I have been to worse restaurants than this...certainly the last time I will eat here. The service is terrible The food is not good The prices are ridiculous. Huge disappointment! One star is very generous. I highly recommend a qualified Manager on the floor at all times. read more

This was a fun place to grab a pizza and sub. Quite a large menu, you'll surely find something you like if you like at least something Italian. This is a bring your own wine sort of place, which worked out well for us, staying so close by. A good selection of indoor and outdoor seating, which was good because we had two kids who did not want to stay still or be quiet. read more

Ordered a pizza via grub hub - 1/2 sausage- 1/2 black olive and onion . Didn't know the sausage isn't shaved anymore if I did I wouldn't have ordered it . Aside from that pretty disappointed pie arrived undercooked. Called and questioned it and was met with pretty much indifference. read more

Really a 3.5 Good food, so so atmosphere. There are so many great Italian restaurants in the area. Dizzying number of choices. And since I grew up in this area, it was amazing that I'd never actually eaten here as it's a mainstay in this part of Cherry Hill. For a combine birthday / Mother's day celebration, we had 5:00 PM Saturday reservations. The ambiance was a little confusing - kinda mom and pop, kinda wanna be upscale with black table cloths and a more private room in the back for larger parties. Service was nice, but I HATE HATE HATE when dirty dishes sit on the table while you are waiting for the next round of food to come. Bread was lovely. I really liked the chicken orzo soup that came with the main entree. The pasta carbonara was a bit salty for my personal taste. Overall, quite OK. read more

The food is amazing, everything is made from scratch. The service was good and the ambiance was comfortable and relaxing. We found it by luck while traveling and worth every penny. read more

See all

We are hyper-critical Cherry Hill foodies who often cook at home to avoid the inevitable dining out disappointment. Italian restaurants can be very polarizing as we all have something to compare it to. Tried this place after several recommendations from friends, and they were right - from the starter bread -a garlic butter-slight tomato bread, the stromboli (we shared just to taste) with side dipping tomato sauce, to our dinner pasta and salad. Both had perfectly cooked pasta (al dente please!), wife had Pasta with Sicilian Style Sauce, and I had the Pasta with Garlic, Oil and Anchovies. Huge portions which mean nothing if it isn't good, but this was both craveable and shareable. We ended up bringing 1/2 of everything home for a second if not third round. This is a great date nite dinner BYOB spot. Two thumbs up! read more

This is a solid, neighborhood, traditional Italian restaurant serving up everything from pizza and sandwiches to fresh seafood, all at reasonable prices. The atmosphere is casual and comfortable and the service is adequate. The food is fresh and on par with what you would expect from a traditional old school Italian restaurant. I ordered the clams and mussels over linguine which was loaded with shellfish cooked to perfection over linguine in a red sauce that tasted homemade. The portion was a good size and I really enjoyed this dish. Others in our party loved their meals which included shrimp cacciatore, shrimp parmigiana, a sausage and peppers sandwich, and eggplant manicotti style. We shared the fried calamari for an app which was only the rings and not the other parts of the squid that we love, but was cooked just right nonetheless. I saw other table ordering pizza, calzones, and Stromboli which looked delicious and tempted us to come back just for that. Michelangelo's overall was very satisfying and definitely a place to return to and add to our repertoire while in the Cherry Hill neighborhood. read more

See all

Veal dish was very tough and inedible. The "manager" Apparently disagreed with me and did nothing to remedy the situation.We have been going to this place EVERY Sunday for over a year and will never be back again. Don't bother. read more

Solid 3.5, came here with my family for a big family dinner there were 7 of us. We were seated right away (my Mom may have made a reservation). Service was attentive and they were definitely on top of things with refills on water etc. Can only speak to my meal and the bread, garlic bread and other bread was served fresh and warm, was pretty tasty. I got the carbonara. I choose the noodles (I know it's usually spaghetti but I don't like spaghetti) and they were cooked well...I didn't really love the prosciutto ham and bacon...would rather it have been the traditional fattier pancetta but didn't take away from the dish too much. Serving was a decent size, definitely had left overs. Would go back and try other dishes. read more

Michaelangelo's Pizza Restaurant - Pasta Carbonara - Pizza Near Me - Cherry Hill, New Jersey

NEVER SEND BACK FOOD AT Michaelangelo's Italian Restaurant - Cherry Hill, NJ - 1334 Brace Rd I would like to share my experience I just had there. I have dinned at Michaelangelo's Italian Restaurant many times and taken out even more times than I can remember. Always enjoyed my food. I ordered for the first time Veal Parmesan. When it came out it was over cooked all away around the edges. Like burnt toast. I am not one to do this but told the waitress I could not eat it like this. She said I would have another one made for you. The owner came storming out of the kitchen (I real mean that) very hostile showing me the center was tender and said he would not make another one. I should order something else. As if I should eat around the burnt part. I can't express how mad he was in this blog. I am 69 years old and never saw anything like this. So what I would say is make sure you like what you order Michaelangelo's Italian Restaurant and never complain unless you want to have a hostile owner at your table. read more

For pizza this place is really good. I would get their pizza any time. I give it a 4.5, maybe higher. For sandwiches, it leaves a lot to be desired. I've gotten sandwiches there several times either thinking that I would give another try or just forgetting how bad they are. At this point we've tried maybe 8 different sandwiches/wraps/ panini's/steaks. None of them have been good, with the exception of the cheesesteak. The chicken cheesesteak was not. They serve the wraps hot, so when we got home and ate them a few minutes later, they were a watery mess. There is no or not enough seasoning, on the grilled chicken or the cutlets. So the sandwiches are ALWAYS so bland. The chicken is a little rubbery. Most of the sandwiches run around $15. The prices are above average and the taste is below average. I want this place to be better. And if they ever made any changes I would gladly update my review. read more

Get the Chicken Orzo soup! The best ever created by mankind! The Pescatore was more than adequate. 4 shrimp, a dozen clams and a full two dozen mussels with crabmeat over linguine. The white sauce left something to be desired as it was lacking flavor. Get the red. Chicken Parm was ok. Not great but very good and plenty. Service was outstanding as various personnel were more than attentive to our every whim. Ambiance is a step above your usual strip mall joint as you can expect a cloth tablecloth and cloth tableware. No napkins! Menu is wide and varied. Give them a try and ask for Pete the owner. He takes exceptional pride in his work! read more

See all

Excellent seafood pasta with good quick and friendly service. Nice atmosphere. Will eat here again!

Nice restaurant in Cherry Hill, nice ambiance and plenty of seating (indoor and outdoor. They also have takeout. Our waitress Paula was initially attentive but she disappeared on our party of five. The food was good, and the prices are fairly inexpensive ($30pp). I would probably come back. read more

The service was great and the food was even better!!! Everything was fresh and made to order! We just left and already are planning our next dinner there! We definitely would recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants real Italian food. My son also enjoyed the chicken fingers and he's extremely picky! read more

See all

Had a wonderful time here! Came on a Saturday night. It was calm and the atmosphere warm and welcoming. The staff were extremely polite and the service was fast! Everything we had was good, though I found the starter salads to be a bit lackluster. Would have been nice if some vegetables (onions, tomatoes, etc.) were included. We had the carbonara (yum! Wish there was peas though) and chicken parmigiana. The food was very reasonably priced. Only other wish was more seafood-free appetizer options (there was a seafood allergy in our party) Would return! read more

See all

Ordered the deep dish that was highly recommended and I would say i would. highly not recommended by me and the group we went with.The pizza was cold as ice In the middle and with that many tipping you would think there would be a lot of flavor but there was no flavor what so ever.. the staff was nice . We all ate a piece of the pie and left the other half there wasn't even worth bringing home. read more

Place is too expensive for the garbage items they serve. The pizza was very undercooked and bland, the cheese is cheap and greasy, the sauce is terrible and the mozzarella sticks and fries are cheap, frozen, overpriced garbage. Really awful. I was excited to try somewhere new but this place isn't it. Spend your hard earned money elsewhere. read more

Ordered a two topping pizza yesterday and it was as good as ever! Some places now use less toppings to keep costs down. That's totally reasonable. Michaelangelo's has kept their quality the same, so you are getting what you paid for. We've enjoyed their pasta and chicken dishes from the menu as well. read more

Excellent food at very reasonable prices. My wife and I eat at Michelangelo's about every 2-4 weeks. We've never had a bad meal. Many of our friends enjoy going with us. It's BYOB. read more

Food great! Always nice and attentive service. Love their pasta dinners. Theirs is the best in the area Baked Ziti Pizza.

Loved this spot and am sad I just realized it was here! Inside is warm and inviting for a big space. Food was tasty from apps to soups to entrees! I got the special of the night which was seafood manicotti and it was to die for!!!!! Huge portion, ate the rest for lunch the next day and still tasted delicious! read more

Michaelangelo's Pizza Restaurant - Special Seafood Manicotti - Pizza Near Me - Cherry Hill, New Jersey

Love this place great family atmosphere very nice city for a date night, food is reasonably priced as well and it's BYOB . Love to get my wine and bring it to dinner. read more

Food: Awesome! It like home meal cooking :) Service: Friendly staff. They even remember what food we normally order. That's impressive! Ambiance: they have outdoor and indoor seating. It's nice. read more

Pizza and apps on the patio. Service was great, food and atmosphere were perfect! Will be back read more

Good food and great service. Been here a few times and everything from pasta to sandwiches and pizza has been delicious.

Well, I'm afraid our second trip to this restaurant wasn't as successful. Food was ok, not quite as good. The worst part was the cockroach on my seat! I thought the owner would do something about it. Just said he was sorry. Last time there. read more

Went for lunch. Ordered a cheesesteak. Huge but previously cooked beef that had been microwaved. Pretty awful.

So drove by and saw that it was crowded so we decided to pull in...atmosphere was like a pizzeria not really inviting. Food was ok but nothing to call home about read more

Tonight we ordered from Door dash ..we wanted 3 meals from our favorite Italian restaurant. Somehow one 2 of 3 dinners arrived. I called the restaurant and Vinnie told me he would fix it. We are new to door dash and this was our first hiccup, Vinnie not only took care of the mistake but sent of a delicious dessert on the house. Thank you for taking care of us!!! We always enjoy the great food and great people at MichaelAngelos !!! read more

This restaurant is wonderful!! The ambiance is great. The service is impeccable!! But the food is made with so much love!! Authentic Italian food; it's quite lovely and the Owner is a Sweetheart!! I promise, You won't be disappointed!!! read more

See all

Michaelangelos has been the point of many great family memories. It's a very convenient location in cherry hill as it is somewhat in the middle. We come here probably once every other week - the meals and service never disappoint. I usually go with Veal Parm, shrimp & Scallops Fra Diavlo but last night I went with Pasta Dolce Vita, it was spectacular. Each dinner comes with salad and soup. The apps are good and are a good sized, we went with the sampler as well as calamari. 5/5 every time for a cheap and quick family dinner with massive portions. read more

See all

Ordered a medium plain cheese pizza for takeout a couple nights ago and it def hit the spot. I see what the hype is about! Updating my review to state that the mozzarella sticks are AMAZING and exactly how they should be! read more

This restaurant was my go to for takeout during the pandemic. I was never disappointed. The food was always delicious. Since the pandemic is on the back of our minds , i still frequently order takeout. The restaurant has very simple decor. They also have a little outside area if you want yo eat outside. Nothing fancy but good food. I never ate inside this establishment so i can't review the service though pick up waits were accurate It seems I'm not able to post this review Hmmmm. A read more

The pizza and our stromboli was sligthly burned. Tasted Burned. This is not the first time. It used to be a quality place. But not now. So disappointed. I was visiting a friend and they ordered. This is the place that me and my family always ordered from. read more

I ordered 2 pizzas and French fries (only one size available). The price was 9.95 and I figured even with inflation they would be big enough to split as most pizza shop do. I got a small fry that was mostly small crumb pieces. read more

Michaelangelo's Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Cherry Hill, New Jersey

I've heard it was pretty good and it's is ok. I ordered online and picked up. Not great service and they packed the cold salad on hot food with no barrier in between. Screwed up the salad so I wasn't thrilled. read more

I'm not sure what to even say. I walked in with my party and they looked at us as if we were confused. No problem, just weird. As we went to go get seated, the person who sat us looked upset. Probably understaffed. Still, it took about 6-10 minutes trying to locate someone to bring us drinks. This guy ignored us the whole time, as if it was too much to take our drinks. Fine. This woman came out and asked the guy if he had helped us. He said "No, I'm busy with those tables there." Funny enough he came back to help "serve" us. Finally they got these 2 women to serve us but it felt rushed. They kept trying to take our FULL plates away and never showed up to refill our drinks. Maybe just once to refill but by then we were already done with our food (mostly to go). The Alfredo was okay, definitely needed more salt. The steak sandwich my fiancé got was so flavorless he had to add seasoning too. Everyone at the other side of the restaurant were well taken care of but not us. Given my experience, this place is somewhere I would NEVER recommend. read more

Michaelangelo's is your standard suburban jersey pizza joint/Italian restaurant. I recently stopped in to pick up my family's takeout order. Pro-Yelp-Tip: they have a check-in offer for 10% off your takeout and dine-in order; although the two guys working the register weren't aware of it they kindly still honored it. The food was packaged up nicely, however put kind of awkwardly in a cardboard box. It was a bit of a struggle for me to transport this dinner for four without dropping anything. I went with the eggplant parmesan sandwich and it was fine. It was neither stellar nor horrible. I've had better eggplant, but you do need to take into account seasonality I supposed. The roll was hardy and tasted fresh. The sauce and mozzarella were neither here nor there. Was I super impressed by my sandwich? Nope. However, this is a family go-to and is a reliable spot for an Italian meal. read more

Michaelangelo's Pizza Restaurant - Eggplant parm sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Cherry Hill, New Jersey

I like to say wow for what I just read. I've been going here for years. For someone to call my friends races is so wrong. They wouldn't let you sit there for 40 minutes either without taking your order. I have brought many nationalities of my friends to this place and never had a problem. There seafood pizza is one of my favorites dishes. If you just wanna enjoy a night out and a good dinner this is the place to be trust me. It is also a BYOB establishment. read more