This place came highly recommended it did not disappoint food was hot and fresh. Service was…read moreoutstanding with good recommendations. The view was very nice and pleasant. prices and quantity was the only issues not a lot of food for the price 1 small fish, and 3 shrimp FFs $19. 6 raw oysters $14. Maybe it's NY.

Yummy food and friendly atmosphere! Pet friendly outdoor seating and covered patio :)read more

Fresh buttery perfection served up here! ;) PJ Lobster House…read morewas the perfect meal option while in town. Popped into this lovey, wood polished establishment for lunch and ordered up crispy juicy coconut shrimp app along with a bowl of lobster bisque soup to start. The soup was creamy and delicious with big lobster chunks, not having to hunt for it or just tasting seafood broth here ;) Both came out quick and were on point. Personally followed that up with a hot a buttery lobster roll. It was fresh and juicy even before adding a bit more butter. They serve it up on a proper roll that was slightly toasted but soft with each bite. My Mr had two of the juiciest lobster tails with cole slaw and a garden salad. Sadly couldn't stay to try out a dessert since we had the baby wanting their liquid lunch too, but know the wait staff was super sweet and quick getting all that was needed and asked for super timely. *Noted: Street and municipal parking lot available. Good stable Koala changing table in the ladies room.

Came by for brunch with my family and based on the reviews, it was supposed to be a solid spot…read more However, some dishes we tried were hit or miss. A lot of it was salty and not memorable. I was so disappointed given the reviews and the promising menu. The lobster dishes were underwhelming, especially the lobster Mac and cheese. The flavor was just a regular baked Mac but with pieces of lobster claw in it. We came during a cooler time of year, Feb. 2025 so that explains why the restaurant was quite empty. Service was good and our waitress was very friendly. However, for the pricing, there were not enough unique items to try. I noticed on the menu there was sushi options. But we didn't order. The lobster bisque was a tad salty. And the fried seafood platter my friend and I shared was good at first bite. However, everything started to taste very one note. I would pass on this place unless it's the right season.

Everything looks so fresh! Wonderful selection. Everything h I bought there has been outstanding!!read more

Super fresh. Ordered scallops, clams and cerviche made from beautiful fresh halibut. Everything was…read morespot on. Best scallops I've had in ages. Nice to see Eddie behind the counter. Friendly new faces too

I do absolutely recommend this place. We been here few…read moreyears back. A lot of remodeling and changes later this place looks amazing. I love outdoor seating and the weather was perfect for it. It was time for lunch and Iam not a big fan of sandwiches my husband ordered few appetizers and main course for the two of us. Everything was delicious and Hailey, our server, fantastic. Very happy with our visit.

Prime location in port that's been on the "try" list for a while, and it didn't disappoint. The…read moreambiance is great, food was very good, and overall a fair value (mostly). As many other reviews have mentioned, service was horrible but thankfully it was a beautiful day and we were in no rush. -Calamari: 4/5, not overly fried with that heavy feeling after eating deep fried food. Flavor was good and the Thai sauce paired well with the peppers. A little light on portion but overall good. -Lobster Roll: 4.5/5, went with the cold version and it was definitely one of the best I've had on the island. Much better than the place up the street with the word in its name! While it was stuffed the flavor was lacking a bit but still very good. I'd come back just for this. -Coconut Shrimp: 2/5, no bueno. Way over cooked, and definitely the worst value overall among the things we ordered. 5 small fried shrimp for $22. Caesar salad was very good too. Overall we were happy with our experience. We're fans of Drift 82 so this was right up our alley. Service was definitely lacking but still a solid experience and we'll definitely be back.

Okay..... the hidden Gem moved to Main Street (Port Jeff Village). The hidden Gem is still serving…read moregood food: but, OMG this place will suffer based on the wait staff. By far and away the worst I've experienced. I took away a star for this reason. The new spot aesthetically is just okay. As always with local restauranteurs little to no attention paid to the noise level. My ears were bleeding throughout dinner. The restaurant needs decor which creates a warmer inviting presence. Our food was delicious but the wait time for the meals and drinks was insufferable. BTW, the wait time for the check was equally as painful. To the owners, get your (you know what) together and figure this out. You will not succeed unless immediate improvements are made.

Service excellent . Gave this place 2 tries…read more Food abominable drenched in butter and sodium. Tastes like frozen seafood from Costco. I had to yak on my way home.

Very unacceptable lobster roll for $39. This is how it arrived at the table. Waiter chuckled when…read moremy boyfriend asked why this lobster roll was on a diet. No offer to fix it or address this poorly prepared lobster roll. Waiter was attentive otherwise. Ambiance was great.

I had the pleasure to dine at the Black Pearl for dinner. We had the best server Angela, who was…read moreconsistently checking in on us. For dinner, I ordered the golden glaze salmon, and it was amazing. She made sure we had all of our items and did so with enthusiasm and a smile! We will defiantly be back and requesting Angela since she made our experience so enjoyable!

*January 2026 Restaurant Week*…read more My wife's bestie made plans for the (4) of us to meet for dinner. We all live close so Fifth Season Restaurant was chosen. I haven't been here in a very long time so I'm excited to see how the restaurant has stayed in business over the years. We are shown to our table upstairs. The bar area on a Friday night looks fun and active. There's great views of Port Jefferson harbor so the restaurant ambiance is nice. We're seated and are given restaurant week menus as well as the wine/cocktail list. Listen, It's Friday nite and I don't want a wine cooler! Give to me a standard Martini stirred (Shaken is just dumb) with stuffed blue cheese olives. The ladies order appletini's and we're ready to order off the restaurant week menu. The menu has a nice selection of different offerings, I'm into all things local so I'm going to start with the beet salad and Red Snapper. The beet salad was loaded with beets! I love beets, they did a good job with this started dish. I must point out, the dish must have been prepped earlier in the day. The green salad was slighty wilted when served to me. The Red Snapper, what is that sauce on top? And the fish was sitting on a bunch of zoodles?? The fish wasn't seasoned, it wasn't very flavorful. I'm eating around the zoodles, meh. The cheesecake I ordered, it was also just a standard dessert. I didn't finish the fish or my dessert. Review is over, Fifth Season Restaurant? See you in another 5 years.

The restaurant itself was very nice. Two stories and we dined on the second floor. They had a few…read morespecials that sounded good. The complementary Crostini was great. The salads we felt were small for the price but were tasty. The main course was delicious and a nice portion. However the small portions continued when we moved over to dessert, which was very overpriced for what you got. The service was also kind of slow. I think they need more wait staff.

The food is fantastic and they made a perfect black and blue ribeye…read more The prices are high but reasonable. But! They are super understaffed, do not expect to get your water filled or see your waiter for at least 15/20 minutes after being seating. Lastly, they have a 3% fee for using your credit card...

Ambiance is nice. Food was good for the most part. We started by ordering 6 individual pieces of…read moreshrimp cocktail and a Caesar salad to share. Honestly the shrimp was a waste - don't recommend. The Caesar salad was flavorful. The lobster Mac and cheese is great - highly recommend! The 22 oz. bone in ribeye was good, but nothing out of the ordinary. The creamed spinach side was extremely tasty - highly recommend that side!