"My grandma and your grandma Were sittin' by the fire My grandma told your grandma "I'm gonna set your flag on fire" (Dr. John) Abuela, Bubbe, Grand-mère, Oma, Avó, Obā-chan, Nǎi Nai, or Ammamma are terms of endearment to say "Grandma" around the globe. In Italy, the word is "Nonnie" which just happens to be the name of an amazing Italian bakery we visited today. To be honest, calling Nonni's a "bakery" really shortchanges Grandma, because it is SO much more than that. Yes, of course they sell an incredible variety of beautifully crafted cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and cannolis, but you can also buy breakfast sandwiches, pizza, stromboli, arancino, stuffed breads, grinders, chicken cutlets and more. Their store is awesome, and you'll find yourself staring at their showcases and refrigerated cases. Service is top notch, with plenty of helpful and smiling folks helping you. We picked up an eclectic group of odds and ends - croissants, donuts, danishes, and a big arancini stuffed with meat and vegetables. We attacked that first as an appetizer with dinner, and it was terrific. I can't wait to sample the rest of their wares. PRO TIP Their Italian cookies look amazing, and we will definitely be back to supply our Thanksgiving dessert table with their Rainbow and Birthday Cake cookie cubes. read more

See all

Nonnie made an awesome banana cream pie for my husband's birthday. Whipped cream topping was so delicious and thick. You could tell it was homemade with love. read more

This place is the best a went here with my parents to get cannolis and I have to say these are the best ones a have ever had this place deserves 5 stars everyday of the year. read more

Nonnie's Italian Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Plainville, Connecticut

Hands down the best cannolis I have ever had in my life. Absolutely amazing. Cannot wait to go and try a sandwich.

this bakery made us a cake that was so beautiful and well done very pretty. They were edible sparkles on it. It was for a bride and groom Cake and a wedding we asked for espresso filling the baker. Noni couldn't have been nicer and more caring and easy to work with. Cake was delicious. I highly recommend this bakery. read more

All I had to see were the famous Italian cookies and I was roped in! So fresh and perfect. Was met by a young man who was very helpful and patient since I didn't know all that I wanted. Tiny and quaint and nestled in Plainville. read more

Excellent place. The service and the owner were great, friendly and welcoming. They fill your cannoli in fresh, and it was really excellent! I wish I'd gotten more. The customers look like regulars. The owner was making fresh coffee cakes raspberry, blueberry, and other flavors. Everything looked fresh. They have olive oil with herbs, bread, cheese, and other stuff too. There's a place to sit down, too. read more

See all

The best grinder rolls in the area. Also love the tiramisu! And the people here are so friendly! Real gem!

I was finally happy to make it to Nonni's after experiencing their cannolis that were gifted to us from our cousins when they stopped by our house. I figured with their fantastically fresh and uniquely stuffed cannolis that were some of the best I've had in a very long time, what else do they have cooking up in there? So I took a drive and had some fun. Upon entering and properly ordering 1/2 dozen mini cannolis which are piped fresh and made to order, I somehow got a dozen but wasn't mad! I also ordered some other Italian pastry classics: rainbow and anisette cookies and a few diff types of cake bc hellooooo.. Then another customer was ordering a sub/grinder and the young gentleman behind the counter seemed to take pride in his sammie making skills so OF COURSE I'm going to support local! Give me one of your best chicken cutlet sandos I said! And that's exactly what happened.. The sando was great but I'd say the cannolis were still my fav and can't wait till go back for more! Follow on IG: ps_onemore4theroad read more

See all

I ordered a small birthday cake. It was nicely decorated and it tasted very good. I was, however, startled by the price. I don't know what other bakeries are charging but I think this one was pricey. read more

Ran into Nonnie's; in a pinch, to grab cupcakes. The cupcakes that were available were absolutely beautiful. Each 4 pack had completely unique, detailed floral designs with both vanilla and chocolate cake. Beyond this, there were also small terracotta pots with the larger sized cupcakes inside, with the gorgeous floral frosting design as well. When my coworkers saw the cupcakes, every single person asked to take a picture of the assortment before anyone started eating- they were truly gorgeous and perfect for this time of year. The taste matched the aesthetic- perfection all around. This is not the first time I have had Nonnie's sweets. My husband ordered my birthday cake from here; a chocolate peanut butter cake with the whipped cream frosting- amazing. I also had their pistachio cupcake with a ricotta frosting, outstanding. I cannot recommend Nonnie's enough. read more

Nonnie's Italian Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Plainville, Connecticut

See all

Dear Nellie and Sal, Monica and I wanted to let you know how much of a hit your cake and cookies were at the event we hosted yesterday. The cake was beautifully presented and delicious; same for the cookies. For the little cake and cookies that remained, Monica and I will consume today. I already had a couple cookies with my morning coffee Thank you and God bless. Peter and Monica Zanini read more

I have tried several things at this Bakery and everything was very good. Just one time I was just disappointed in the chocolate cake which happens to be my favorite because it was not fresh it was dry. read more

Came in before closing . Staff was attentive and friendly . Fresh cannoli cookies came out , I'm assuming by the owner . We got those, a cake slice and other cookies . They just started selling grinders . We'll need to come back for . The menu for them looked great . read more

Nonnie's Italian Bakery - Goodies - Bakeries Near Me - Plainville, Connecticut

Happened across Nonnies. Cute spot. The house made cookies (vanilla wafers) were a nice surprise. Worth the visit!

We ordered a chocolate mousse cake at the last minute and they were very accommodating. The cake was tasty, moist and the mousse was nice and light with the perfect amount of sweetness. Everyone loved it! The young man at the counter was courteous, knowledgeable, patient and helpful. Looking forward to going back to try the many other delicious looking items. read more

Big rip off $100 for 12 squares of gluten free and they were terrible never going back Stay away from his place read more

Amazing customer service, family owned and operated local spot with delicious cakes, pastry, cookies, & stuffed breads. I had a special cake made for my Moms 70th BD party & Nonni's took the time to REALLY listen to what we wanted. My Mom is picky and she ABSOLUTELY LOVED her cake. Our guests are still talking about the yummy strawberry & peach cake! Highly recommend! read more

Nonnie's Italian Bakery - Nonni's Bakery birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Plainville, Connecticut

Made French toast with their fresh gluten free bread SO good. Gluten free cheesecake, stuffed breads, cupcakes, bagels, cookies and chocolate cake. Cinnamon buns and pastries and everything you else could imagine for the gluten eaters too read more

Nonnie's Italian Bakery - Made French toast with their gluten free fresh bread - Bakeries Near Me - Plainville, Connecticut

I really love this little bakery. I was in a bind and needed a cake within two days and every other place that I contacted said they could not do what I needed. For reference it was a white cake, with a picture of Ronald McDonald on it with a raked texture and matching frame. So in my opinion it was a cake that was not complex, but for some reason the large grocery stores refused me. When I went in to Nonnie's , everyone was so warm and kind. They were personable and became really invested in my silly McDonald's Birthday Cake Debacle. The cake was loved by all that ate it. Very light, but fulfilling. I would recommend anyone who needs baking done, to take a visit to Nonnie's. They treat you like family , their prices are VERY fair and I will definitely return again. also there Italian cookies next level good! I plan to grab some more in a couple days. read more

Nonnie's Italian Bakery - Needed cookies for 50+ people at the last minute and they surpassed my expectations - Bakeries Near Me - Plainville, Connecticut

See all

The cakes and cupcakes for our sons first birthday party were amazing! Not Only the look, but they tasted amazing. Usually I am not a cake person, and I'm never a frosting person, but this cake and frosting was so delicious. I had many guests at the party comment on the flavor. The owner was very very sweet also and very helpful on the phone when placing the order. Overall extremely happy! read more

Nonnie's Italian Bakery - Cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Plainville, Connecticut

See all

Boy was I wrong! After a year of settling in, the new owners have done a bang up job in the transition. All I can say is this is now my go-to Italian bakery. An absolute gem!!! read more

What a great place! Called last minute on Pi Day 2023 during a Nor'Easter to see if they had any pies left, only to learn that there were none- oh no! Not to fear however, as the offer was presented to make any pie flavor that I wanted within 30 minutes, and they even stayed open late to make sure I got it! Phenomenal customer service, and a cute place with great ambiance. I would recommend Nonnie's to everyone! read more

I was excited to check out a new place in town. Smelled fantastic when I walked in and I bought a cookies and cream pie. It was $30 so I was a little bit surprised. It was okay. Not $30 okay but okay. read more

My family and I came here to purchase some pies and cakes having had a taste of these fine creations at a work gathering. After the first spoonful of the banana cream cup I was hooked and I don't usually like banana cream. Everything that we bought everyone loved We will DEFINITELY be back!! read more

I ordered a birthday cake in a days notice. They were able to make a canoli cake for my birthday and it was the best cake I've had. Everyone loved the cake and the whipped cream frosting. I will continue to order my cakes from Nonnies! Tasha read more

I can't say thank you enough to this company. My friend had a terrible tragedy in her family and I don't live in the state anymore to physically be there. They made a special order cherry pie & delivered it for me. They had the kindest employees to speak with and followed through as promised. I, 100%, will be ordering from them again. Shop small!! read more

Gluten free cupcakes that are DELICIOUS! No one at the party could tell they were gluten free. Everything we've had has been fantastic from the flourless chocolate cake to the carrot cake. Can't wait to go back! read more

I've had a great experience with Nonnie's me and my wife have been going through a lot the past couple of days and my birthday came very unexpectedly. But that was no challenge for Nonnie's with two days to spare, the employees were very helpful and cooperative. They listened to my instructions very well and proceeded to surpassed my expectations. The cake was very delicious and exactly what I expected and then some. Overall had an amazing experience I would highly recommend to anybody. read more

We were so excited to try out this new place in town. Not only was it $30, but for the banana cream there was no bananas in it and tasted as if it was instant banana pudding in the shell. I could have made it for under $5. Sorry but we will not be back read more

This place opened right before my husband's birthday and he loves pie so I was excited to try it. I bought a key lime pie and it was incredible. I'm not even a big pie person but I couldn't stop eating this one. They are also incredibly friendly and they gave me a bunch of little samples of their other pie flavors. They were also amazing, especially the peanut butter chocolate one. They had a lot of other things in the case and you can buy small versions of the pies if you don't want to buy a whole one. I will definitely be going back for more. read more