Always a great experience at Stella's! The food is really good, portions are plentiful and the prices are totally reasonable. I had friends coming over so picked up a family meal for $35- it came with 1 pizza, 1 baked pasta (chose Siciliana with eggplant) and garlic knots. When I went to pick up the meal, the restaurant was packed, which is always a good sign, a delicious variety of pizza was on display for the taking. It's a very casual place and has plenty of seating to eat there. After I paid, the man assisting me behind the counter told one of the helpers to bring my food to the car, which was REALLY nice and appreciated since it was raining. The meal was perfect for everyone to share and you can't beat that deal for good food! Stella's will be a regular place for me! read more

Stella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

Kind of dated place along merrick road. Hungry so popped in for a slice. Not great. $6 for a slice and Small soda. Not much to say. read more

Mediocre at best. For Nassau County i would say standard but not a spot to go out of your way to visit. The eggplant roll was tasteless lacking flavor. Buffalo chicken roll was okay and buffalo chicken pinwheel was even better but overall portion was very small. Quick service and standard ambiance for pizza restaurant, but would only visit again if convenient. I've had much better. read more

Stella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Eggplant Parmigiana Roll - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

Great food ,great service Close to the beach . They listened and gave us exactly what we expected read more

There are so many good Italian restaurants in Nassau County...sadly, this is not one of them. Today, I gave them a second chance and was very disappointed. I ordered a chicken parm entry. It came with a salad ( 1 small tomato, 1 slice of cucumber and a teaspoon of shredded carrot). I had to ask for silverware and a plastic fork was literally thrown on my table. Nice. The entree arrives and , surprise, it's not chicken parm but an extremely mushy eggplant parm. ( Frozen and microwaved no doubt. ) I'm done at this point. $31.00 for soggy eggplant, a bottle of water and a very meager salad. No how, no way will I give them another chance. P.S. Just look at the exterior of this place before you enter. No pride in their appearance usually means no pride in their food. read more

The staff is extremely nice and friendly. The food is fantastic, along with the service.

Staple here in Bellmore for almost 50 years, I've been coming here since I was a kid, Joe and his family are fabulous. People never had any complaints, their food is delicious, everything from the pizzas to take out to the dining room desserts. Everything was great always had a wonderful time, I hope they continue the tradition. read more

Stella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Chicken Bruschetta , Eggplant and Ricotta , trifecta, Brooklyn & Sicilian slices - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

I was surprised that the pizza here was quite good. This is close to Mill Pond Park and a good stop for hungry people. One side is closed, so walk around and you will find the entrance. Place is bigger than expected and I did not spy any old pizzas, most looked fresh. I had the Brooklyn pizza and the crust was crisp and sturdy. Sauce tasted fresh and I tasted pecorino Romano sprinkled in there. It was a good size and I was good with one slice. Tables and facilities are clean. There are sealed plastic utensils if needed and also spices. Inflation has caused good prices to escalate. Three slices of non-regular pizza was close to $12. read more

See all

Went back again today with the wife and got some takeout slices. We ordered the Honey Mustard Bacon Slice, Eggplant, and Chicken Bacon Ranch. Everything was excellent and each slice was a meal unto itself! The gentleman helping us was very pleasant, and we will definitely be coming back for more specialty slices. read more

A nice surprise. Had never been to Stella's. Food was delicious, service excellent. Sometimes the simple places are the best. read more

We moved into the neighborhood and were starved so we ordered pizza without reading any reviews. We got chipotle chicken pizza. It's disgusting. It's like a barbecue sauce bottle diarrhea-ed all over the pizza. The cheese fell off because they used that cheap ass barbecue sauce instead of tomato sauce. Never order chipotle chicken pizza from here unless you want cheap super sweet barbecue chicken pizza. The crust was the best part of the pizza read more

Stella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Diarrhea barbecue chicken pizza. Chicken Chipotle Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

Great food, great service, fair prices, what more do you want? They also have quick delivery and have always gone out of their way to offer great service. read more

Make sure you get a receipt on your take out order as they overcharge on your order. They owe me $15 on an overcharge.

We had a 90th birthday party at Stella's this past weekend. The party room was perfect for our 30+ guests and we all felt so comfortable. The serving staff were attentive and pleasant! They were extremely helpful with everything we needed, making sure we were happy. And the food! A good Italian cook always makes sure there's more than enough to feed the masses and Joe definitely delivers! Everyone loved the appetizers! The stuffed clams were tender, the stuffed mushrooms so full of different flavors and the calamari cooked perfectly! The main course choices are excellent and everyone thoroughly enjoyed what they ordered. Joe and his staff definitely go above and beyond to make sure everyone has what they want! I've been to several parties at Stella's - this was my first time hosting there. Joe and staff made it very easy! We had alot of fun and made a wonderful family memory for everyone! (The pizza is amazing too!) read more

Stella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Grandma loved the food and had a great time at her party! - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

I've lived in the area for awhile but have never ordered from Stellas before. I've heard good things so when my fiancé said he wanted pizza I recommended we try it. Pizza 7.5/10 He ordered a 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 meatball pie. As far as the taste goes it was great but because of how heavy the meats were every time he picked up a slice all of the meat and cheese slid its way down to the edge of the pizza Spinach pinwheel 7/10 Taste was good but I wouldn't go out of my way to get it again. Escarole and Bean soup 0/10 Honestly this was so bad I couldn't even eat it. I took two spoonfuls (1 to start then tried stirring it up good to see if it would help and took another spoonful). It was awful! I felt like I was eating a spoonful of olive oil and couldn't eat any of it. read more

Stella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Meatball and pepperoni pizza pie - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

I've been going here for years. The food is always great ( especially the chicken cutlet parm hero). Service is always fast and friendly. Definitely recommend! read more

It's been there like forever, with good reason. The Pizza is always perfect, Staff if friendly and always clean read more

Great food and good service. I would go again. Reasonable prices. Nice back room for fine dining. My friend goes all the time. She must like it too read more

Not worth it!! Price's are astronomical. They don't even acknowledge coupons. B'4 going there checked all prices. Was supposed 2b $23.23. But when they rang up was$27 & change.. I confronted them & they said that's wat registered said.. Lol..? So turned 2 walk out the door & guy said "stop .. I got ya". BUT 2 no avail.. Still got charged $25.51..hahaha . Was hungry so left it @ that. Came home, checked recipet..lol again.. GOT CHARGED 4 a "non-cash charge"!!! THIS PLACE IS BOGUS.. Not 2 mention pizza was awful. read more

Great food, great service, great experience. Owner Joe great guy made sure everything was great. I will be back!

Another LI pizza joint that performs as expected, doesn't disappoint doesn't over impress either. but in my ongoing quest to find one or more menu items that are standouts, I'm gonna agree with reviewer Moe G., the deep dish, Sicilian Eggplant Slice is worth stopping in, that slice is a five star slice. read more

The people who work here are incredibly kind and empathetic. I babysit a 5 year old autistic boy and we love to come here after school. Our last 2 visits we were taken care of by Charlie, and he was so kind to my little buddy. He answered all his questions and made him feel welcome. Today, we went back and Charlie had 3 little toys from the quarter machines for him. They played with the toys together on the counter. Another older man who works there told him that once he finishes his pizza, he would get some free ice cream as well. I wish I got his name too! He was so excited, they let him go behind the counter to pick his flavor. The whole car ride home he was so happy about his new friends at the pizza place. Such a wonderful staff there, and the food is great too! read more

I really enjoyed the soup here and appetizers!!! The service was great. Music was a great touch. I tried the sangria (Aye Carumba) BEST I've ever had! read more

Stella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - The Sangria - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

Came back to an old favorite and had a great pie with pepperoni. There's a reason why Stella's has been around forever, thanks guys.

They have some good slices, but the eggplant parm is god awful. Literally mush in soggy bread. I've tried it twice and swore to never get it again. Felt like gambling tonight and I lost big. Do you guys just freeze that shit for months at a time? read more

This will be my LAST time going to Stella's!!!! I've been going for years and my family regularly orders their hero's but never again will I step foot in that restaurant after tonight's experience. As I was eating my meatball parm hero, I saw something poking out the side of the sandwich. At first I thought it was a burnt piece of cheese, but I opened up my sandwich to take a closer look... to find a full ROACH sitting in the middle of my sandwich. As horrifying as this was, I called the restaurant to kindly let them know. In response, the owner told me that the exterminator was just there last night (clearly he didn't do a good job) and asked if he could give us something else to eat. Will NEVER eat there again... I want to puke!!!!! read more

Stella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - ROACH IN SANDWICH - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

I came here for a big group party, they have a private room in the back. If your party isn't big enough, they will sit other patrons in the same room. I felt bad for them. The food was really good and the party set up was appetizer, salad, pasta and entrée. Their penne alla vodka was very good and I have to say their meatballs tasted just like my great grandmothers. It was so juicy and moist. However, the sauce that came with the spagetti and meatballs was as liquidy as water. Put some paste in there, gezzz. Another reason for the lack of 5 stars was because I went to get their corona ice king ices after the party. There was one person attending counter and like 7 or 8 people making pizza or just chatting. Having to wait at least 5 minutes, I bolted. At a pizza counter, I would expect some efficiency. read more

I have been ordering from Stella's since my family moved to Bellmore two years ago. I've been to Stella's for dinner with the family, ordered delivery and even had them cater my parties. Stella's is consistently good. Fresh, flavorful food and attentive service. The baked clams and penne a la vodka is on point. My daughter loves their baked ziti. And the grandma pies are terrific. My family's favorite local Italian restaurant! read more

Ordered a chicken parm dinner, didn't get my pasta and didn't realize until I got home. When I called the woman who answered the phone she said you have to ask for the pasta or you don't get it, which doesn't make sense but I did say chicken parm dinner with penne anyway. She told me she'd send someone ASAP, which took 50 minutes from my first phone call. Workers there are very stubborn and I felt like they were trying to get away with something by saying you have to ask for pasta or you don't get it. They were just making up CYA excuses. There are too many other pizzerias in Bellmore/Merrick to ever have to go back there. Next time skip this place for Italian food, no need to deal with their workers and their sneaky tactics. Too many other good Italian places in the area to subject yourself to this. read more

The food is awesome. The owner went above and beyond. I came with a group and they kept bringing out food. I would come here for all occasions read more

Take out is one thing that I don't recommend here, but eating here is great. When I take out from here it's so shitty and salty the food, especially the pizza. Last night I ate here and it was so great, the staff was friendly and attentive. I had the shrimp scampi it was excellent. This is a nice restaurant to dine at, they even give fresh pizza bread.. so yummy! read more

Pizza used to be good a few years ago but recent purchases are less than Stellar!! Better places around for pizza & food and close by ! read more

I love love love this pizza place! Must haves : Chicken bacon ranch deep dish slice Buffalo chicken pinwheel Grilled chicken wrap Chicken roll Caesar salad slice The meatballs The list can go on! Just don't like that they use their hands a lot when touching the food. read more

I've been here around five times and I don't know why this is my first review here! They start you off with a huge basket of bread and cut up pizza slices... so good. I ordered calamari, shrimp, and fried zucchini as an appetizer. When you order an entree, you will get a salad as well as a side of pasta. Once again, I ordered the penne siciliana. More crowded tonight then the other nights! Def recommend!! read more

This place used to make Good Pizza years ago. Don't know if the ownership changed. As their pies - are doughy. undercooked. I wouldn't order from Stella's pizzeria again . You would think that a place that's been around for so many years would know not to send out undercooked food . People tend to get stuck on a home town name . I would try new places . Places ,That probably put more effort into their orders as they are building their business. I think Stella's pizzeria lost that motto . They are surviving on what once was. And people are afraid of change . So if you are looking for a good stomach ache go for it . Stella's will deliver it for you. read more

If it's cold outside please put on the heat for your patrons. 29 outside 64 inside Brrrrrr read more

Ordered delivery, food came on time as expected and was piping hot. However I ordered rigatoni alla vodka and they gave me penne. They also didn't include napkins, plastic ware, or grated cheese which I thought should have been included. Pasta was okay, just wish it was the correct one. Wings were good and salad was big for the price paid. Overall it was okay, I'll probably just stick to pizza next time though. read more

Stella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Ceasar salad - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

Stella's has been my family's go to pizza place for well over 2 decades. Speciality slices are great--my faves are the buffalo chicken, barbecue chicken, and chicken parm slices. Their pinwheels are great, as are their pizza rolls and sausage & pepper rolls. They're the best in this area for just good, plain NY pizza. Wouldn't even think of going anywhere else. read more

Honestly I don't know what I'm more mad about, the pizza being disgusting and cold or the fact I can't rate this place a 0 star. Stay away from here and go to La Piazza. Food is not fresh at all. read more

Stella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Gross old meatballs thrown on unsliced pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

Pizza was ok. The kid in the front just don't notice me. Told me I'm next and keep taking orders from others, seems like those were the regulars. Wouldn't go back even if it taste like diamond. read more