Customer service is seriously lacking. Wait time is ridiculous; if you're really hungry go elsewhere. Prices are NOT current on the menus, they're a few dollars higher. Calzones are not worth the money or the extra wait time. Pizza sauce is from a can and has zero personality. We should have read the reviews before we spent money here. Avoid this place if you value your time and money! read more

Most overpriced pizza ever!! Decided to call in a pizza on the way home. It was a small 3 topping pizza and when I got there it was almost $20.00!!! When I commented on how expensive it was for what it was their response was "well if you had ordered one of our regular and taken toppings off it would have been cheaper" How would you know this when calling an order in?? They didn't bother to tell me that and to top it off there were so few toppings on it you could count them, had no flavor and it was tepid at best. Won't be going back there and will stick with the usual pizza place in Sisters read more

We decided to stop here on our way to Sunriver to read the family. We just paid $64 for 2 large pizzas and 2 beers. We felt the pizza wasn't great we felt it was like it was like cafeteria pizza. The crust wasn't good at all no flavor to the crust. One pizza was a cheese pizza and I have had way better cheese pizza at Pizza Hit and would have cost $7.99 for a large. For he money we spent for 2 large pizzas we were expecting way better pizza. Sad to say our family will NOT be coming back. read more

Disappointed. No flavor. Little sauce and very little meat. And expensive. We were in Sisters for the 4th and were disappointed that Papa Andreas pizza was gone. This restaurant doesn't match up at all. read more

The Best Pizza in town -- Period.

MARTOLLI'S is absolutely the best pizza in Central Oregon. If you like thin crust pizza, this is the place to go. Don't waste your money anywhere else! They have great friendly service too. We eat here often and really enjoy every pizza we have tried. You can tell they use quality ingredients. They have great salads too. Definitely worth the drive to Sisters! read more

My husband and I drove through sisters on our way from Portland to bend and found this place. They were so nice and welcoming. The pizza we got was delicious! As we were eating our slices the manager even brought us over an extra slice on the house. Great place, we will be coming back on our next trip! read more

Great pizza and service. Took an entire girl's lacrosse team and everyone enjoyed the pizza and atmosphere. The pizzeria worked with me to order before hand. Excellent place. Highly recommended read more

The toppings were good but the crust was absolutely horrible! It was worse than a crappy microwave pizza to be honest. On top of that, it took about 45 minutes for them to cook our pizza! I'm amazed that this restaurant is rated so highly. This place will forever stand out in my mind as one of the worst restaurants I've ever been to. read more

Eaten here a bunch and when I order slices for a quick meal the pizza is always cold. It would be good if the spent a little more time warming their slices. I don't know if the workers just don't know what they are doing or don't care but if they would take a little more time it could be good. Until then I will be eating at the other pizza place in town. read more

If you want a really stiff over worked pizza crust this is the place to go I don't know what they are thinking maybe they should go to cooking school to learn how to cook and make pizza before owning a pizza place never again will I go. read more

My wife and I were traveling from Portland, OR to Sunriver, OR with our two children. We left Portland late and didn't get to Sisters until about 8:10. The kids love pizza so we pulled over and headed for the door. The "PIZZA" light was out but it did say "Open". We walked in and everyone there was ready to leave for the evening. There were two slices available and because of the late hour we thought that was going to do it. Instead we were encouraged to order a pizza, sit down and watch the Blazer game with the staff of Martolli's. Not only was the pizza unbelievably good (the Margherita pizza had delicious garlic slices!) but the warm reception and genuinely friendly staff really made this a "must stop" if you are in or near Sisters. We will stop EVERY time we pass Martolli's, everyone should do the same. Thank you Martolli's!! read more

Love the pizza and the place is very clean! Yummy! I looked them up and they received 100% on their health inspection. Nice

Good pizza but pretty spendy for what you get. I ordered a small white veggie and it was $12 for 4 slices. But overall it tasted great.

I gave it two out of five stars becuase the person that took our order was not very nice, the pizza took at least 20 minutes and the pizza was not very good, the dough was very hard. With the exception of that, it was good, the man that brought the pizza was very nice and it was a friendly environment. read more

Great pizza place with huge slices. Stop in and grab a slice or call in an order. If you can and like ask for the olive oil garlic on the pizza instead of regular tomato sauce. It's fantastic. The new family that runs it is great. Family friendly too. Martolli's salad is yummy, with the candied walnuts. read more

We recently bought a second home in Sister's, and we tried Martolli's based on the reviews. The pesto cini pizza is one of the best Pizza's I have ever eaten! Crust is fabulous, exceptional toppings meld together extremely well (pesto, grilled chicken, garlic and carmelized onions!...now we try and order a pizza for take out a couple of times a month! My husband has also had the Outlaw and it was really good too! read more

You'd be better off picking up the most freezer-burned, frozen pizza you can find at the grocery store up the street. It will certainly be less expensive. Sauce covered cardboard. The flavor is not existent. So disgusting. We ordered several different variations. All were inedible. I guess when you're the only gig in town, you can get away with murder. How do you screw up pizza THIS bad and that's all you make? Shame on your restaurant. Revolting and a rip off. read more

Great slices and salads. Great for a quick post mountain bike ride lunch. Offers GF personal pizzas as well.

I love this pizza! The crust has a good mouth feel and taste. The sauce has a tanginess and is generous. The toppings are fresh and plentiful. Each time I come in the staff are courteous and smiling, always nice to see. This business appears to be well run, and has improved significantly with the new ownership about two years ago. Whenever we come to Sisters we cannot help but stop and get a Martolli's pizza! read more

The best pie I've had since moving back west from NY! Thin, crispy crust. Sold by the slice...makes everyone happy.

As someone who has lived in New Jersey, these guys make a pretty great pie. I try not to order ahead when getting take out so I have a chance to grab a beer and BS with the guys working there - who are always fun to talk to. Best pizza in town and likely all of Central Oregon (though haven't tried all the places in Bend yet). read more

Great pizza, beer and service. Wish my dad didn't live on the outskirt's of Sisters, because I'd pay them extra if they'd deliver a pizza to McKenzie Canyon down the road to my dad :) read more

Well. It was slow as really really wet laundry drying in a tub of water. SLOW. I don't know about the pizza cuz we haven't cotton it yet. Hopefully this gets better. WAY BETTER. read more

Didn't know the recycle center served pizza. We placed an order for one pizza, two salads, and a calizone. Took well over 45 mintutes for just the pizza. We had to ask about our calizone to make sure it even made it out. $12.00 for a brick. The worst calizone we ever had. We talked with the chef to get our money back after he saw what it looked like. He replied with, "I've cooked harder ones than that and they loved it.." On another note, the soda was beyond flat. We asked to have it fixed but to no avail. The pizza displayed in the display case looked extremely unappetizing as it had been sitting for a very long time. Definitely will not be eating here again. If you plan on spending your hard earned money on good food, don't go here. Better off to buy a frozen pizza. read more

Pizza and service just fabulous! I appreciate specifically when I have ordered near closing and they've waited after hours for me to pick it up! That's customer service! It's not often you find a joint you can call near closing and not feel like a burden! Thank you Martolli's! read more

Highly recommended by several friends. Decided to make a point try it out this weekend and give it a chance. Glad we did!!!! Great little stop in the heart of Sisters, fantastic aroma filled the cozy, clean shop. Ordered a medium Rip City, two Martolli's salads, and a couple of Boneyards. Food arrived quickly despite being very busy. Great Pizza! I highly recommend Martolli's in Sisters. Pleasant helpful staff, great place to sit and people watch, fantastic food. read more