Grabbed some pizza and wings here and it was pretty much what you'd expect from a solid local spot. The food hit the mark--good flavor, hot and fresh. The pizza had a nice crust and the wings were cooked well, with decent sauce options. Service was okay--not bad, just kind of standard. Nothing stood out, but everything was ready in a reasonable time. Overall, a reliable place to satisfy a pizza and wing craving. Nothing fancy, but it gets the job done. read more

See all

I found a slong long hair in my fries and my pizza I like my cheese drippy and it tasted like dick there was hair in my pizza

Well I gave them another try even though I Never even got an apology about the steak Stromboli without steak. So the pizza was ok but the subs they don't put anything on the ends of their subs. So either end is just bread. read more

See all

A couple friends of mine just moved to Wrightsville last month, and I decided to bring them some food home, so I gave Marcello's a shot. Amazing service, decent prices, decent waiting times as well. Now my friends nephew keeps bugging him to take him here lol. Great Pizza spot, 10/10. read more

Basically one of the very few places open for dinner on a Monday night. Menu seemed okay and the website was functional. But definitely a disappointing take out experience. First, my order was complete and accurate, which was a good start. The pizza was just alright - crust wasn't too crispy and likely too many vegetables on it near the center, which made that part mushy and watery. But the biggest problem was the Mexican chicken salad, which was advertised as mixed greens (I got iceberg) and grilled chicken (I got clumps of deli meat). Just not quality ingredients I was expecting. Best thing I would recommend was the chicken Parm dinner, that was good. read more

Marcello's Pizza - This was their rendition of a Mexican salad. Not grilled chicken but a clump of lunch meat. - Italian Near Me - Wrightsville, Pennsylvania

Since my local mom and pop pizza place shut down Marcelo's is my 1st or 2nd pizza place to go to. Good crispy wings, the chicken fingers used to be banging but they changed them and they're horrible quality. But I can look past that cause the pizza wings fries sides are good. I like the cheese fries for my first side. Service is always quick, whoever working is tending to me is always nice and speedy. I appreciate that, I'll go to any location and the quality is almost all the same which is cool, you never really see that anymore read more

Out of the 4 pizza places in town this is my go to place. My order is always hot and ready for pickup when they say and they are a nice bunch of people who work there. read more

Great local spot for pizza and subs !!! The owners deliver the best customer service I've ever experienced in a pizza shop before. Quick to fix anything and always putting their customers first... they have even donated food items off menu to us when we had all our babies at different times ( toddler and twins over here ) .... Seriously, most generous and considerate owners you could experience. Have an issue ? Just ask for them ( monia & alessio) read more

Marcello's is under NEW ownership/management and the new owner was born and raised in Italy so the sauce is more authentic Italian than most pizza shops. He works there daily so you know there is pride of ownership! The interior is all freshly redone with new tables and booths and bright open feel. The slices looked delicious even at 2pm, normally a time when food isn't as fresh since it's less busy. I got the caprese pizza with fresh mozzarella, grape tomatoes and sautéed basil. Nice thin floppy slice with a tender crust and slight crunch. Wish I had ordered more! Will definitely be back to try the mango hab pizza, the shrimp and avocado sal and the yumminess that looked like an Italian grinder and a pizza crust had a baby. Plenty of parking, perfect for families. read more

Marcello's Pizza - Caprese slice, photo taken at an angle, slice was generously sized - Italian Near Me - Wrightsville, Pennsylvania

See all

Asked guy behind the counter how long slices were tjere looked loke all day he said I dont know just got here probablythese fast food places wonder why tjey are losing.businessyeah pizza sucked ueah barely warm and soggy! read more

The East York location is the one I visit. Service has always been good. Only ate inside once, interior is rather sterile. Usually do pick up. Always accurate. Their special is excellent loaded with toppings and at a good price. Also good cheese pizza. read more

If I could give it a minus rating, I would. The food was terrible. It wasn't hot at all. It tasted awful. Never eating there again.

Oh my where do I begin. First off not all of these are affiliated with each other. So don't judge them as a whole. I like the food at marcello's. The problem I am having is that every single time I place an order here. It's wrong. Well tonight is my last time. I ordered a stuffed pizza. I got a cheese pile on a slice of paper thin crust. There was no top crust! Which is what makes it a stuffed pizza. When calling this establishment back and asking them to describe this item. They proceeded to tell me it's crust on top and bottom. When I asked why mine had no top crust they told me they were afraid it would burn. So to sum up. They sell you a product for a price but make it however they feel is ok. I've ordered from here several times. Always disappointed with some major mistake on the order. read more

Marcello's Pizza - a cheese pizza in a box - Italian Near Me - Wrightsville, Pennsylvania

We had ordered pizza before here under the old owners not the best but the pizza we had tonight under new owners was very good! Will be trying sandwiches next time! read more

Tried out the pizza place for the first time. I called in an order for pickup. The person answering the phone didn't seem to know the computer system too well and it took some time to order a large plain, veggie and pepperoni - items that you would have thought easy to order. I forgot to order breadsticks so I called back. I was surprised to find that they cost $6 for an order of plain breadsticks, but maybe they would be spectacular or something. I was about 10 minutes late for pickup. My fault but the pizza boxes just didn't seem that hot when I got there. I asked for napkins and got pointed to the one at a time dispenser, kind of dumb when they could handed me a stack for 10 people. When i put the pizza in my truck there was a strange smell. It wasn't pizza, it turned out to be the pizza boxes. Kind of like wet socks. The pizza flavor was ok but all 3 of them had raw dough in the middle. Disappointing - hence the 2 stars. The breadsticks were a bit of a joke. An order of 6 dried out torpedoes of bread with a cup of sauce. Overpriced because the quality was so low. 2 orders cost more than a large cheese pizza! I'll pass on going there again. read more

The pepperoni pizza was supper yummy. Only thing that I wish was that they had shaker cheese on the tables.

The pizza is not cooked the whole way through..... hardly any meat on the subs!... breadsticks were a joke!,hard and dry!....even the Service sucks...I would not go back if you paid me read more

I found Marcello's Pizza very bland. The sauce was especially blah. Nice amount of cheese & toppings, tho.

Marcellos is very family friendly. The prices are fair and they have amazing coupons and deals. That's food is amazing, especially the pizza and hamburgers, but it's waiting time is decent, not bad, nor perfect, but half. The man who owns it is very generous and is very kind and respectful. I recommend this place for dinner since they have a wide variety of items to order. read more

My sister and I were out in the Columbia area and stopped at the first place we saw. This was it, and so glad we did! The food is fantastic! And the service was great! We will be back for sure. read more

Have been here many times for lunch and of all the places in town they are the best hands down. The folks working are pleasant and polite. The food was delicious. Pizza has great flavor, wings are alright, and sub sandwiches are fantastic. Overall a great place. read more

Typically, I like their food. Unfortunately, 2 out of the last 3 times we've ordered from there we've had unwanted items in our food (my son's food). The first time it was a red sticker - like an expiration date kind of sticker. Yesterday, we found staples (like 7 stuck together) in my son's side Caesar salad. I am so grateful we found it before he ate it! read more

Changed hands now called Giambancos thought that I would give it a second try Marcello's used to be ..just okay. Ordered an italian sub and sausage parmesan sub. Italian sub was light on the meat and parmesan sub was made up of little sausage pellets... Disgusting. read more

I like this place. It is right up the road from me and convenient. Great french fries and very good pizza. I had a California cheese steak on my last visit and I was happy with it. I would get it again for sure. The people working there are friendly and inviting. Worth a stop for sure! read more

This restaurant always always always messes up any order whether you place it online if you go into the restaurant or if you wait there they mess up every order! We ordered a stuffed crust pizza tonight well done when we got our delivery I handed a five dollar tip the delivery guy and said happy holidays he was super nice we open the stuff crust pizza and there's no crust on top the pizza isn't even done it's maybe just 1/8 of an inch The crust and the pizza itself is not done we ordered it well done there is no top on the pizza all it is is a big glob of cheese with a couple pepperonis I called back into Pizza Shoppe and before I said pick up or delivery I asked the girl who answered what exactly is your stuff crust pizza and she explained it as crust on the bottom crust on the top and all the goodies on the inside so then I proceed to tell her that we just placed an order we did not get a stuffed crust pizza but you already got our money you already got a five dollar tip for the delivery driver...And then the girl tried to give me an excuse as to why you asked her to be well done and we didn't want to burn the top of your stuff crust pizza then I asked for the manager and he tried to justify why there was any crust on the bottom read more

I am so glad that the restaurant is Marcello's again. Past negative reviews, most likely were for the short time that it was Giambanco Bros. Now that the restaurant is back in the right hands, the food is back to being great! The pizza is the best in the area, in my opinion. The wings are good, too. The staff is very friendly. read more

I was there, last night to pick up a take out order. I arrived just in time to see a young male plop my pizza on the floor from the oven. OOPs, we will have to make a new one. No free drink or anything was offered while I waited. I arrived at 5:20, finally at 6:00. I was on my way out the door, did I hear any sorry about your wait, or we took some money off for your patience??? OH NO. And then I arrived home with my pizza. The crust was burnt so black that the whole pizza tasted like charcoal.Even the toppings smelled and tasted burnt. So, I will never return, too many other good options. Service was not great and the food was even worse. I will drive farther, pay more , get good food and be much happier. read more

Love this pizza. They are not stingy with the toppings or cheese. Subs are good too. The manager is really great and friendly. They deliver where most places will not. Yummy food. read more