Excellent little ice cream shop with fast lines and great service. Parking is limited and line can be a bit long but overall had a great summer experience as we ordered our cones and listened to some live music outside. Ice cream was very good, and would recommend for your next ice cream fix. read more

10/10 recommend. Ice cream, service, atmosphere, and ownership are all top notch / first class!

Love me Some McNulty's ice cream! This place is a staple in st James and a great place to take the kids to get ice cream in the summer. This place is always packed and they have a great selection of home made in house ice cream that a blow your socks off. Very good and no cutting corners making this amazing ice cream. If you're looking for a cool place to bring the kids for ice cream and want a do something different then carvel! McNulty's is the spot and you will not be disappointed! This place is a made house and always busy but the line goes fast. Great place with lots of history in the neighborhood. read more

I've visited McNulty's twice with my daughters, and while the ice cream itself is good, the customer service has been disappointing both times. The staff came across as unfriendly and uninterested, almost as if they didn't want to be there. Interactions felt very dry, and it seemed like basic questions or requests were met with annoyance. It's unfortunate because the quality of the ice cream would definitely bring us back, but the overall experience matters--especially when visiting with kids. I'm hoping this is something that can improve, as a more welcoming atmosphere would make a big difference. read more

6-29-25. Cute old school looking ice cream shop located in a residential area. It feels like you took a trip back in time (not with the prices, but the atmosphere itself). Plenty of your standard ice cream flavors to choose from in addition to a few limited sugar free options. The young staff were friendly and they definitely were more attentive then your average "Carvel" employee. A pleasant experience and a refreshing treat on a hot summer day. read more

What a great spot to have a delicious dessert ! Everything is fresh , it's just a delightful place !

We drive from our town to come to McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor. Port Jeff has so many ice cream spots, why Bill S, Why?! Because Yelper, McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor is truly a hometown business: The business employs teenagers who are working behind the counter McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor recognizes Veterans by offering a 10% discount American flags are everywhere, Merica! I have been bringing my family here for years. My son and I share a birthday month. McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor can take a picture and put it on an ice cream cake?? Every October, we order an ice cream cake with our picture on it. My youngest son, he had to be about 10 at the time, he tells me he doesn't like crunchies in our birthday cake. What?! Crunchies are the best part! We both like chocolate peanut butter so over the years we made it work. During the summer there are long lines so be prepared to wait outside after you get your ice cream. Inside there are a few tables inside but the action is outside. There are plenty of tables set up outside to enjoy your ice cream in our beautiful Long Island town. I'll usually drive one of my hot rods to McNulty's on a nice Saturday night. Typically one of the dads will come over to talk cars, it's a very family friendly spot. As far as ice cream? My wifes go to is one scoop of Coconut Almond, its her favorite. As for me, two scoops! Always one scoop of Rocky Road and the second scoop is a seasonal flavor. Last night, I chose a scoop of cookies and cream. McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor is a great neighborhood spot. Great ice cream with lots of family memories. read more

McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor - My two scoop creation - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Miller Place, New York

See all

Love this place for having my Only8 low-fat frozen yogurt. They have delicious homemade ice cream too! The pistachio is amazing! Cute little family run ice cream shop.There are Bench's to sit on outside or a few tables inside. They also carry take and go homemade ice cream cakes! read more

Pretty straight forward. Great ice cream and great selection. Service is fast, interior is clean and ice cream is yummy! read more

See all

This ice cream parlor is amazing. I have been coming here since I've been a kid and it has remained one of the best ice creams I've ever eaten the service is wonderful as well! Gail the owner made me a birthday cake with 3 different flavors and all the toppings. It was amazing!! I would recommend this place to anyone :) read more

Not your typical ice cream shop! Enjoy McNulty's delicious ice cream presented in a fun and creative way. Something for everyone, including frozen yogurt and dairy free ice cream. Staff is welcoming and helpful. Bright and cheerful atmosphere. This shop is a must try!!!!! read more

See all

What are you waiting for - go get the best local made icecream on the island. Massive scoops, & special seasonal flavors. This place also does so much for and with the community too (along with events for kiddos). Plenty of parking and outdoor seating. Their custom banana split cake with multiple flavored icecream is as a huge birthday party hit! - this is a place you shouldn't miss! They also have a trailer for house party calls. I bought a winter hat with their logo, just go. It's worth the long lines! read more

See all

Almost $9.00 for a medium size soft-serve vanilla yogurt with almond topping??? That's ridiculous. And, there were hardly any almonds added (they put them in the middle instead of on top, so they don't spill off. It would not have mattered, since there were so few) OVERPRICED AND VERY DISAPPOINTING read more

Yummy homemade ice cream with good service and a nostalgic vibe! This is right near cedar beach. See the sunset, then have ice cream at Mcnulty's, trust me. Enjoy. read more

See all

Everybody was very kind and helpful. Thank you mcnultys staff. The Ice cream was delicious

They didn't have a lot of flavors my family wanted but it's a cute ice cream place. Friendly and helpful staff pretty fast service. They don't fill my sisters cup all the way and it was all toppings barely any ice cream. Honestly very disappointed. read more

Absolutely the best ice cream experience I've had. I've been coming here for 20 + years and it always manages to get better each time. The quality is top notch & they always give generous amounts. The ambience is that of the classic ice cream shops of the 50's and 60's. Very homey feel. The staff are so up beat and pleasant to converse with. This spot is a 10 outta 10 and I highly recommend them if ya'll got a hankering for some ice cream read more

Finally tried McNulty's!!! Appreciate their late hours (11pm on a Saturday) along with their soda section since my fiancé was super thirsty. Ice cream was delicious and HOMEMADE!!!! If you're in the area, be sure to check this place out! read more

See all

Great variety of ice cream and deserts. Great after a day at the beach out and about. Service is always great and fast. Soft serve is delicious and they have a great amount of available customizations for your ice cream. Great outdoor seating too. read more

The staff behind the counter were young, pleasant, and more than helpful!! McNulty's is a cute local ice cream parlor, with a small-town vibe. (Just what I had been looking for!) They had some seating inside as well as outdoors, which was perfect on the night I was there. I went in with one thing in mind, but by the time I ordered, the lady next to me had the most amazing looking cone...I ended up ordering just as she had! (I believe it was the Chocolate Almond ice cream...yummy!!) I had been in the vicinity, but ended up traveling a little further west to visit McNulty's and I was very pleased with my discovery!! read more

How this place only has an average of 3 Stars bewilders me. I guess people don't get the old fashioned ice cream shop concept. Yes that's what this is. Let's get a couple of things out of the way first. The parking lot is gravel and can be a little difficult entering and exiting but if you slow down and position your car it will be fine. Second, cash only. Don't get me started on why but it is what it is and you're not spending $100 on ice cream so don't whine. Ok now that we have all of that out of the way let's talk ice cream. All kinds of flavors both soft and hard ice cream. All types of toppings and hot fudge... hmmmmm. Banana splits, sundaes, the whole gammit of specialty ice cream. I recently found out they do that edible picture on a cake. Could have used that a couple of months ago. Mostly young kids here, so I convince my grandkids to go so I fit in without looking silly. Not to hard to convince them either. So fill your pocket with some cash drive slowly so you can get into the parking lot and enjoy some of the best ice cream around. read more

McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Miller Place, New York

Went at an off time no wait service was good selection was large I was happy with my sundae. Ice cream flavors were yummy

First of all, great service! The lady behind the counter was friendly and working hard while being extremely pleasant and cheerful. But it's all about the ice cream people. I haven't tried every flavor they have but I don't get the hype. Very bland ice cream! and the consistency isn't really all that rich. Tastes like cheap grocery store brand ice cream to me!! And it's expensive-ish. Lastly, the size small is TOO BIG. One probably wonders why would I complain about THAT? I'd rather pay 5 bucks for a good single scoop than have to pay 7.60 for a small size cone where the cone can't even handle all the ice cream on it! Anyway it's a cute vibe and I get the whole let's go out for ice cream thing, but the ice cream ain't all that. read more

Amazing ice cream! So many different choices of flavors. Super friendly and polite staff.

Love this place!! From the moment you pull up, they have great curb appeal. Very cute place!! Inside is just as cute!! Clean and clearly lots of pride!! Ice cream was soooo good! Not overly sweet. Not too rich. And Good flavor. Lots of variety on the menu. Looking forward to going back! read more

Strong recommendation for the seasonal flavors. The fruits flavor is not that strong but I like the mixed light taste which is just the summer ;p read more

See all

McNulty's is a cute little ice cream store way up north in Miller Place. I really enjoyed the country vibe of North Country Road. McNulty's stands out along the non commercial tree lined road. Ice cream is homemade with many flavors, nothing too edgy. Friendly young people offering to let you taste first . Not needed as it was easy to pick a few : ). Took home a mixed pint and had a mixed flavor cone to go. All good. Is their bright green pistachio my idea of amazing .. well no.. was the chocolate dark in color.. uhm a bit light.. but the flavor was fine. It was clean inside, cheerful and everything tasted exceptionally fresh as this place seems to move its product. So worth stopping in when near there or surrounding towns. Three and a half stars. ========= CASH ONLY - No ATM ========= read more

See all

Great ice cream. However if you care about health I would not recommend. Corn syrup is one of the top ingredients. As well as many other artificial ingredients and dyes. I wish that they'd offer ice cream without high fructose corn syrup. read more

i grew up as a child going to mcnultys. I used to ride my bicycle there with my family and enjoy amazing sundaes and nice cream flavors that when ordered I received the correct item. the past 6x I have ordered from there the order has been incorrect or it has been cancelled without any means of contact to inform me. I am truly disappointed with the customer service and the lack of attention that the employees have, or should I say do not have. I would not recommend this place anyone more and you have lost life long customers bc of this read more

Ice cream is always delicious! The only catch is that the prices are pretty steep. Enjoy!

Pretty surprised to see a 3 star rating for a place that always has a line out the door, is involved in the community and is usually the first place young teens go to get their first job. I've always had pleasant experiences as long as I can remember and tonight, they put the icing on the cake. I called in right before they closed at 9:45 to see if they had mint Oreo ice cream and if so I'd be right in. The young man on the phone told me yes they did. Being that I only live a minute down the road I drove there about 3 minutes after the call. I got there just in time and shared excitedly I only wanted Mcnultys ice cream, since I just got my wisdom teeth removed, only to be told it was cash only. Disappointedly (in myself and the situation, not them) I left the store, not wanting to hold them up any longer by going to get cash. (At this point it was about 9:55 I get a call as soon as I get home from the young man at the counter who must have retrieved my number through the caller ID. He told me "The owner said it's ok, and for you to come back and just take the ice cream." I was so touched by this act of kindness. I wound up going back wth money anyway since I was home, but needed to shout this place out in reciprocation for their compassion. Bravo McNulty's! read more

Lovely place. Small town feel. Great ice-cream. Vegan flavors available. Great service

Have been coming here my whole life, at least once a week during the summers with my family. Great atmosphere and the line usually moves pretty quickly. Ice cream is usually very good. I have never had any issues up until the last two weeks, I'm not lactose intolerant- my ice cream tasted kinda sour last time and I thought nothing of it but got super sick after. My dad, who ordered something different too, got so sick after he ate his as well. Thought maybe it was something else and went the week after again but got sick AGAIN, so did my Dad. AGAIN. Not going to be trying it again for a long while. Also not to be all Karen, but the manager/owner was there both times these past couple weeks that we've gone and they were so intense to the workers, such a tense and stressful vibe that emitted through the whole store. I was scared and stressed for the workers and felt like at any moment the manager would try to hover and find something wrong or fight with someone. If you work here, God bless-I'm sure it builds great work ethic but that's not the vibe you want when it's just ice cream. read more

Cute place with indoor and outdoor dining. Delicious, creamy homemade ice cream with definitely have me coming back for more.

Charming little ice cream joint that has been around for quite a while serving the local area. Used to be better. The staff is still a bunch of nice polite kids, but the quality of the ice cream seems to have gone down a notch or two. Homemade (or at least it used to be) with plenty of flavors to choose from yet out of the three I had in my sundae none really stood out among the mint chip, vanilla peanut butter, and butter pecan. I mean, it was ok but didn't wow me. Kind of bland. Still, it's a decent bet on a wam summer day to grab a cone or cup of ice cream and sit on their patio enjoying a cold treat. Some tables inside but can get pretty busy and full as it's a small place. Also, the parking lot is just as tiny so be prepared to park along the busy street when it's crowded. Cash only is kind of a drag though. Especially if you're paying for the group and the tab is close to $30. read more

The number of times I've placed an order long before their closing time, only to have it cancelled, is extremely disappointing.

We've been coming here for years! My favorite is the black raspberry ice cream with little chocolate raspberry candies inside, which I order every time. Also we ordered the heath ice cream. Alas, another Long Island ice cream parlor that DOESN'T USE GLOVES when scooping the ice cream, right after handling money. We were anticipating this, and rather than embarrassing the poor chap who was working back there all alone, we opted to order our ice cream in cups. Am I the only one who takes issue with this uncleanly practice? Perhaps they wrap the cone in a napkin, but still, hands are very dirty after handling money so please at least (if you're not going to wear gloves), WASH YOUR HANDS before handling food. It's as bad as not washing after using the bathroom. Seems like a Health Department issue. At any rate, the ice cream tasted great as always, but the owner of this place should really consider instructing their employees on how to be as cleanly as possible. Also how to be as friendly as possible, as this young man did not make us feel welcome, nor did he smile at all during his interaction with us. read more

Best ice cream this side of Italy. I'm in my 30's and have gone here every summer since I was a kid and now do so with my daughter.

I came here after dinner as a family member recommended I take my 2 children for "the best ice cream around here" the ice cream sure looked delicious for this dessert lover. Selection selection selection.. they had a huge variety with waffle cones waffle bowls and a gigantic selection of toppers. I went with a waffle cone with chocolate and couldn't be happier. The kids each got a cookie dough as that's their new favorite of the week they scarfed it down faster than me! The Parking lot is very big and they have plenty of outdoor seating and a few indoor tables as well. The staff member I dealt with wasn't the most welcoming or nice person I asked a question and got a nasty "if you let me finish you wouldn't have a question" I shrugged it off but then she continued to show no interest or passion... she range me up and I asked how much a second time and she clearly was upset and barked 17 and change... she was wearing a thick mask and it was hard to hear her. 4/5 ice cream 2/5 service. read more

When I first moved to the area this was one of the places I was told to try. A year later and multiple visits I can say Mcnultys really is a treat. Great service & great ice cream. read more