We drive out of our way for these bagels. Worth the trip! They have such a nice crust and soft middle. Love the egg everything and the sesame. The cream cheeses were fresh and tasty. Make the trip you won't be disappointed! read more

Nope... from 5-stars to 1! I can't take the difficulty in ordering the same damn thing, and EVERY single time either of the two girls behind the counter say, "...with cheese, right?" I NEVER say with cheese, EVER! I just don't understand for the life of me how 'every' breakfast or lunch order, when read back, is always WRONG... every single #$%?@! time! Just too frustrating to go in here first thing in the morning. A bagel with an egg & bacon should not cost $6.28! read more

Small storefront with laminated menu up at the counter. Basic items overall, but had your typical bagel cafe offerings. Bagels were tasty and thick. Prices were average. They were quick to turnaround my 3 sandwiches as well. Would buy more bagels there in the future. read more

Mama’s Bagels - Sausage, egg and cheese with hash brown on a salt bagel - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Milford, Connecticut

Bagels are delicious. Limited variety. Got a bacon, egg and cheese on an everything bagel and 6 bagels to bring home $16. The reason for 3 stars: 1. They don't post pricing anywhere. 2. There was only 1 small table to sit (they have 2 small tables outside but it was raining). 3. They don't ask for your name when you order something. My daughter purchased a sandwich and received the wrong one. She went back to return it. She misheard what the woman said because it was loud and she has an accent. Luckily, the correct recipient of the sandwich took it, trusting my daughter didn't touch it, because the girl working there gave us such attitude. I don't think she would have replaced it. read more

Stopped for a quick lunch. Tiny place with one little table. Looks like you can sit outside in nicer weather. We had a Tuna & a chicken salad on an everything bagels! Yummmmmm. Will definitely go back! The Asiago & French toast bagels looked amazing. A menu board with prices would be a welcome addition. The laminated pages with pics of items was not too user friendly. read more

Mama’s Bagels - Tuna, LTO on everything bagel - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Milford, Connecticut

Ever since Bagel Barn closed a while back, New Milford has been lacking a great grab-and-go breakfast spot on the main drag. After a while, Mama's finally opened up in the Staples plaza. When you walk in, you'll notice that they don't have a menu. You see the bagels and the cold salads, and coffee and espresso machines, but you have to guess at what they have -- and how much it will cost. Fortunately, they have all the typical breakfast items at what turned out to be reasonable prices. I didn't know they had eggs or bacon, so I ordered their egg everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. I don't typically like carb-filled breakfasts, but Mama's is changing my mind fast. Egg Everything might be my new favorite bagel, and the scallion cream cheese complemented it perfectly. Someone I was with ordered a turkey sandwich on a bagel, and the filling was so generous that she's saving the other half for lunch. (I couldn't get a bite.) We dined in. They have only one table, next to the cold salad case, so we spent our time staring at their lunch options. If we hadn't filled up on bagels, the Greek salad and spinach orzo salads look wonderful. read more

Mama’s Bagels - Egg Everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Milford, Connecticut

Wow, pizza and Thanksgiving, catering service Honestly, my wife can order their turkey and do her special dishes what a time saver above and beyond a bagel place with good bagels read more

Mama’s Bagels - To my surprise, they have pizza Sicilian style. Very tasty. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Milford, Connecticut

See all

Egg and Asiago bagels are to die for!! Closest thing to a NY bagel I have found yet in CT! Highly recommend!

Mamas bagels - approaching the best bagels in New Milford. Variety of food available; some Spanish dishes, too!

Stopped in early one morning, was a little disappointed there were no signs/pricing and not a lot of cream cheese options. I spoke with the woman behind the counter and she said they had not had their official grand opening yet, so they were still a work in progress. The space is clean but very small, but they are doing the best they can with their equipment and counter spaces. The bagels themselves were very good and I can't wait until they have more cream cheese flavors! The staff/family were great, I wish them much success!! read more

Food is delicious and made well. A little on the pricier side, however, the service is great! Their fruit is usually not ripe (especially mango) so I would avoid, but everything else is a 10/10. Most of the workers are very sweet with the exception of one lady, but for the quality of food you receive, it doesn't matter that much lol! Definitely check them out!! read more

The customer service on the several occasions I stopped by was terrible. Could have been that it was early morning and that she was by herself at the front. The bagels however are excellent. read more

Excellent bagels at an affordable price, great service. I go there after working out next door at Planet Fitness. You can not go wrong.

FOOD IS SO SO GOOD! Super cheap and the mac and cheese balls + bacon egg and cheese are to die for. Actually the best BEC i've ever had.