I keep giving Mellow Mushroom a chance and they keep breaking my heart. Sat at the bar. A small pizza and a glass of wine. Didn't catch the bartenders name but she was definitely slammed and hustling. My pizza...Thai dye. Should have had curried chicken, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions. So so lacking on toppings. I had about 7 pieces of chicken on a small pie. Not good for what I paid. read more

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg - Thai dye pie. Hardly any toppings. - Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Ordered the holy shiitake pizza, four to five thin slices of mushroom for an entire pizza, some slices had zero mushrooms. I've ordered this at several Mellow Mushrooms before, they actually put mushrooms on their holy shitake pizza. Disappointed when the feature of the actual pizza is mushrooms! read more

10/10 dining experience overall. I ordered a TOGO Shiitake pizza from Hannah and she personally assured a high quality pizza. When my pizza arrived, it was absolutely scrumptious. Out of all the monumental moments in my life (weddings, funerals, vacations), the time I took my first bite of Shiitake remains at the top of the list. Manager Kennedy was super sweet and delivered impeccable customer service. The ambiance of the restaurant was peaceful, yet alive thanks to the amazing and caring staff read more

The vibe of the place is amazing! We had the Avocado hoagie and Cheese pizza. They tasted good and fresh. Service is good.

Mellow mushroom Fredericksburg is my local pizza place and go figure I go to Williamsburg only to get more mellow mushroom. Love their shiitake pie / hands down the best pie they have!!!! Not a fan of their veggie one but that could just be my taste buds. Go try this place if you haven't already!!! read more

Came to Williamsburg for work and was told the mellow mushroom was the spot for pizza. I'm glad I listened because they weren't messing around! I ordered hot wings and a small holly shiitake plus added pepperoni to it. The pizza was way better than I could have imagined.The pizza crust was soft and chewy with just the right amount of crunch. The sauce, mushrooms, and the pepperoni tasted awesome. It's hard for me to believe that this is a chain restaurant. The service was fast and often and our drinks never had the chance to get empty. The waitress was friendly and attentive to our every need. The store has photos and decoration's that seemed straight out of the Beatles yellow submarine movie or a Grateful Dead show. I loved it! The wait staff wore super cool tidied shirts ( sold them in house also) and all looked like they loved their jobs. If I had more time in town I would go back. Don't sleep on it if you run into one! read more

See all

Amazing Pizza! Delicious and Unique. The crust is awesome! The Holy Shiitake pie was so good and even just the cheese pizza! Love it! Will be back for sure! Good service too! read more

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg - Holy Shiitake - Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Service was excellent. Pizza topping was enjoyable, but the crust was just too thin and wimpy. ( I see they have a thick crazy option... I would recut!) What kept this from a 4 star review was the coffee/ tea problem. They were out of coffee, the server said they had tea in a " big" teabag. It was literally the size of a rolled up pair of socks, soaked up and cooled the water in the cup. I was left with a third of a cup of lukewarm something. read more

Great food, ambiance and service stuff. But the utensils and plates that were served to us were super dirty, makes me think how bad the hygiene in the kitchen would be. Utensils were rolled in a napkin so should have seen it while doing that. Probably too lazy to clean and wipe them. read more

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg - Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

So Gooood a must try!!! Came here after watching the Fireworks for Illumination, had a long wait but it was so worth it!! read more

See all

This place is terrible. It doesn't help that it is overpriced and the GF pizza is floppy and gross. What's worse is that my wife orders it just to order something and then just eats the cheese. $20 for some lukewarm mozzarella. read more

My friends and I came to Mellow Mushroom for dinner, and I was a huge fan! I ordered a pizza that was half Veg Out and half Merry Prankster. I also ordered it with the vegan cheese option, which I appreciated that I could do with no extra cost. The pizza was delicious! I liked the Veg Out half more than the Merry Prankster one, but I would definitely order both again. I also tried a bite of the Holy Shiitake Pie pizza, which my friend ordered, and thought it was very tasty. There's a fair amount of indoor seating and we had no trouble getting a table on a Friday night. The pizzas came out pretty quickly and the server we had was great. Would definitely recommend this for a fun pizza night! read more

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg - Veg Out and Merry Prankster - Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Nice family atmosphere for having lunch. I ordered a hamburger with lettuce, tomato, pickles, and I paid extra for fried onions, fried mushrooms. Order came with tater tots. Bruschetta very tasty, bread was a little soft. Pretzel bites with dipping sauces was delicious. Wings were scrumptious. The waitress was very knowledgeable about the food on the menu. read more

See all

Great Pizza! I would highly recommend mellow mushrooms! Portion size is large! The service friendly as usual. read more

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg - Holy Shitake - Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Definitely recommend! Excellent pizza, wings and drinks. The vibe is great. Inside and outside are both super cool. Even our waiter had a total mellow mushroom vibe. Everything done the the napkins were cute. We tried 3 different pizza and all three were great. We found the bbq chicken the most amazing tho. The wings were fantastic with a creamy sauce and fresh veggies on the side. We got a pitcher of red sangria which was fab, and the kids got French lemonade also really yummy! The only negative thing I can say about this place is that it took long. Long wait for table and food, but with obvious good reason. That didn't affect my 5 star rating, we weren't in a rush anyway! read more

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg - 3 small pies. Hawaiian, all the meats and bbq chicken. Wish I could remember the cool names on the menu for them! - Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Food was very tasty! We ordered meatball for my kids to share. They can be picky so I was not expecting them to devour the meatballs! They were gone before I can get a bite. Their pizza is also delicious. Garlic breadsticks were incredible! My Greek salad was virtually appealing and tasty. Our waitress was also very good and helpful. They have a large outside seating area. Overall if you are at Colonial Williamsburg and looking for a good place to it, try this place! You won't regret it. read more

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg - Greek salad! - Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

This a great pizza place to check out when in Williamsburg. Great energy inside and great decor. We came in for a late dinner and tables were still filled. Our waitress was super nice and helpful. We ordered some drinks and apps, and they came out in a good time. Everything was delicious. We all ended up ordering more drinks since they were so good. Then came our pizza and salad. Pizzas were piping hot and smelled delicious. Both pizzas were so flavorful and appetizing. The salad was nice, crisp and refreshing. By the end of it we were stuffed and happy. read more

See all

TIP: Make sure you check-in here on YELP when you arrive & you can get an order of FREE pretzel bites with a pizza order. It will give you a code and ask you if you want to use it now or later. Just show your code to the server to use at that moment. WIN WIN! Now, to get back to your most pressing questions. YES-there will most likely be a line for your party to be seated (times will vary depending on how many people in your party), unless you go to the bar and find an open spot (what we did). YES-you WILL fall in love with thier Cloud 9 wingz. YES- their pizza is also worth writing about too (Merry Prankster-muy bien). We ended up here b/c just about every other place around Colonial area was busy at peak dinner time and we needed to go somewhere we could sneak in to get something to eat before our ghost tour. We put our names in but was able to get a spot at the bar before we were called. Had a lil over an hour to eat and get to our destination with enough time to spare. WHen we sat down, our wonderful bartender/server took care of us the whole time there. we ordered a few drinks and then the Cloud 9 wingz, Merry Pranksters pizza (thin crust), and salad. We also got an order of the free pretzel bites (Thank you Yelp). The Cloud 9 wingz are incredible. Double fried & very flavorful. The salad is just that. My gf was eating my wingz after her salad. go figure. The pizza was also great, I had a piece and then took the rest home. We got the smallest pizza which had 4 pieces. They have lots of outdoor seating, perfect for the upcoming summer months. They are equipped with heaters right now so you can sit out there now on a chillier nite. Before we came back to Jer-Z. I put 2 orders for pickup at Mellow for the wingz, just as good. Great experience & great food! Very pleased! read more

We stayed at Great Wolf Lodge and ventured out for dinner. We enjoyed our dinner so much the first night, we came back for dinner again the next night! We ordered two pizzas and apps the first time, and burgers and salads the next day. The pretzel bites are AMAZING. We devoured them both times. They aren't traditional pretzels, more like tiny breadsticks. Service was great, the staff was very nice, and the food was delicious! We'll definitely come back when we're in the area! read more

See all

We ordered from a Williamsburg Inn home. They do not deliver so we had to drive there. Thin pepperoni with cheese and sweet honey mustard, Delicious! Highly recommend! We arrived, pizza was hot and ready to go with plates, and silverware. I wish you'd deliver someday! read more

What a great way to wind down a wonderful graduation day for my niece that started in Richmond with her ceremony and followed with a casual and relaxing dinner in Williamsburg! Given how large our party was (15 people), we ate out on the patio. The weather and Colonial willliamsburg provided such a nice backdrop to a wonderful evening! There were plenty of choices from which to choose, so everyone was quite happy! I ordered the Cloud-9 naked wings with Thai chili on the side. The wings were perfectly crunchy on the outside and tender on the inside,paired with the Thai chili sauce and it was delectable!! We then had cake from Whole Foods for dessert in celebration of my niece's graduation ‍ to top it off!! The service was prompt and friendly, considering how large our party was and on a Saturday night!! The staff was very accommodating and even allowed several people in our party to use the Yelp coupon/discount offers from their apps! This was certainly one of the most fun and memorable times where everyone got together and enjoyed a great celebration in such a relaxed setting!!! I highly recommend this place for large parties in a quaint yet cozy outdoor setting!!! read more

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg - the entrance to the restaurant - Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Pizza and water parks. What could be a better combo? Venturing out for food we could afford for a decent price, we found ourselves here. We came later at night, but it looks like parking could be an issue at high peak times. Easily sat our party of 6. Server was friendly but as the restaurant got more traffic, she became less attentive to us, and we'd sit waiting for napkins, boxes, and even the check. The buffalo chicken dip was heavenly. It was smooth, melt in your mouth dip with perfectly crisp mini garlic toasts. The kids loved the garlic toasts, so when we ran out, the celery wasn't a bad touch either. The bacon included in the dip was plentiful and in the perfect middle of crisp, but limp. It wasn't incredibly spicy, as my husband could handle it and even wanted more. The loaded potato pizza was different. The way the menu described it, my mouth started watering. When I took a couple bites, I just wasn't impressed. I felt it was mostly crust, but it got rave reviews from my husband and brother. The funky q chicken was bomb. Incredibly flavorful, perfect amount of barbecue, and ingredients spread out evenly. I was really skeptical because while I don't mind barbecue, I didn't want my pizza drowned in it. I originally vetoed this pizza, but glad we tried it. It was easily my favorite of the two. On Mondays they have a man who comes around and makes balloon animals for the kids. I believe he's there from 6-8. He made my kiddo a mermaid, a bear holding a heart, and a cool dinosaur hat. Kept them well behaved for the rest of dinner. The owner even came around as we were finishing up, introduced himself, and asked if we needed anything. They do offer military discount as well. read more

See all

Pizza and pretzel bites were very good. The meatballs and green salad looked great as well. It was a good location with good service and decent prefixes for a tourist town. read more

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg - House Special - Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

We had the pretzel bites and Great White Pizza. It was really good. I think I should have asked for the spicy cheese for the pretzel bites, but it is what it is. You should also keep the extra cheese for the pizza crust. The service was excellent. It is kind of a loud place, but not extreme. It's like any food place that has outdoor seating. read more

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg - Great White Pizza - Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

I went to mellow mushroom and had a horrible experience I got the text saying my table was ready and walked up to the host stand. When I got there the host was fully ignoring me and my party and helping other people. I kept trying to get her attention but she was not responding. The drink I got had so much salt in it and it was really disgusting I do not recommend coming here. The food was was undercooked and mostly raw. read more

I've seen Mellow Mushrooms in Florida when visiting my parents, but always steered clear because I'm not really into chain restaurants. My daughter and I decided to give this one a chance. She got the magic mushroom soup and it was the best mushroom soup that we've ever had. I got the house special pizza. That sucker was loaded and tasted soooo good. If I had a Mellow Mushrrom in my area, I would be a regular. Definitely go here if you get a chance, you won't be disappointed. read more

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg - House Special - Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Absolutely DELICIOUS pizza! We loved the taste so much we gave serious thought to opting into the franchise to bring one to our city. Then we remembered we're poor. Will have to settle for vacationing in areas with this restaurant. read more

We ate there twice during our trip to Williamsburg. We had pizza the first time and burgers the next. Food is great and the staff were attentive and friendly. read more

We needed a place to have dinner that was air conditioned, did not require a reservation, was reasonably priced, and not too far from our exploration around Colonial Williamsburg. We were seated promptly and the server was friendly. I got their Holy Shiitake and my husband built his own. We also got some classic hot wings. Food was hot and everything was really good. I'm a big guy and a small was plenty of pizza for me. read more

If you're after the familiar Mellow Mushroom menu with unique, tasty items, you won't be disappointed with this version of Mellow Mushroom! They've got a nice outside seating area overlooking a bustling parking lot. If car watching is your thing, you're in luck! Don't let the host/hostess seat you near the edge of the patio, though - you'll be watching cars all day while waiting for someone to take your order. The menu is just like you've seen before.... read more

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg - Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

9/28/21 On 9/19/21 we spent our second to last day in Colonial Williamsburg.  We saw this restaurant on the first day and this time around, decided to eat here. The air conditioning system was cranking out cold air and I would have been cold if not for the long sleeve Baltimore Ravens mock turtleneck shirt I was wearing.   The store has a lot of things to take pictures of and I took them.  We saw some people still wearing face masks, but not everyone  was following the parks guidelines.    The restaurant was very busy, but we decided to wait the 15 to 30 minute wait.  When we were finally lead to our table, the look of the seats would be hard on my ass and the people I was with. We decided to see if we could get the open booth we passed.  I asked a waiter near us and she lead us to the booth after it was cleaned and sanitized.  The table was open ended on both sides and we could see the Raiders vs Pittsburgh Steelers.   The food we ordered was delicious,  but The Steelers were not having such  good time.   By checking in through Yelp, we were given the opportunity to try a free order of the pretizal balls aka cheese balls... ...get your mind out of the gutter.  Yes, these cheese balls were tasty. We all ended up having a pizza to keep our order simple.  It did not take us long to get filled up on the pizza, but carrying around the pizza while walking around Colonial Williamsburg was not ideal.  We ended up eating the whole pizza. Our waiter had a great personality and great vibe.  We made sure he received a great tip from us. I recommend coming here at least once while visiting Colonial Williamsburg. read more

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg - 9/19/21 Time for lunch, but there is a 30 minute. "Is it worth it? Let me work it"... and I'll tell what I think. - Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

I've been wanting to try this kitschy, flower power, vibe restaurant (glass beaded curtains anyone?) for awhile and yesterday we were in town to visit my son who's at W&M, so we popped in. They offered outdoor seating, and while the heaters were wonderful, there was too much chill in the air so maybe next time. The service was great! Hosts at the door were friendly and funny and we got seated quickly. Our server was great! I can't remember her name but she bears a resemblance to Miley Cyrus so, Miley, you rocked. She made good suggestions and gave us info since we were first timers. Onto the food. We had a Cobb salad, a small Great White, and a small personalized pizza. We also ordered pretzel bites ,which were were extremely delicious and filling! We got beer cheese. I liked it - we all did. The salad is huge. If you want a nice dinner salad, I doubt you can go wrong with any of their salad choices. You won't want anything else! The pizzas were amazing. It's so hard to find a good white pizza. Theirs is great, with fresh garlic and olive oil, tomatoes, and pepper dews. And of course loads of ricotta and mozzarella cheese. It tasted like Saturday night at your Italian grandmas house. The other pizza we got had thick pepperoni, red sauce, mozzarella, and feta. The best part of both pizzas was the crust. Crispy, crunchy, and chewy. The pizza bites were so good, too. I've decided this restaurant does bread well!! 5/5 will go back after graduation and sit outside. read more

See all

Ordered a large pepperoni and wings, this is what was delivered burnt wings and a clearly vegetarian pizza, about as from pepperoni as possible. Should have just called dominos or flushed the $43 bucks down the toilet. Called to tell them that they sent the wrong pizza, they blamed Grubhub, put my wife on hold and never picked up again. This place deserves a zero, they clearly do not understand anything about customer service. Everyone makes mistakes, decent human beings, and decent business people own up to their mistakes and offer an apology, even if they don't mean it. I would avoid this place at all costs. Update: I was notified via Yelp by the owner that he would issue a refund, which is much appreciated. Hopefully, his staff will check the orders better next time before they are delivered. read more

See all

Nice atmosphere, Big city vibe small town feel. We chose to dine outside. Nice varierty of drinks Pizza was great tasting I got a thin crust pepperoni, it was perfection. Service was friendly not too over the top. Pretzel bites were awesome for an appetizer. I will come baxk next time I'm here. read more

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg - Thin Crust Pepperoni Pizza - Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Our friend took us here to see the historic area of Williamsburg. It was very interesting and a beautiful place. He also stated that he knew of a great pizza place that he wanted us to try and Mellow Mushroom we went! There's parking everywhere around the establishment so that wasn't an issue at all. Once we arrived inside we were quickly greeted and seated. You could smell the deliciousness in the air. Our waiter was very friendly and gave us recommendations and told us to definitely get the pretzel bites with beer cheese. How could we not. We ordered the Holy Shiitake and the Mighty Meaty pizzas along with the pretzel bites and some drinks. Once the food arrived it was mind blowing!!! The bites were phenomenal and the pizzas were just as good!! I couldn't stop eating them even when I was fool!! Even if the Shiitake Pizza had no meat it was amazing!!! A definite must try!!! The cleanliness of the restaurant was good and so was the bathrooms. We had a great overall experience and if you are in the mood for pizza and a great time with friends and family, that this place is a must!! read more

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg - Menu - Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

I love mellow in any state, my son suggested this spot for a quick dinner. This restaurant is in a big building along with other restaurants. We were told there would be a 45min wait but we were seated in about 25mins. This restaurant was really nice & clean, customer service was good. Would visit again if in the area read more

Table of 8 on busy holiday, so we knew we needed to be chill. No problem waiting 40 minutes for a table - this is an annual tradition. Appetizers arrived at table with out plates or utensils - those came 12-15 minutes later after we asked twice, dip was cold. Food runners kept bringing food to our table that wasn't ours. Forgotten chicken for chicken Greek salad arrived 30 minutes after the salad arrived and server was asked 2x about it and then walked to front to alert manager once after that. Requested drinks, pepper and other things multiple times before they arrived. Attempting to pay we waited 10 minute for server, gave up and took to front where I was told I need to go find the server, they couldn't ring us up in the front. Really sad and frustrated - family looks forward to this every year. This all seemed systemic - hopefully new or improved management next year. read more

Fun, family atmosphere, excellent service, quality food and drink. I highly recommend. A special recognition to Brooke who served us, and was absolutely the highlight of our evening with her huge heart and welcoming smile. She took care of our kids and my wife and me after a sudden storm drove us inside. She was challenged by the sudden crowd but made us feel like we were her only table. read more

We were excited to try Mellow here in Williamsburg since we've never been to this location. We've enjoyed the other locations we've been to. We were sat down immediately, however, after about 10 minutes we had to walk up to the host to ask for our server; no one had came to us. Disclaimer: we were sitting right in front of the bar and several servers passed us but did not come to our table. We asked to move to another area if it was going to take much longer since the bar area was a bit too loud. After moving to another section in the back, our server went ahead and took our order. When I checked in, Yelp gave us a free pretzel bite appetizer. This made us super happy and the spicy beer cheese was delicious! Hubby ordered a mushroom soup, wedge salad, and a small holy shittake pizza. I ordered a small sausage and mushroom pizza. Everything was good. We would probably come back when in the area, but we will make sure it's not during peak hours. read more

See all

A great marriage of psychedelic and Italian... what a trip! The pizza at Mellow Mushroom is surprisingly awesome! I ordered the "HOLY SHIITAKE PIE" and holy shiitake was the flavor yummy! There were three types of mushrooms on this pizza, drizzled with truffle oil and a garlic aioli sauce. I am very critical when it comes to pizza and this was one of the best pizzas I have ever had. The ambience was straight from the 70s and the vibe was warm and cozy! read more