I will say that I was a bit skeptical coming in - however, so glad I did. Got 2 cheese slices, and a spinach pinwheel- everything was great. I noticed that they also make tacos and decided to order one to give it a try and it was delicious! I ordered an el pastor taco-can't wait to come back to try different ones. read more

Ordered baked ziti with meatballs, garlic knots with sauce and a cannoli to try. Overall there is a lot of food, however sadly it's average at best. The garlic knots came without the sauce (ordered through grubhub) which wouldn't be a big deal if you weren't charged extra for the sauce. The baked ziti was ok but the sauce didn't have much flavor. It came with half a hero roll as the bread. The cannoli was packed ok but put in a bag sideways so the filling had started to come out. If you're looking for average Italian food at a pretty average price this is the place. I don't crave Italian often and this reminded me why. The delivery driver was an in-house driver and even had the nerve to ask for a tip. Given that I ordered through Grubhub and tips are added on to the order from them I found this offensive. read more

Mamma Gina's Pizzeria - Baked ziti with meatballs - Italian Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

First time visiting here , ordered 2 regular slices to go They heated up the slices for me which was fine Pizza was ok.... read more

See all

It has been always good pizza place at least for our family. But today, I was so surprised by how much the portion of everything reduced by at least 30% less!!! I understand everything price raised in this inflation but they should just raise price than reduce the amount of food. I am so so furious about this. Because My family is big in number. We will starve after tonights' dinner for sure. One time, maybe a half year ago my pizza did not have tomato sauce. But still went back to the place. Recently it takes like an hour to get take out....and Once it took one hour and half to get take out, we still gave a chance. I was loyal customer for over ten years. So sad but It's time for us to look for different pizza place. read more

See all

Found this spot on my lunch break one day when my stomach was screaming for a buffalo chicken slice! Of course I obeyed my belly and this pizza did not disappoint! It was really good! Chunky pieces of spicy chicken and a decent amount of cheese..not too spicy and the texture was perfect! It was So good that I recommended it to a co-worker who wanted to order 2 large pies for the office. He got 1 whole buffalo chicken pie and 1 pie with 1/2 sausage/pepperoni and 1/2 plain! They were all delicious! My coworkers loved it. The service here is good too! Way Above average pizza and good service, can't go wrong with that! read more

New ownership ruined this place. Pizza sauce is disgustingly sweet and inedible. Also why would i ever order tacos from a pizzeria?

Our pizza last night, chicken Marsala pie. Not bad but new management I'm sure they will catch on. Very wet pie read more

Mamma Gina's Pizzeria - Chicken Marsala Pie - Italian Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

So Tuesday night I placed an order for delivery. For myself I got the Tortellini Alla Panna, I ordered a Grilled Cesar Salad wrap for lunch the next day and a rice ball and some garlic knots for my sister. Before I ordered I called my husband who was out with our son and asked them if they wanted anything and they both said no they ate already. Just as the food was delivered my husband and son come home and I didn't get any further then opening it when they both said let me try that and the two of them not only tried it but loved it! They both went and got a bowl for me to share my tortellini dish with them. I mean come on it's a generous order but not for 3 adults!! Now they are sitting at the table eating and I get up to get some water, when I come back they are in the bag and had split my wrap (so now I had no lunch for the next day) and they got into the garlic knots my sister was trying to defend from them eating. GRRRR they were like savages!!! So needless to say the food was delicious! I ordered again tonight but this time I got enough for everyone so I can eat my own dinner in peace. My sister said next time she orders from there she's taking hers to go LOL Bravo Mama Gina's our compliments to the chef! read more

I called an order for pickup. I asked for a total and it took about 5 minutes to get a total. When I got there the food wasn't ready. I reminded the kid working of the drinks I was getting he still forgot to charge me so I had to go back again. I get home to a burnt pie. Not worth it not good. read more

Mamma Gina's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

During the quarantine, this neighborhood pizzeria came under new management and ... EVERYTHING improved. Maybe the former owners needed a break but I never felt like a "valued customer." All too often it seemed like I was bothering the guys behind the counter. The food was pretty good though so I kept coming back. WELL, this is now our third time ordering from the new owners and now we LOVE this place! The food is fresh, the portions are bigger and everyone behind the counter is friendly and appreciative!! Their Sicilian pie is thick, flavorful & BIG, the chicken roll is very tasty and their entrees always taste fresh. Mangia! read more

Birria tacos for the win. Best I've had, friendly staff! Go get some as soon as you can

I will say that if you don't want pizza then try their tacos. So effing good. Eat them when there; fresh and hot. It's so good. Had the shrimp quesadilla large and it was just so good read more

very very very bad service! do not go here gabriella & the manager do not have good customer service especially for delivery orders!!!!! the pizza is not worth the drive, walk or headache save your money! there are much better pizza resturants in the area!!! please beware what type of business owners comments under yelp post negative comments. just shows what type of owner & person you are sir. when exactly did i skip the line? when i placed my order online lol you were rude over the phone! you are getting me confused with someone else im not surprised im sure ppl get upset with you on a daily basis with that attitude. WHO THE HELL IS ASHLEY????? read more

Mamma Gina's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

I'm not sure about the rest of the food but the buffalo chicken pizza is a BANGER! I've had LOTS of buffalo slices in my life and I can honestly say this is the best one. The crust is crispy, the taste is amazing, they dont skimp out on the chicken for sure and the bottom is ALWAYS CRUNCHY to tie it all together.One slice is filling and the slices are pretty cheap. This place is nowhere near where I live and I make the trip all the time . read more

Mamma Gina's Pizzeria - THE BEST buffalo chicken pizza - Italian Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

Close to home and the new owners are friendly and the food delicious. I love the bbq chicken pizza as well as the ziti slices they have. And not they offer birria tacos and Mexican fare. Can't complain this place is a go to spot for pizza or tacos, perfect combo. read more

You can make all the complaints you want because i will be surely making my own .. worst place of business you are truly disgusting. That place you call a pizza shop is disgusting and department of health will be in contact with you as well..you work to please you customers i came over there because you called me a f*** idiot all because i asked for more sugar on the zeps. We paid ur delivery guy and rip on top of it and u couldn't even accommodate one of you loyal customers. DISGUSTINGGGGGGGGGG I WOULD NEVER EVER EVER TREAT MY CUSTOMER THAT WAY ESP SINCE I HAVE MY OWN CLIENT I DEAL WITH EVERY DAY AND THEY LOVE ME YOU THINK YOU CAN TALK TO PPL HOW EVER U WANT Noooo ur rude human being If i could give this place zero stars i would .The guy that took my order is so rude!!!!!!! I always ordered from them and brought business to this establishment but clearly they don't appreciate their loyal customers one i told them the pizza wasn't all the way cooked. Very very doughy . It just looked bad i never seen it like that before i figured they was just having an off day. 2. I told them there was no sugar on the Zeppoles and the guy told me he is not sending the delivery man back over for here that then he called me back to call me an idiot.. read more

This review is based solely on the grilled chicken and broccoli slice. It was fantastic and had some great flavor. I love pizza......I love grilled chicken......and I love broccoli, so it only makes sense that I would totally dig this slice. Had a hint of garlic flavor and it was drizzled with some olive oil. I would return just for another one of those bad boys! read more

I've ordered takeout for yrs from this place and I have to say the delivery service sucks they say 45mins and it turns out to be an hr in a half ,its happen several times and it unexceptalbel and I'm only 1/4 0f a mail apparently they don't care about a good paying customer. I've complain to the owner to no avail they don't care. read more

Average pizzeria. Food is blah. Taste and looks bland. They're delivery girl has a serious attitude problem Shouldn't have tipped her. read more

Mamma Gina's Pizzeria - Burnt and tasteless. Yum - Italian Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

Have been a returning customer for a little bit, I asked them to put my full tray of wings in a pizza box so that they stayed crispy by the time they were delivered but they were not able to accommodate even after I called requesting for them to be placed in a box. So I needed up with soggy wings. read more

See all

It was a cold rainy day and I didn't want to go out to pick up my pizza from my usual place. I also didn't want to talk to anyone on the phone considering the reviews I've seen. LOL Anyway, saw they have ordering available from yelp so I checked out their menu. Saw the garlic knot crust pizza in one of the photos and was super excited about it. I thought it was something unusual for Valley Stream and the pic looked amazing. What I got...was a little disappointing. I don't know if I got reheated pizza or not, but the pizza just didn't look like it was a fresh pie. Most fresh pies have the gooey cheese on top and is piping hot. This wasn't... The garlic knot crust tasted alright, but they were small and stale. It's ok...but I definitely wasn't impressed. read more

I only go here because my son like the pizza and their special is good. However the owner is nasty, rude and very disrespectful to his worker and even customers. I have no idea why he is still in business. I have witness on many occasions him screaming and cursing out his workers in front of customers. I always tell the workers they are better than him and should leave. read more

Not sure what is going on here but every time my business orders pizza here it comes as something else. Always a surprise. But not a good one. Don't know if they are trying to save $$ with cheap cheese and dough but you would think pizza is cheap enough to make why cut corners. Greed is such a turn off and a sure way to end business. We are OUT. read more

LOVE THESE GUYS! THOSE GARLIC-BBQ WINGS ARE A P R O B L E M ! ii work at a physical therapy office and order on my lunch break ALL the time and they may take a little while to come sometimes but it's well worth it. read more

Tried Mamma Gina's since they offer a gluten free pizza in addition to the first time purchase offer from seamless for 20% off your first order. I have only had one other gluten free pizza unfortunately the crust on this one did taste like cardboard I had the feeling that they don't make it there. The toppings were fresh and delicious I ended up taking them off the pizza and just eating that with the salad I ordered. It's always interesting how these pizza places all have a different take in anti-pasta salad. It was your typical salad. My son loved his pizza ate three slices till we discovered the other side was burnt. Unfortunately for a seven year old growing up on Long Island he was disappointed as he considers himself a pizza enthusiast. He had given two thumbs up till he found it. The delivery driver was extremely friendly and offered to bring it in for me since I answered the door holding a baby. I was really taken back by his thoughtful offer as most delivery drivers just hand you the food and leave. This is why I'm giving three stars we will give them another try just to see if the burnt pizza bottom was a fluke. read more

See all

Love their Sicilian pie. Good service. Good food in general. read more

Usually order from them all the time, I made a mistake with my Grubhub app and inputted a wrong phone number on the app, but on the delivery instructions the correct number was posted, after an hour I called and was told that the delivery man had rang the doorbell and knocked on the door, both of which were obvious lies, instead of an apology I was told to "order somewhere else" and then hung up on. Real unfortunate and just shows what kind of people work at that place. read more

I ordered the Baked Ziti Siciliana and it wasn't spectacular. The sauce tasted manufactured. I also ordered the Manicotti which was undercooked and the Ricotta had absolutely no flavor. Staff was very nice though. Damn shame since the food isn't great. It was a quick bite but I wouldn't recommend Mama Gina's and I won't be returning. read more

Mamma Gina's Pizzeria - Baked Manicotti - Italian Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

See all

I just don't understand how you serve pasta with any flavor or seasonings. For example, I ordered the baked stuffed shells. They were stuffed with ricotta - and very bland. There's no salt, pepper, parsley, oregano, not one HINT of spice. I don't understand why the food can't even be garnished. This place serves factory style pasta, nothing homemade about it. read more

Would not go there again. We ordered over the phone and the first sign should have been the "5 more minutes" after we'd been waiting in the resturant for at least 5 already. We had called at 7:10 and didn't leave until 8:00. Ordered the number 6 family feast- 2 medium pies (we got one 1/2 meatball 1/2 cheese and the other with sausage) each with 1 topping, 6 garlic knots and a medium soda. We also ordered an order of 6 wings. On their website the family feast is $23 and the wings are $6. Finally got the food and opened the box to check if it was correct. And I will tell you neither me or my parents have ever seen anything like this- the meatball pie literally just had whole mini meatballs on top. Not sliced or cut up at all. Just whole spherical meatballs. And when we actually ate it we could tell they were frozen/ store bought meatballs. When they rang us up to pay they told us "$43". We asked how that could be? And they said "you got toppings" they then looked back at the special and realized and said "$35" we asked "how" again and they told us because we got a soda and we told them again that the soda was apart of deal. They fixed that and told us "$31". Again we asked how and they said that the special was 25$ and the wings were 6$. After telling them that it said $23 on the website they said "no it's on our menu as $25. Whatever, we payed and left. When we got home and looked at the wings they had some sort of batter or breading on them even though we had asked on the phone before ordering if they were battered or breaded and they told us no. Garlic Knots don't have much flavor and the pizza was ok but not the Italian New York style pizza you'd expect from a place on Long Island. Would not recommend. read more

Mamma Gina's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

I'm giving two stars for the soup. It was decent and hot. Mama Gina used to be our go to takeout for Italian. They're going Steadily downhill the past few months!! New owners? Cooks? No clue,, but Every order lately is terrible. This last order will be my last. I'm done complaining and getting partial refunds for inedible food! And the portions are half what they used to be... can't eat the food anyway, so I guess it doesn't matter. But the prices isn't half so why cut down on portions? This last order of eggplant parmigiana with rigatoni was Just Awful! The pasta is So tasteless not even the sauce has taste and the eggplant literally tastes like they half fried it, left it to drain and then took the Cold pieces and covered them in tasteless sauce. Wth!! I tried heating it, but it's just disgusting. So disappointed. Send a complaint to Grubhub and get a big $6 back! Mama Gina just lost a Very Long time customer read more

Overpriced for tasteless food. Pizza was just okay. The garlic knots were tasteless burnt bread with no garlic!

Absolutely love this place . We order from here several times a month. The portions are good. The taste is consistent. Great for take out or delivery. Try them out. read more

I've been ordering pizza from mamma gina's since I moved to valley stream. They make GREAT pizza. Fast and courteous service for the most part. Sometimes the delivery is slow. read more

So I went for lunch with my girlfriend yesterday. Service: The service was great really, when we walked in they seemed really nice, respectful and we asked if they had pasta plates and the guy gave us the menu, we then ordered 2 pasta carbonara. The server brought us the food smiling and brought the utensils. They were also playing a funny moments tv program which was a nice way to eat while entertaining. Food: The food came really fast, we didn't have to wait so much, which is very important.The plate was huge! and they also brought bread, it was absolutely delicious, I posted a pic on Instagram and everyone wanted to know about the place! The prices are really good also. We're definitely going to come back! Thanks for your service. read more

Mamma Gina's Pizzeria - Pasta Carbonara - Italian Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

It went from bad to freaking awful....originally it was a good place to go, then the original owner sold the place...the next owner was rude as fuck, pizza was ok but service was crap because of the owners attitude, now not sure if even one Italian works in the place. pizza crust taste wood, dry tomato sauce and a sliver of cheese. Not worth the money. read more

I always saw great deals for this pace in my local paper so one day a few friends and I decided to try it out. Our coupon gave us a large pizza, 2 heroes, a large salad, and garlic knots. For around 25 bucks this is a good deal and the prices in general seemed to be very reasonable; however, the price only foreshadowed the meal that was to come. The pizza practically fell apart on us when we took it out of the box with the cheese running everywhere. The salty taste that went along with it didn't sweeten the deal. The salad was very bland and nearly flavorless with iceberg lettuce and a small portion of veggies. It may be stereotypical but it often seems that pizza places no matter how good they are, don't know how to prepare a proper salad, but that's a thought to ponder on some other time. Anyway, the garlic knots were nearly inedible and loaded with grease, but luckily the one small bright spot in this meal were the chicken parm heroes which were actually kind of decent, albeit a little too chewy. We were full after the meal but the feeling in our stomachs wasn't one of satisfaction. Oh and by the way, the store banner is CLEARLY a photo-shopped image and provided a good laugh to us, but it pretty much sums up the overall quality of Mama Gina's: mediocre presentation for mediocre food. read more

I ordered food for delivery at my job. It took over 1 1/2 hrs. And when it did come there were no utensils and napkins in the bag. I called them and was told they don't really give out utensils and napkins. So how was I supposed to eat soup and salad?????? Very unsatisfied. read more

Reading everyone one reviews was good but maybe tonight wasn't my night to order from mamma Gina. I order a grandma pie wasn't impressed got an over done crust, it was cut uneven, the sauce was way too much and it looks like it was just slap on, the cheese was way too little for the pie. read more

The food gets 4 stars. I've ordered pickup four times here. Once they were totally accurate. The last two times were the worst for accuracy. The food is good. My order is 3-4 entrees and something is always barely warm. And they do themselves no favors when the person answering the phone has never looked at the menu or maybe doesn't understand the menu. They are relaying, usually very poorly, your instructions to the chef who cooks very well and with good ingredients. read more