McArthur's Bakery has now become an online bakery. You place your order online, pick-up your cake or have it delivered to you. The Lemay Ferry location is closed for foot traffic and you can no longer come inside to pick up a sweet treat. Luckily the cake I wanted was one of the hundreds of cakes offered. You can no longer order a custom cake. Ordering online was simple. I was able to get my questions answered via email. The cake pick-up process was not a problem. My cake was beautiful and delicious. Yellow cake with strawberry filing and lots of buttercream icing! The price was very reasonable. read more

McArthur's Bakery Cafe - Me and my cake! - Bakeries Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

See all

IF they reopen again, I'd be shocked. They butchered this place into the ground. Screwed up two birthday cakes within a month. Specifically asked them to write on the cake and both times they didn't. The second time I went in for a cake, doors were locked and the cake was in a display case right inside the front door with construction going on all around it, so you couldn't even get into the shop itself. Not entirely sure how that's sanitary but ok. I see why your doors are shut permanently. Way to ruin an STL institution read more

I was absolutely elated with the dessert trays ordered for my Son's wedding rehearsal dinner. The large assorted dessert trays were gorgeous and filled with so many delicious options. And the gooey butter cake and brownie trays were just as amazing. There were guests starting with the desserts before dinner and I received so many compliments on them so I will pass that on to McArthur's here! This was my first experience with McArthur's but it will not be my last. The bakery was clean, bright, smelled amazing and had some beautiful desserts. I'm not even a sweets person but I was eyeing the display case when picking up my trays. Online ordering was a breeze and super convenient. Thank you, McArthur's!! I will be back. read more

We stopped in to grab some to go lunch after church. Line was long, but moved fairly quickly. Lots of people in the back working, but only 1 cashier. Restaurant was busy, but seemed to be pretty clean and organized. They have Halloween/fall decorations up right now which is nice. We ordered some sandwiches and one of the chicken bacon ranch potatoes. And stepped off to the side to wait for our name. The drinks are soup in an odd way, as you can get refills of anything yourself, except for the lemonade, which is turned around to the counter side. For $4, I'd think they relax about too many lemonade refills per customer. After about 10 minutes, we heard our name get called from the register area, not the to-go pick up area, which was a little confusing. We had to ask the people waiting in line to order to move over so we could pick up our food. Everything tasted fine, and our total for 4 people was around $50. Similar quality to Panera, but I like the options here better. read more

McArthur's Bakery Cafe - Chicken Bacon Ranch potato - Bakeries Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

As always, our breakfasts were excellent! Those roasted potatoes could be a meal by themselves! Everything was hot and fresh. You order at the counter, and a server brings to your table. Their coffee is very good, rich, not bitter. They're always friendly and efficient. The decor is very fresh and, and the restaurant is always clean and well maintained. Don't forget the tip jar on the counter!! Breakfast and lunch, 7am-2pm. read more

See all

Food: 2 Stars Service: 4 Stars A cool concept, housing a cafe, bakery, and ice cream parlor all under one roof. Their cakes are moist and decadent and no one can pull off their signature buttercream frosting. But what turned me off wasn't their sweet baked goods, but the menu items from their cafe. Portions are big, but flavors are bland and often overcooked. I couldn't taste any of the chives in their cheddar chive biscuit, and their potatoes were dry, charred, and flavorless. I wish their fried chicken had more seasoning in their batter. It was the most tasteless piece of fried chicken I've ever had. Their short rib hash, for the most part, was their saving grace. (as long as you removed the burnt potatoes). The folks behind the counter were polite, but they had forgotten my hot latte. Halfway through our meal, I asked them about it and they brought me an iced one. I really like McArthur's, and hope they're able to turn things around in their cafe. As it stands, it's a bust for me. read more

See all

We stopped in for a sweet treat today. We tried the strawberry cream cheese croissant, lemon blueberry tart and a chocolate chip cannoli. The staff were very friendly and happily assisted us in picking out what we wanted to try. The dining room is super cute and everything was nice and clean. We'll definitely be back. It's a great place to come and sit down with your friends or family and treat yourself. read more

See all

A wonderful local boutique bakery. It has ice cream, donuts, a small cafe and cakes. And oh, the cakes! What a selection! They even had a slice of amaretto cake with raspberry filling that I could take home! The counter staff was very helpful and knowledgeable. She saw me looking at the cake and asked me what my favorite was. I told her, and she said that she thought there was some in the freezer. She disappeared and a short time latter had two slices of amaretto cake with raspberry filling! She was also helpful to me in finding the particular sweetener in their ice creams. Located in a strip mall, it is clean and accessible. read more

See all

Unfortunately, I'll never go to McArthur's again. Having grown up in South County, I was so excited to learn that they delivered to St. Charles, where I live now, so I was thrilled to use them again for a bridal shower I was throwing. I ordered the cake months in advance, toward the end of July 2024, for an October party. The young person who took my intake seemed a little unsure about what she was doing, and that should have been my first tip off. I explained what I wanted (see first photo, handwritten notes - spooky / elegant / fall theme for bridal shower, shades of purprle, add flowers, "Congratulations Dani"). The order person and I discussed the theme and looked up some photos on Pinterest while I was there. I mentioned that the decorators could call me if needed for clarification, because I really wasn't confident in the order person's abilities. I then called a few days prior to delivery to confirm the details and to make it clear, again, that this was for a bridal shower. The cake was delivered on time by a very nice gentleman. Imagine my surprise when I opened the box and saw a literal HAUNTED HOUSE. This is a Halloween cake, not even close to a bridal shower cake. It looks nice, but again, absolutely NOT APPROPRIATE for a bridal shower. As you can see on the second photo (delivery invoice), it was never noted anywhere that there should be flowers, and "fall theme" was also omitted. Even still, I'm at a loss how we got a haunted house from "spooky, elegant, purple" bridal shower theme. I called and spoke with a nice woman who advised that she or the manager would call me back. Holly the manager called me back, but was clearly already upset. She kept interrupting me, and told me that if I could bring the cake in in the next 35-40 minutes, they could "add some flowers". Well, again, I live in St. Charles and it was going to be unlikely that I would make that time frame. Then Holly explained to me how this was my fault, because I didn't provide any pictures, the invitation, or guidance. I told her that the girl I placed the order with never suggested that I bring in an invitation, and that she didn't really seem to think that this was going to be a problem. It just totally shocked me how Holly seemed to want to pass the buck. Like, of course I didn't know what to put on the cake. I'm not a cake decorator. That's why I paid over $100 to go to the professionals. By this point, my mild amusement had shifted to anger, just based on Holly's "not our fault" reaction. I told her that bringing the cake it at this point wasn't going to be good enough, and that I wanted a replacement. She put me on hold, and then came back a few minutes later and said that they couldn't get me a new cake, but they'd refund my purchase. Well, okay, but I still don't have an appropriate cake. When I asked again about bringing the cake in to have flowers added like she had said, Holly advised that this was no longer on the table. I told her that I was going to come bring the cake in because that's what she told me I could do, and then she said I was threatening her, hung up on me, and then the store refused to answer the phone when I called back. I then called the Kirkwood store and spoke with Bree, who was much more pleasant. She said she'd do some investigating and someone would call me back. Holly then called me back again, and was less rude but still interrupted me frequently. She confirmed that I'd still be getting a refund, and said I could bring the cake back in and "the general manager who is not a decorator" could add some pre-made flowers to it in the morning, but then I'd have to drive back in to get it before the shower. At this point, I don't know if the time and the gas would be worth this half-measure. McArthur's used to be where everyone in South County got their cakes. I don't know what's happened to them but I'm so unbelieveably disappointed in both their product and their service. I can't wait to see the bride's face tomorrow when she gazes at her beautiful HAUNTED HOUSE cake. read more

See all

McArthur's will ALWAYS have a place in my heart. My grandma used to bring donuts from their shop when I was growing up. Great memories and great pastries! Friendly staff and a nice little shop! read more

Went here for a sweet treat while running errands and was honestly underwhelmed. There wasn't a huge selection of desserts to pick from and it was dead. I got this cake and it just didn't do it for me. For the price of the cake, I expected better. I only ate a few bites and threw it away. read more

McArthur's Bakery Cafe - White Strawberry Delight Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

Got a cake and a pie for my friend's birthday, and they were delicious! Everyone kept asking where they were from. I have been a customer since getting donuts as a child... glad to see a business stay consistent over the years! read more

I contacted them last minute for an order after I found out my friend had a miscarriage. They were so sweet and quick to reply to my email. They went above and beyond to help me and I could not be more appreciative for their wonderful service and delicious baked goods. read more

I ordered breakfast from here for the first time this morning and it was so delicious. I had a veggie omelet, potatoes and wheat berry toast. The potatoes were my favorite! read more

McArthur's Bakery Cafe - Veggie omelet, potatoes and wheat toast. Sorry for the half eaten plate lol - Bakeries Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

Speciallty cheesecakes with rich, creamy cake base, laden with multiple fresh fruit slices !! Across from Mehlville High School. Have some sandwiches too, I believe. I like it. Sort of "gourmet-ish" fare read more

The place is clean updated and open. Donut and pastry selection not as big as I had hoped. A good macaroon selection. A nice shake and ice cream bar. Coffee is just coffee or latte. They have cakes ready to go that is nice. There is an all day brunch menu and kids menu pricing mostly à la cart style. read more

See all

I came here to have a coffee and use their wifi to work on my license credits. It's so cute inside and the staff were inviting. They do have wifi you can use, which is always nice. The lady recommended a custard puff since they were done serving food at 2 pm. I have a sweet tooth, so I was happy with her suggestion. The coffee was delicious, but i wish it was a bigger amount. I enjoyed the custard puff. However, I will order something else next time. It was served cold. The custard inside is perfect, but the outer shell tasted off, like the dough was tough. The hard chocolate shell was good. read more

McArthur's Bakery Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

See all

Great cakes that you order. Fabulous baked goods. Have not tried sandwiches served in bakery.

Tried the avocado toast for breakfast!! Delicious!!! Can't wait to go back and try other items!!! read more

McArthur's Bakery Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

Called in a cake order for curbside pick up and everything went smoothly! Customer service was great, I can never think of the name of the cake. You can place your order online but I just called it in! They offer free delivery if your order is over $35! You can also pick up in store, they have social distancing policy and limit the amount of customers inside. Now onto the star of the show...Strawberry Delight cake! Annnd that's just what it is...A Strawberry delight! The cake was tasty, moist and sweet. The strawberry filling was sweet but not too sweet, not too thick either, a nice ratio of cake to filling to the fluffiest whipped cream frosting on the outside all under a layer of white chocolate shavings! Yep! It was that good! I ordered the 9" but man after the first slice I was like DANG I SHOULD HAVE GOTTEN THE BIG ONE! Ooh well there will be another occasion and I will get the large, which will be too much but as I write this....I so wish I had another slice! Ooh yeah, great gooey butter danish! Will definitely be back! read more

McArthur's Bakery Cafe - White Strawberry Delight - Bakeries Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

Although they aren't open as early as they used to be it's still my go to spot when in the area that time of the day

What in the world is going on? I grew up as a little girl thinking I'd get my wedding cake here. I would see brides-to-be having consultations and looking at wedding cake displays in the side room. This is terribly sad. I ordered a wedding cake tasting box, and was prepared to pick it up and leave but I had no idea what an ordeal it would be to get it. I had to wait outside for a few minutes is 96 degree heat with my elderly mother after ringing a video doorbell and being met with locked doors and covered windows. Then another customer came up and was confused and when they called the phone number there was no answer. It was extremely odd and dystopian and borderline felt sketchy and dangerous waiting by the parking lot and not at all what I grew up with. I grew up coming to this bakery with kind workers greeting us and a beautiful bakery interior with open doors and seating inside. I used to get donuts and coffee with my grandparents, birthday cakes with my family, and their buttercream icing filled chocolate donuts were my favorite in my early 20s. It started going downhill during or after Covid when donuts got removed off the menu. I still had great memories and loyalty here though but that all changed today. This was awful and this bakery is not even a resemblance of what it used to be. So heart breaking I definitely won't be getting my wedding cake here and my family will probably never return again after what we experienced today. read more

I want to be clear first. I was a PROSPECTIVE customer. Not a customer. This review is about the service I tried to receive. I can't speak to the food. I needed two cakes delivered. I work like anyone else so asked if they could arrive any time in the afternoon. I was told, their window is 7am - 5pm. I can get that, but asked if mine could maybe even just go at the tail end of their orders. No flexibility. I asked if they left it at my house, how long would I have to get there before the cakes are ruined. They said they wouldn't leave them there even as I stated I was willing to run the risk because I really wanted the cakes. I could even had Ubered home the moment I knew the cakes were there. No luck. And the woman on the phone kept cutting me off, didn't want to work with me, and made no effort to even sound like it was unfortunate that she couldn't help me. Just what she can't and won't do. Let me be clear. This is a free service. So I didn't expect too much in the way of excellence. But I didn't expect zero customer service at all. Just "We have a window of longer than a work day, it can come anywhere in that window, and you better be effing home because we won't leave it". Even HVAC people give you a narrower estimate. Don't know how good they are and I won't because they won't be getting my business. read more

Well, The Scoop ice cream bar is lame. Pre packaged waffle cones? Hot fudge on the menu but don't have it? Vs the cost? You'd have a better experience buying stuff at the grocery store and make it at home. Way bother. What the heck happened to MacArthurs??? read more

I came to McArthurs almost every week as a kid for years! The service was always great, friendly faces and warm smiles greeting you, and the food was always perfect! I loved how it was set up all the colors and decorations, very dark earthy tones but they felt homey. I haven't been back in a while due to moving to a different city but I drive by every once in a while and think about how excited I got to go! read more

McArthur's has been my go to bakery now for the past 10 years. Between birthdays, 1st Communions, and graduation, we have been extremely happy with their cakes. Not only are their cakes delicious, their customer service is one of a kind. Today was a prime example of what great service they provide. The cake I ordered online for Easter, somehow didn't make it thru their ordering system. I called and Sonja took care of me right away. She apologized profusely and advised that they would be able to give me a cake today. It was still the flavor I wanted and the same size that I needed. She advised they would refund me (which I told them they didn't need to do) and 20 minutes later, they arrived at my house (in West County) with the cake and additional goodies for the family! Thank you McArthur's bakery for coming thru during the Easter weekend and this Covid-19 crisis. Our family will always be loyal customers. read more

McArthur's Bakery Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

See all

Ordered from the new cafe part, so good!! Biscuits and gravy and the breakfast potatoes. Also got an iced mocha, which was great! The set up inside is cute. And all of the employees were so nice. Will definitely be back soon. read more

We went for breakfast and were not impressed. They try to do too much but I'm more of a Waffle House guy.

We had a Christmas Yule log cake last year and It was truly amazing!!! Order it. Seriously. It's amazing at the holiday. We forgot to leave a review and this cake alone is worth it. I do wish they had more pastries available like they used to. For example cut pieces of cakes or just specialty desserts but that changes nothing about my experience. read more

First of all i was ignored by at. Least 4 people before a young lady in the back came out to assist me. The problem for me came as I was the second person that should of been waited on but I was the last. I haven't been on South County in a while and really forgot the racial overtones that exists in those areas. It saddens me. I never said a word to anyone just took pictures and made a point to observe everyone and what they were doing. I wanted to give them a chance not to be this way but unfortunately it is the case. On top of that the gooey butter cake doesn't hold a candle to the Gooey Butter at Companion so much better in taste and texture. Imma a fat girl and relish carbs especially baked goods and after two bites it sits on my desk. Im sure I'll toss it because it's just not good. So no reason to go back to this store. Customer service is horrible and so is the Gooey Butter. read more

See all

My daughter decided to go full on Saint Louis and have Gooey Butter cake for her reception. She ordered 2 full sheet pans of the amazing goodness. She got one traditional and one chocolate chip. We cut them into large squares and wrapped them individually in cute dessert boxes and they were an absolute hit with the wedding guests. I would say that most agreed that there is nothing that beats the traditional GBC flavor, perhaps it's sweet enough and the chocolate chocolate chip with drizzle, was super sweet. Not at all a bad thing, just sweeter than the traditional. read more

Basic chain bakery with a lot of pastries on display and a few food items to order. Some generic Panera-Ask seating inside. Traditional bakery goods. Some free samples. I ordered a basic breakfast sandwich and coffee which were not great. Coffee had grounds in it breakfast sandwich was very greasy read more

McArthur's Bakery Cafe - Indoor seating area - Bakeries Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

See all

Sadly, a few years ago, they removed doughnuts from their menu. I understand their reasoning but when I walked in there today, their normally busy shop only had two customers. It's a shame they felt this change was necessary. read more

My family's been coming to this bakery for over twenty years. Always get delicious and beautiful birthday cakes for the family. I live in IL. I also love they now have delivery ( up to 25 miles) due to the pandemic. It's a wonderful service. My children are now grown and they now shops at McArthur's for their cakes. read more

See all

This will be the first time I have ever complained, but customer service is quite horrible. Their " filled cupcakes aren't really filled, it's just a small squirt of icing from the top". Hostess cupcakes have more filling and at $25 5 inch cake or more for 12 cupcakes don't bother. So disappointed it used to be the best read more

My first time here and maybe the same for my wife despite her awareness. I know we attempted to visit on a previous occasion but they were closed. You're wow'd when you walk in the door and see the illuminated cases of baked goods flooding your brain with thoughts of all the treats you should buy. We asked a friend where to purchase an Ooey Gooey Butter Cake and were lead to McArthur's given our desire to take one to family in the Chicago area. My wife saw the macaroons and was in heaven with the options. She went for the combo bag since it was cheaper and offered a variety. She asked the clerk to pick his favorite bag which turned out to be one with a passion fruit flavored macaroon...didn't disappoint. I got a double chocolate brownie although I didn't think it was anything special and have had better. A wonderful place with plenty of options. read more

See all

My grandmother, who is diabetic, loves their sugar free goods. You can't ask for more than a happy grandma.

This has been my go to spot. We haven't been able to come here as often as we used to since we moved. When we started planning the wedding in lighting fast time obviously they were my first choice and first on the list to schedule a consultation. We had the consultation for a wedding cake scheduled. Late January to early February schedule the first evening or weekend appointment we could get out hands on. Now comes the day. I call to confirm the time. The voice over the phone confirms my time. I ask her if there was an appointment before us if we could come earlier. No . So I explain to her we have a hard stop at 5:50 to get to downtown for another event. She explains shouldn't be an issue. We leave with plenty of time to get early... so we thought. We do live 45 mins(without traffic) away. Traffic is terrible and we are late. We get a call 8 mins after our appointment time. I see it's them on the cashier id- I explain yes, sorry, traffic, but we are 2 minutes out. The voice on the other end tells me that sorry we have to reschedule. (Let's think about this. I've made it clear early that day that I know I'm going to be rushed and have to leave earlier anyway. So I wouldn't even be keeping them later than they already intended. So the argument b of we want to go home on time is not relevant.) After hearing the curt unsympathetic voice having told her simply we won't be rescheduling. That I wasn't going to make the trip again she said sorry then have a great day. By the time I hang up I'm on the other side of an intersection looking at the place. I did go . Since the open sign was bright and on. I did go in and explain to the women not behind the counter in the empty store that your need to reschedule was absurd. Mainly because the time it took you to hang up I was there. Had you not been a hurry to dismiss me over the phone and gotten the full story then this would have been avoided. I was told I was being rude and that I was the who yelled at her over the phone (mind you my fiance continued to the baskery after I hung up because he was completely unaware there was a major issue- so it goes to show you how much I was "yelling") so I got "you can leave" and left I did. We basically were showing up to pick out the cake.... order and go. We have been there plenty over the years but wanted somewhat of the "show" since it was an investment and a big day in our lives. Instead we sat in an hour of traffic for naught. Best cream horns ... sad I have to start my cake buying process all over. read more

What happened to McArthur's Bakery!?! It seems like they are phasing out of business. It's the week before Christmas and they hardly have anything. Shocking. No assortments of Christmas cookies or cakes. No cheesecakes. Everything has to be pre-ordered. Then the poor things can't open till 9am. Will go to Federhoffers Bakery on Gravois from now on. It's out of the way for me but, they're still normal. read more

You never get a second chance to make a first impression. We live in St Charles MO. So about 25 miles from McArthurs's. We've seen their tv ads for years and always wanted to go. Today, being my best friend's birthday I thought "what a great day to go". Well, that was the thought. Walking in there were no numbers to pull for place in line so we headed for the display case. One employee was busy with a couple in picking out the design for a celebration cake of some sort. We were never acknowledged. We never even received eye contact from anyone working there. Unfortunately we left. I'm so sorry that what seems to be an institution in St Louis can't staff adequately for Monday Morning traffic. read more