Siiiiigh....the Golden Arches next to my Wonder Years of schooling....is so very hit or miss & honestly this ish costs too much for what it is even with the app...and considering the growth of other locations to purchase food in the area with higher quality and better prices;this location better stop and I know those #'s only stay afloat from US local parents pockets(a middle school & a HS,which I graduated from).I had a card which my uncle received from Corporate because of a tornado of an order we had received from this location.I have to admit,a month ago I had the most delectable nugget ever from this exact location...it was yummy and I don't eat them I don't like the process nor the meat.This nugget was a flash to my days as a child on the playground between the parking lot and the restaurant with a huge metal shiny Grimace:)Back to the incident:so I order an oj,hash brown & utilize the card for an egg McMuffin...when I opened it I was wondering why the poached egg looked black under the white...this egg was so extremely overcooked that the green surrounding the yolk appeared black through the white.I threw it out.One bite,I started pulling it apart.So,in a nutshell they fumbled the order that was to make up for a prior order by honoring a coupon sent for a free Sammy that was served yucky and an overcooked egg.I was disappointed.The cashier was a nice young person.Do Better read more

See all

Now they decided to charge people for sauces if you don't order nuggets. How is the ketchup free when people have that in their food (not counting the packets handed out)??? But wait, you already hiked up the prices, so you covered the cost of it all too. Charging for sauces is BS! ( I don't mean Buffalo Sauce either!) read more

I know it's McDonald's can't expect much.. but at least put ketchup on the burgers .. lol it's that simple also hire people who actually care? Or like have some sort of pride jsut a thought... since when is a quarter pounder jsut a burger with cheese read more

The manger was very disrespectful and we was trying to walk out and she followed us and told us to get off the skate board but we wasn't even on it and she said that she was going to call the cops but we was already leaving...‍‍ read more

HORRIBLE! Please avoid this restaurant unless you want the most painful stomach pains. Food is unsanitary and I got food poisoning just 3 hours from eating. And not to mention it was first thing I ate all day & pretty much last. Stomach pains started from 7pm to 2am. Every single time i have ate from this Mcdonald's I have extreme stomach pain and it has never happened with any other Mcdonald restaurants. Never Again, please save yourself. If i could I would give 0 stars. read more

Last time I went to the e drive through there was a cup of cigarettes on the counter and the person that was working there looked drunk

mcdonald's is amazing. I love mcdonald's. this place is so good and always has good fries and the ice cream is always working. go here.

On Thursday, August 29th the McDonald's in Islip have Dirty employees. They don't wear hairnets and I don't see gloves on their filthy claws. every time I order food from there, I have to make two left because they don't have burgers cooked. And I always have to wait. I would probably get a faster response from the plastic Ronald McDonald sitting in the lobby. I return home to my house get all cozy comfy on the couch because I'm starving. And I can't wait to bite into my burger lo and behold what do I find ?? A nasty long curly died hair in my food filthiness! read more

I've never had McDonald's that tasted this leftover. Everything was cold. You can tell it was made a while ago and was just sitting out. The drive thru was pretty busy so I'm very surprise nothing was being made fresh. read more

Normally I'm not one to write a review, but what happened to me today was outrageous. I ordered a twenty piece McNugget expecting 20 nuggets. I got 19. As you can see this has effected me drastically. I've never been so enraged towards this McDonald's this much. Because of this I shall not be returning ever. Goodbye and good day to you. read more

I went here placed a mobile order for crispy chicken deluxe meal the chicken sandwich was missing the bottom bun and they weren't nice about it really don't wanna go back but the one in oakdale the mobile order price is always changed they are the 2 closest to me read more

McDonald's - a burger in a box - Fast Food Near Me - Islip, New York

This is the worst place i have ever seen the staff is unprofessional and don't get me started with the teenagers that work here they have no idea what they are doing and are unbelievably rude even the adult workers.The food is always almost cold and old the customer service here is unbelievable can't believe this place is still opened. read more

Very slow and usually makes you pull around into parking lot to wait. Fries are SOMETIMES hot. They have their good and bad days. Will always return though lol! read more

Order large fries and they give you a half empty container Order nuggets then they ask what sauce do you want and they fail to give you sauce Place sucks and it's managements fault read more

It's a very nice Mcdonalds in a convenient location! If you're going to eat in, I HIGHLY recommend when the sun is setting!! (Or coming up as well I suppose) They have an AMAZING view of the sun when it sets, it is beautiful!! read more

Absolutely the worst. Poor service, they always get the orders wrong. You go through the drive through you'll be lucky if your order wasn't given away. stay away. read more

Things the manager should do before hiring people here: 1) Give potential employees a simple math test, example 4+2. 2) Give potential employees a mock order and show them the importance of checking and double checking customer's orders. A few days ago I order (2)10 piece nuggets, (2) small fries, and (2) cheeseburgers. My order was ready within 5 minutes. My son pulled out his nuggets and fries and my two burgers. My daughter went to grab her fries and nuggets, but there was nothing left in the bag wtf? Went back to the McDonald's and picked up the rest of my missing items. Apparently 2+2+2=4 at this McDonald's. read more

They are taking forever to get my order and it's only 5 ideas asked the guy to the drinks in the cup holder and he forgot to do that wtf

If giving no stars was an option I would most definitely be doing this right now. These employees are incredibly ignorant they don't know what is going on ever (VERY DISORGANIZED) .Every time I order from there there is an issue the order is incorrect or when they do get the order correct I have to argue with the cashier in order to get my food that I have paid for. Most definitely not worth the stress better off going to McDonald's on fifth Avenue in bayshore this is ridiculous! read more

I usually like the service I get here in Islip and haven't had any complaints worth reviewing... until today!!! My kids begged me for McDonald's today so after getting my food from somewhere else I decided to grant them their wish. I placed the order at 7:22pm, I paid and they gave me one of those free fries ticket and told me to pull up in the front and wait for someone to bring it out. There were already 3 cars in front of me and I watch the employees come out one after the other bring orders to the cars. You know when you just know that an order is yours???? Well that was me today. After they gave my order to the car in front of me a guy comes out with a bag hands it to me and walks off. I pull over and look in the bag... it was not my order. I also see the car with my order digging through the bag and quickly drives off. Lucky them huh?!?!? I go inside the store to tell them that they gave my order to the car in front of me. I show them the receipt and they say their well rehearsed "sorry" and proceeded to make my order... my kids asked if I could buy them a strawberry pie. Well because they have all the pies they had away the the car in front of me they were out and needed 8 minutes to make a new set. REMEMBER: I got there at 7:22 and I didn't leave there until 7:53. I was so mad that I didn't realize I was there that long otherwise I would have asked for my money back. Well the kids had hot food but by the time I got home my food was cold. I swear I will never go to that McDonald's again!!!! read more

They forget items all the time. Worst McDonald's around. The remodel is horrible. It does not fit the downtown at all.

The best McDonald's in the area, service and food. Plus the view from the parking lot at sunset is just beautiful

We go here for breakfast twice a month. But---and it's a big but---50% of the time the coffee is hot, 50% it is tepid. They are always sorry and make it right, but why does this happen so frequently? Inquiring minds want to know. read more

It's hit or miss. The cashiers suck at the drive through and stuff is always missing. Been here twice this month and they let me down both times. If I order three items you would think they would be able to get it right. So disappointed with this McDonald's. Another thing is if they ask if you want bbq sauce with your chicken nuggets it's never in the bag. You always having to ask for it before you drive off read more

McDonald's is McDonald's, you know what you are getting. This McDonald's looks like it was remodeled recently, looks clean and well designed. The new Signature sandwiches are good. The prices have been creeping up, so the Buy One get One Free Coupons are necessary to keep the bill reasonable. read more

Don't bother going to this McDonalds. Everyone is pleasant enough but the customer service stinks. They talk up the McCafe but the coffee is never made, almost always they have you pull to the other side of the building and wait for them to bring it out to you. The wait many times exceeds 10 minutes and you'll wonder if they forgot about you or what. I even called them on the cell phone one time to remind them I was still outside waiting! This is not fast food. Check your order before driving away from the window because what's in the bag will be incorrect as many times as it's correct. The response is come back if it's wrong- are they kidding? The drive through line creeps and winds out to the street. Re train the staff, get better management or close the darn place. This McDonalds is not worth going to. read more

24 minutes at the drive through but that's nothing new with this place, and you ask for a cup of Mac sauce and this is how you receive it? This place is terrible customer service, longest wait time we have ever experienced, and so inconsistent with their food.. always cold. Last ice coffee I received had no ice in it.. read more

Can we discuss the elephant in the room? Or should I say on the drive through line??? There's always a line a mile long for the drive through - definitely need another window or more workers because I've never seen McDonald's line this long everyday and I've lived in multiple towns - food is always good here - clean place read more

If you enjoy grey cold hamburgers, cold French fries, apple pie stuck to the container, and a nice melted sundae, this is the place for you.

Whoever was responsible for making my mcdouble with mac sauce on 8/2/2020.... I would let you use my mouth for your pleasure because you pleasured my mouth with that mcdouble. You're a true artist and I hope your boss gives you a raise. Thank you. read more

I recently went to get a cup of coffee from this McDonalds. I'm not pleased. I had to wait a long time for the coffee. It was hot, but it really didn't have any taste. When you order something, why can't they give you what you want right away? I had to wait at the counter for a while. I understand that they have to cater to so many people, but another worker could have helped her with my order. read more

I been to this place alot ever since I was a baby. We would always go there every Friday. I can't even get enough of those happy meal toys from the late 90s/early 2Ks. I've alway have gotten a cheeseburger with no ketchup and pickles, small fries, 4 prince chicken McNuggets and a hi-c orange drink. But now that I'm all grown up I'm eating Big Macs and quarter pounders with large fires and Diet Coke. read more

I live in islip so if I need a quick meal I usually stop here and mainly use the drive thru. But Sunday night around 9:15 for some unknown reason I was in the line waiting for at least 30 mins and let's just say I wasn't happy about it. People were honking and the line just wasn't moving and then when I finally got to the window my food wasn't even in the bag and the girl was just starting to get my food when I got to the window. I'm waiting 30 min you think my food would be all ready and all I had to do was pay but no still had to wait even at the window. Then I asked why the long wait and all the employee had to say was idk not my fault. Seriously ridiculous. read more

This has to be the worlds slowest McDonalds! Over a 45 minutes wait on the drive thru line. This is completely unacceptable for fast food. They need to get their act together! It would be quicker to drive to other area locations and get your food than wait in the line. read more

Clean, quick, and friendly, foods to be expected. Steak, egg & cheese burritos are pretty good.

I've been coming here since I was born. Service was always spot on. Then, they renovated the place. New managers, new staff. ABSOLUTELY TERRIBLE. I've been here twice since the refirbishment. Twice they messed up my change and orders. Today, I went to buy an Incredibles toy. After waiting on the line for 20 minutes I picked out one for $2.16. Meanwhile, everyone was sending there food back. The manager was walking around yelling at people. I gave a $20 and my change was $17.84. The new guy couldn't do anything. The cash register was out of singles! So I'm waiting, the managers like, one sec. So I wait and wait while she walks around with her hands in her pockets, and after 20 more minutes, I finally get it. Of course, more people are sending their orders back. This is unbelievable. The new staff are untrained and nasty to the customers. What a shame. And you'd think the manager wanted to solve everything and make peace, but nope, she just walks away barking orders. In the future, if I want McDonalds, I will take my bussiness elsewhere. You've been warned. read more

I asked for two tap waters. It took about 2 minutes and a lot of effort, and resulted in me getting 5 tap waters, and the manager saying, "Ya'll better stop playing with me. Absolute disgrace. read more

Ok so I don't eat McDonalds often but on occasion I am in the mood for their fries. My concern is not the food (fries were banging). We went through the drive-thru, line wasn't long so I figured why not. Well to my surprise driving up to the window to pay and there is a young man standing outside who walks over saying the total is $$$. Ok, confused I ask why do they have you outside. He explained he collects the money to help the line move faster. Who in the world came up with dumb a$$ idea. One, he literally has a cash register opposite of the cash register inside, two it's 89 degrees outside. And three after paying I STILL had to wait to get my food. Another five minutes parked at the drive through reservation station. I understand trying to make things easier for the customer, however how they are going about it is all wrong. There was NO NEED for that young man to be standing in the hot sun with no covering to collect money, where two inches away the lady inside could easily do the same thing. It almost looks like some form of punishment for the staff who is not on the right side of management. McDonalds you all really need to come up with a new game plan. Shame on you for allowing that young man to stand out in the heat when your drive thru line was not long at all!!!! read more

I like Mc Donalds. I hate what they did to the Islip one. It's now a dark box on the outside and the inside is even worse. The former retro look was in need of an update but making it ugly and unfriendly really sucks. If I go back it will be to the drive in only read more

Clean, fast service. As far as a rating it gets 5 stars compared to other McDonalds. Been going here for 16 years. Well run place.