This is the best pizza in Central Oregon. Really. I love, love, love this pizza... and I'm one serious pizza critic. I have worked at all the major pizza joints (while I kid, but regardless I know what I'm talking about). You can eat anything at this place and be happy. I have tried most of the different pizzas here... and also the salad is good. You can also grab a beer or glass of wine here for a pretty good price. If you like pizza, this is a place that cannot be missed. YUM! Okay, I gotta go eat some pizza now... read more

We read the Yelp reviews and decided Martolli's of Sisters was going to our reward after a beautiful hike along the McKenzie River. We arrived at martolli's at 6:45 P.M., the sign on the door stated they were open until 8:00. As we walked through the door a woman employee said, "We are not taking anymore orders today." and ushered us out the door. As we were being guided to the door I proclaimed, " we just drove 75 miles to eat here. The woman said, "that's a shame." Unbelievable! This shop does not deserve anyone's business. Just close the doors and go home. read more

Best pizza place. We travel through Sister's a lot, and i really enjoy stopping here. Their pizza has the right mixture of sauce and i love the garlic read more

I haven't been to Martolli's for years and was very impressed with all the toppings and taste. Great pizza!

Love sisters and have had good experiences at Martolli's in the past. However, out of 3 orders with our party, 3 of them came out wrong - either missing something or just the wrong thing. They did work on fixing things as best they can, but it still was disappointing. We will be back at some point, but it felt like they were really struggling today. read more

This place has stepped up their game with a new manager. Toppings were generous when they used to be sparse. Customer service was great! And they offer delivery!!!! Can even leave at your doorstep for "contactless" pickup. read more

Was REALLY hoping this place would get better under new ownership. But instead, prices went up and the pizza tastes like cardboard and every time I call the girl is super snappy on the phone. read more

Great people, even better pizza. Perfect crust. Perfect crunch. Great sauce. Right amount of toppings.

Been stopping here every time we work in Bend over the last 3 years. This place used to be good. After our last couple of trips and yesterday we're done with this place. Our slices looked like the bastard child of MOD pizza...cracker thin with barely any tomato sauce. Disappointing! read more

What's not to love about Martolli's pizza? The slices are huge, the ingredients are fresh, and the pies are plenty. Priding themselves on maintaining recipes originally crafted in 2002, this eatery hand-preps their dough and sauces daily. They use slate ovens to cook the pies, meaning you'll always get a crispy and authentic taste. Having such a variety of ingredients also means that they get pretty crafty with some of the combinations - which is great for the vegetarians among us. Prices aren't that shabby either, which is nice. My experience has always been a positive one at Martolli's of Sisters. If you've got a hankering for a mouthwatering slice of goodness - check them out! 3.5/5 stars. read more

Martolli's - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

See all

This is my favorite pizza in town. I've been going here for as long as I can remember and enjoy this staple of the community. The staff is friendly and helpful, even during summer rushes and local events. The food is great, they do a good job of keeping slices of pizza stocked for when I just need to get a bite to eat. The menu has a pretty decent selection and their cheese bombs have become a must when I get food. read more

As a New Yorker, Martolli's has delivered the closest thing to a NY slice I've had yet in Oregon. The crust was crisp, the dough had a clean crackery taste, and they didn't drown it in sauce. Also, the pepperoni was in wide, thin slices that were perfectly embedded in the cheese, and while the sausage was in chunks (it's best finely crumbled) which I don't prefer, it also held into the crust without falling off. The staff are also friendly. The only reason I didn't give them five stars is because the slices are small for the price-- $3.50/slice, which is why I only got one. Perhaps that's the price they have to charge to over the cost of their obviously high-quality ingredients. I will definitely come back when I'm traveling through Sisters again. read more

Awesome customer service, and great pizza! I had a large order I needed to pick up to deliver to a job site at 11:00 am. I called and found out they open at 11:30. After talking to the lady I let her know my situation and she took my order and told me it would be done at 11:00am. The next day I show up, they come open the door for me and they were just finishing up my order! Awesome experience I never expected them to open up early for me to get it done but they did and had an awesome attitude about it! Thank you! read more

This is the most perfect pizza i've ever seen in my life. The placement of the tomato's, the perfect even slices, everything. With covid and everything going on they handle it very well and continue to deliver amazing service. Wonderful employees too!! Definitely recommend coming here and trying it out. read more

Used to be our go to pizza at the start of our central Oregon weekends. Disappointed in the quality the last few times! read more

Martolli's - Little light on the toppings. We didn't order "light toppings" nor the budget pizza. Disappointing!! - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

way overpriced and super super super low quality pizza that isn't good. I'm quite certain the only way they are able to continue to operate and stay in business is because of the continuous stream of unsuspecting tourists that flow through Sisters. Objectively I understand that sort of business model but the customer really receives little of value in return for their money, which makes the already bad taste in their mouth even worse. read more

Make sure you buy a slice of their pizza to taste before spending any amount of money here. Went in last night to buy pizza for our group, spent $90 bucks on 3 separate pies. Our entire group thought it was disgusting! Every. Single. One. Of. Us. If I hadn't seen the dough being thrown around behind the counter while ordering, I would of thought it these pizzas were pre-cooked and frozen. And the crust? What a joke. No flavor whatsoever. Tastes like the lunchable pizzas you give your kiddos to tide over their appetite. Do yourselves a favor and go to Rays and buy some Digorno pizzas before throwing away a small fortune at this place. read more

Extremely terrible service came in with my daughters and the lady accused them of touching the umbrellas outside when they were just sitting there talking to family on FaceTime.will not be coming here again read more

My husband and I stopped in here when passing through and really regret it. The girl working seemed less than pleased to have guests and just stared at us when we said we would like a few minutes to look over the menu which was extremely overpriced. We each ordered a slice and sat down. We were shocked when the girl behind the counter stuck each slice on a plate, and microwaved the pizza to warm it up. She then set it on the counter, told us our food was ready, and walked away. After that she completely ignored us. Not surprisingly, the pizza was really dry and tasted like cardboard. We didn't even get a "goodbye" when we bussed our own table (which is super tacky to ask of customers). We really regret wasting our money here. We really liked how cute the town was, but this experience really left a bad taste in our mouths. read more

I made a order. They took my information and then called back and said they couldn't fill it. Very rude and not even a apology. Now I have to wait for my credit card to be refunded. POS!!!!! read more

The people who work there are nice, but the pizza...not so much. We went here because of the rating (4 stars), plus we read some of the reviews that were really positive. You don't get a choice of crusts, pan, thin etc... They make it the way they make it, which is very thin, with very little flavor. The sauce was just ok. It is comparable to Little Caesars, in my opinion. They have a very small dining area, so if you don't like small spaces, I'd recommend ordering it to go. We were disappointed, and won't be back. If you're ever in Eugene, or Creswell, Roaring Rapids in Eugene and My Boys Pizza, in Creswell, serve much, better pizzas. read more

Came here for the vegan options. They have vegan cheese but that isn't clear on their website (had to call to confirm). We had a garden salad and vegan pizza with olives, tomatoes, artichoke hearts and onion and it was very tasty! We ordered pick-up and it was a smooth process. Kind staff. read more

By far the best pizza in Sisters. Perfectly seasoned crust, great sauce and generous toppings. Very friendly staff. Well done all around!

Stopped in for a slice this evening and was delighted with just their pepperoni pizza. At only $3.50 a slice I found the piece very comparable to in town (Bend) and the quality was better than I had anticipated. Will be coming back for sure. Cute lil pizza joint. More people picking up orders than eating in, very nice vibe. read more

Martolli's - Menu boards on the freezers! - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

See all

Gluten-free pizza crust was great, but they really skimped on the sauce and cheese, resulting in a very dry pizza. Also, the cheese was not sprinkled on top of the other toppings, so all the toppings, which had dried out in the oven because of so little sauce and cheese, fell off the pizza as soon as a bite was taken. :( Sad because for so little extra they could have made an excellent pizza. I just felt like they were skimping. read more

The ladies working here are so incredibly nice. I came in minutes after they were technically closed, trying to find some place that offered vegan food. They fired up their pizza oven and made me a delicious pizza. I can't thank them enough! read more

Great Pizza, lost one star for serving my veggie slice luke warm. (Pizza should be served hot)

i was highly impressed with the customer service and the quality of the food I've known dylan and his parents since i was a freshman in high school and I am proud to say that they are amazing awesome people and have absolutely amazing food one of the best pizzas I have ever had the cheese bombs were the BOMB. i will be coming back every chance I get. highly suggest trying read more

Hand Tossed pizza is cool. And watching the guys in the back spin that dough really raised my hopes of actually getting a decent calzone. But once again I am left wanting...will I ever find a true authentic, rich in flavor calzone as those I have had in the past back on the east coast. First of all, the menu stated that the calzones come standard with cheese, sauce, and ricotta as well as the choice of two toppings and additional charges for more toppings. My calzone had NO ricotta in it. And very very little of the toppings I paid extra for. It was nothing more than a pizza rolled up into a pie....not a calzone. The dough, while hand tossed, was not very flavorful at all. Just plain and bland. The food wasn't terrible, but it wasn't anything to write home about either. And the service was mediocre as well. Our food was brought to us outside....without any silverware...which we then had to get up and go inside to get. Really, guys and gals, a little bit of effort goes a long way with people. May I also suggest letting people pay at the end of their meal so they can tip for good service, instead of charging up front with the option to tip. I am not tipping for service I have yet to receive...and obviously, judging by this experience, would not have received anyway. BTW, it's funny how the people who work here are reviewing the place and calling it the best pizza. lol. Get out of Sister's kids and experience the world a little. read more

Got a couple slices on our way through Sisters as we headed toward Bend. Nice little place with a few beers on tap, 4 different pizzas to select slices from, salads, calzones etc. The pizza was really good and the staff was very friendly. We liked it so much on our way into Bend that we stopped here again on our way back. read more

We stopped in there the other night to grab a couple slices to go. The door was locked, but they were open and just ignored my kids at the door. When they did finally come to the door, they seemed very put out by having to get their slices. Very disappointing considering we always liked this place in the past. read more

Dis-Gus-Ting!! Do NOT take a chance on this dinner option. It is nothing short of gross. I was so bummed that a basic pizza could be so f***ed up. Sad excuse for a restaurant. If zero stars were an option, I'd be all over it. read more

This is my favorite pizza in town. Their large is perfect for our family of 5 and they have a great selection of specialized pizza to choose from, you can always change it up. The pizza and salads are super yummy we've never once had a problem when we come in. I love this I can go in at lunch and buy pizza by the slice (always 4 options) or for dinner a big ole pizza for the whole family. My personal favorite pizza is the Marchetti (garlic sauce, spinach, Italian sausage and candied walnuts) I know walnuts on a pizza, but somehow it works! They are not overly crunchy and like I said it all just goes together so well. Every time we bring family and friends there from out of town they are willing to try it and love it! Not a HUGE fan of the crust, but I like a fluffy crust and these aren't. Not enough for me to not eat there though obviously. read more

Better than most thin-crust pizza in New Jersey. Very crispy crunchy slice without being overcooked. Had a slice of margherita and was pleasantly surprised that the slices of garlic were roasted. Plenty of fresh basil, rich tomato sauce that wasnt sweet both pluses. The mozzarella was a little on the bland side so 4 stars. The place itself was spotless; the staff super nice. read more

Delicious pizza! We had the pepperoni, cheese and the meat combo. Great flat pizza. Even the pizza by the slice was nice and fresh!! It had a nice atmosphere and outdoor seating! They also have beer and wine! We will definitely be back!! read more

Martolli's - Meat combo! Has BBQ sauce, chicken, pineapples, jalapeños, onions and Canadian bacon! Yumbo! - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

Just had the BEST Pizza ever here in Sister's! The staff were amazing, resteraunt was clean and inviting and food amazing! Couldn't of chosen a better stop for dinner on my way through Sister's!!! read more

Love this place! The crust is fantastic, sourdough, just the right crispness. Sauce is tangy and they are not skimpy with it. They have plenty of topping options. The service is really fast. A truly excellent pizza and spot in Sisters! Thanks for being there! read more

Got our overpriced pizza last night like the rest of the sister-ites and realized the kalamata olives and pepperchinis we ordered on half were put on afterwards and were hard and cold and rest had melted ... we didn't want to be picky our family ate it anyway , bout 4 am we were all puking even my 11year old threw up olives!! Discusting place and we paid $30 for a medium !! Ugh never going here again read more

Great place for lunch. We did the lunch special and the yummy thin crust crispy pizza, the delicious salad and a drink were perfect! The young lady that waited on us was very friendly and energetic. Will certainly come back next time we're in Sisters! read more

I give this place a 4 star rating because my pizza was very delicious but my girlfriends didn't get there's till 10 minuets after my pizza so I waited for them so we could eat together and my pizza got cold fast! Overall I really liked it and would go again 8/10 recommend! read more