I had the melt shop years ago and loved it. When i stumbled across it while shopping at woodbury commons, I had to get it! This is located in their food court. I got the grilled cheese and parmasen tots. Both were as good and delicious as I remembered. One of the best grilled cheeses ever! Food came out and quick and was tasty. Staff was also very friendly. It seemed like their menu is bigger now than I remembered, will have to try other stuff next time. read more

Melt Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

This was my first experience with Melt Shop while shopping at Woodbury. I went with a grilled cheese, fries and Mac and Cheese. I'm glad I went with the Mac because the portion of fries was relatively small. Nonetheless, the process to early was simple, the staff was courteous, and they didn't take very long to make it. I found the grilled cheese to be adequate and the Macaroni was good, but to my surprise, it was cold. The store had not been open very long and I wondered it was cold-- it was still tasty though. I see a lot of complaints about prices-- however, since I'm from NYC, it's right on par. read more

See all

The mozzarella sticks were tasty and the chicken Melt was decent. The melt is not as good when it cools down because the cheese hardens up a lot. The Food took about 8 minutes to cook even though there was only one person ahead of me. The cashier was fast and offered suggestions. The dining area is very loud and can be crowded. Not a bad option when visiting the Commons.... read more

Melt Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

See all

First, you pay a premium eating at Woodbury. A Big Mac meal at McDonald's is $14. The shop bacon cheeseburger was about $16. It says it's made from Waygu beef though it is definitely better than a Big Mac but it is just an ok burger for me, not one that costs $16 or even $10. Service was almost non-existence due to staff shortage. The guy who ran the register had to go back to kitchen to help to get the orders out and there are only 2 other guys who worked there. Our fries were fresh but the burger was not ready so when we got our order the fries were no longer fresh. Management can definitely do better with staffing. I understand this is at a food court but if you are charging a premium on food, I think you should try to do a little better to earn your business. read more

See all

Got some lunch from here on our day trip to Woodbury commons. Not too many people, easy to put in an order quickly. The menu looks mouthwatering. But when I got my chicken sandwich, it was utter disappointment. Just plain bread, with a piece of chicken and barely some mayo on it, just to check off the box. The picture in the menu had no resemblance of what I was served. I did order a chocolate shake too. It was little better than quality than the sandwich. read more

See all

Located in the food court of Woodbury Commons. Friendly staff and clean. The line moved quickly and didn't have to wait too long for the food. It was all good. Sadly, most of the cheese settled at the bottom of the tots. read more

Melt Shop - Cheesy tots - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

Lady at the counter was rude and seemed like she couldn't care less if she was working or not. Asked specifically for no burger sauce. I asked to confirm and she didn't acknowledge. When the order came out, sure enough had that on the burger. Then when I asked her for refund she was so nonchalant about it (probably does it multiple times a day from customers who are not happy). Too many other options in this food court to go here. Avoid. read more

A good number of food options at this large food court. I picked the melt shop because I specifically wanted a plant based burger. Sadly it was very average. Not bad, just pretty bland and the bun seemed slightly stale. Next time I'd probably just get a slice of pizza next door or his the McDonalds. read more

Melt Shop - Salad with crispy chicken - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

See all

Food court atmosphere, outlet high prices, but can't go too wrong with cheese and bread We enjoyed the lunch of grilled cheese and crispy chicken sandwich. They were very messy to eat and very oily, but what do you expect? Also the staff don't seem to engaged (yes food court). read more

Pull The cameras for Location LGA6MLSH, ORDER ID 414921, POS ORDER ID 2856, DATE 12/21/2025, Time 8:24PM. There were 4 or 5 workers behind the counter. they were/performed: Rude Customer service. Did not acknowledge customer. Gathered in group, having a loud boisterous conversation with lots of laughs, still not paying attention or looking to see if there were customers. The female was the rudest of all. After a long while she did glance in the direction, but never even said hello or anything. I finally interrupted and asked the female if my food was even being made, she got annoyed at that, but she said yes after the second time I asked. A few minutes later, my food was ready, the older guy had been the one to cook the food. The female handed my food to me, and was then acknowledging me, when I was leaving, but by this time, but it was way to little way too late. This is so sad... The workers should have been at stations, not gathered around just BS'ing, There should have been one or two workers that as soon as a customer walks up, those workers instantly acknowledge the customer. Throughout the process, a worker without having to be asked, should let the customer know that their food is being prepared and would be out shortly. At a minimum, the workers should have said, Hello, I can help you or you can order at the kiosk, your food is being prepared now and will be out shortly, thank you for ordering from the Melt Shop, enjoy your food and have a nice day. Last thing, I only went to the Melt Shop because there was no one there getting food, and all the other places in the terminal to eat had lines. You should be asking yourselves why you were not getting customers, maybe its because the workers were being so loud and boisterous that no one else wanted to deal with them. Maybe in order to save labor, you may want to rethink the amount of workers you have there at that time, only one person was working while the others were stealing time. and not providing the service they were hired to provide. I will give props to the older worker, he made a great sandwhich. read more

Melt Shop is a solid place for fast food if you love cheese and sandwich. We were there without many choices in the food court of Woodbury Outlet. The staff was rude, reluctant and served everything slowly. There was a long line during lunch time but the staff did not have a sense of urgency and just talked to each other. We had their signature chicken sandwich - Nashville Hot Chicken and 3 pieces of chicken strips with hot honey sauce and fries. The food was overall not bad and we love the hot honey sauce, which was super appetizing. The fries were overcooked, dry and greasy. read more

See all

So disappointed. My korean bbq burger sounded so good on the menu. Well, I unwrapped my burger but it looked like it was squished by someone mistaking it for making a snowball. Inside, the burger was drenched with a salty imitation korean sauce. I couldn't even taste the coleslaw nor even see it under the dark salty sauce. Maybe I'll have better luck with different choice next time read more

Melt Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

See all

Food was substandard for the price charged. Cook clumsily dropped my burger on the floor, and it remained there until the moment I left. On the second burger, he danced with the spatula and burger while looking at me as "look how talented I am and I don't drop it twice". read more

Melt Shop - Burger on the floor next to the cook. - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

My favorite food court meal that I can remember. Eager to try something new, I chose the Meltshop. The veggie sandwich was fabulous: roasted sun dried tomatoes an mushrooms, fresh arugula, goat cheese and Muenster on hearty whole grain. Young man at the register had eaten the sandwich previously so could respond to my questions so I took the risk and ordered. My thoughts: I love the flavor and would have eaten three more if given the opportunity. It's a sandwich portion but sooooo tasty. I LIKE goat cheese so I did not find it over/powering. I did not deconstruct to examine but it seemed a bit light on the shrooms. The arugula provides a bright peppery note. The only negative - mine got a bit shook in transit and did not look as pretty as possible when the box opened. I will be back. And I will order this. PS - a bit confused - is there a space between words (like on bag) or not (like on sign). Just a branding issue. read more

See all

I was looking to get out of the city today and figured I'd head north and explore different areas. I saw the Melt Shop right around where I wanted to explore so I thought it would be the perfect destination and I'd just make the rest of my day revolve around this food! Almost 2 hours later I arrive and the damn place is closed!!! Lights out closed! It says it opens mid-day today and has hours listed!! Only a small section on their site discloses it's temporarily closed.... after the fact for me. So I got the next best thing, Chipotle With free double guac... that was nice!!! Anyways..... it really messed up my day and I will try to correct the yelp and google listings to closed. I was going to order 4 sandwiches too and take them home to have for the next few days too.... really bummed!! read more

Melt Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

Very short staffed. 3 employees to manage the whole store on Labor Day Weekend is just unfair to the employees. One was handling the cashier while the other 2 were running around making food. Order took 20 minutes. Poor management. read more

When selecting 5 Stars Yelp illuminates a confirmation that says, and I quote, "Woohoo! As good as it gets!" Is Melt Shop really, Woohoo, As good as it gets? No, not even close. However, in so far as food courts go, Melt Shop sits firmly atop the pile making them the Woohoo, As good as it gets in that particular genre. Now, I'll go one step farther and declare their BLT on of the best I've ever eaten and folks, I've eaten a crapload of BLTs. Bread is beautifully artisanal, lettuce, cold fresh and crisp, tomatoes ripe and delicious and bacon that's absolutely spectacular. Now, in interest of full disclosure, food court food generally sucks so the bar is set noticeably lower than it would ordinarily be. But quite honestly, if I ordered this BLT at a pricey Manhattan eatery and was charged say $18 for it, I wouldn't have complained a bit. Yeah, it's that good. Whenever I go to Woodbury Commons which really isn't that often, I always make sure to pay them a visit. You should too. Oh and the girl with the black hair and the lip piercing is awesome. Just sayin. read more

Melt Shop - Truly epic BLT - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

Great grilled cheese sandwiches! Ordered this and the tots. The truffle on the grilled cheese was delicious. If you're in the mood for comfort food in the woodbury commons food court, this is a great place to head over to. read more

Melt Shop - Truffle grilled cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

Terrible quality of food. I've been to melt shop so many times in my life but Saturday morning I went for a fried chicken sandwich and the meat part was so hard to bite into it felt frozen still. My teeth started hurting half way in I decided to just toss it out and go for another restaurant. It was not bearable. read more

We're from out of town, but after looking at all the other selections, we had our hearts set on MELTSHOP. Imagine my surprise when we walk up at 630 and THEY'RE CLOSED! What the heck? The dude behind the counter was like "we're closed, I wanna go home". Awesome. Way to represent. Maybe next time. read more

Did not receive what I asked for. payed 10 dollars for a cheap made sandwich I could've made at home.

Out shopping with my daughter and planned to get Chipotle. The line was too long-about 40 min wait so she settled for Melt Shop. The best thing about this place was the wait... about 10 mins. We should have run when one of the girls making food had a ponytail down to her thighs with NO hair net but she didn't pack our food. My daughter got the grilled chicken sandwich, which was super dry. The bread was nicely grilled on the outside but was too greasy. To our horror, the fries were scarce; not even a handful but the biggest issue was the frozen fries in the box. Very pricey for a sandwich, fries, and drink at $18.51. Will NEVER eat here again. read more

Melt Shop - Amount of Fries that came with sandwich. The 3 on the right are frozen. - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

A let down. We ordered grilled cheese, cheesesteak, burger melt, chicken fingers. They didn't look anything like the ones "advertised" in Google Map. Totally overhyped reviews. The grilled cheese was dry, while the burger melt was a grilled cheese version with some bad meat on top, which by the way, wasn't a burger. It was minced meat from last week. The cheesesteak wasn't like the one advertised where you can dip in the cheese sauce. The sauce was so dry and totally tasteless. The chicken was disappointing. If you're looking for a decent place to eat at the Outlets, try others but not the Melt Shop. We spent $62 for bad food and meh shakes and hyped spring water. Nothing was worth the time and $ spent. read more

Melt Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

See all

A meal for 2 people cost us just shy of $50. Why go here when Chipotle is right there? I was going to give it 2 stars because the food tasted OK, but then the food was also small, and for the amount of food that we got, the price is a punch in the gut. I can feed 4 people for the same amount of money and good at Chipotle. read more

it's okay. short lines compared to other stores but pricey. we got mac and cheese with waygu. not as heavy as expected

Terrible customer service and unethical sales tactics. The woman at the register, Maria, was so rude. I ordered a small drink with my sandwich and she was trying to charge me for a large size because they didn't have the small cups. She didn't even tell me she was up-charging me! It was only because I saw the price on the register. When I asked her she just said, Do you want it or not? I said No. I'll never go back there. I'll try another one of the food vendors. I don't support businesses that try to scam their customers. read more

Umm, terrible service. Everyone just stands around. They have no cheese ?? Isn't it called the melt shop?? I'm literally writing this review as I'm waiting for my order. read more

This is just in the food court of the Woodbury Outlets. As most shoppers, after I was done, I was starving and this place was new so I decided to try it. I was v excited because I looked up foods around the area and this place looked bomb. I got the buffalo chicken grilled cheese and it was really good. Although, I wish the chicken resembled the photo they used. They use like a thick, big piece of chicken and it's not bad but it just wasn't expected and somewhat hard to eat. I got the shop tots and they were very good. Your usual tater tots with parmesan and cilantro. My friends got the loaded and the cheese tots and the cheese on both of them were questionable. It made me glad I stuck with regular tots. I got their strawberry lemonade and that was good. Don't think I'd really be back, it was good but nothing too stand out that I had to come back. Everything was cute tho! read more

Melt Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

Melt shop at woodbury was better than expected but way over priced for the amount of food. I paid like 13 dollars for a chicken sandwhich with nothing else. I was definitely hungrey after my sandwich. The portion was decently sized and overall had a great taste. But def overpriced. read more

My server was super polite and patient. He was happy to run through options and make suggestions. I haven't had this anywhere else at this food court. Usually treated as if I'm on a conveyor belt even when there is a queue! Cheese melt was delicious! read more

Melt Shop - Outside - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

I'm in love with their truffle melt. Very cheesy but is well balanced with the arugula. The bread is well toasted and the truffle oil is the perfect finish. read more

Melt Shop - Truffle melt - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

Never in my life have I ever dealt with such terrible people in my whole life. After waiting 20 mins for our food, i asked for a refund and the man starts yelling and calling me Karen. And the two girls in the back join in and start ganging up on us. So embarrassing, acting like animals out of the zoo. Completely disgusting can't stress it enough. HORRIBLE PLACE STAY AWAY read more

I usually love the Melt Shop but this experience wasn't as lovely. I waited twenty minutes for my plant based burger, which looked like raw meat. No thank you! Service was great though... I recommend the milk shakes! read more

Melt Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

3.5 but service was good so increased to 4. Had the Fried chicken sandwich. It was good and filling. Would be nicer if it was pressed/pannini like sandwich read more

Bad, bad sandwiches, doesn't look any similar to the menu pictures, it tastes just like a "blah" sandwich made at home, the cheese tot's taste like plastic cheese with cardboard, only two things I bought with no drinks total $15 dollars, ridiculous expensive for the low grade quality. read more

Extremely dissatisfied with ordering a grilled chicken sandwich only to get a few bites in to notice a weird texture. Upon dissembling the sand which I noticed the chicken was uncooked and felt completely disgusted to have already consumed a portion already. Also it wasn't exactly a cheap sandwich but I still had to toss it away because I already left the premium outlet read more

Melt Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Central Valley, New York

Melt Shop is located in the main food court of Woodbury Commons and offers quick-service grilled cheese sandwiches, soups and sides. Unfortunately, this location falls a bit flat in both service and food and leaves a lot to be desired. The staff seemed absent-minded and fairly dismissive of customers when they would inquire about menu items, in addition to spending more time socializing among themselves rather than attending to the line, which as you can imagine, can grow quite quickly during peak afternoon and evening hours. When it comes to the food itself, this is standard cafeteria fare. The grilled cheese is uninspired and greasy while you have to pay upwards of $3.00 for add-ons. The tots were typical of what you'd find in the frozen aisle of your local grocery store and accompanied by a so-called 'housemade' cheese sauce; a salty, unnaturally flavored concoction that tastes anything but. The purportedly 'homemade' tomato soup similarly had a distinct store-bought flavor. And therein lies my recurring criticism of Melt Shop. While none of the food was particularly bad, everything I tried was underwhelming and less-than-satisfying. Melt Shop boasts of offering homemade comfort food with artisanal ingredients that is "better than our mom's", but it didn't even manage to be better than my old high school lunch line. I am a realist when it comes to food court eats so I certainly wasn't expecting a Michelin-star meal or anything, but at least aspire to be at the level of Pret A Manger or Au Bon Pain-- two other gourmet sandwich chains with locations @ Woodbury Commons as well. read more

They comment us saying they'll hook us up with credit for future orders but don't reply to emails or follow up emails. I guess they don't want redemption. But hey, that's okay with me (: I don't have problems with going to other locations. read more

Had the roasted veggies sandwich with added grilled cheese on multigrain bread. It had the possibility of being a four star meal yet it was overpowered with goat cheese. Too much Goat cheese gives the pasty ugh taste and therefore my sandwich was no longer pleasing. I couldn't even finish it. Their homemade melt sauce was ok, a spin of a chipotle mayo by it wasn't enough to revive my meal. The Oreo shake was good, not a must try but if your in the mood I would recommend. The tater tots were a hit, very good. Nice crispy and golden the best way to go. Customer service was fantastic. Overall, tweak the ingredients to your liking and you'll be happy. read more

Melt shop is eh. When it first opened it was a pretty neat concept, now i find all the food is half-assed and greasy. The tator tots and milkshakes are pretty good though.. as far as the sandwiches, not sure i'll indulge in one again. read more