This is one of my favorite places to visit in New Paltz. It has one of the best happy hours in the area. On the weekends it turns on a late-night party scene filled with college students. It is lined up right in Main Street with other smaller restaurants and bars. This was one of my favorite cheap eateries in the town while I was in college. I have been here twice since for happy hour specials. I ordered the chicken wings and the shrimp tacos. The drinks were around $5 which is a steal compared to New York City prices. In the past they used to offer a large fishbowl drink for your birthday. It was huge and took several people to drink it. Currently it is the size of a large cup as you can see in the picture. It does the job but it is much smaller than what it was in 2010. The staff here is very friendly and helpful. I usually sit at the bar which is a great place to meet others and watch the game. Everyone usually comes in for drinks and a quick meal. There are large tables for families to come in and spread out. Everyone was nice here. I plan to come back soon and take advantage of the happy hour specials again. read more

McGillicuddy's - Sports Bars Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

Great wings and decent selection of drafts. Service was a bit slow. Booths are super uncomfortable and brutal to sit in for a whole meal.

Way overpriced for the portion size and quality - the wings lacked flavor, pretzels were hard and cheese was oddly solid, the fries tasted like they were fried in oil that ran down a sumo wrestlers crack Server was nice, service was fast, and place was mostly clean read more

super rude and confrontational staff. I experienced racism with a few friends from a waiter. She was super perky with the other customers and then unusually rude to us. I wouldnt recommend this place. the food is also bland. it's sad that this bar is the way it is now. read more

McGillicuddy's New Paltz If you haven't been drinking at McGillicuddy's past midnight have you really ever been to New Paltz? Cabaloosas, Joes, P&Gs and Cuddies all late night drunken hangs. Your typical wing and burger type food. No complaints but not really anything to brag about either. Decent French onion soup. Probably most noteable for their wings ($14.95 for 10). They are good but only thing that stood out was the large selection of flavors to choose from https://www.instagram.com/b.overly_delicious/-- in New Paltz. read more

McGillicuddy's - Sports Bars Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

A popularNew Paltz staple since the 90's, it's location is right in the downtown strip already teeming with pizza joints, coffeehouses, and bars. Weekday nights are quieter, with a live DJ on Fri & Sat nights for the younger SUNY New Paltz crowd. Never a wasted trip; plenty of tv's to catch the big game and some of the best wings around. read more

McGillicuddy's - The Godfather, paired with an Angry Orchard on tap. - Sports Bars Near Me - New Paltz, New York

After a long hike at .Minnewaska State Park, my best friend, Pots & Pans, and I stopped at McGillicuddy's. Not our first time here. It's our "go-to" spot in the New Paltz area for wings. And since Pots is my "wingman", we indulged. Two sets of ten....teriyaki and garlic parmesan. Our server, Taylor, was swift (and affable, attentive, and helpful). Wings were delicious. Gooey, meaty, finger lickin good. The drummies were yummy, the wings were Ba-da-bing good. And, for once, Pots did not use a knife & fork to eat them. There's hope for him yet. Voted best wings in the Hudson Valley for a reason. We concur. 5 delectable stars read more

See all

The first thing I will say is that the staff knows how to pour a Guinness, which is always a plus. This is one of the busier places in town with all sorts of college kids and locals mixed. Their potato soup is one of the best I have had in my life. As for the rest of the standard menu it is not my cup of tea, but their weekly specials are some of the best dishes in town. I highly suggest following their instagram and taking a look what they have on special and checking it out, it is well worth it read more

Place is stuck in the 80s with the ceiling covered in dust near vents , bathrooms were clean . We stopped by for lunch at 1230 and ordered wings as that's what they advertised as what they known for . Wings came out fast so it indicated they were pre- cooked. They were dry , out of all the wings I had they are 6 out of 10 . We had parmigiana and house sauce . It was ok . Staff were friendly and worked fast . read more

McGillicuddy's - Sports Bars Near Me - New Paltz, New York

After a trip around Minniwaska Park, we decided to stop at a tavern for dinner. A wonderful tavern with delicious dishes. The onion soup is beyond praise. The waiters are very friendly, helped with choosing dishes, and were constantly smiling. Our waitress Megan is above all standards. Thanks to everyone who served us. I definitely recommend visiting. read more

See all

I was in the area and was looking for a good spot for lunch. I'm glad I stopped here! I've passed McGillicuddy's many times but had never stopped in. I was looking for a burger and am glad I came here. I ordered an iced tea, tenders, a burger and the peanut butter mousse. Everything I tried was so good! The bar and seating area was pretty large. You could definitely host a large party here or have a big event in this space. There were lots of seats at the bar, and there were many spacious, large booths. I'm glad I stopped here and found good food in the area. I'd highly recommend checking out this spot if you're in the area. read more

On January 21, 2025, we stopped to eat McGillicuddy's before attending a basketball game at SUNY New Paltz. We chose the restaurant because they had convenient hours, location, and fairly good rating. We ere not diasppaointed. The atmosphere is typical of a sports bar with TVs in strategic locations and music playing in the background. We ere promptly seated and waited on by our server,Morgan. Our server, Morgan was very attentive and served us very quickly. We were on time schedule to get to the game on time. Morgan was kind enough to inform us of the time. The food was served hot and was delicious. I would recommend McGillcuddy's when you visit New Platz. read more

I live up in PA but we were in NY visiting a few parks and decided to stop in this small town for some grub. The place was very empty when we went in, buttttt it was a Wednesday so that makes sense I guess. With that being said the service was veryyyyy fast. As for the food, I got the Nashville chicken sandwich and my boyfriend got something off their specialty menu. I believe it was the brioche BLT with Turkey? The drinks were pretty good too. Only reason for 3 stars is I got a stomach ache a couple of hours after eating here. My boyfriend was fine though so maybe just me. read more

McGillicuddy's - Nashville chicken sandwich - Sports Bars Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

CUDDY'S! One of our go-to spots while matriculating at SUNY NP, had many a fun night dancing on the seats, going to 10 cent wing night, and drunkenly staring at myself in the bathroom mirror and realizing I am too drunk. Revisiting it as an adult nearly a decade later, and it's barely changed, save for the plexiglass Covid barriers between booths. I'm glad that getting in a weekend getaway to my old haunts provided me the nostalgic hug from Cuddy's. We ordered wings and fries and reveled at how cheap the drinks were (especially the beer). My blueberry vodka lemonade was delicious! Wings were well-cooked and flavored (although wish mine were spicier). The garlic parmesan fries were a bit too greasy but... bar food y'know? We gotta talk about something! read more

McGillicuddy's - Sports Bars Near Me - New Paltz, New York

Whenever I'm in New Paltz I come here. Great atmosphere and super friendly staff. We always order the wings for an app. They are delicious. The burgers are first rate. A generous amount of fries come with them too. read more

Service was better than we'd experienced in the past and our server was lovely and attentive. Stopped in for a World Cup game and ordered a bunch of bar apps. Almost everything was burnt, poorly seasoned or both. Not a fresh ingredient in sight. The nachos had a cheese sauce that was cold and bland. The mozz sticks were burnt to a crisp. The garlic cheese curds were soooo tiny /mostly breading and without any garlic flavor at all. Boneless wings "volcanic" flavor were alot more medium-mild to me so go for a hotttter hot hot flavor if youre a heat lover! I'd probably only come back for happy hour or to catch another game read more

McGillicuddy's - a table full of food - Sports Bars Near Me - New Paltz, New York

The low reviews threw us off. We walked by several times because we didn't think it was going to be good but then we said "Eff it. We going in and eating us some chicken wangs!" And hot damn, they were good! We had the Jamaican Dry Rub and it was crispy, juicy and lots of herbs and flavors. We also ordered the Inferno Buffalo Wings and they were no joke. It burned but a good burn that you can't stop. The Irish Spring rolls were innovative and highly recommend. We also ordered the Fried Pickles and everything was very delicious. Service was great and we were able to catch the U.S. Opens will dining. Music was also surprising good and I would like to follow their playlist, please and thank you. All around a win our books and we will be back :) read more

See all

worst drinks of my life. i cant believe how horrible the drinks were. service was not it. rude. truly horrendous mixed drinks

The music is horrendous and loud!!! The seats stink of vomit.... Needs a deep clean!! Ewww good is mediocre

Good Irish bar. Large crowd in daytime . Folks come to drink and eat. The food is great. The inferno sauce is flavorful but not that hot. Bartenders are friendly. I feel all circular bars should have 2 bartenders. Overall good . read more

Really mediocre burger made from a frozen pattie and over cooked. If you can't do a decent burger, what's the point? Got some Brussels sprouts menu "special." It was inedible. Fries were good. read more

Really excellent, friendly service!! Good beer and cider selection, and food was good for a pub!

I know McGillicuddys from my New Paltz college days and mannn they still don't disappoint ! Stopped by here and they have spacious outdoor seating which is great! They have a delicious pumpkin cider w the honey brown sugar rim omg food was great too! Wings are the best but the burgers !!! Holy cow! They're so worth it! Price is great too. It was 5 of us and we ordered with our eyes and way too much food Ms it only came out to about $110. Def a must try if you're in New Paltz town. read more

See all

Awesome place! Good food, and super fast service! Wasn't even here for 10 mins and I have my drink and food. It's big and not to loud

1 star. Just finished a good lunch. My lil girls and I go all the time for the wings and they always give lil gifts in a treasure box for the kids. Good service always. Unfortunately I can no longer support the business... they added a $2.40 surcharge to the bill. Asked why and it's the new credit card system, charges when using a credit card... unacceptable. It is the cost of doing business. You can raise prices like every other business, that's understandable. But I hate when they sneak in fees. Unfortunately it made us tip $5 less for the lovely waitress. It's not the money, we tip 25% normally but only did 20% today and will not be going back. Sad. Same with cash only businesses, in 2023 we will not support. Update: Come to find out that my outrage is justified. They are in violation of NYS Section 518 of the General Business Law. https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/GBS/518 To be compliant, they have to charge everyone the higher price and give the $3.5% discount that they are sneaking in to customers who pay with cash. Instead of handing me one bill, I give credit card, come back for signature with a new and improved total amount bill. I'm sure most will not care or notices. But I noticed the shady and unlawful business practice. Not sure why it bothers me... I'm more disappointed really, one of my go to places since 98' when I first came to SUNY... greed? desperation from inflation? not sure, but too bad. https://www.lovelawfirmpllc.com/library/are-credit-card-surcharges-allowed-in-new-york-state-.cfm#:~:text=If%20you%20operate%20a%20small,to%20use%20a%20credit%20card read more

My best friends and I went to cuddys for our 10 year friend anniversary and Peter gave us the best service of our lives! What a kind and sweet young man. Service was amazing! read more

the service isn't ideal, as it is slow and rude. Additionally, my friend and I walked into a bathroom as a male and genderfluid person (which they aren't accommodating in offering a separate bathroom), so they threw us out when they saw us enter the bathroom and claimed we were doing cocaine. POOR service, especially the only Hispanic bouncer they have who is homophobic, transphobic, queerphobic, etc. Complained to the owner and he threatened to ban us just because we complained over "unjust claims" from the bouncer, which were extremely justified and were profiling!! if I could give ZERO STARS I would! read more

Here from out of state for a graduation, and place is packed! Only a 10min wait. Was hesitant after reading a few negative reviews. But our server Kate was professional, timely and had a nice smile while taking care of a lot of customers. Only 4/5 stars cause our cheese sticks could have been take out of fryer a bit sooner (saw that in another review too ). I know. picky picky. Anyway, the turkey BLT , Classic burger and fries were delicious! A ton of screens to watch sports too. If back in this area, we will definitely come back! read more

They have decent chicken wings and other bar foods. Lots of seating and drink options. Good place to go out for a night of drinking!

Nice, large pub with great food and service. The wings were close to perfect, crispy, awesome buffalo sauce. But then the blue cheese burger was also delicious, two meat patties with fried onions, the thing was a beast, good for sharing. To bring it together the margaritas were absolutely on the money. I could have downed a pitcher of the concoction. Bartender was great. Finally, the waitress was a sweetheart. This is really a 4.5 star rating. read more

Grate pub it reminds me of a true Irish pub the phille cheese stake out of this world no waits on Mondays so come here with family read more

McGillicuddy's - Irish nachos - Sports Bars Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

I came in dead really hunger so I got my favorite a phille cheese stake and Irish nachos please visit here you will leave and want to come back read more

McGillicuddy's - Best sandwich ever: it's a super good phille cheesesteak - Sports Bars Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

Service was good. Great place for a game and drinks. Will check it out again in the future

This was my second visit and it was really good again. My only complaint is the place smells a little! When you walk in the door you get hit with this stale beer smell! Good is really good at reasonable prices!! Had wings both time there and they were really good!! Burgers are very big and I recommend upgrading to the waffle fries!!! I got the grilled Reuben this time and it had a TON of corned beef on it! Very good!!! I think this is one of the best places in town! read more

McGillicuddy's - Reuben-soooooo good - Sports Bars Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

It is the staple of the New Paltz community. Great place to get food with the family, to catch up with old college friends, and even a good place for the local nightlife. Great little spot for anyone who wants to experience a unique New Paltz. read more

after a day of hiking at Mohawk we were looking for a bite to eat. driving by it said outside seating and we were sold. it was 2 adults, 2 kids and a toddler. The manager came out with a treasure chest of toys for them to pick from, great touch to keep the kids happy. Overall the food was very good and the service just as attentive. read more

Great place BEER to hang out, listen BEER to music, take in some of the local sights, and EAT ! BEER Great food! The Mac & cheese is BEER awesome, and check out the Mac& cheeseburger picture! BEER The things about 8" tall!! BEER The Rueben was nice BEER & crunchy, with nice tender meat. Not rubberized BEER microwaved meat. Great food, great atmosphere, and did I mention GREAT BEER ? Municipal parking around the corner. read more

See all

What is going on at this place lately ? It's going downhill and fast . The food was always just OK nothing to rave about but this last visit was the worst . The management is embarrassing. The owner addresses nothing and leaves customers to speak to a 20 year old "manager" named Deanna who is constantly seen speaking/flirting with a male coworker leaving no other option but to leave a Yelp Review. The Fish sandwich tasted bad like the fish was actually bad . I did not eat it in fear of getting sick and the marinara on the kids pasta was thick and disgusting. When I complained and asked to speak to the manager not only was I charged for everything but she never came over . Until this place gets new help and a better manager for better customer service , we will not be returning . read more

What a find ! We came across new paltz on our way to Mohawk mountain house a few years back and put a pin in the map to return. This round we discovered McGillicuddys - sandwiched between the walkway and mountain house this deliciously friendly pub is a must go to for grill brew and deserts ! read more

McGillicuddy's - Dessert - Sports Bars Near Me - New Paltz, New York

McGillicuddy's is a spacious, clean, friendly pub. There is a parking lot directly behind the restaurant, which made it easy to get to and from. read more