelling at us from inside the store. He also told multiple women to stand outside in the cold to wait to be served when there were only like 3 people inside. But yeah my advice would be to fire this guy he is going to chase away all business. read more

Madison Fare - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Incredible. So addicted to this frozen yogurt I literally travel into the city from Queens for it. Its the perfect texture/flavor and the toppings are the best you'll find at any of the frozen yogurt shops. It has the other spots beat by leagues. read more

Great yogurt but the server Amin was beyond rude. Truly unprofessional and horrible service!

Madison Fair Frozen Yogurt was honestly such a strange and uncomfortable experience. The whole vibe felt off from the start. The workers seemed visibly annoyed when we asked for more than one topping, like it was a huge inconvenience, and even scoffed when we asked for a lid. It just felt really unwelcoming and awkward the entire time. Definitely not the kind of place you want to hang out and enjoy a treat. read more