This pizza restaurant is soooo delicious. The man who took my order was very nice I asked him how the tortellini in cream sauce is he said really good. Well he was not lying. The Tortellini are huge and the sauce amazing. I'll definitely be back read more

See all

We ordered a Grandma pie and a large House salad last night . It was delicious! Fast service too!

In the past, food from this restaurant has been very good, although Sunday nites weather was extremely bad, the football was on and we were looking for some pizza. I called the restaurant and a dizzy person answered the phone, I placed my order, when I got to the restaurant the person I talked to was looking at me very strange. I asked if she was alright, and she immediately asked if I was alright. My order came out it was not what I wanted she continued to act like shit. Long story short, the place must have changed hands again, Pizza was shit. read more

Good for takeout, this place is pretty busy but services fast. Definitely try to order online for fast service. I got eggplant parm and it was at a good price and tasted delicious. I wish there was more sauce for the pasta, the bottom of my dish was just plain pasta so that was upsetting. But the amount of food you get for price is great! The cheese calzone was also great. Wouldn't mind ordering from here again with more sauce read more

Have been ordering from here for over 10 years. I always get the #2 special, cheese pie, penne a la vodka, garlic knots, salad and a free bottle of soda. I order this every week. Was very disappointed to see that the pasta dish was 1/4 filled. Called to complain and was told that this is how they'd be serving the "special orders" now. Mind you, I ordered the week before and received a order filled to the top of the container! The attitude of the person I spoke to had a "I don't care attitude." I won't be ordering from them again and neither will my school district for catering orders. read more

Great food at a fair price, we got the pizza combo which includes pasta, salad and a soda, all the food was delicious. Definitely coming back read more

The aunt who owns the pizza place is sooo nasty! She participates in too good to go, but when you come to get your food, she's nasty & she doesn't speak a word of English. It's left over food that's been sitting out all day & she doesn't want to part with it even though she's getting paid. Once I was leaving & the staff was talking about me to a customer & of course I heard & let them know! I went a few times & it keeps getting worse. I'm done! Let them throw their left over pizza in the garbage where it belongs! read more

awful costumer service very rude and lier's. I order a pizza and after and 1 hour and 1/2 never received it called and they said they called me and attempted to deliver pizza which they never did as I had no missed calls from them and a dog who would have gone crazy if they attempted to deliver pizza here. refused to refund money read more

Ordered pizza from here many times. But this time I should have known it was going to be bad because it came too fast, wasn't cooked properly. Sausage wasn't done. Really surprised. Usually pretty good. read more

if I could give this place ZERO stars I would. I would never in my life think about stepping foot in this establishment but my friends got pizza to go from there and I actually have food poisoning been vomiting all night. This place is gross inside too. don't go here it's horrible food read more

Good Food Great customer service. One of the best Italian/Pizzeria's in the neighborhood.

This place really has zero customer service.. i ordered pizza faithfully every week and most Of the time they would serve it cold when I finally complained the guy was like "oh well" when I asked To speak to the manager he said "I am the manager" when i said ok can I speak to the owner he said "I am the owner" since then I have not been back and refuse to ever order from them. I'd rather drive to galleria who doesn't deliver then ever order from them again. Appreciate my money appreciate my business. read more

They only got 1 star because Yelp makes you give a star to give a review. They deserve NO stars! Went here to order some food and saw little bugs flying around the garlic knots. The workers act like they didn't see it. This was enough to make my stomach turn and know I will never go in there again. Don't waste your money. There is a better and cleaner pizzeria up merrick and to the left next to Pats Farm read more

This is one of my favorite pizza spots. They have a large variety of specialty pies. Stop by, I don't think you'll be disappointed. Sometimes on nice days they have tables out front so you can enjoy your food in the fresh air. read more

I don't know what has happened to the pizza and food here, but it is terrible. New Owners?? The pizza is always soggy and mushy even if you ask for it well done. The sauce is very bitter, like it wasn't cooked long enough. The food is disgusting. Ordered just tonight and it was so peppery it couldn't even be choked down, and I love spicy food. The ricotta cheese in the lasagna was soured. It was inedible. So disappointed.I have gone here for years, but I will never order from here again. read more

Bro awesome place and awesome food! Great customer service. Will definitely come again!

Been going here with my family for several years now! Michael anthonys never lets us down! The chicken bacon ranch slice is to die for!! Keep up the good work guys and we shall continue to make you our number one spot!! read more

Place used to be somewhat decent absolutely horrible now crap pizza super stale obviously left out for days and then meatballs are obviously frozen and cooked in a microwave. Never going back again and I live across the street. Especially after this coronavirus and no one has money they're charging more for frozen food then when they had fresh food. read more

my family and i used to love this place so much, went back for the first time in a while and the pizza we got was awful. it seemed like it was made in the morning and just left on top of the oven all day, our pie and two speciality slices as well. so disappointing. got there within 15 minutes of ordering so I know it couldn't have gotten like that so quickly. we ended up throwing out the rest of the pie. we were going to drive back to complain but it didn't seem worth it tbh. just, disappointed. read more

Not the best pizza but good. Friendly staff/owners. Clean place Came in on Saturday afternoon for lunch and service was fast and friendly

Be honest when a customer asks if you are under new ownership. Be honest when asked if it's quicker for pick up or delivery. Called two weeks ago...pizza was cold when it arrived and I chalked it up to the weather. I ordered again tonight and person I talked with after ordering two heroes and a salad said my delivery would take 35-40 min which was ok during dinnertime. Didn't arrive. Called again after waiting an extra 10min, was told they were waiting for a driver to come back to bring it ???? Called 15 min AFTER THAT because there was STILL no delivery and was told by nice man on phone that the order wasn't finished yet. My credit card was charged to an Erick's Pizzaria so it seems after all has been sold. Guy on phone was kind and he delivered our food finally. Said he has no idea what is going on but there are NEW OWNERS. Used to be my go-to for delivery. Food was warm and ok, customer service makes me sad...the owner wouldn't get on phone to explain or offer an apology for delay on order. I'll be moving on... read more

Great pizza & service ! Food taste excellent every time I order it's exactly what I asked for friendly staff

Pretty fundamental, solid NY pizza. Nothing to write home about, but it's cheap and fast and very consistent... especially when there's lightning and thunderstorms out and you don't want to travel any farther than yo have to. Both the pepperoni and the italian sausage are good. read more

I live around the corner, walking distance for a little over a decade. I remember it being better when I first moved to the area. The pizza is just OK. I have been "burned" by it on occasion with a bad crap attack after eating so i have relocated my pizza buying habit to other close by pizza joints. I use this place as a last resort kinda choice. read more

Review of take out pizza only... I asked my italian neighbor where does he get is pizza and he told that Michael Anthonys is the best. I did ring and they did bring the best pizza. Not to cheesy or doughy - just right. MA's in my new place. read more

Just moved to Merrick from the city and have been trying to find a good pizza spot like the city! Well I finally found one and this is the spot! read more

Great pizza! Huge slices. But... don't have your pizza delivered. It always takes forever and arrives cold. Staff is polite. The place is clean. I'm not a fan of their pastas bc they taste generic. The salads are great! read more

The only good slices of pizza are the Grandma slice and the buffalo slice besides that every slice is to greasy

Always good pizza. Something about their cheese. Slices are huge and a good deal if you are just grabbing lunch. I usually get delivered, but if I pick up I am in and out fast. read more

Small neighborhood pizza shop. Clean & pleasant atmosphere. They always accommodate special requests. Lots of variety & imaginative toppings. It's my favorite place for a quick bite. read more

I gotta say, you guys have a lot of potential. Pizza is definitely better than most others in town, and the slices are huge. However, you guys should really throw out the older slices and not serve them to customers. Coming in at 3pm, I shouldn't be getting slices from the night before. The pizza is great; if they served fresh slices, guaranteed they'll have customers return. When a slice is served that is clearly old, it makes customers feel mistreated / betrayed. I get that it costs money to make pizza and you don't want to waste it. but, giving people old crusty pizza (where the white mozzarella has turned brown- and not from heating it), you will have customers not return, and that in turn will probably cost more money than throwing out the old slices will. I used to work at a pizza place so I can tell when slices are from the night before; the place that I worked at- all pizza were thrown out at the end of the night, and I would take some home with me. So I can definitely tell what overnight pizza looks like. It's unfair to faithful customers. This is the second time it has happened, and I hope it's the last, because I will not be returning otherwise. read more