It's a tradition to go to Massey's Frozen Custard every time we visit Carlisle. It seems like there's always someone new working in there, but we had a great person helping us out. The shop is really needing a good paint job and cleaning at the order window, but it's still looks frozen in time like the 40's. We always order the Raspberry Custard, but the other custard flavors aren't as flavorful as they use to be. read more

Masseys Frozen Custard - Store front - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

Ice cream was good. One person had peanut butter and rollo flavors and one had cherry vanilla as a fresh peach sundae. The peaches were amazing. The cherries in the cherry vanilla were maraschino, not fresh, which was a little weird. The ladies behind the counter were friendly and efficient. The outdoor seating area was a nice touch. Plenty of parking. read more

Masseys Frozen Custard - Menu offerings - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

I got the purple cow and peanut butter cup sundae custards. Some of the best ice cream I've ever had! Service was also great as the girl at the counter was very helpful on deciding what to order. read more

It has been quite some time since I've been to Massey's but always remembered it being good. Took my kids here to celebrate the last day of school. The ice-cream was delicious, truly amazing. It soured my experience just a little when I found a hair in my strawberry sundae. Within a few minutes, my son found a hair in his root beer float. And then I could barely believe it, but my daughter then found a hair in her ice-cream cone. One hair, gross, but it happens. Two? Then Three? I don't know how that is even possible. Ruined the whole experience. Quite a shame since the ice-cream was so amazing, but I won't be spending anymore of my money here. Please wear hair nets when making your custard! Two stars because the ice-cream was good...until...it wasn't anymore. :( read more

Good I like their custard with the hard shell chocolate. But it's not made the same way each time so that's my only issue. Sometimes the whole thing has chocolate all over and sometimes the chocolate is only on the edges and none in the center. read more

This is a local favorite with a selection of custard desserts. I enjoy the Arctic Mount with Kit Kat candies, but there are soft serve and hand dipped options, cones, and dishes. New options I saw this visit include gluten-free cones and dairy free, but free, and vegan oat milk ice cream. read more

See all

Pls update your hours bc every time we come here maps and the website says they're open and the people working there say that they're closed or closing early. Just came there at 7:40 tonight and it was open til 10 according to maps hours and the people just said "we close early today" and made us leave. So pls update the hours bc this is like the 3rd time we've walked 20 minutes to get here and you're closed read more

Top ice cream critic in the Philly metro made the trek to Carlisle to see what all the hype was about this famous Massey soft serve. After ordering his typical kids size vanilla soft serve he found the closest picnic bench out back to test it on his palette. And the vote is in.... LOVE IT! Five star experience. Must come again. read more

See all

It's a good place food wise tasted a lot different but still good. that's not the problem though, I had a irritable experience and I was very uncomfortable. the other day I came for a soft serve and there was only two people at the counter the place was packed full and there was like a good 4 or 5 people in the back making a ruckus there was yelling then the person checking me out told me that she had to go to the back to get my change so I wait for a good 3-5 minutes with the second girl at the register there didn't seem to be any manager at all or at least not helping. read more

You better understand that "hand dipped" means they scoop it out of the can. Soft serve is just that, it comes out of the machine. It took me a few tries to understand what she meant when I asked for "hard chocolate" and she asked me if I wanted "hand dipped." Hell no, I dont want "hand dipped." I'm glad we figured it out after a few tries. Anyway, I ended up with the hand dipped chocolate with chocolate sprinkles. (the kiddie size dont judge.) It was creamy and fresh. Pro tip. There are 2 doors on each side. There is a sign on both which no one reads that says "form lines by both doors" No one followed the sign. We walked to the other side and were served right away. So if you see a massive line, just go to the other side and walk in. You're welcome. Anyways, I learned a lot at this visit. Hand dipped is good and so is reading directions. Enjoy folks read more

Masseys Frozen Custard - a hand holding a bowl filled with seeds - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

4:10 today Two young men behind counter Both waited on one women who bought one item I was standing there waiting The one young man was standing by the register and I asked for a chocolate shake At that moment a couple he knew walk in and he walked to the other side of the register to wait on them. At this point the other young man asked me what I wanted. I walked out and will not return. read more

Best ice cream place around. It is always busy but they are efficient and don't need to wait long. The ice cream is yummy. Must go.

I am an ice cream lover, and, also, an ice cream snob. Not just any ice cream will do. A couple of years ago, we discovered Masseys Frozen Custard on a drive through Carlisle. Don't let the store's name fool you - they have MUCH MORE than just frozen custard, which is delicious! They have almost every ice cream you can think of - all wonderful. However, on this trip, we were dealing with some health issues, yet, in the extreme heat, Massey's called out to us. Guess what?! They had low fat, no sugar ice cream, which was THE BEST ice cream ever! You would never know it is low-fat and sugar free. We will go out of our way to come back to this ice cream haven! read more

Delicious soft serve and awesome gluten free cones! The staff use safe food practices for patrons with allergies! Nice experience and would definitely recommend! read more

Quick service & a variety of flavors including soft serve & daily flavor specials. They do citrus/tropical fruit custards really well. Extremely refreshing! read more

A Carlisle treat for locals and tourists alike, Massey's is located right off the main road near the Dickinson tennis courts and their gym. It's tiny (no room to sit inside) but there's lots of seating (no tables) outside. Service is very warm and helpful, and you can try samples. Great prices and service. Lots of options to choose from. Worth a visit if you're in town. read more

See all

40 years later after moving back home to Carlisle and still amazing Arctic Mount is my favorite! Banana, pineapple and vanilla wafers

Old school roadside ice custard stand. Seems to always be a line so the locals vote yes. Stuck with the basic soft serve custard flavors of vanilla, chocolate and twist. Skipped all the extras and other flavors. read more

I've been going here for 50yrs I got a banana split and it was the worst just2 small scoops of ice cream the topping are nothing but juice it was really bad the place had really gone down hill they want to charge big prices for nothing if the banana split got any smaller they should take it of the menu im gonna start going elsewhere read more

Really good frozen custard, didn't really understand the hand dipped terminology lol. So communication started a little slow ! But the value and product was extremely excellent !! I will be back every time I'm in the area ! read more

This place hasn't changed much, or at all, since I first stepped foot in the door in 1994, and I hope it never does. Hit with an icy blast of AC, we settled on some classic custard and a milkshake for our car's inhabitants and settled in for one of my favorite, utterly delicious old fashioned summer treats. I generally stick to classics- either vanilla or chocolate. The custard is so good, and I recommend it nice and simple. Parking lot and covered benches available, though shade doesn't help much in 90 degree heat. My favorite spot in Carlisle! read more

Masseys Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Masseys will always have a special place in my heart:) When I was younger, I used to go to summer camp that took place at Dickinson College, which was just a few steps away from this place. My counselor would take us here to get treats and I'd in turn take my parents here on the last day of camp before we drove back to nyc. I've never had frozen custard anywhere else so I'm obviously extremely biased but Masseys' tastes like they've definitely perfected their recipes hands down. I love how compared to ice cream, frozen custard has a slightly denser (almost fudgier?) texture and is super rich and creamy, literally nothing compares to it, especially on hot summer days. There's always a bunch of really fun flavors to choose from everyday and they also have options for lactose-free, gluten-free, and dairy-free dietary restrictions. The prices are fairly reasonable and there's also lots of benches for seating outside of the store. Definitely a great spot to visit whenever you're in the mood for a sweet treat. read more

Love Massey's, Custard is great, flavor options constantly changing and you can't beat the price. My husband and I love to sneak away for a little, late evening treat, to enjoy on the tailgate. read more

If you've ever had Masseys, you will likely never step foot in a Dairy Queen again. Masseys scoops phenomenal custard, and they're always rotating flavors so it never gets boring. I've tried the strawberry shortcake, Elvis, blackberry crumble, and vanilla. All were great. I always add hot fudge, and they're really generous with it. If you get a fun flavor like strawberry shortcake, there will be nice big chunks of fruit and cake. I usually get a scoop in a cup due to my hot fudge addiction, but most people get cones and there are some great instagram moments! Cones can be covered in sprinkles or chocolate dipped. Very fun! You can only fit so many people inside, so there might be a line out the door, but it moves quickly. There are benches outside if you want to sit and stay for a while. It's a great place to go when you feel like getting out of the house on a warm weekday evening. read more

I like their milkshakes, rich and yummy. But their customer service is 0. The kids on the front need a basic training on how to talk and treat customers. They were racist and had an attitude that we didn't know what a chocolate ice-cream would look like. read more

The place to go for creamy custard. It'll take a few tries to figure out the best flavor .

Went to Masseys a few weeks back . I was craving a dipped cone. The chocolate they use for dipping has no flavor at all. I'm not even sure what it is. The cherry dropped off the top of one of our sundaes so she charged us for an extra cherry. read more

We came here when visiting my husband's old childhood home. It's a super cute spot with great flavors. Try the canoli or Nutella! Definitely one of the better places to get ice cream and there were tons of options! read more

I honestly don't understand how this place has such good reviews unless people have never eaten ice cream or custard before. Not only was the menu confusing and poorly organized but the pricing was awful too, purely because of the confusion with toppings or using a different type of custard. Anyways, the custard itself was extremely bland. I ordered the s'mores and chocolate cake batter. Unfortunately it tasted like vanilla (which I hate) and some type of low-fat or sugar free chocolate ice cream with no trace of cake batter. I was extremely disappointed and will head to brusters next time I'm feeling a frozen treat. read more

I wish I could come all the way back from Hawaii just for a vanilla cone with the chocolate dip.. I miss pretty much everything about the whole Massey's experience.. the way it smells inside, the flavors they have and those crappy picnic tables outside. Someday... I'll acquire another Massey's cone-o-joy. read more

If youve lived in Carlisle longer than a few years - youll know that Masseys is the place to go for all things ice cream. Sure theres a fancy new corporate Brusters in town - but it doesnt compare to the hometown ice cream and goods that Masseys serves up. Ive lived in this town all my life and Masseys has stood the test of time. Its a small walk in -order - walk right out kind of joint and is located right in the heart of the college, so expect a line and a bit of a wait. But its worth it. read more

Oh wow Great ice cream, cute little place, excellent prices read more

Been having ice cream at Massey's for more than 20 years.. And it's always an amazing experience.. I make sure to stop by when ever I visit Carlisle read more

See all

Tradition is not a good enough reason to continue going here for ice cream. The cramped ordering area is claustrophobic, hot and not conducive to ordering for a family. The frozen custard is ok but there is much better frozen custards in town that I won't mention because I don't want to give the appearance that I am a shill for the competition. Flavors are limited unless you want an arctic blast or something. read more

This was the best frozen custard I have had for many years. They don't make frozen custard in New England so this was totally a treat! The last time I had it was in WI and this was equally as good. Cute little place and the folks working inside were super nice. Even my dogs got a frozen treat with a biscuit in the cup :) Hope to get back there next year again. read more

This is a no frills roadstop-type frozen custard stand with some throwback vibes. Good for a quick fix but wouldn't go too far out of my way. read more

Masseys Frozen Custard - My little bro macking on "small" carmel pretzel scoop mmmm - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

Had a fabulous dish of home made vanilla frozen custard at this classic establishment open 1949. http://retroroadmap.com/2010/09/29/masseys-frozen-custard-open-since-1949-closed-for-the-season/ read more

Found out about this place from some locals who highly recommended it and decided to come here to satisfy my ice cream craving. I got a vanilla soft serve cone and it was just what I wanted. Soooooo good on a hot summer night. This is such a good summer spot and I can't wait to go back to try a dipped cone next. read more

I grew up in Carlisle, going to Massey's week after week (back then they closed for the winter!). Everything was always delicious, and the milkshakes were amazing. It was one of the only places that would make a chocolate milkshake correctly (vanilla ice cream and chocolate syrup). It's gone way downhill since then. I stopped by out of nostalgia for one of those milkshakes and couldn't believe how awful it was. Horrible consistency, and, hard to believe, but it wasn't even cold! It was thick and somehow held that consistency at room temperature - which is how it was served to me. It's hard to imagine a milkshake that's not cold, but that's what you're getting there now. Back then they used to use a machine to mix them up. Now, it's some kind of strange mix they pour out of a soft serve machine. Honestly, any fast food place has better shakes and soft serve than this. The hand dipped frozen custard is the only thing worth going for. Other than that, I'd head a little further down the street and go to Leo's. The quality is much more impressive! read more

Great custard, great staff I have grown up eating Masseys I feel like I couldn't go anywhere else, because it won't measure up, to the wonderful treats they have read more

Masseys Frozen Custard - Yummy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania