"You're not the only one With mixed emotions And you're not the only ship Adrift on this ocean" (Rolling Stones) McFadden's was a real mixed bag for us. It was a Pirates game night, and the fans were starting to roll in. We grabbed dinner before the game and were pretty underwhelmed. Service was very slow, with long lapses. The food was good- Philly Steak Nachos with Tater Tots ($16) and an Italian Deli Panini ($14) with Onion Rings ($3). Soft drinks were $3 each. Besides the service issues, we found the restaurant to be in a state of disrepair. The tables were very "icky-sticky". Oh, let's talk about the restrooms too. There are three paper towel dispensers in each restroom. In the men's room all 3 were empty. In the ladies' room, one was empty. Now in baseball 2 out of 6 equates to a .300 batting average which is terrific. But when it comes to availability of paper towels, that's an epic fail. read more

See all

I hadn't been to McFaddens in ages, tho we used to go often enough that they'd hand me my drink as soon as I got to the bar. Sadly, they changed their burgers (previously good) to smashburgers. I'm not a fan of those, so I don't know how theirs compare. I got a wrap and tho the chips weren't as good as before, the chicken in my grilled chicken wrap was perfectly prepared & very tender. The egg rolls were also delicious! Service wasn't great, even before they got crowded, but it was good enough. I was surprised that tho they remodeled some the floor is still the same horrible sticky floor that reminds me of a dive bar or gray party. They also have a bathroom attendant which I (& my allergies) hate. I'm allergic to perfumes and it was horrible. They did allow children in the dining area, which was a surprise and worked well for our group. I'm not sure if this policy (not carding at the door) is in place for games or even all concerts, so if you're dining with children before a game or show, I'd recommend calling to ask. The location can't be beaten when going to events at PNC Park. Still a very good option. read more

See all

I was scared by the bad reviews but our experience here was amazing! We stopped in about an hour and a half before a pirates game and although it was busy we were seated within 10 min (when everywhere else around was completely packed). Service was quick and friendly and OMG... the classic loaded Irish "nachos" (cheese fries) were to die for!!! There was so much delicious cheese sauce and queso and I added some extra buffalo sauce that really set it off. Would definitely come eat here before a game again. read more

McFadden's Saloon - Crab dip, bbq "Irish Nachos", reuben with onion rings - American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Decided to drop in after a ball game and wait for traffic to thin out. Was immediately seated and few minutes later the waitress stopped by to get our drink orders. The noise level was so loud because of the music that my friend and I could hear each other even though we were sitting opposite each other. Drinks arrive, and we're ready to order. My friend, a very picky eater, ordered a plain hamburger with mustard, pickles, and onions. I ordered the Cubano with tater tots. The food arrives, and since there are no condiments on the table, we ask for ketchup, salt and pepper. My friend's burger was perfect, a rarity for her. Usually, she has to send it back to be more fully cooked (she was not asked how she wanted her burger done. It just came out medium-well). Now this is where things went south. The food server, not our waitress, brought out a little condiment cup with some salt, two (2) paper packets of pepper and another condiments cup of ketchup. Something you'd expect at Arby's or Taco Bell, not a bar restaurant. I asked if it was Heinz ketchup because it just didn't taste right. Not bad but just not right. Turns out it wasn't. Who doesn't serve Heinz ketchup ? In Pittsburgh, of all places ? My Cubano sandwich was extremely disappointing. Probably the worst Cubano I've ever been served. Normally a Cubano is roast pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles and mustard pressed (aka, Panini). This sandwich was a little ham, Swiss, shredded pork (and very dry pork, at that), no pickles, salami, pepperoni, possibly a slight touch mustard (there may have been some yellow but you definitely couldn't taste mustard) pressed. Well, we tried McFadden's Saloon now and truly never expect to go back. read more

This place is hit or miss but mostly miss. I've been here a couple times and it was okay and I've also been here a couple times and it sucked really bad. I'd say if you go here before or after a game it's not going to be a great experience because the staff can be rather rude due to it being so busy and it taking them forever to serve you food and/or drinks. But then again that should be the best time to go here and they should be on their A game because that's when they should be their most impressionable to make sure customers keep coming back due to having a great experience. Also, I have been here on just a regular weekday or weekend night and it's rather lame. TBH: the food is mediocre bar food at best and the drinks are your typical watered down mixers. Honestly, there are better places to go in the area but this place should be the best due to its size and location and you think it would want to do better considering the numerous bad reviews. New management would probably help this place flourish. Just saying! *Not recommended read more

$10 charge for using a credit card that bartenders do not prior disclose to customers! Moreover, they do not ask customers if they want an open or closed tab & further charge them later. They won't provide you a receipt for your card transactions either. Very poor form! I am very disappointed in McFadden's, I typically enjoy this bar but these tactics are deceitful and dishonest. Will not be purchasing from their bar again. read more

Hello NateNation let's start this out by saying it is a Steelers home game day but this is also my second d time here and both times WAY understaffed so let's start there ... with that I mind the food slappppps -- the Irish nachos just aren't cooked but I really enjoyed them me lady was kinda impartial... Now the wings man butter me up and call me a shrimp dang those wings are tastey crunchy large bbq ugh yum so good - the other shining star, the Frieda holy freaking crap the fries - you know the fires are good when me lady doesn't need ketchup, have you ever heard that in your born life?! No ketchup for fries yes yes yes that is how good these fries our holy Mac and cheese wow. Me lady also got the beef brisket... it was beef brisket It was just that nothing special. Come here for the fires, the wings and the fricken PITTSVUEGH STILLERS!!! Wings fries Stillers baby long live mcfaddans I will be back. read more

See all

Avoid this place at all costs. Particularly if you're are a POC. The staff is incredibly rude, the place is filthy, and the food is disgusting. I went this past Monday following the Steelers vs Texans game to meet a few coworkers. Some random guy starts talking to me and proceeded to drop a couple n-words into the conversation. Now, this isn't my first encounter with racism so the word doesn't send me over the edge of being violent or irate, but I absolutely checked this guy. I asked him what makes him so comfortable saying that to me especially with everything going on in the world right now. As we're having this conversation his friends start to surround me and shortly after security is grabbing me. I explain to security this guy is calling me the n-word and using it unnecessarily in conversation. The security says they don't care what happened I was being way too aggressive and causing a disturbance. So they take me outside and I'm pissed at this point. As I'm outside security is trying to convince me they also removed the other guy involved, but took him out the rear exit to avoid a confrontation escalating outside. Sounds reasonable, but I knew they were lying to my face. So I waited out front to see if the guy ever came out. Sure enough 15-20 mins later the guy walks out. You sorry, no good, descendants of cavemen. I've already contacted the police to attempt to get security footage as well as my lawyer to see what further legal action can be taken. I'm hoping this review deters people from supporting this shit hole. I don't know how it's still open with all the health code violations, but I will do everything in my power to expedite the demise of this poor excuse for a business. I HAD to give one star if I wanted to post this, but I wouldn't recommend this place to an enemy. Fuck you Mcfadden's read more

went on a Saturday night and was good vibes until they didn't let my friend on the bar because he was a guy. clearly they want to carry an imagine but are limiting the amount of fun people can have at their mid bar. not sure if we'll be back read more

Place sucks never go there. Drinks are way over priced hardly any alcohol in them straight mixer. Bartenders are rude. The bar is dirty and doesn't have character everything is spread out. Would not recommend at all. read more

Food is horrible, I had a burger with bbq and the sauce was so hot I was breathing out flames plus everything was COLD, I returned it and in its place was extremely salty paddy. Hubby did not like his burger either. read more

In town visiting from Texas. Decided we wanted to go out to a bar/ club scene downtown. Good drink prices ( 2 for $15). DJ on Friday night played a great mix. We will be back for sure!!!! read more

I've been coming to McFadden's off and on for years now and it never disappoints. TV's everywhere you look which is great for game days, friendly fun staff and an outdoor patio to enjoy the outside. McFadden's always get's the job done. Food is always hot and tasty - make sure you try the wings! Best Irish bar in the city hands down. Stop in for a drink, and you'll end up staying for many many more. read more

Just across the street from PNC Park. A big Steelers fan hangout. Lots of tvs, a little loud and our food was prepared quickly and very tasty. read more

McFadden's Saloon - Bar area, large open room, tvs everywhere. - American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Walked in... smells like a dive bar.... I mean there is a je ne sais quoi- about it... my wife asked for a wi e.... "We don't have wine- go to Hyde park"... a bit rude... went to Tim's watch bar- a lovely - pleasant place .... read more

McFadden's is awesome! It's one of the highlights of the north shore area, as the bar vibe is animated and full of room to dance, watch any of the abundance of TVs, or carry on. The service is exceptional, and the array of liquor is excellent. McFadden's is a tremendous spot. read more

Let's pause for a moment and be thankful for Groupon. Okay. For $13 you get $30 of food, or beer, according to our bartender. Great! Any time I can save some money, it's a good day. I ordered the potato pancakes, and the McFaddy MacDaddy. Josh got the 24/7 burger. So, it is positively obvious that they have one cook, with access to a microwave and a deep fryer. Everything flew out of the kitchen in less than 10 minutes. The pancakes were misleading in the menu, making it seem like they were going to be somewhat homemade, or an amazing version that you wouldn't be able to tell that a big truck brought in a month ago. I digress. They were sad little pucks. But, salted and served with creole seasoning mixed with sour cream, they kind of redeemed themselves. Burgers. I love burgers. But these only came over cooked, and mine, with mac and cheese was just plain pasta with a slice of cheese plopped on top of it. The bacon was off the hook, though. Josh's burger was all kind of heart disease friendly. Egg, bacon, meat, and syrup. He liked it. But he likes everything. Service is amazing. They paid attention to us all evening, even though we weren't boozing like the rest of the crowd. So, it's probably a better place to drink, than eat. Happy Eating! read more

McFadden's Saloon - I'd like to call it Fatty McFatterson. - American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

I am never coming here again. I liked the vibe until I asked for a cup of water and they denied me. I'm already spending and excessive amine of money on their alcohol and the fact you can't give me a small cup of water? Not cool. I have never been to a bar that denied me water. Care for others. It's that simple. How much $ are you actually losing by offering those in need with a cup of water. Ridiculous!!!! read more

Ok, three-four star bar but food is quite horrible. Tonight I ordered a Rueben sandwich (no meat) and they somehow managed to make the worst sandwich I've ever had in my life. I couldn't even finish the food because it was so over saturated in dressing. read more

McFadden's Saloon - Rueben - American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Tried to go there for dinner after the Pirate game to show out-of-town family The 'Burgh! What an embarrassment!!!! A prepubescent boy was carding EVERYONE at the door----half of us were OVER 60 years old!!!! The 22-40 year olds showed their IDs! That wasn't good enough for "Pubert". Refused to let us in because those 60+ didn't have ID-----Ummmmm.....we walked the North Shore Trail to go to the game and didn't have our drivers licenses with us! Fine! We walked a couple doors down to Tom's Watch Bar where we were treated like royalty!!!! The service was great! Way to go, Amanda (our server)! Food was good, price was reasonable! Will definitely go to Tom's Watch Bar again! McFaddens's, YOU SUCK!!!!! read more

None and done! Went there after a Pirate game with our parents who are both over 60. Both my parents left their IDs in the car, and the punk outside refused to let them in! He wouldn't let us talk to a manager and just kept smirking at us saying, "sorry, you can't see a manager, I have to check everyone's IDs." This fetus looked like he was 18 at most! We went to Tom's Watch Bar and the service was great! After looking at other people's reviews of mcfaddens, it looks like we dodged a bullet. Mcfaddens is the place to go if you want a place that's staffed by Jagoffs. read more

I went for my 21st birthday and my friends and I were roofied that night at McFadden's. Do NOT recommend, creepy men and it was dead on a Friday night and the staff was so incredibly rude. We only went for their half price drinks for birthdays. Do not go here, you will get roofied and have a horrible night. If I could give 0 stars I would. read more

Avoid this place. Food is sub par....probably the worst food I had experienced at a bar/restaurant in a very long time. Servers were friendly and nice & that is the only positive thing I can say. read more

Great atmosphere, quick service, delicious food, and amazing wait staff. We went as a large group and the orders were perfect and the passing process was quick and convenient. read more

if I could give this place zero stars I would. I went out for my friend Jordan's 22nd birthday. We went from tequila cowboy to McFadden's. As we got our IDs checked and made it inside my group, and I had to go to use the restroom. which happens when you spend money and drink. I went to the men's restroom. I took a piss, went up to the sink to wash my hands and as i was doing so I was assaulted by 2 security guards working that night and thrown out of the bar without any explanation or reasoning. I tried to file a police report and they basically said I have no grounds to stand on bars can do what they want. I would not recommend going here. read more

terrible service, small drinks and will double charge your card and not give you refund!!

I have had a friend win the half off drinks party a few times. That is the reason I've gone aside from once on a Steelers Sunday. It's usually fun, nice, and cheap (especially when someone wins the half off drinks VIP.) This bar is never my first North Shore choice, but it has been fun when I've gone. Pretty dark inside. People dance on the bar sometimes (usually girls.) gets pretty packed on game days. There is an outdoor seating area with a nice view of the river. Great location in North Shore, right next to PNC Park. read more

I'm giving one star because the service was the poorest I have ever experienced. It was a busy post Steeler's pregame day, so I expected slow service and that isn't affecting my rating. I asked the hostesses for a table for one. They replied I should go to the bar, despite a few open tables behind them. I walked around the entire bar, not a single seat available. I went back to the hostesses, who begrudgingly showed me to a small two top, and took away the 2nd chair. ODD. I ordered the fried provolone cheese triangles & the Yinzer Diet (Steak Salad). The appetizer never came, my salad was served, and I had to tell my server the app never came and request it be taken off the bill. She said she had to ask the manager! I waited 30 minutes for her to return with my correct bill. I didn't tip, for the first time in my life. Usually, I tip %20 for even mediocre service. The food is underwhelming and the drinks overpriced. $9 for a Smirnoff Moscow Mule. I won't be back & unless you want a rowdy bar for game day drinks, skip McFadden's. read more

McFadden's Saloon - $2 Cheeseburger for Happy Hour - American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Very poor service, anybody that tries to get in will be denied unless you are a good looking female. Joke of a bar and the prices are out of this world. read more

I got kicked out for carrying seven drinks and dropping one on the way to our table. Not a single person offered to help carry them. We will not return to this establishment. read more

Beware! THE BAR STAFF WILL ALTER THE TIP AMOUNT ON YOUR BILL. Upon calling to advise management they refused to provide an image of the receipt. Would advise avoiding this establishment or you may potentially find an unauthorized 50% tip on your sizable bill. read more

If I could give this place 0 stars I would. Just moved here from Florida and wanted to have a good night out with friends. Waited in line for about 30 mins to be denied at the door that I was apparently swaying. I was completely caught off guard and baffled considering I just started my night and didn't even have a drink yet. My friends and I were all in shock and felt we were targeted. Will never go back here again. I was a bartender for 10 years so I'm very familiar with the bar scene. I have never felt more humiliated and disrespected for such accusations that were false. Yet they have girls wasted underage dancing on the bars.. says a lot ! This place is a shit show to say the least. read more

First time I went, it was great food and waiter was super nice and made me and my friend a great drink. Months later, I decided to take a large group of family and friends after a concert for food and drinks. Husband was treated horribly after we entered with a bouncer ripping something out of his pocket from behind with no warning and when I saw our previous waiter (red bearded male) at the bar I described the drink and had asked him about the name of the drink and ordering it again. He was super arrogant and rude and treated me like I was a total idiot. We sat down for a moment and the chairs, tables and menus were all sticky so we ended up leaving and ordering a pizza back at the hotel. I was embarrassed I even suggested the place. Also like to mention I had left a voicemail and email for a table for before the concert to celebrate 2 birthdays and never received any type of response. Never again! Do yourself a favor and walk down a block to the next place... it is cleaner and servers who know how to treat a person with respect. read more

Stopped by early this evening for a bite to eat and a drink. I was greeted at the door immediately by a very friendly young woman and escorted to the bar when I asked if I could sit there. Again, I was immediately greeted by a very friendly young man who took my order (after recommending the turkey, bacon hoagie) and gave me my beer. He was very friendly and we started talking. Apparently he just finished his shift working as a nurse. I was impressed, not only with that but with the turkey hoagie which was AMAZING. The manager, Tyler, stopped over to check on me and told me that the turkey is smoked in-house! I would definitely go back here the next time I'm in town. read more

McFadden's was the one place near Stage AE that we'd put off going to, but in all sobriety, I had a commendable pre-concert meal here recently. Our appetizer, the cream cheese-based Kilmore Quay Crab Dip, was loaded with lump crab meat and baby spinach, making it an ooey gooey mortar for the chewy but crisp garlic pita toast points that were tasty enough to be eaten plain, quite frankly. A similar starter from Thee Olde Place Inn was pleasantly recalled. In regards to my main course, I did something I have never done before. When my medium-rare burger came to the table with all the pink and juiciness cooked out of it, I sent it back. The exchange resulted in a profit of flavor via a luscious, rosy patty that dripped flavor like a honeydew melon. The Steel City Burger giddily defames Primanti Brothers by including a milky cole slaw (instead of a vinaigrette slaw) and peeled french fries (adequately prepared to boot) inside a wrinkled, glossy, soft, buttered bun. Each bite was creamy, crunchy, carnivorous joy. A helping of housemade, cauldron-crisp potato chips completed the entree for me in sea-salted, can't-eat-just-one, gourmet supermarket fashion. And there was a time when I thought New York Deli's purple bags of chips were the snack food pinnacle. Damn, was I young and sheltered. Ah! Fashion. Well, I may not recall our server's name, but I do recall that she was dressed like any other gal you'd see walking or jogging about in comfortable athletic attire. Lascivious? Revealing? Inappropriate? Hardly. Furthermore, she was attentive, talkative, and very nice to my girlfriend and I. I just turned 40, am in a serious relationship, and I liked McFadden's more than I anticipated. P.S. The joint is as spacious as a fire hall. Throw a bash! P.P.S. I do agree with other reviewers who stated that the food is a tad overpriced. read more

See all

This place was pretty awful. We only went here because the friends we were meeting made the choice. First, it is insanely loud. Like hurting your ear drums loud. There was absoutely no reason for it. It isn't a dance club at 5:30 in the afternoon. You are trying to eat a meal and have to shout to actually talk to your dining companions. They were clearly targeting men with the way the servers were all dressed. Two of them were actually showing butt cheek. Our server was very attentive until she noticed that the three guys with us all had wedding rings on. Then she was basically MIA for most of the evening. We saw the shot girls and miller light girls more than we saw our server. Food was mediocre at best. I didn't expect anything outstanding, but it was clear most of the items were purely frozen items that were reheated. We waited quite a bit (but they were busy) but two people's orders were cold. It was pretty obvious it had been out for a while and the server didn't pick it up for whatever reason. Perhaps the most egregious thing was the prices. I get it is a bar near the stadiums, so the entree prices were high but not unacceptable. However, I asked for extra celery and was told there would be a $3 charge. Three dollars for four pieces of celery?! Extra blue cheese was also insanely over priced. Most places will give you celery for free or maybe charge fifty cents. But three dollars?! And when I questioned the price the server said "does that mean you don't want it? It's not that expensive" If you are a 21-25 year old single male, maybe you would enjoy this place. Otherwise, stay away. read more

Drinks are expensive and parking is tough. $5.00 for a Miller Light bottle even during happy hour!? or maybe happy hour isn't available every night? That seems a bit high to me. It expect to pay that much for Corona maybe. I recommend arriving early because of the parking. Many of the parking lots are "lease only". Sure parking is available but it might be a little walk. read more

VERY confused as to why my account was charged extra after a night out? Had 2 mixed drinks & a water .. I know for a fact the 2 drinks would've equaled $12 because I got a round prior that cost that much. Not sure how I was charged $30???? Clearly someone has given themselves a big tip. Not sure how to even go about fixing this as previous reviews say they won't provide a copy of your receipt. read more

This bar is good for 1 thing and that's getting drinks before a pirate game or after a Steelers win...that's it! I've never eaten here but this surely isn't a place I'd ever pick to eat at when there are plenty of better options near by. Another thing that sucks is they charge a cover when it's busy. I've been in line and have seen it go from $5-$15 as the line got longer! I guess the two nice things are...it's huge, lots of space to move around and they have an outside area. Honestly there's not much else to say. Typical sports bar, nothing special but I'll continue to visit when going to games. read more

McFadden's Saloon - American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Rude service. Waited for "2 people" to come out and after watching more than 2 people leave, was told by The hostess 5 minutes later that they don't have any tables. Would have left immediately if that was the case, frustrating. read more