I was genuinely disappointed to see so many negative reviews for this amazing collectible shop…read morebecause my experience has been the complete opposite. I've sold several Pokémon cards and other collectibles here, and I felt I was compensated fairly every time. Many of the negative reviews seem to come from personal collectors who naturally place a higher emotional value on their collections. The reality is that collectibles are a market like any other--their value fluctuates based on supply, demand, and current trends. Just because someone paid retail or above retail doesn't mean the market will always support that price. The owner, AJ, is knowledgeable, honest, and transparent about how he evaluates collections. If you're willing to ask questions instead of assuming you're being lowballed, he'll gladly explain the process and how he arrives at his offers. I also took the time to compare buyback offers from other collectible shops, and most either offer significantly lower percentages or aren't interested in purchasing certain items at all. If I had to make a comparison, I'd say many other shops operate like a used car lot, while Collectible N Stuff feels more like CarMax--straightforward, professional, and transparent. AJ is a genuinely friendly, down-to-earth person who clearly knows the hobby and the business. Based on my personal experience, I highly recommend this shop. Five stars!

I've visited this business a couple times. Limited slab selection though they have several binders…read moreworth of vintage to modern and even Japanese singles. They have a few sealed English and Japanese product from Evolving Skies/OF ETBs to the Chinese Gengar 151 boxes. They also have Magic and sports cards. They have a WILD selection of Pop figures too. In terms of selling, I was told they don't buy Pokemon common or uncommon bulk but they might for V's or better. I did see them buy like 2 bigger than flat rate boxes worth of Sports cards. I was told depending on the item, they can buy 70% cash or 80% trade. In terms of buying, they say they price cards based on how much they also got them for so I've seen 10% below to 20% above TCGPlayer market price. Just like all your purchases, do your due diligence and see if you agree with their comps or if you are willing to buy at a slight premium for the convenience of being able to check out the card and not needing to wait for pay for shipping. AJ was great helping me out. Very personable. No issues getting prices when some cards were unmarked. I also sold some slabs to him, a lot I couldnt give a flying fc while some I know had value but I just didnt have the time to sell. I had to comp the valuable ones in person but he gave me all the time I needed, never rushed me or sounded annoyed and the rest I essentially just used to help me get a better percent on what I valued. Note that the highest valued slab was ~$150-$200 depending on how you comp. We ended up with a 60 or 65% coin flip probably less with the random slabs I added on.. Never did I think I'd coin flip in a shop. I did win, but did I really? Haha. I did get cash which I wanted cause I'll be going on a couple trips but overall still a positive experience for both visits in the shop.

Very knowledgeable and good community feel. Interesting discussions about. One of the best GW…read moreselections I've seen in a small store setting. Word to the noob: you will be paying those stupid GW prices. But this is set by corporate, so don't take it out on the kind and passionate owner.

I adore this comic shop. I visited here on a whim and was pleasantly overjoyed with the…read moreexperience. The staff (owners?) were so nice/kind - welcoming, but not overbearing or pushy. I felt free to look around and enjoy the great artwork. Plus, this is by far the most organized shop I've seen in the bay area. In literally 5 minutes, I felt like I knew EXACTLY where everything was. That made the experience so much easier (although I don't mind hunting through bargain bins every now and then). In short, it was an amazing experience and I'll definitely be back. If you have any interest in comics, check this place out. You won't regret it.

Caldwell's Comics and Cards is located right in the heart of Downtown Gilroy with a wide selection…read moreof new and old comic's, trade paperbacks, kids books, Pokemon, Magic cards, action figures and funko Pops plus and many more. The owner is kind and knowledgeable on many subjects while staying up to date with the latest entertainment news. I was surprised to find some of my favorite comics that I use to enjoy as a kid still holding their value and new additions that I wasn't even aware were printed. Caldwell's Comics and Cards is one of those hidden gems in Gilroy California that surpasses in quality of products for the price and provides a great edition to our inner collector in all of us.

Came here to look at comic books and check out the Pokémon selection! Was very pleased with the…read moreselections this store has. Owner is very knowledgeable and helpful. Told him what I was looking for and is like he knew what I was looking for. Walked out very happy with my purchase. Great store and very friendly owner. Highly recommend this store for anyone that is looking for comics, posters, cards, funkos, posters, and they even have game nights!

A very large selection. Back issues were 50% off. Current issues had many variant covers on the…read moreracks that I did not see at my local comic book store in San Jose. Very good value for issues available. Definitely, will be going back!

Good unopened sport pack selection, including some 80s junk wax. A lot more comics than sports…read morecards. Also has a lot of non-sport inventory. Prices are a little inflated, especially on vintage singles. The gentleman working when we visited was very nice, honest, and easy to talk too! I like the cheap grab bag offerings. We love supporting local card shops. Son and I bought some cheaper packs to open tonight!

Terrible place to go I walked in asked if they was taking one piece card most of my card are psa…read moregraded already an he didn't even take the chance to look at them just said we are not taking them rn we don't need them but he didn't even look at them if ur selling one piece card pls do not go here they dont deserve them or any cards shut them down

This place is definitely up there with regards to all of the card shops I've visited!…read more The atmosphere was great (not crowded at all, but I went with a couple of friends close to closing) and the person at the counter was friendly, knew their stuff, and easy to talk to. Good selection of singles, and the prices are reasonable too. Would totally come back again!

Best card shop in Gilroy! They always have a good selection and are always friendly with my 9 year…read moreold who takes forever to decide on what he wants to add to his pokemon collection. Lol great place to take your kiddo who wants to add some singles to their pokemon collection as they have a good selection of unique cards for a good price. They also have an awesome stream on whatnot as well.

This shop is the last of it's kind. Shop full of dudes that know what they're talking about,…read moreinventory of stuff you need for your car. Machine shop too. This is the only place my car buddies ever recommended in the 20+ years I've been living down here. Thanks for being in Los Gatos, real easy access from the Blvd.

Lots of universal items like oil, anti-freeze, hose clamps & all the maintenance stuff you need…read more They also have an in-house inventory of various vehicles. They often have parts for my mid 90's van & Jeep but not always BUT what they don't have in stock they can usually get in a couple hours. Service is usually wuick & mostly friendly. I like to check here first to support small, privately owned business plus it reminds me of 60's/70's parts stores i used to visit with dad when i was 10. I do have a sour taste since they gouged me on snow chains a couple years ago when we were heading to the Sierras and they knew everyone else was sold out... $180 plus tax for rear chains?? We paid because it was our only option. Give them them a shot... at least so you know what they have on the floor & get all the basic automotive items you're likely to need.

There is nothing better than a great LCS, and that is what Triple J Collectibles is. Besides having…read moreoutstanding prices, and plenty of stock, the staff is very friendly, and very knowledgeable. They are TCG gurus on all platforms. They also have sports cards, from High end products, to the newest releases, and Vintage packs. Funko Pops, other cool collectibles and a large selection of supplies. Its what a LCS should be, and where I will always go to rip packs.

My wife and I are very new to Magic the Gathering and lately we've been looking for TCG stores to…read morebuy packs and hopefully find a place that we can also ask questions about the game and how to navigate it as new players. J was incredibly welcoming and generous with his knowledge and also made the experience far from intimidating. Had a really amazing selection of MTG packs that were priced very fairly and had a lot of really cool retro collectible cards right when you enter that really made us feel like kids in a candy store. This is the type of store you just keep coming back to. Can't wait to start playing!